Alteration review
Historical Commission
Recorded outcomeApproved
Recorded conditions
Approved in concept; addition must connect to main block below the projecting eave; project to return to Commission for final review; SHPO review required per prior agreement
Prior meeting reference: Architectural Committee voted to recommend approval in concept provided addition connects below projecting eave; prior agreement with University, Commission, and Pennsylvania Museum & Historical Commission regarding Smith Hall demolition
- Vote tally
- 5 to 2; 1 abstention; 1 recused
- Criteria cited
Votes and testimony
Votes
- David Schaafyes
- Eileen Evansyes
- John Herzinsyes
- Michael Sklaroffabstain
- Rosalie Leonardyes
- Sara Merrimanno
- Scott Wildsno
- Thomas Sugruerecused
- Vincent Riverayes
Testimony
- Anne Behasupport, person
- David Hollenbergsupport, person
- John Galleryoppose, person
- Preservation Allianceoppose, organization
- University of Pennsylvaniasupport, organization