civus

Property profile

145 SUMAC ST

OPA 21302473035 linked recordsCouncil district 4
Applicant: HAL SCHIRMER, ESQ.Overlapping RCO: 21st Ward Democratic CommitteeOverlapping RCO: Friends of the WissahickonOverlapping RCO: Wissahickon Interested Citizens Association

Different people can share a name and appear on the same profile.

About these name links

Actor profiles are grouped by kind and normalized name. Two people with the same name may appear together in this first version.

Zoned RSA-5Residential/Residential Mixed-Use
View on Atlas
Owner
BAUMGARDNER HEATHER
ZIP code
19128
Year built
1920
Market value
$544,400

Historic

Designation status and decisions from the historic property record.

5 decisions
Historic address
145 SUMAC STREET, 145 SUMAC STREET (HOLT HOUSE)
Year built
1920
Building description
SEMI/DET 2.5 STY MASONRY
Owner
BAUMGARDNER HEATHER / MARCIN ROBERT J

Source links open full minutes. Exact passages have not been matched to these records.

  1. Nomination

    Document type: DC

    Recorded outcomeNo decision

    Recorded conditions

    Owner applied for demolition permit prior to nomination notice — Commission has no authority to review; attorney requested tabling pending expert review; nomination for twin at 147 Sumac Street to be heard at next Committee meeting; nomination for 147 previously submitted, withdrawn, and resubmitted too late for this agenda

    Criteria cited
    Full source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Testimony

    • Jeffrey Allegrettisupport, person
    • John Mantonsupport, person
    • John Messingoppose, person
    • Joseph Menkevichneutral, person
    • Leonard F. Reuteroppose, person

  2. Nomination

    Document type: DC

    Recorded outcomeApproved

    Recorded conditions

    Designation applies to the parcel containing the building at 145 Sumac Street only; 150 Kalos Street parcel excluded due to notice concerns.

    Prior meeting reference: Committee on Historic Designation meeting of 26 March 2015

    Criteria cited
    Full source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Testimony

    • Bonnie Wilkinson Markoppose, person
    • David Orphanidesoppose, person
    • Deborah Gribben-Zameskaoppose, person
    • Hal Schirmersupport, person
    • Jeffrey Allegrettisupport, person
    • John Mantonsupport, person
    • John Messingoppose, person
    • Joseph Menkevichsupport, person
    • Leonard F. Reuteroppose, person
    • Oscar Beisertsupport, person
    • Patrick Grossisupport, person
    • Steve D'Agostinooppose, person
    • Wissahickon Interested Citizens Associationsupport, organization

  3. Nomination

    Committee on Historic Designation

    Recorded outcomeDeferred

    Committee recommendations are not final Commission decisions.

    Recorded conditions

    Remanded to future Committee on Historic Designation meeting; property owner and equitable owner jointly requested continuance

    Prior meeting reference: 10 July 2015 Historical Commission meeting; tabled at that time

    Vote tally
    6-0
    Criteria cited
    Full source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Votes

    • Bruce Lavertyyes
    • Douglas Mooneyyes
    • Elizabeth Milroyyes
    • Emily Coopermanyes
    • Jeff Cohenyes
    • Suzanna Baruccoyes

  4. Nomination

    Historical Commission

    Recorded outcomeDeferred

    Recorded conditions

    Remanded to 15 January 2020 Committee on Historic Designation meeting

    Prior meeting reference: 10 July 2015 meeting; tabled since 2015

    Vote tally
    13-0-0
    Criteria cited
    Full source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Votes

    • Betty Turneryes
    • Dan McCoubreyyes
    • Emily Coopermanyes
    • H. Ahada Stanfordyes
    • Jessica Sánchezyes
    • John Mattioniyes
    • Josh Lippertyes
    • Kelly Edwardsyes
    • Kimberly Washingtonyes
    • Melissa Longyes
    • Meredith Tregoyes
    • Robert Thomasyes
    • Steven Hartneryes

  5. Nomination

    Committee on Historic Designation

    Recorded outcomeApproved

    Committee recommendations are not final Commission decisions.

    Recorded conditions

    Designate under Criteria A, D, and J; period of significance amended to end at 1940

    Prior meeting reference: 10 July 2015 Historical Commission meeting — nomination tabled

    Vote tally
    4 yes, 2 absent
    Criteria cited
    Full source minutes
    Votes and testimony

    Votes

    • Bruce Lavertyyes
    • Douglas Mooneyyes
    • Elizabeth Milroyabsent
    • Emily Coopermanyes
    • Jeff Cohenabsent
    • Suzanna Baruccoyes

    Testimony

    • Heather Baumgardnerneutral, person
    • Kim Chantryneutral, person

Linked public records

Records are sorted by date and cite the basis for each property link.

  1. HearingLinked by address
    Historical Commission — Feb 14, 2020
    Philadelphia Historical Commission

    Check the source for how this record relates to the property.

    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    crosswalk_address
    Stored score:
    95% confidence
  2. HearingLinked by address
    Architectural Committee — Jan 28, 2020
    Philadelphia Historical Commission

    Check the source for how this record relates to the property.

    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    crosswalk_address
    Stored score:
    95% confidence
  3. HearingLinked by address
    Committee on Historic Designation — Jan 15, 2020
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionapproved

    Check the source for how this record relates to the property.

    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    crosswalk_address
    Stored score:
    95% confidence
  4. HearingLinked by parcel number
    Committee on Historic Designation — Jan 15, 2020
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionapproved
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  5. HearingLinked by address
    Historical Commission — Dec 13, 2019
    Philadelphia Historical Commissiondeferred

    Check the source for how this record relates to the property.

    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    crosswalk_address
    Stored score:
    95% confidence
  6. HearingLinked by parcel number
    Historical Commission — Dec 13, 2019
    Philadelphia Historical Commissiondeferred
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  7. HearingLinked by address
    Committee on Historic Designation — Nov 13, 2019
    Philadelphia Historical Commissiondeferred

    Check the source for how this record relates to the property.

    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    crosswalk_address
    Stored score:
    95% confidence
  8. HearingLinked by parcel number
    Committee on Historic Designation — Nov 13, 2019
    Philadelphia Historical Commissiondeferred
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  9. HearingLinked by address
    Historical Commission — Apr 13, 2017
    Philadelphia Historical Commission

    Check the source for how this record relates to the property.

    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    crosswalk_address
    Stored score:
    95% confidence
  10. Linked by parcel number
    Building permit 673580 — 145 SUMAC ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCOMPLETED
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  11. Linked by parcel number
    Building permit 671004 — 145 SUMAC ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCOMPLETED
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  12. Linked by parcel number
    Building permit 667209 — 145 SUMAC ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCOMPLETED
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  13. Linked by parcel number
    Building permit 666777 — 145 SUMAC ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCOMPLETED
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  14. Linked by parcel number
    Building permit 646514 — 145 SUMAC ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCOMPLETED
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  15. Linked by parcel number
    Building permit 649586 — 145 SUMAC ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCOMPLETED
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  16. Linked by parcel number
    L&I demolition 649586 at 145 SUMAC ST
    Philadelphia L&I DemolitionsCOMPLETED
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  17. Linked by parcel number
    Building permit 647318 — 145 SUMAC ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCOMPLETED
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  18. Linked by parcel number
    L&I violation 3741637 at 145 SUMAC ST
    Philadelphia L&I Violations
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  19. Linked by parcel number
    L&I violation 3741635 at 145 SUMAC ST
    Philadelphia L&I Violations
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  20. Linked by parcel number
    L&I violation 3741638 at 145 SUMAC ST
    Philadelphia L&I Violations
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  21. Linked by parcel number
    Building permit 636404 — 145 SUMAC ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCOMPLETED
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  22. Linked by parcel number
    Building permit 637560 — 145 SUMAC ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCOMPLETED
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  23. HearingLinked by address
    Historical Commission — Jul 10, 2015
    Philadelphia Historical Commission

    Check the source for how this record relates to the property.

    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    crosswalk_address
    Stored score:
    95% confidence
  24. HearingLinked by address
    DC — Jun 9, 2015
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionapproved

    Check the source for how this record relates to the property.

    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    crosswalk_address
    Stored score:
    95% confidence
  25. HearingLinked by parcel number
    DC — Jun 9, 2015
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionapproved
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  26. Linked by parcel number
    Building permit 614141 — 145 SUMAC ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCOMPLETED
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  27. Linked by parcel number
    Building permit 611453 — 145 SUMAC ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCOMPLETED
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  28. Linked by parcel number
    Building permit 589948 — 145 SUMAC ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsEXPIRED
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  29. Linked by parcel number
    Building permit 589945 — 145 SUMAC ST
    L&I permits on hearing parcelsCOMPLETED
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  30. HearingLinked by address
    Historical Commission — Apr 10, 2015
    Philadelphia Historical Commission

    Check the source for how this record relates to the property.

    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    crosswalk_address
    Stored score:
    95% confidence
  31. HearingLinked by address
    DC — Mar 26, 2015
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionno_decision

    Check the source for how this record relates to the property.

    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    crosswalk_address
    Stored score:
    95% confidence
  32. HearingLinked by parcel number
    DC — Mar 26, 2015
    Philadelphia Historical Commissionno_decision
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  33. Linked by parcel number
    L&I violation 3262340 at 145 SUMAC ST
    Philadelphia L&I Violations
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  34. Linked by parcel number
    L&I violation 2683283 at 145 SUMAC ST
    Philadelphia L&I Violations
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence
  35. Linked by parcel number
    ZBA appeal 25265 at 145 SUMAC ST
    L&I appealswithdrawn
    View on Atlas
    Link details

    This is the stored score for the link between this record and the property.

    Method:
    opa_exact
    Stored score:
    100% confidence