civus

Property profile

214 VINE ST

OPA 88100006228 linked recordsCouncil district 1

Actor profiles are grouped by kind and normalized name. Two people with the same name may appear together in this first version.

Zoned CMX-3Commercial/Commercial Mixed-Use
View on Atlas
Owner
VINE NEW ASSOCIATES LLC
ZIP code
19106
Year built
2023
Market value
$7,161,400

Historic

Designation status and decisions from the historic property record.

18 decisions
Historic address
2-16 VINE STREET (THE JAYNE ESTATE BUILDING), 2-16 VINE STREET, 208 210 AND 212 VINE STREET AND 207 209 AND 211 NEW STREET, JAYNE ESTATE BUILDING 2-16 VINE STREET, 2-16 VINE STREET (JAYNE ESTATE BUILDING), 208 210 AND 212 VINE STREET; 207 209 AND 211 NEW STREET, 214-20 VINE STREET
Year built
2023
Building description
NON PD PKG LOT COMMERCIAL
Owner
VINE NEW ASSOCIATES LLC
  1. NominationApproved
    Vote tally
    unanimous
    Criteria cited
    Sole remnant of nineteenth century commercial development along the waterfrontImportant example of work of architect John McArthur, Jr.Only known warehouse structure by McArthurAdvanced form of warehouse design with eight separate units unified behind single grand facadeResulted from Jayne Trust, estate of important Philadelphia patent medicine magnate Dr. David Jayne
    Source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Votes

    • Caroline Golabyes
    • David Baldingeryes
    • David Brownleeyes
    • Ira Myersyes
    • Janet Klein Hymanyes
    • Richard Tyleryes
    • Sandra Tatmanyes
  2. NominationApproved
    Vote tally
    Unanimous
    Criteria cited
    Significance as 19th-century commercial buildingOnly surviving example of its kind on Delaware AvenueNational Register criteria
    Source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Testimony

    • David Brownleesupport, person
  3. Alteration reviewNo decision
    Source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Testimony

    • Theodore T. Bartley, Jr.support, person
  5. Alteration reviewApproved
    Source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Testimony

    • Theodore T. Bartley, Jr.support, person
  8. Demolition reviewDeferred
    Vote tally
    Unanimous
    Criteria cited
    Financial hardshipInability to secure financingCarrying costsPublic nuisance violationPre-purchase knowledge of historic designation eligibilityDemolition by neglectNational Register of Historic Places listing
    Source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Testimony

    • Dayl Pearsonsupport, person
    • Old City Civic Associationoppose, organization
    • Penelope H. Batcheleroppose, person
    • Randal Baronneutral, person
    • Richard Goldsteinsupport, person
    • Roger Prichardoppose, person
  9. Demolition reviewDeferred
    Source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Testimony

    • James Cuoratoneutral, person
  10. OtherNo decision
    Criteria cited
    Historical significanceFinancial hardship claimPublic policy concernsStructural conditionArchitectural importance as nineteenth-century Delaware Avenue waterfront commerceIncome tax credit eligibilityFacade easement
    Source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Testimony

    • Dayl Pearsonsupport, person
    • Jason Nathanneutral, person
    • Michael Kearneyoppose, person
    • Roger Prichardoppose, person
    • Scott Wildsneutral, person
  11. Demolition reviewDeferred
    Vote tally
    unanimous
    Criteria cited
    Financial hardship analysis requiredEconomic viability of reuse optionsIncome tax credit availabilityFacade easement options
    Source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Votes

    • David Brownleeyes
    • David Hollenbergyes
    • Edward A. Montgomery, Jr.yes
    • Jason Nathanyes
    • Reverend William D. Thompsonyes
    • Scott Wildsyes
  12. Demolition reviewApproved
    Vote tally
    Unanimous
    Criteria cited
    Financial hardshipEconomic viability of rehabilitationInability to obtain financing for preservation scheme during favorable marketSale of property practicabilityCurrent market conditions and real estate downturnAssessment by independent appraiser Reaves Lukens
    Source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Votes

    • Barbara Kaplanyes
    • Edward A. Montgomery, Jr.yes
    • Jason Nathanyes

    Testimony

    • B.T. Waterfront, Inc.support, organization
    • Daryl Pearsonsupport, person
    • Gray Smithoppose, person
    • Old City Civic Associationoppose, organization
    • Richard W. Thomoppose, person
    • Roger Prichardoppose, person
    • William Bladesneutral, person
  13. Demolition reviewApproved
    Vote tally
    Financial hardship report adopted 10-2; demolition permit approved 4-3 with 1 abstention
    Criteria cited
    Financial hardshipSection 14-2007 of the Philadelphia CodeHistoric American Buildings Survey
    Source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Votes

    • Barbara Kaplanyes
    • David Brownleeno
    • David Hollenbergno
    • Edward A. Montgomery, Jr.yes
    • Jason Nathanyes
    • Reverend William D. Thompsonyes
    • Scott Wildsno
    • Stephanie Wolfabstain

    Testimony

    • Dayl Pearsonsupport, person
    • Gray Smithoppose, person
    • Howard Kittelloppose, person
    • Old City Civic Associationoppose, organization
    • Preservation Coalition of Greater Philadelphiaoppose, organization
    • Roger Prichardoppose, person
  14. Demolition reviewApproved
    Vote tally
    9-2
    Criteria cited
    Financial hardshipGood faith effort by owner to rehabilitatePenn Central constitutional taking testNo viable use currentlyNo Transfer of Development Rights program available
    Source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Votes

    • Barbara Kaplanyes
    • Christine Washingtonyes
    • David Brownleeno
    • David Hollenbergno
    • David Wismeryes
    • Edward A. Montgomery, Jr.yes
    • Jason Nathanyes
    • Scott Wildsyes
    • Stephanie Wolfyes
    • William Brownyes

    Testimony

    • Barbara Kaplansupport, person
    • Gray Smithoppose, person
    • Howard Kittelloppose, person
    • John Streetsupport, person
    • Old City Civic Associationoppose, organization
    • Preservation Coalition of Greater Philadelphiaoppose, organization
    • Richard Tylerneutral, person
    • Roger Prichardoppose, person
  15. Alteration reviewApproved
    Vote tally
    Majority voted to recommend approval with conditions
    Criteria cited
    Source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Votes

    • Amy Steinyes
    • Dan McCoubreyyes
    • Dominique Hawkinsno
    • Nan Guttermanno
    • Rudy D'Alessandroyes
    • Suzanne Pentzyes

    Testimony

    • Ben Leechneutral, person
    • Eve Parrotsupport, person
    • Rich Thomsupport, person
    • Stuart Rosenbergsupport, person
  16. Alteration reviewApproved
    Vote tally
    unanimous
    Criteria cited
    Source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Votes

    • Anuj Guptayes
    • Betty Turneryes
    • Dominique Hawkinsyes
    • JoAnn Jonesyes
    • John Mattioniyes
    • R. David Schaafyes
    • Ralph DiPietroyes
    • Robert Thomasyes
    • Sam Sherman Jr.yes
    • Sara Merrimanyes
    • Thomas McDadeyes
  17. Alteration reviewDenied
    Vote tally
    6-0
    Criteria cited
    Source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Votes

    • Amy Steinyes
    • Dan McCoubreyyes
    • John Cluveryes
    • Justin Detwileryes
    • Nan Guttermanyes
    • Rudy D'Alessandroyes

    Testimony

    • Franklin Bridge North Neighborsoppose, organization
    • Gary Vernickoppose, person
    • Julie Morningstarsupport, person
    • Robert Gurmankinoppose, person

Linked public records

Records are sorted by date and cite the basis for each property link.

  1. DatasetLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    L&I violation VI-2025-039553 at 214 VINE ST
    Philadelphia L&I Violations
    View on Atlas
  2. DatasetLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    L&I violation VI-2025-039555 at 214 VINE ST
    Philadelphia L&I Violations
    View on Atlas
  3. DatasetLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Rental license 0955572 at 214 VINE ST
    Philadelphia L&I Business Licenses
    View on Atlas
  4. DatasetLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Building permit EP-2021-012684 — 214 VINE ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCompleted
    View on Atlas
  5. DatasetLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Building permit MP-2021-007215 — 214 VINE ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCompleted
    View on Atlas
  6. DatasetLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Building permit PP-2021-020884 — 214 VINE ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCompleted
    View on Atlas
  7. DatasetLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Building permit FP-2021-001794 — 214 VINE ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCompleted
    View on Atlas
  8. DatasetLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Building permit CP-2020-006382 — 214 VINE ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCompleted
    View on Atlas
  9. DatasetLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Building permit ZP-2021-002698 — 214 VINE ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCompleted
    View on Atlas
  10. DatasetLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Building permit ZP-2020-006870 — 214 VINE ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCompleted
    View on Atlas
  11. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Historical Commission — Nov 13, 2020
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionno_decision
  12. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Architectural Committee — Oct 27, 2020
    Philadelphia Historical Commissiondenied
  13. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Historical Commission — Jul 11, 2014
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionapproved
  14. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Architectural Committee — Jun 24, 2014
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionapproved
  15. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Historical Commission — Oct 9, 1991
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionapproved
  16. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Historical Commission — Sep 11, 1991
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionapproved
  17. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Committee on Financial Hardship — Sep 5, 1991
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionapproved
  18. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Historical Commission — Jun 12, 1991
    Philadelphia Historical Commissiondeferred
  19. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Committee on Financial Hardship — Jun 3, 1991
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionno_decision
  20. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Historical Commission — May 8, 1991
    Philadelphia Historical Commissiondeferred
  21. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Architectural Committee — Mar 28, 1991
    Philadelphia Historical Commissiondeferred
  22. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Architectural Committee — Aug 25, 1988
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionno_decision
  23. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Historical Commission — May 11, 1988
    Philadelphia Historical Commissiondeferred
  24. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Architectural Committee — Apr 28, 1988
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionapproved
  25. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Historical Commission — Jan 27, 1988
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionno_decision
  26. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Architectural Committee — Jan 14, 1988
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionno_decision
  27. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Historical Commission — Oct 28, 1987
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionapproved
  28. HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidence
    Committee on Historic Designation — Oct 2, 1987
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionapproved