Alteration review
Architectural Committee
Committee recommendations are not final Commission decisions.
Recorded conditions
Denial as proposed; approval of revised application with smaller addition, appropriate historically accurate windows (not vinyl), with staff to review details including window and door details pursuant to Standards 6 and 9; addition may be clad in cement-based stucco or wood frame with clapboard siding; stair and elevator to be reduced in scale and oriented away from building façade
- Vote tally
- 6 Yes (denial as proposed, approval of revised application with conditions), 1 No
- Criteria cited
- Secretary of the Interior's Standard 6: Deteriorated historic features shall be repaired rather than replaced; replacement of missing features shall be substantiated by documentary, physical, or pictorial evidenceSecretary of the Interior's Standard 9: New additions/alterations shall not destroy historic materials; new work differentiated from old and compatible with massing, size, scale, and architectural features
Votes and testimony
Votes
- Allison Lukachikyes
- Amy Steinyes
- Dan McCoubreyyes
- John Cluveryes
- Justin Detwileryes
- Nan Guttermanyes
- Rudy D'Alessandrono
Testimony
- Bujar Gjokasupport, person
- Erion Peshkepiasupport, person
- Randal Baronneutral, person