civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - June 3, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jun 3, 20266h 30m

you're not going to have any. You're not showing on this that there's.

Similar wording

may i uh speak yes yes so i do have uh some you see where it says the sink and everything

Similar wording

espresso machine to the left of that before the uh as you can see storage there's a storage room

Similar wording

uh in the closet so i had storage there in which i keep a lot of items and then i also have some

Similar wording

cabinets uh across that i keep some uh cups and and stuff of the matter just a general note it

Similar wording

be helpful if the plan was to scale because i think right now i'm assuming that your uh your

Similar wording

tiles are one by twos but they're like things are not all the same size it also looks like the pan

Similar wording

the plan has been manipulated it's so it's also it looks misleading um and in the hand wash station

Similar wording

being behind the ice cream freesia makes it seem unlikely that a person's going to wash their hands

Similar wording

yeah i mean the the plans were uh not architecturally prepared so we we do understand that

Similar wording

it's a little a little bit uh confusing on some of the items uh mateo more that it's misleading

Similar wording

understood it's just misleading each of those tables are shown right now with like less than

Similar wording

six inches between them no chairs and they're only like depicted at about a foot and a half wide so

Similar wording

So, like, that's not what it would be in real space.

Similar wording

So it does make me wonder about egress, access to doorways, access to bathroom, access to the stairwell, the basement, to have, like, clear circulation path through here as well.

Similar wording

Both ice cream and coffee are things that tend to have long lines.

Similar wording

So I just question the flow, the way it's drawn.

Similar wording

Hey, and you guys thought I was rough.

Similar wording

uh mathel do you uh so so uh zen why don't yeah why don't we consider doing this why don't you

Similar wording

you know go back and relook at it figure out listen to what some people said and we'll give

Similar wording

you a uh a uh resumptive hearing and see if i can come up with a better plan okay

Similar wording

okay so i'm going to that's going to be 8 8 26 at 9 30 a.m thank you okay sure all right number six

Similar wording

26. mi2025 007 639 523 tasker street jennifer bitzilla is the attorney

Similar wording

hi i'm already a panelist for some reason so here you go here you go um you know you've

Similar wording

already been sworn just take state your name for the record sure jennifer bazidlo b-a-z-y-d-l-o

Similar wording

could you identify your client the relationship to the property sure my client is aurora jacob

Similar wording

and she is the property owner and i see that uh dickinson square gave you unanimous support and

Similar wording

council member squill also is a non-opposition our vice chair has a few questions good evening

Similar wording

have you submitted your documents and exhibits five days in advance of this hearing i did and

Similar wording

do you waive the reading of the refusal and simulate to its accuracy i do okay jennifer bring

Similar wording

us home okay all right so i'm going to try to keep this one also pretty short and simple this is i'll

Similar wording

just say this is through a series everybody says but go ahead this is the third time we're here

Similar wording

and this is actually already been approved but it expired so um with that in context um like i said

Similar wording

i'm here today representing aurora jacob she is the property owner also on the line i have their

Similar wording

design and build company G space with Angela and Michael. So let's just get into this a little bit

Similar wording

Um, so let's just get into this a little bit here. Um, I have the, you know, all the exhibits were, um, submitted. I won't go through them. Um, but so this is the property here. Uh, it's in ours. It's, it's a parcel. It's about, it's 1,342 square feet. And there's an existing three story structure on it.

Similar wording

here. I have the

Similar wording

um my client aurora obtained this home in 2010 when she purchased it from her siblings who had

Similar wording

inherited from her parents and the family has owned this property since the 1980s um like i said this

Similar wording

is our third time before the board on this project due to a series of unfortunate events um that you

Similar wording

know stuff happens okay so in 22 i'm just going to run through that briefly uh in 2020 in 2010

Similar wording

after the property was obtained, Aurora went ahead and applied for a zoning and use permit

Similar wording

for a three-family dwelling and an addition on the second and third floors in the rear of the

Similar wording

property. In 2011, that zoning variance was granted for both the use and the construction

Similar wording

of the addition. And then she went ahead and started that project and obtained a bunch of

Similar wording

of permits, as you can see here. Unfortunately, the contractors that were hired that first

Similar wording

time pulled permits began work and disappeared without finishing the job, but did take a

Similar wording

lot of her money. So she gathered up her money again, and in 2015 and 16, she hired another

Similar wording

contractor who started the project again, and again, did not finish the work. This is

Similar wording

not G-Space. This is not the current contractor, just to be very, very clear. So what I will

Similar wording

say is that all the prior work was done with permits and the structure itself is that we're

Similar wording

talking about is up we can see it in the back here this is the back structure i'll show you the plans

Similar wording

so in 2024 Aurora hired me knowing that our zoning permit for the use had expired

Similar wording

um and we came back here and there was a new zoning permit issued for the three-family dwelling

Similar wording

and the reason we did not at that time go ahead and ask for a zoning permit for

Similar wording

the rear yard length was because when i had looked at the permits for that addition it was marked

Similar wording

closed so i had assumed that and the contractors had assumed that that part of the work had been

Similar wording

finished and we didn't need to renew a variance for that. However, when they went to go apply

Similar wording

for the permits to finish up the project, Elle and I said, oh no, the contractors never

Similar wording

got the final sign off and you're going to need to get a new variance for the extension

Similar wording

in the back. So, like I said, the work is done, the permits were pulled, apparently

Similar wording

they just did not get the final inspection and that's where we are today so um let me just show

Similar wording

you the current state of the building oops sorry one second i'm on the wrong thing um

Similar wording

as you can see this this building is mostly together um these are some examples of the

Similar wording

units the additions already been fully built um and again this was all with permits with

Similar wording

electrical plumbing this is what it looked like before the project was started um so what we're

Similar wording

looking for is to kind of renew that 2011 permit 2010 2011 permit so that we can get those final

Similar wording

sign-offs and any other do any other additional work i think the uh smoke uh the uh fire suppression

Similar wording

system needs to be fully hooked up and get this building finally back into use um so let's just

Similar wording

see a couple more things here so here's the plan you can see here this is um let me just zoom in

Similar wording

because you can see here kind of where the addition was built on the back um so i think

Similar wording

things to point out here is that first of all even when the first time around the the rear yard was

Similar wording

not actually shortened at all there had been a smaller like a shorter structure all the way to

Similar wording

the line where this addition is now it was just that there was one section that needed to be

Similar wording

completely rebuilt and the other sections just had additional floors built over it because it

Similar wording

was that typical thing where you had three stories in the front and an older addition in the back

Similar wording

and so it was just building up on a footprint that was already there so this hasn't changed

Similar wording

the the rear yard length hasn't changed since this building was constructed in

Similar wording

the early 1900s, some, whenever it was, a long, long time ago, right? And we were just building

Similar wording

up. Like I said, and it's already there, if not for these contractors.

Similar wording

like i said and and it's already there uh if not for these contractors walking away it would have

Similar wording

been signed off on and this building would be occupied now um so but i did want to also say

Similar wording

that let's just go to the aerial photo this is not an uncommon rear yard you can see there's

Similar wording

lots of other properties on this block that go pretty far back onto the property line um

Similar wording

and I will also note that there is no refusal for occupied area because there is quite a

Similar wording

large side yard on this that's almost six feet wide it's like five foot nine inches so you have

Similar wording

a lot of open area still and there is an alleyway in the back here that's like reserved for that

Similar wording

we're not occupying. We had a meeting with Dickinson Square which is the same group that

Similar wording

we met with before, and they voted to, there is I guess 14 people in attendance, it was

Similar wording

a unanimous support, and also Aurora and the design build team had previous to this, went

Similar wording

out to reach out to the community, and we got 25 letters of support from near neighbors,

Similar wording

seven on the same block, and five from the block on the rear, and none of those letters

Similar wording

of support are from the same people that were at the community meeting. So we had pretty good

Similar wording

representation between the community meeting and this block and the letters of support

Similar wording

of people that are supporting this project. So just in summary, before I have my client come on

Similar wording

and adopt my testimony, you know, we're trying to really just finish up this project that was

Similar wording

first approved in 2011. The use was renewed in 2024. It was clearly some weird glitch that it

Similar wording

It was marked closed, but it wasn't closed.

Similar wording

So now we just need to go ahead and get the zoning variants for the existing edition that

Similar wording

was built with the 2011 permit to finalize the project and get these units back in operation.

Similar wording

So with that, I would ask Aurora to raise her hand and adopt my testimony.

Similar wording

please raise your virtual hand and wait to be sworn in

Similar wording

or jacob please raise your virtual hand and if you cannot find her you can if

Similar wording

there's either angela or michael dibucci you can have them raise their hand

Similar wording

thank you my client's a little um she's not as familiar with technology so she might have had

Similar wording

um miss bazidlow is angela is she one of the owners of the property because i only have aurora

Similar wording

jacob listed on the deed um she angela is the design professional so she can't be okay okay

Similar wording

yeah as a witness okay got it yeah thank you hello mike hi could you please state your name

Similar wording

and spell for the stenographer yes my name is angela di prima hyphen bucci that's a-n-g-e-l-a

Similar wording

di prima d-i-p-r-i-m-a hyphen b-u-c-c-i do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth

Similar wording

and nothing but the truth i do yes so proceed angela you heard my testimony um do you believe

Similar wording

uh what i described um as the the history of this property and the additions on this property is

Similar wording

accurate yes okay um and if i asked you all those questions you would have said basically what i

Similar wording

said correct yes all right that's i just wanted that to be on the record then if we can't get

Similar wording

our board to adopt at all all right questions from the board

Similar wording

questions from our attorney hillary emerson not at this time mr chair questions from the virtual

Similar wording

audience

Similar wording

planning commission maybe one with the planning commission the comprehensive plan recommends no

Similar wording

change in zoning at this location to the current rsa5 residential single family

Similar wording

the proposed addition was construction constructed under permit number 309036

Similar wording

the planning commission recommends that the board grant their requested variance for a rear yard

Similar wording

sat back mi2025-007-639-523 tasker street i vote yes with proviso certificate of occupancy to be

Similar wording

obtained yes michael johns my vote is yes with proviso sure i'll guess

Similar wording

My vote is yes, with proviso.

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston, my vote is yes, with proviso.

Similar wording

Tanetta Graham, my vote is yes, with proviso.

Similar wording

Ryan McAdams, my vote is yes, with proviso.

Similar wording

Hi, Owen, my vote is yes, with proviso.

Similar wording

Thank you, counsel.

Similar wording

Thank you so much.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Is there anyone in the audience whose case has not been called?

Similar wording

Mr. Chair, I do not see any further hands.

Similar wording

Okay, thanks, everybody.

Similar wording

And I would tell you what, we're about 40 minutes ahead of schedule.

Similar wording

because he had a start in 650 or something like that the last one right

Similar wording

thanks everybody we we we did get through a lot of work

Similar wording