civus
ResolutionADOPTEDCeremonial

Resolution 110588

Supporting United States Senate Resolution 185 and United State House Resolution 268 - Reaffirming the Commitment of the United States to a Negotiated Settlement of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict.

Introduced Sep 8, 2011CITY COUNCILOfficial record: City of Philadelphia via Legistar

Introduced by

Councilmember O'NeillCouncilmember GoodeCouncilmember Reynolds BrownCouncilmember KenneyCouncilmember DiCiccoCouncilmember KrajewskiCouncilmember RizzoCouncil President VernaCouncilmember GreenleeCouncilmember MillerCouncilmember BlackwellCouncilmember ClarkeCouncilmember KellyCouncilmember TascoCouncilmember Green

From the floor

Passages in the official transcripts that cite this file number. Every quote links to its exact place in the record.

  1. Reverend Bill Borror, commenting on Resolution 110588. (Witness approached witness stand.)

    Chief Clerk · Stated Meeting, September 15, 2011 · Sep 15, 2011 · official transcript, this passage

  2. Madam President, distinguished members of City Council, good morning. My name is Marc Zucker and I appreciate the opportunity to speak on behalf of the Jewish Community Relations Council of the Jewish Federation of Greater Philadelphia, which serves the needs of the Jewish community both locally and overseas with ten constituent organizations and thousands of volunteers over the course of its 72-year history engaging…

    Mr. Zucker · Stated Meeting, September 15, 2011 · Sep 15, 2011 · official transcript, this passage

  3. Madam President, Councilmembers, my name is Tom Tropp and I'm the President of the Regional Office of the American Jewish Committee. First of all, thank you for this opportunity to address you. The American Jewish Committee supports Resolution 110588. The resolution reaffirms the U.S. commitment to a negotiated settlement of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The American Jewish Committee supports the creation of a Pa…

    Mr. Tropp · Stated Meeting, September 15, 2011 · Sep 15, 2011 · official transcript, this passage

  4. Thank you, Madam Council President and Councilmembers. I'm in support of Resolution 110588. I am a Philadelphia resident. I recall 1978 when Jimmy Carter attained his greatest achievement in office. That was peace between enemies for life, peace between Israel and peace between Egypt. Anwar Sadat literally lost his life because he forged this peace agreement, because he was unfortunately assassinated three years late…

    Mr. Gordon · Stated Meeting, September 15, 2011 · Sep 15, 2011 · official transcript, this passage

  5. Thank you. My name is Howard Katzoff and I am Executive Vice-President of Congregation Shaare Shamayim within Councilman O'Neill's district. In 1967, the UN established a Resolution 242, which said security must be accomplished through negotiations so that all states can live in peace within secure borders. Israel in 1967 accepted that resolution and the Palestinians rejected it. To this day, the Palestinian Authorit…

    Mr. Katzoff · Stated Meeting, September 15, 2011 · Sep 15, 2011 · official transcript, this passage

  6. Good morning. My name is Brett Goldman and I am from Fox Chase in Northeast Philadelphia. I was asked by my fellow members of the American Jewish Committee to join them here this morning because of my experiences living in Israel over the past few years and having just returned from Israel last week on a month-long business development trip in Tel Aviv and Jerusalem. Having been in Israel during the height of the rec…

    Mr. Goldman · Stated Meeting, September 15, 2011 · Sep 15, 2011 · official transcript, this passage

Status timeline

  1. Sep 8, 2011Introduced and Ordered Placed On Next Week's Final Passage Calendar · CITY COUNCIL
  2. Sep 15, 2011ADOPTED · CITY COUNCIL

Official documents

Documents open on the City of Philadelphia’s legislative site.

Full text

Read the full text as published

..Title Supporting United States Senate Resolution 185 and United State House Resolution 268 - Reaffirming the Commitment of the United States to a Negotiated Settlement of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict. ..Body WHEREAS, The Council of the City of Philadelphia expresses its strong support of United States Senate Resolution 185, and United States House Resolution 268 (S.E. 185 and H.R. 268), each of which reaffirms the commitment of the United States to a negotiated settlement of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict through direct Israeli-Palestinian negotiations. They also reaffirms opposition to the inclusion of Hamas in a united government unless it is willing to accept peace with Israel and renounce violence and, further, it declares that they declare Congress' opposition to Palestinian efforts to gain recognition as a state through the United Nations or otherwise outside direct negotiations demonstrates absence of a good faith commitment to peace negotiations, and , and declare that such recognition will have implications for continued United States aid and diplomatic support; and WHEREAS, The policy of the United States since 2002 has been to support a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict; and WHEREAS, A true and lasting peace between the people of Israel and the Palestinians can only be achieved through direct negotiations between the parties. This was the feeling of Palestine Liberation Organization Chair Yassir Arafat, who wrote to Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin on September 9, 1993, stating that all outstanding issues relating to permanent status will be resolved through negotiations; and WHEREAS, The reconciliation agreement signed by Fatah and Hamas on May 4, 2011 was reached without Hamas being required to renounce violence, accept Israel's right to exist, and accept prior agreements made by the Palestinians (the Quartet conditions). Hamas, an organization responsible for the death of more than 500 innocent civilians, including two dozen United States citizens, has been designated by the United States Government as a foreign terrorist organization and a specially designated terrorist organization. It has violated international norms since 2006, when it kidnapped and held captive Israeli sergeant Gilad Shalit, and it continues to forcefully reject the possibility of negotiations or peace with Israel. By contrast, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has accepted expressed his acceptance of a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict; and his willingness to negotiate with the Palestinians, without preconditions; and WHEREAS, S.R. 185 and H.R. 268 express Congress' support the position of Secretary of State Hillary Clinton that the United States "will not deal with or in any way fund a Palestinian government that includes Hamas unless and until Hamas has renounced violence, recognized Israel and agreed to follow the previous obligations of the Palestinian Authority." The United States has also vetoed, under two Presidents, 11 United Nations Security Council resolutions related to this conflict and our Permanent Representative to that organization has stated that it is "unwise" for the United Nations to attempt to resolve key issues between the Israelis and Palestinians; and WHEREAS, S.R.185 and H.R. 268 both reaffirm Congress' "strong support for a negotiated solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, resulting in two states: a democratic, Jewish state of Israel and a viable, democratic, Palestinian state, living side-by-side in peace, security and mutual recognition." They state Congress' "firm belief that any Palestinian unity government must publicly and formally forswear terrorism, accept Israel's right to exist, and reaffirm previous agreements made with the state of Israel." They also reiterate Congress' "strong opposition to any attempt to establish or seek recognition of a Palestinian state outside of an agreement negotiated between Israel and the Palestinians," and Congress' support of the President's opposition to a unilateral declaration of a Palestinian state; now therefore be it, RESOLVED, BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA, That we hereby express the strong support of this legislative body for United States Senate Resolution 185 and United States House Resolution 268. We acknowledge the bipartisan and overwhelming support that both of these Resolutions received from members of Congress, including those representing the people of the City of Philadelphia. We also express our strong support for United States governmental actions that discourage both Israelis and Palestinians from pursuing unilateral steps that undermine negotiations between them. It is our hope that this strong message by the United States Congress and other legislative bodies around the nation will help bring about the peace so desperately needed in this region. FURTHER RESOLVED, That a copy of this resolution be transmitted to Ambassador Susan E. Rice, United States Permanent Representative to the United Nations, for inclusion in the official record. ..End