Alteration review
Architectural Committee
Recorded outcomeDeferred
Committee recommendations are not final Commission decisions.
Recorded conditions
Tabled for up to 6 months to allow applicant to refine proposal with a small group
Prior meeting reference: Commission previously approved glazing of the porch
- Vote tally
- Committee voted to table for a period not to exceed 6 months
- Criteria cited
- Site guideline: not recommended locating new construction on the building site in a location which contains important landscape features or open spaceSite guideline: not recommended introducing new construction onto the building site which is visually incompatible in terms of size, scale, design, materials, color, and texture
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- American Institute of Architects (AIA)oppose, organization
- Athenaeum of Philadelphiaoppose, organization
- Design Advocacy Groupoppose, organization
- Herbert Levysupport, person
- Joanne Phillipssupport, person
- John Carrneutral, person
- John Galleryoppose, person
- Joseph R. Catellisupport, person
- Laura M. Spinaneutral, person
- Linda Rosaniosupport, person
- National Park Serviceoppose, organization
- National Trust for Historic Preservationoppose, organization
- Preservation Allianceoppose, organization
- Richard Tyleroppose, person
- Robert P. Thomassupport, person
- Rudy D'Alessandrooppose, person
- Suzanne Pentzoppose, person