Resolution 240764
Condemning the Supreme Court’s decision to allow the criminalization of homelessness in Grants Pass v. Johnson, and reaffirming the City of Philadelphia’s commitment to housing as a human right.
Introduced by
From the floor
Passages in the official transcripts that cite this file number. Every quote links to its exact place in the record.
“Good morning. My name is Eric Tars and I serve as the Senior Policy Director at the National Homelessness Law Center where I helped to organize the national support for Gloria Johnson and her fellow homeless plaintiffs in the Johnson versus Grants Pass case at the Supreme Court. And I'm also a proud Philadelphia resident. In short, despite widespread understanding that everybody needs a safe place to sleep, the Supre…”
Mr. Tars · Stated Meeting, September 26, 2024 · Sep 26, 2024 · official transcript, this passage
“Hello. My name is Sterling Johnson. I'm from Philadelphia Community Land Trust in Philadelphia Housing Action. I'm here to support Councilperson Brooks' Resolution 240764 condemning the Grants Pass decision from the Supreme Court. First, I don't want to forget this, the reason that we're here is to support families, mostly Black and Latinx families and my organizing. I'm going to shout out justice for the Mitchell ch…”
Mr. Johnson · Stated Meeting, September 26, 2024 · Sep 26, 2024 · official transcript, this passage
“The ayes have it. The motion carries and the resolution is adopted. Will the Clerk please read the title of Resolution No. 240764. 9/26/24 - STATED - 2ND READING”
Council President Johnson · Stated Meeting, September 26, 2024 · Sep 26, 2024 · official transcript, this passage
“The Chair recognizes Councilmember Brooks for a motion regarding Resolution No. 240764.”
Council President Johnson · Stated Meeting, September 26, 2024 · Sep 26, 2024 · official transcript, this passage
“It has been moved and properly seconded that Resolution No. 240764 be adopted. All those in favor of the motion will signify by saying aye. (Aye.) 9/26/24 - STATED - 2ND READING”
Council President Johnson · Stated Meeting, September 26, 2024 · Sep 26, 2024 · official transcript, this passage
Status timeline
- Sep 12, 2024Introduced and Ordered Placed On Next Week's Final Passage Calendar · CITY COUNCIL
- Sep 26, 2024ADOPTED · CITY COUNCIL
Official documents
Documents open on the City of Philadelphia’s legislative site.
Full text
Read the full text as published
..Title Condemning the Supreme Court's decision to allow the criminalization of homelessness in Grants Pass v. Johnson, and reaffirming the City of Philadelphia's commitment to housing as a human right. ..Body WHEREAS, The United States Supreme Court issued a ruling in the case of Grants Pass v. Johnson, permitting the city of Grants Pass to criminalize people who do not have homes, even though there were no open shelter beds; and WHEREAS, That ruling came in spite of a long history of Supreme Court precedent prohibiting the criminalization of a status, such as addiction or homelessness. When cities do not have enough beds for every person experiencing homelessness, ordinances criminalizing camping inherently criminalize people who do not have beds. Cities that follow these ordinances are throwing people into jail for simply not having a bed to sleep in; and WHEREAS, Research has conclusively shown that the best long-term and most cost-effective solution to problems related to homelessness is a housing-first approach that prioritizes deeply affordable housing and placing people in long-term supportive housing environments. Incarceration leads to problems like inability to secure housing or a job, and forced treatment programs double the risk of death for people suffering from addiction; and WHEREAS, Media coverage from The Kensington Voice has highlighted some of the brutal consequences of criminalization; 34 people were arrested, with the Philadelphia Department of Prisons prepared for intake. Those arrested did not receive social services; and WHEREAS, People suffering from addiction are at increased risk of death when incarcerated; One of the 34 people arrested, Amanda Cahill, died in a Philadelphia jail a few days later; and WHEREAS, These predictable consequences of criminalizing homelessness and addiction can only be mitigated through comprehensive housing, public health infrastructure and investments; not jails and incarceration. Disappearing people does not help our communities, and criminalizing homelessness is contrary to the principles of love that drove the founding of this City; and WHEREAS, Philadelphia has an opportunity to demonstrate how cities can support every person, help people receive support when they need it, and provide the space to ensure problems rooted in lack of housing are not continuously repeated. A radically conservative Supreme Court cannot be the guiding light on how Philadelphia treats the people who live here; now, therefore, be it RESOLVED, THAT THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA, Condemns the Supreme Court's decision to allow the criminalization of homelessness in Grants Pass v. Johnson, and reaffirms the City of Philadelphia's commitment to housing as a human right. ..End