civus
Search historic records

RITTENHOUSE FITLER RESIDENTIAL HISTORIC DISTRICT (APPROXIMATELY 2 360 BUILDINGS BOUNDED GENERALLY BY BROAD STREET TO THE EAST MARKET STREET TO THE NORTH SCHUYLKILL RIVER CORRIDOR TO THE WEST AND A VARIED SOUTHERN BOUNDARY)

1 decision
Source address
Rittenhouse Fitler Residential Historic District (approximately 2,360 buildings bounded generally by Broad Street to the east, Market Street to the north, Schuylkill River corridor to the west, and a varied southern boundary)

Decision timeline

Decisions, votes, testimony, and links back to source minutes.

  1. NominationNo decision
    Vote tally
    No vote taken at this meeting; hearing continued to 14 December 1994 regular meeting
    Criteria cited
    Historical and cultural significanceArchitectural significanceHigh degree of integrity (less than 7% non-contributing buildings)Nearly 150-year history as an exclusively residential neighborhoodPennsylvania Supreme Court ruling (1993) that listing property as historic is not a taking under Article I, Section X of the Pennsylvania ConstitutionU.S. Supreme Court rulings since 1978 that historic designation is not a taking under the Fifth Amendment
    Source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Testimony

    • Barbara Klaczynskasupport, person
    • Berdell Buckleyoppose, person
    • Catharine Franklinsupport, person
    • City Planning Commissionsupport, organization
    • David Mitchiesupport, person
    • David S. Traubsupport, person
    • Ellen D. Lipscombsupport, person
    • Florence Halpertneutral, person
    • Frank Weiseoppose, person
    • James D. Crawfordoppose, person
    • Jennifer Goodmansupport, person
    • Joseph Sorgersupport, person
    • Kiki Bolendersupport, person
    • Lenard L. Wolffeoppose, person
    • Lenore Millhollensupport, person
    • Margaret Baconsupport, person
    • Maria Romanachoppose, person
    • Michael Sternsupport, person
    • New Central Baptist Churchsupport, organization
    • Preservation Coalition of Greater Philadelphiasupport, organization
    • Richard Tylersupport, person
    • Rittenhouse Coalition for the Restoration of Sacred Placessupport, organization
    • Robert J. Hotessupport, person
    • Samuel Diamondoppose, person
    • Susan Maxman Architectssupport, organization