Nomination
Document type: DC
Recorded outcomeDenied
Recorded conditions
Rescission denied; designation amended to indicate that the c. 1856 Italianate building is historically significant, but the 1960s and 1970s additions and alterations are not historically significant
Prior meeting reference: Individually designated 1 November 1973; listed on National Register as part of Hamilton Family Estate District (certified 1978); staff sprinkler system application approved 2000
- Vote tally
- Unanimous
- Criteria cited
- Section 5.5.c.1 of the Commission's Rules & RegulationsCriteria 1 — additional information shows resource does not meet criteria for RegisterCriteria 2 — error in professional judgment at time of designationOriginal 1973 ordinance — Commission authorized to designate properties it deems historically significant
Votes and testimony
Votes
- Bruce Lavertyyes
- David Schaafyes
- Hyman Myersyes
- Janet Kleinyes
Testimony
- Anthony Fortesupport, person
- Esaul Sanchezsupport, person
- John Galleryneutral, person
- Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphianeutral, organization
- Robert Powerssupport, person
- Sam Olshinsupport, person
- Tom Lussenhopsupport, person