civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - August 26, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Aug 26, 20267h 14m

wednesday at 2 bm much appreciated thank you very much all right have a good day all right

Similar wording

All right, number four.

Similar wording

So, Mr. Chair, we're now going to continue to complete the 2 p.m. list.

Similar wording

Is that correct?

Similar wording

What's that?

Similar wording

We're going back to the 2 p.m. list, right?

Similar wording

Correct. Yes. Thank you.

Similar wording

And we're going to be hearing Mr. Patterson.

Similar wording

m i 2026 002175 30 to 48 snyder avenue ronald patterson is the attorney mr patterson please

Similar wording

state your name and spell for the stenographer good afternoon ronald patterson p-a-t-t-e-r-s-o-n

Similar wording

right claire harrison law firm 1835 market street you swear or firm to tell the truth the whole

Similar wording

truth nothing but the truth yes i do mr patterson could you identify your client a relationship to

Similar wording

the property sure uh my client clients is first the the tenant is advanced auto parts stores

Similar wording

yep uh and the landlord is the goldenberg group which i represent both okay our vice chair has

Similar wording

a few questions good afternoon have you submitted your documents and exhibits five days in advance

Similar wording

of this hearing yes i have and do you waive the read no the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy

Similar wording

yes i do all right thank you you can proceed with your case i just need to be promoted

Similar wording

are we putting bringing Mr. Patterson in Mr. Patterson has been allowed to promote thank you

Similar wording

yeah Enron I'm in thanks

Similar wording

this is goldberg shopping center dinner it's it's one of them yes i'm going to explain that thanks

Similar wording

okay so this application regards 30-48 snyder avenue uh there's a vacant tenant space in the

Similar wording

shopping center is snyder south owned by the goldenberg group here's an aerial photograph

Similar wording

here is i-95 surrounded by all these shopping centers here's the ikea shopping center with

Similar wording

lowe's that's a goldenberg shopping center snyder south which is what we're here for snyder north

Similar wording

over here is the target so it's surrounded by um commercial as you'll see zooming in on here's

Similar wording

snyder south snyder north targets back here this uh parcel here was the intellects parcel

Similar wording

which i'm working on we have we're converting that to a shopping center as well so it's it's

Similar wording

in a it's in a commercial area here or just tap these for purposes so this is the space

Similar wording

we're referring to this corner which used to be a right aid store

Similar wording

target acme lowe's ikea

Similar wording

So

Similar wording

So it's located, the particular store is on the corner of Snyder Avenue here and Front Street,

Similar wording

also surrounded by Water Street and Jackson Streets. It's space number one, it's about

Similar wording

10,425 square feet, last occupied a year ago after a Rite Aid vacated the store.

Similar wording

The proposal is for an advanced auto store which sells retail parts and accessories,

Similar wording

So it is a commercial retail store. We're located in a CA2 commercial auto-oriented zoning district, which allows for the largest shopping centers possible, like the IKEA shopping center.

Similar wording

And the use here falls under, not commercial, but it falls under an industrial use category code of personal vehicle equipment sales and services.

Similar wording

so it's also located in the cdo central delaware riverfront overlay which makes this use of

Similar wording

refusal advanced auto is a sales his retail sales there are no repairs such as body and fender and

Similar wording

painting which would be those uses that are typically included in that category

Similar wording

and this is probably one of the reasons why it's prohibited in the overlay yet again it's just

Similar wording

retail sales. I'll go through more of the store. Here's the old Rite Aid. There's a rear, which

Similar wording

we're keeping these murals, paintings that are on both sides. Swanson Street side.

Similar wording

It's the surrounding area. I'm sure we're well aware of them.

Similar wording

here's what the rebranding would look like within the shopping center

Similar wording

again keeping the artwork here and i'll further move down to the floor plan so

Similar wording

we can talk about that if there are any questions about that so they stated we're an overlay the

Similar wording

overlay is part of the language in the overlays says the purpose is to connect the public and

Similar wording

neighborhoods to the waterfront and promote sound economic development we believe this use as retail

Similar wording

is not inconsistent with the code or the area and fits within the character in the context of the

Similar wording

area as to the property it's a large space it's been hard to lease finding one large retail that

Similar wording

replace another but as you'll hear we this use actually has lesser density impacts in terms of

Similar wording

customer trips and cars than the Rite Aid did so with that said I want to introduce you to Ashton

Similar wording

Quinn if you could I sir could you please get close to the mic state your name is spelled for

Similar wording

the stenographer all right I'm going to relax here yep go ahead sorry name is Ashton Quinton

Similar wording

Ashton, A-S-H-T-O-N, Quinton, Q-U-I-N, T-I-N.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, told truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Counsel?

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

So, Ashton, you're familiar with this location?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And what's your position with Advanced Auto?

Similar wording

Construction Project Manager.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Again, you heard my testimony.

Similar wording

Would you agree it's true and accurate?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And I do adopt it as if it were your own?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And so just to reiterate, so it's a retail store?

Similar wording

Correct.

Similar wording

Right, no auto repairs?

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

No body fender, no painting?

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Is there much to do there to convert the building?

Similar wording

No, it's an interior outfit.

Similar wording

Okay, and here's a floor plan.

Similar wording

I think I have some interior photos as well.

Similar wording

Give me a second.

Similar wording

Should be toward the end.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

Scroll up a little bit.

Similar wording

Sorry, I did provide them. I can't find them.

Similar wording

Anyway, days and hours of operation.

Similar wording

Days of seven days a week, Monday through Saturday, 7.30 a.m. to 9 p.m., and then Sundays, 9 a.m. to 8 p.m.

Similar wording

And how many total employees would be employed here?

Similar wording

Total hired at these locations tend to be around 15 employees, but around five per shift.

Similar wording

And the parking is adequate or reasonable in the shopping center for this?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay, and I'm sure you've done studies, but is there a comparison you could say?

Similar wording

i'm sure you've done studies but is there a comparison you could say what are the the customer

Similar wording

what are the cost

Similar wording

trips or how many customers within a store compared to the right aid on a typical day

Similar wording

the average maximum amount of customers in the store at a given time is probably around four

Similar wording

to five okay tends to be in and out sales and if we look at this floor plan um is where is the trash

Similar wording

storage so the trash would be small trash containers for lunch disposal and miscellaneous

Similar wording

trash there's also a dumpster area in the back on the swanson half side that we would take all

Similar wording

of our trash out to um and yeah that's really good okay and is there any hazardous waste here

Similar wording

so there is uh oil storage container for customers to drop off their used motor oil

Similar wording

It will get dumped into the oil containers, and then once the container gets filled up to a certain capacity, they call a company called Safety Clean to come and collect them and then drop off an empty container in addition to a container for oil filters.

Similar wording

And that's all stored inside, right?

Similar wording

That is all stored inside to the rear of the space near the receiving doors.

Similar wording

Okay. And I also have for Ashton, if there's any questions, I would say that we did meet with the Whitman Council's community group on June 17, and we have a letter from them with proviso conditions, which I'll turn this around here, which we're fine with.

Similar wording

is there anything other thing for us erlyn okay uh questions from the board

Similar wording

yes so is there a charge for that expense of dropping off oil because i didn't know that

Similar wording

no it's complimentary oh wow okay well that's good people for people to know so typically with

Similar wording

businesses like this especially in the city you have folks that may i may buy a can of oil and

Similar wording

you know i'm just gonna pop my pop my hood right in the parking lot or my engine with the oil and

Similar wording

then go um so is there a system where your employees will monitor that parking lot uh

Similar wording

making sure that folks won't do those like minor tweaks of you know adding fluids to their that

Similar wording

you guys sell to their uh automobiles um is there like periodic watch of that so um wait before you

Similar wording

Before you, before you, before you answer that, can I break in here?

Similar wording

Council, our member is being very nice.

Similar wording

I got to tell you, every one of these places that I go to, you've got people that are running

Similar wording

businesses in these parking lots, repairing cars, repairing, replacing batteries, replacing

Similar wording

motors in some cases, doing body work.

Similar wording

And so the question is, what are you going to do with the existing properties that you

Similar wording

have and including this one to kind of deal with those kind of nuisance conditions in these parking

Similar wording

lots and it goes on and on and on I'm about to probably pull out a video of something you know

Similar wording

what's what's your answer to that we've learned I'll let Ashton speak we learned a lot about this

Similar wording

and I learned a new term called shade tree mechanics so it this did arise at the meeting

Similar wording

and that's why we talked about these proviso conditions um we'll do as as much as we can and

Similar wording

we talked about this with whitman council they are comfortable with the landlord because they

Similar wording

know the landlord the golden brew group would not want this happening in uh their in their parking

Similar wording

lot but ashton if you want to address what you had proposed to do so yeah so there is a couple

Similar wording

of conversations we have internally with these types of situations with the shade tree mechanics

Similar wording

One of those items is to let our staff or our store team members know and operations team members know to necessarily notify the authorities when it comes to those types of services or items being conducted on the site.

Similar wording

If there is any waste left behind, our store team are notified to just come clean it up and throw it in our dumpster.

Similar wording

Those are kind of the expenses or the risks we're willing to take.

Similar wording

But we have a strict policy not to necessarily engage the public when it comes to those acts, because we don't want to jeopardize their safety.

Similar wording

In addition to that, it's also beneficial for us to just have communication with the local police

Similar wording

or sheriff or whosoever and just figure out potential processes when it comes to having

Similar wording

maybe security or patrol, as well as possibly just talking to the landlord and seeing if there's a

Similar wording

possibility of engaging in tow trucks or tow companies to because we've heard stories where

Similar wording

because we've heard stories where people would leave and abandon cars for these shade tree

Similar wording

people would leave and abandon cars for these shade tree mechanics and

Similar wording

mechanics and the client, whoever their client is, has to come and see that the car has been

Similar wording

sitting there and unable to be serviced. So we have some ways to try to alleviate that stress

Similar wording

within the neighbors and whatnot, but it's kind of a process that we're trying to figure out what

Similar wording

works best in the area. So you can commit to at least like if any debris is left from those

Similar wording

mechanics that your your staff yeah yeah we've done that in multiple locations i've had stores

Similar wording

in long island where we've had that taken care of in brooklyn so when you so when you contact the

Similar wording

the local authorities what do they do because uh you know i'm not too far from one and i could go

Similar wording

out there right now and they're probably about 15 different mechanics working on cars right at this

Similar wording

moment so what what what did they do so you call the local what did they do yeah it was sometimes

Similar wording

we call we call multiple occasions and sometimes they just don't come out or you know every times

Similar wording

where the store manager would come out and just let it be known to the people who are doing these

Similar wording

repairs in the parking lot but at the most um we're kind of limited with what we can do it's not

Similar wording

like we can but we're in agreement with with you and the landlord that they would take action

Similar wording

the best they can i don't know what they can do on the street but yeah i guess these are the

Similar wording

parking lots yeah these are the parking lots these don't in the streets these are literally

Similar wording

on your parking lots yeah and i guess i have a follow-up question because this is not something

Similar wording

that we can provide though but how much control do you all have as a store operator to put up

Similar wording

signage in front of the spaces that are in front of your store that say things like no loitering

Similar wording

or sort of inform people, no stopping, no wait.

Similar wording

Like their target, for example, has to do it for their pickup, right?

Similar wording

So like how much control do you guys have in putting out signage in front of the store?

Similar wording

We have a lot of control.

Similar wording

We have a branding department that could put up appropriate signage that is needed.

Similar wording

And we can put them all along our storefront.

Similar wording

And then we can coordinate with the landlord as to posting probably post signs on the property

Similar wording

within our lease line, whatever he allows, but we can definitely have that conversation.

Similar wording

And then I just have a question about your typical customer. How often are you guys getting

Similar wording

like larger bulk orders? So the trucks would deliver to the store on occasion, possibly once

Similar wording

a week, and it comes after business hours. Not inventory. I'm saying like as a customer,

Similar wording

I'm going to walk in and I'm going to order, I don't know, 20 tires or like a bulk order

Similar wording

from a customer? How often does that happen? Not often. We don't do large bulk orders. So

Similar wording

our service is basically DIY customers. That's somebody coming out of their house and want to

Similar wording

get windshield wipers or anything. They'll come in and buy something off the sales floor.

Similar wording

And then we have a clientele, which we call pro services. And those are the local mechanics in

Similar wording

the community. They don't typically buy bulk. They buy on order. They will call in the order

Similar wording

to the store they'll receive that call and they'll have it ready and then they will we will have a

Similar wording

delivery vehicle that comes from our store that will deliver the product to the mechanic so they're

Similar wording

not having to come because i'm more worried like just about loading zone or like anybody that might

Similar wording

have a larger than normal order no mostly taking those to them yes we have a delivery service with

Similar wording

a small car that we just drop off the mechanic so they run an account with the store yes they

Similar wording

They lock in an account with what they call our CMM, and they get that service provided.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Other questions?

Similar wording

Questions from our attorney?

Similar wording

I have two questions.

Similar wording

You indicated in your paperwork about, it looked like signage.

Similar wording

Signage is not part of this.

Similar wording

That's correct.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

I just want to make sure.

Similar wording

It would be a separate application.

Similar wording

Okay, great.

Similar wording

I also wanted to kind of clarify the address of this, because when I was reviewing things,

Similar wording

there's a couple different addresses and not that we asked for it but we didn't have a lease for it

Similar wording

which maybe would have clarified you know what i mean from the tenant so we have the address you

Similar wording

know that was on the application is 30-48 schneider avenue but i thought i read pen schneider avenue

Similar wording

on your sign plans so we need to make sure yeah that's no that or do you have a unit you know

Similar wording

what i mean because it was the the the opa address is 30-48 i think it once might have been an aka

Similar wording

10 snyder or that was colloquially known as that but the official address is 30-48 okay so that

Similar wording

would be okay thank you i would just add before planning speaks yeah if i may just to close it

Similar wording

you know we believe a hardship exists for the space it's been too large to rent and we have a

Similar wording