civus
ResolutionADOPTED

Resolution 210692

Proposing an amendment to the Philadelphia Home Rule Charter to revise the composition of the Zoning Board of Adjustment, by increasing the number of appointees, providing for confirmation by Council of appointees, and specifying qualifications that appointees must possess; and providing for the submission of the amendment to the electors of Philadelphia.

Introduced Sep 17, 2021Committee on Law and GovernmentOfficial record: City of Philadelphia via Legistar

Introduced by

Council President ClarkeCouncil President ClarkeCouncilmember ParkerCouncilmember ParkerCouncilmember Quiñones SánchezCouncilmember Quiñones SánchezCouncilmember JonesCouncilmember JonesCouncilmember GauthierCouncilmember GauthierCouncilmember BrooksCouncilmember BrooksCouncilmember BassCouncilmember BassCouncilmember GreenCouncilmember Green

How members voted

  1. Vote on Dec 16, 2021 · CITY COUNCIL

    Aye (17)

    Councilmember DombCouncilmember GreenCouncilmember GymCouncilmember OhCouncilmember SquillaCouncilmember JohnsonCouncilmember JonesCouncil President ClarkeCouncilmember HenonCouncilmember Quiñones SánchezCouncilmember BassCouncilmember ParkerCouncilmember O'NeillCouncilmember BrooksCouncilmember GauthierCouncilmember Gilmore RichardsonCouncilmember Thomas

From the floor

Passages in the official transcripts that cite this file number. Every quote links to its exact place in the record.

  1. Okay. Good morning, Council President and members of City Council. My name is Bonita Cummings and I'm the Director of Strawberry Mansion Community Concerns and a member of the Citywide RCO Coalition of Philadelphia. Dec 16, 2021 Stated Meeting December 16, 2021 The need for Resolution No. 210692 and Bill No. 210669 appealing to the electors is due to the overzealous change of the Philadelphia Zoning Code of 2011 and…

    Ms. Cummings · Stated Meeting, December 16, 2021 · Dec 16, 2021 · official transcript, this passage

  2. Hello, everyone. My name is Odessa Tate of All in the Family Dec 16, 2021 Stated Meeting December 16, 2021 CDC in Strawberry Mansion, and I'm also a member of the Citywide RCO Coalition. I'm in support of Bill No. 210669, Resolution 210692 of the ZBA reform. Democracy is for the people, and the leaders of the City have a great responsibility to its residents to ensure security, protection, and fairness. The City's Zo…

    Ms. Tate · Stated Meeting, December 16, 2021 · Dec 16, 2021 · official transcript, this passage

  3. Hello. I'm sorry. My name is Eloise Young. I'm a facilitator for the HMC Squared RCO in West Philly and I'm also a member of the Citywide RCO Coalition. I'm also a longtime -- lifelong Philadelphia resident. HMC Squared supports Bill No. 210669 and Resolution No. 210692 for the reasons outlined in the letter to City Council from the Citywide RCO Coalition as well as the letter by the 46th Ward Democratic that was jus…

    Ms. Young · Stated Meeting, December 16, 2021 · Dec 16, 2021 · official transcript, this passage

  4. Good morning. My name is Susan Nam. I'm commenting as a Mount Airy resident and activist, artist from District 8. I'm here today to continue vocalizing my support for Bill No. 210669 and Resolution 210692. There's a reminder that needs to be made about where the people have been and continue to stand in the City of Philadelphia. The movement of some but not all policymakers, developers, and active political action gr…

    Ms. Nam · Stated Meeting, December 16, 2021 · Dec 16, 2021 · official transcript, this passage

  5. Good morning. My name is Susanna Burger and I speak in opposition to Bill 210669 and Resolution 210692. The legislative process behind this bill and this resolution will have negative effects for Philadelphia, and it should be slowed down. With the new ZBA Chair, any justification for this legislation is no longer applicable and we need to wait and see how the ZBA operates under this new Chair until any restructuring…

    Ms. Burger · Stated Meeting, December 16, 2021 · Dec 16, 2021 · official transcript, this passage

  6. Hi. My name is Chris Hinkley and I'm speaking in opposition to Bill 210669 and Resolution 210692. I think the proposal will have negative impacts for Philadelphia and I think its passage should be delayed. With the new ZBA Chair, things have changed and the legislation needs to be slowed down. We need to see how the new ZBA Chair operates with the ZBA until any restructuring decisions are made. And I'm afraid if the…

    Mr. Hinkley · Stated Meeting, December 16, 2021 · Dec 16, 2021 · official transcript, this passage

Status timeline

  1. Sep 17, 2021Introduced and Referred · CITY COUNCIL
  2. Dec 6, 2021HEARING NOTICES SENT · Committee on Law and Government
  3. Dec 6, 2021HEARING HELD · Committee on Law and Government
  4. Dec 6, 2021AMENDED · Committee on Law and Government
  5. Dec 6, 2021REPORTED FAVORABLY · Committee on Law and Government
  6. Dec 9, 2021ORDERED PLACED ON FINAL PASSAGE CALENDAR FOR NEXT MEETING. · CITY COUNCIL
  7. Dec 16, 2021ADOPTED · CITY COUNCIL

Official documents

Documents open on the City of Philadelphia’s legislative site.

Full text

Read the full text as published

..Title Proposing an amendment to the Philadelphia Home Rule Charter to revise the composition of the Zoning Board of Adjustment, by increasing the number of appointees, providing for confirmation by Council of appointees, and specifying qualifications that appointees must possess; and providing for the submission of the amendment to the electors of Philadelphia. ..Body WHEREAS, The City's Zoning Code is of fundamental importance to all Philadelphians. It defines the physical backbone of the City by regulating how land may be used; by determining the size, height, and type of buildings; and by stating what activities are permitted within those buildings. It profoundly affects the well-being of all who live and work here, and it shapes the growth of our communities for decades to come; and WHEREAS, The Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA) is a critical component of the City's Zoning Code, with the authority to grant "variances" -- exceptions to the requirements of the Zoning Code - that can permanently change the character of a neighborhood; and WHEREAS, It is essential to ensure that the ZBA execute its authority in as professional a manner as possible, with the on-board expertise and institutional support necessary to arrive at consistent, well-reasoned decisions when considering requests for variances; and WHEREAS, The Administration has recommended administrative measures to further support the ZBA's capacity, including, for example, mandatory training, physical improvements to ZBA facilities, and additional administrative support from City Planning Commission staff; and WHEREAs, As part of this essential reform, Council has concluded that the composition of the ZBA itself needs to be revised by (1) increasing the size of the board from five to seven members, all of whom would continue to be appointed by the Mayor; (2) providing for Council confirmation of these appointments; and (3) requiring that the ZBA include members who possess specified areas of expertise and members who are recognized leaders from community organizations; and WHEREAS, Under Section 6 of the First Class City Home Rule Act (53 P.S. Section 13106), an amendment to the Philadelphia Home Rule Charter may be proposed by a resolution of the Council of the City of Philadelphia adopted with the concurrence of two-thirds of its elected members; now, therefore, be it RESOLVED, BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA, That the following amendment to the Philadelphia Home Rule Charter is hereby proposed and shall be submitted to the electors of the City on an election date designated by ordinance: Strikethrough indicates matter deleted by these amendments. Italics indicates matter added by these amendments. ARTICLE III EXECUTIVE AND ADMINISTRATIVE BRANCH - ORGANIZATION * * * CHAPTER 9 DEPARTMENTAL BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS * * * � 3-911. Zoning Board of Adjustment. The Zoning Board of Adjustment shall be composed of five appointed seven members appointed by the Mayor with the advice and consent of a majority of all the members of City Council. All members shall have a demonstrated sensitivity to community concerns regarding development and the protection of the character of Philadelphia's neighborhoods. The members shall include an urban planner, an architect, an attorney with zoning experience, a person with experience in the construction industry, and at least two recognized leaders from community organizations. The Director of Planning and Development shall be an alternate member who may replace any absent or disqualified appointed member. * * * APPENDIX * * * CHAPTER A-2 � A-200 Schedule. This Charter shall become effective on the first Monday of January, 1952, except in the following particulars: * * * (19) Zoning Board of Adjustment. The amendment to this Charter relating to the Zoning Board of Adjustment and adopted by the voters at the May 17, 2022 election shall take effect October 1, 2022. Nominations of the Mayor's appointees shall be transmitted to Council for Council's advice and consent no later than the second stated session of Council occurring thereafter. Appointees serving on the Board immediately prior to the effective date of this amendment shall continue to serve until their replacements or reappointment have been confirmed by Council. * * * ..End