InformationalNo decision
Property profile
9504 JAMES ST
OPA 88865131828 linked records
Actor profiles are grouped by kind and normalized name. Two people with the same name may appear together in this first version.
Zoned RTA-1Residential/Residential Mixed-Use
- Owner
- MCCARTHY BRENDAN
- ZIP code
- 19114
- Year built
- 1987
- Market value
- $252,900
Historic
Designation status and decisions from the historic property record.
- Historic address
- 4137-4141 MAIN STREET NE CORNER OF JAMES STREET, 2134 STREET. JAMES STREET ENGLISH VILLAGE, 2141 STREET. JAMES STREET, 1220-1222 STREET. JAMES STREET SHARP'SOUTH COURT, 2127 STREET JAMES STREET, 2127 STREET. JAMES STREET, 2201 STREET. JAMES STREET, 701-711 STREET. JAMES STREET, STREET. JAMES STREET, 2134 STREET. JAMES STREET, 2131 STREET JAMES STREET, 2137 STREET. JAMES STREET, 2141 STREET JAMES STREET
- Year built
- 1987
- Building description
- RES CONDO 2 STY MAS+OTH
- Owner
- MCCARTHY BRENDAN
- Demolition reviewNo decision
- Vote tally
- unanimous
- Criteria cited
- Structural deteriorationImminent danger
Votes and testimony
Votes
- David Hollenbergyes
- Herbert Levyyes
- John Dickeyyes
- Penelope H. Batcheleryes
- Richard Tyleryes
- Theodore T. Bartley, Jr.yes
Testimony
- Nicholas L. Gianopoulossupport, person
- Alteration reviewDeferred
- Vote tally
- Committee voted against making any recommendation; review to be reopened at 29 August Committee meeting
- Criteria cited
- Insufficient documentation (no scaled drawings, missing photographs)Proposed work to all four major facadesDemolition of 1927 two-story addition on Van Pelt Street facadeStability of proposed freestanding walls without foundationDestruction of original fabric (masonry cut for French doors)Sunshine Law requirements for public process
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Bernard Nearyoppose, person
- Bobbye Burkeoppose, person
- Center City Residents Association (CCRA), Historic District Committeeoppose, organization
- Jennifer Goodmanneutral, person
- Marion Rogelsupport, person
- Alteration reviewDeferred
- Vote tally
- No vote taken
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Marion Ruth Rogelneutral, person
- Alteration reviewDeferred
- Vote tally
- postponed one month
- Criteria cited
- Preservation of built street wallArchitectural completenessBalancing property owner interests
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Bobbye Burkeoppose, person
- Henry Magazineroppose, person
- Judith Edenneutral, person
- Marion Rogelsupport, person
- William Fisheroppose, person
- Alteration reviewDeferred
- Vote tally
- no vote taken
- Alteration reviewApproved
- Vote tally
- Voted to recommend approval of reduction of Van Pelt Street addition to 8' wall with second floor french balcony; voted to recommend denial of french doors on south facade with requirement that new doors fit the opening
- Criteria cited
- Compatibility of french doors with original opening size on south facadeNon-matching brick and mortar infill inappropriateVisibility of bracing and mechanical systems from public right-of-wayRequirement for historically accurate window replacementsZoning variance required for 8' garden wall
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Bobbye Burkeneutral, person
- Center City Residents Association (CCRA)neutral, organization
- David Feldmansupport, person
- Judith Edenneutral, person
- Alteration reviewApproved
- Vote tally
- unanimous
- Criteria cited
- Preservation of historic opening configurationsCompatibility with English Village residential characterAppropriate rehabilitation methodsHistoric precedent in similar buildings
Votes and testimony
Votes
- Arlene Matzkinyes
- Barbara Kaplanyes
- David Brownleeyes
- Duane Bumbyes
- Joseph Jamesyes
- Scott Wildsyes
- Susan Rabinovitchyes
- Wayne Spiloveyes
Testimony
- Center City Residents Associationsupport, organization
- David Feldmansupport, person
- Marion Ruth Rogelsupport, person
- NominationApproved
- NominationApproved
- Alteration reviewApproved
- Criteria cited
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Nikki Marxsupport, person
- NominationApproved
- Alteration reviewDenied
- Vote tally
- Lattice denied 3-1; pergola and planting box denied unanimously; planting area with bluestone curb approved
- Criteria cited
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Bernard Neareysupport, person
- Elsie Faulconeroppose, person
- Heather Ascheroppose, person
- Jules Zacheroppose, person
- Marion Rogelsupport, person
- Michael Shafferoppose, person
- Nikki Marxoppose, person
- NominationApproved
- Alteration reviewApproved
- Vote tally
- Unanimous
- Criteria cited
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Mario Prestasupport, person
- Nelson Batyckisupport, person
- Alteration reviewApproved
- Vote tally
- Majority (McCoubrey dissenting in preference for wood windows)
Votes and testimony
Votes
- Dan McCoubreyno
Testimony
- Michael Aschersupport, person
- Tim Kernersupport, person
- Alteration reviewApproved
- Vote tally
- unanimous
Votes and testimony
Votes
- Daniel Quinnyes
- David Amburnyes
- David Schaafyes
- Joan Schlotterbeckyes
- John Mattioniyes
- Robert Thomasyes
- Rosalie Leonardyes
- Sam Shermanyes
- Sara Merrimanyes
- Scott Wildsyes
Testimony
- Tim Kernersupport, person
- Alteration reviewApproved
- Criteria cited
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Michael Aschersupport, person
- Tim Kernersupport, person
- Alteration reviewApproved
- Vote tally
- Unanimous (Consent Agenda)
Votes and testimony
Votes
- Daniel Quinnyes
- David Schaafyes
- Dominique Hawkinsyes
- Joan Schlotterbeckyes
- John Mattioniyes
- Miles Wilsonyes
- Robert Thomasyes
- Rosalie Leonardyes
- Sam Shermanyes
- Sara Merrimanyes
- Susan O. W. Jaffeyes
- Alteration reviewApproved
- Vote tally
- Unanimous
- Criteria cited
- Roofs Guideline
Votes and testimony
Votes
- Daniel Quinnyes
- David Schaafyes
- Dominique Hawkinsyes
- Joan Schlotterbeckyes
- John Mattioniyes
- Richardson Dilworth IIIyes
- Rosalie Leonardyes
- Sara Merrimanyes
- Susan O.W. Jaffeyes
Testimony
- James Campbellsupport, person
- Alteration reviewApproved
- Vote tally
- Committee voted to recommend denial of added stucco layer and chimney stucco, approval of storm door
- Criteria cited
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Tim Kernersupport, person
- Alteration reviewDenied
- Criteria cited
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Elsbeth Brownsupport, person
- Steven Cohensupport, person
- Alteration reviewDenied
- Vote tally
- Not explicitly recorded; staff recommendation of denial, per prior Committee recommendation
- Criteria cited
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Steven Cohensupport, person
- Alteration reviewDenied
- Vote tally
- Unanimous
- Criteria cited
- Standards 2Standards 9
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Steven Cohensupport, person
- Alteration reviewApproved
- Criteria cited
Votes and testimony
Testimony
- Amy Steinneutral, person
- Ben Sabaghsupport, person
- Nan Guttermanneutral, person
- Rudy D'Alessandroneutral, person
- Suzanne Pentzneutral, person
- Alteration reviewApproved
- Vote tally
- Unanimous
- Criteria cited
Votes and testimony
Votes
- Antonio Fiol-Silvayes
- Anuj Guptayes
- Betty Turneryes
- Dan McCoubreyyes
- Emily Coopermanyes
- John Mattioniyes
- Michael Finkyes
- R. David Schaafyes
- Rachel Royeryes
- Robert Thomasyes
- Steven Hartneryes
Testimony
- Ben Sabaghsupport, person
- NominationNo decision
- NominationDeferred
Linked public records
Records are sorted by date and cite the basis for each property link.
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissiondeferred
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionno_decision
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissiondenied
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissiondenied
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissiondenied
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissiondenied
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionapproved
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissiondeferred
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissiondeferred
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissiondeferred
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissiondeferred
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionno_decision
- HearingLinked by parcel number100% confidencePhiladelphia Historical Commissionno_decision