1123-33 SPRING GARDEN ST

Historic address

1123-33 SPRING GARDEN STREET

Year built

1984

Building description

HSE WORSHIP ALL 3 STY MAS

Owner

CENTRAL INVESTMENT LP

Source links open full minutes. Exact passages have not been matched to these records.

1. Apr 16, 2009

   Nomination

   Document type: DC

   Recorded outcomeApproved

   Recorded conditions

   Paragraph on page 18 regarding architect Augustus Welby Northmore Pugin to be deleted from the nomination. Committee recommended criteria a, d, e, and h (not b as originally nominated).

   Vote tally

   Unanimous

   Criteria cited

   Criterion ACity heritage or significant personCriterion BImportant historical eventCriterion DDistinguishing architectural styleCriterion EWork of an influential designerCriterion HFamiliar visual landmark

   Full source minutes

   Votes and testimony

   Votes

   • David Schaafyes
   • Janet Kleinyes
   • Penelope Gilesyes
   • Richardson Dilworth IIIyes

   Testimony

   • Amy Doughertyneutral, person
   • Andrew Palewskisupport, person
   • Angela McFaddenneutral, person
   • Bernadette Kinniry, RSMoppose, person
   • Bevan Lawsonoppose, person
   • Callowhill Neighborhood Associationsupport, organization
   • Dorothy Krotzersupport, person
   • Eileen DeBenedictisoppose, person
   • George Thomasoppose, person
   • John Gallerysupport, person
   • Joseph Lukachoppose, person
   • Keely Societysupport, organization
   • Kevin R. Boyleoppose, person
   • Preservation Alliance of Greater Philadelphiasupport, organization
   • Siloamoppose, organization
   • Victoria Siusupport, person
2. May 8, 2009

   Nomination

   Historical Commission

   Recorded outcomeApproved

   Recorded conditions

   Nomination adopted with omission of paragraph on page 18 regarding architect Augustus Pugin

   Prior meeting reference: Committee on Historic Designation meeting, 16 April 2009

   Vote tally

   10 to 3

   Criteria cited

   Criterion ACity heritage or significant personCriterion DDistinguishing architectural styleCriterion EWork of an influential designerCriterion HFamiliar visual landmark

   Full source minutes

   Votes and testimony

   Votes

   • Daniel Quinnyes
   • David Amburnyes
   • Della Clarkyes
   • Denise Smyleryes
   • Joan Schlotterbeckyes
   • John Mattionino
   • Laura Spinayes
   • Leslie Benolielyes
   • Richardson Dilworthno
   • Rosalie Leonardyes
   • Sam Shermanyes
   • Sara Merrimanyes
   • Scott Wildsno

   Testimony

   • Amy Hoopersupport, person
   • Andrew Palewskisupport, person
   • Bevan Lawsonoppose, person
   • C. Anne Andersonsupport, person
   • Callowhill Neighborhood Associationsupport, organization
   • Carla Blackwelloppose, person
   • Dorothy Kratzersupport, person
   • Eleanor Walkersupport, person
   • George Thomasoppose, person
   • Joe Lukachoppose, person
   • John Gallerysupport, person
   • Keely Societysupport, organization
   • Kevin Boyleoppose, person
   • MANNAoppose, organization
   • Melvin Whiteoppose, person
   • Michael Lewissupport, person
   • Preservation Alliancesupport, organization
   • Richard Keaveneyoppose, person
   • Shannon O'Rourkeoppose, person
   • Siloamoppose, organization
   • Sisters of the Blessed Sacramentsupport, organization
   • Sr. Maureen Lowryoppose, person
   • West Poplarsupport, organization
   • William Schicktanzneutral, person
3. Aug 24, 2010

   Demolition review

   Architectural Committee

   Recorded outcomeNo decision

   Committee recommendations are not final Commission decisions.

   Recorded conditions

   Application forwarded to Architectural Committee and Committee on Financial Hardship; completeness of submission confirmed by staff

   Prior meeting reference: Designation hearing May 2009; Commission suggested hardship application be submitted at that time

   Full source minutes

   Votes and testimony

   Testimony

   • Joe Lukachsupport, person
   • Siloamsupport, organization
4. Sep 8, 2010

   Demolition review

   Document type: CFH

   Recorded outcomeNo decision

   Prior meeting reference: Individually designated 5/8/2009; Architectural Committee reviewed application on 24 August 2010 and voted to recommend approval of demolition; Commission to meet 10 September 2010

   Criteria cited

   Section 14-2007(7)(j) of the historic preservation ordinanceSection 9.4 of the Rules & RegulationsSale of the property is impracticableCommercial rental cannot provide a reasonable rate of returnOther potential uses of the property are foreclosedSection 9.2 of the Rules & RegulationsSection 10.2 of the Rules & RegulationsSection 6.7 of the Rules & Regulations

   Full source minutes

   Votes and testimony

   Testimony

   • Andrew Palewskioppose, person
   • Bevan Lawsonsupport, person
   • James J. Scottsupport, person
   • Joe Lukachsupport, person
   • John Frondorfsupport, person
   • Kevin Boylesupport, person
   • Marissa Parkersupport, person
   • Michael Barmashsupport, person
   • Preservation Alliance for Greater Philadelphianeutral, organization
   • Save Our Sitesoppose, organization
   • Siloamsupport, organization
5. Sep 10, 2010

   Demolition review

   Historical Commission

   Recorded outcomeNo decision

   Recorded conditions

   Both Architectural Committee and Committee on Financial Hardship recommended approval of complete demolition; full Commission decision not yet rendered in text provided

   Prior meeting reference: Individually designated 5/8/2009; Committee on Financial Hardship, 8 September 2010; Architectural Committee, 24 August 2010

   Criteria cited

   Section 14-2007(7)(j) of the Philadelphia Code

   Full source minutes

   Votes and testimony

   Testimony

   • Amy R. Hooperneutral, person
   • Ariana Dreleysupport, person
   • Bernadette Kinnirysupport, person
   • Bevan Lawsonsupport, person
   • Carla Blackwellsupport, person
   • Cyndi Gutierrezsupport, person
   • Jean Kirksupport, person
   • John Frondorfsupport, person
   • John Galleryneutral, person
   • John Rosatosupport, person
   • Joseph Lukachsupport, person
   • Kevin Boyle, Esq.support, person
   • Lori Curtissupport, person
   • Marcel Belissesupport, person
   • Marion Harringtonsupport, person
   • Marissa Parker, Esq.support, person
   • Matthew Tetersupport, person
   • Michael Byrnesupport, person
   • Michael Ragnesupport, person
   • Sarah McEneaneyneutral, person
   • Siloamsupport, organization
   • Sr. Cathy Maguiresupport, person
   • Sr. Maureen Lowrysupport, person
   • Steven Brownsupport, person
   • Susanne Cassidysupport, person
   • Trish DiPietraesupport, person
   • Zak Hagertsupport, person
6. Jan 11, 2013

   Demolition review

   Historical Commission

   Recorded outcomeApproved

   Recorded conditions

   Commission opined that demolition approval remains in effect for a purchaser of the property, as financial data pertains to the property and not the applicant

   Prior meeting reference: Board of License & Inspection Review request of 8 January 2013; Appeal #19463

   Vote tally

   Unanimous (executive session)

   Criteria cited

   §14-2007(7)(j)

   Full source minutes