Demolition review
Architectural Committee
Committee recommendations are not final Commission decisions.
Recorded conditions
Applicant must demonstrate no feasible reuse for 152 N 2nd St before demolition can be approved; structural defects at 152 N 2nd St should be addressed with repairs; rebuilding of upper floors of 148 N 2nd St acceptable if following historic preservation standards; massing must be reduced and stepped down toward Quarry Street
Prior meeting reference: 2017 reclassification application for 152 N 2nd St denied; 2018 in-concept review of development at 152-160-64 N 2nd St reviewed but no approval or denial motion adopted; Gnome Architects' 225 Quarry Street / 151 N 3rd St project previously reviewed and denied by Architectural Committee
- Vote tally
- 6 yes, 1 absent
- Criteria cited
Votes and testimony
Votes
- Allison Lukachikyes
- Amy Steinyes
- Dan McCoubreyyes
- John Cluverabsent
- Justin Detwileryes
- Nan Guttermanyes
- Rudy D'Alessandroyes
Testimony
- Derek Spencersupport, person
- Julia Haymanoppose, person
- Keeping Societyoppose, organization
- Oscar Beisertoppose, person
- Paul Steinkeoppose, person
- Preservation Allianceoppose, organization