civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - February 5, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Feb 5, 20257h 1m

I never had.

Similar wording

vacations. I started saving money. And finally, I was able to buy a house. I mean, even with a

Similar wording

mortgage, but still, I bought the house for $125,000. Even the condition was not good. Even

Similar wording

the house was in a very bad condition, I was thinking that I would be able to make the repairing

Similar wording

works myself.

Similar wording

Yes, I was building a house, having all the permits for the construction, I have gone through all the inspections, I can provide all the necessary papers that you would require or you would need, so I have some parts of them here with me, some parts are in my case.

Similar wording

I have all the necessary confirmations

Similar wording

and permits. Everything

Similar wording

is here. Would you like

Similar wording

me to provide them to you?

Similar wording

Not right now, but thank you.

Similar wording

Interpreter, could you tell her

Similar wording

show

Similar wording

I want the house show that she says

Similar wording

this is my house.

Similar wording

I read a photo.

Similar wording

Right.

Similar wording

I want you to show

Similar wording

the house and show

Similar wording

the basis

Similar wording

on the fact that he is your house.

Similar wording

Is this your house here?

Similar wording

No. Where is your house?

Similar wording

Where is your house?

Similar wording

My house. Oh, this is my house.

Similar wording

That's your house there. Yes.

Similar wording

This is your house there. Yes.

Similar wording

Yes. Yes. Okay.

Similar wording

Alright. Thank you.

Similar wording

and and could you explain to us what the issue is what you what you see is the issue here

Similar wording

could you get her to do that please

Similar wording

хорошо в таком случае можете пожалуйста объяснить в чем здесь проблема какая какая

Similar wording

здесь основная причина да yes когда я строила дом у меня не было в планах вот этой козибы сбоку

Similar wording

So when I was building the house, I didn't have plans to have this casaebo on the side.

Similar wording

2-3 фита выше моего уровня.

Similar wording

Вода и грязь течет ко мне.

Similar wording

И я спросила инспектора.

Similar wording

Он сказал, да, вы можете сделать это козиба.

Similar wording

И козиба стояла с 2018 года.

Similar wording

Ко мне не было претензий.

Similar wording

В 2019 году у меня есть бумаги.

Similar wording

У меня все инспекшн, окей.

Similar wording

Я завершила уже шитрик внутри.

Similar wording

Покрашено было.

Similar wording

А потом был ковид.

Similar wording

In the 19th and 20th year, I did not work, no one did not work in the house, and in the 19th and 20th year, I received the first valuation.

Similar wording

Yes, so I didn't have plans to have this casebo.

Similar wording

and when

Similar wording

I was building in the house

Similar wording

you could see that the water

Similar wording

was

Similar wording

flowing in

Similar wording

into the Crowley space and the

Similar wording

basement, this is why I

Similar wording

decided to

Similar wording

in the basement and the

Similar wording

Crowley space, I have

Similar wording

water heater

Similar wording

what is it

Similar wording

boiler, gas

Similar wording

light everywhere and

Similar wording

I'm scared. Inspector say I can put Kaziba. Okay. This is the in-depth speaking. The client

Similar wording

stated in English. Should I provide that information and repeat that information?

Similar wording

Yes, please. Yeah. So in my basement, I had a heater.

Similar wording

Yeah, so in my basement, I had a heater and some other electronic devices.

Similar wording

And this is why I was scared that the water could damage it.

Similar wording

And I spoke to the inspector and he stated that it's okay for me to build up the gazebo.

Similar wording

Do we have a picture of the gazebo?

Similar wording

Just next to the house with the roof.

Similar wording

And that's when I also asked to provide the permits for those.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

All offices were closed. I couldn't go anywhere.

Similar wording

And on April 2020-2022, I sent an appellation.

Similar wording

I asked to make a complaint. I asked to allow me to make a CZIPA.

Similar wording

And then it came out that according to the documents,

Similar wording

it turns out that not all my land is mine.

Similar wording

Not all my land is mine.

Similar wording

right in 2022 i can provide the exact date it was january 22nd i received my first notice

Similar wording

that's when the pandemic ended in february and uh on april 4th of 2022 i sent an appeal

Similar wording

asking to provide all the necessary documents and approvals to build this gazebo.

Similar wording

And then it turned out that the land does not belong to me completely.

Similar wording

Wait a minute, let him interpret.

Similar wording

um yes um so i couldn't do anything for several years because i was trying to collect all the

Similar wording

necessary documents to make everything in a correct way so on november of 2022 i was

Similar wording

able to get the detailed consolidation with all approvals

Similar wording

How does she have any more testimony?

Similar wording

I understand that I may have violated something, but when I looked at the houses that were built next to me, new houses, there was a distance between the houses, a small distance between the houses, but in the old houses, right?

Similar wording

Wait, wait, you have to give the interpreter a chance to interpret.

Similar wording

Okay, okay.

Similar wording

Could you tell me what she was just saying?

Similar wording

um yes so uh in the period from 2018 to 2022 i had my gazebo uh ready built ready and built

Similar wording

and i had no problems at all but after that period i started having issues after it was completely

Similar wording

built, I started to receive notices. I understand that I may have violated some rules. But I could

Similar wording

see the other new houses build the same things, just like me, or just in the same territory.

Similar wording

Just like me, just in the same territory.

Similar wording

Is there anything else you can tell us?

Similar wording

So, let's suppose and assume that

Similar wording

I'm gonna remove this gazebo and I contacted the certain agencies and found out that to remove and to fix it

Similar wording

it would require from 20 to 30 thousand dollars. I'm a retired person, I'm 69 years old

Similar wording

and my income is only 1500 dollars per month. I cannot afford that.

Similar wording

basement and crawl space. I will live in constant stress, so my house will be on fire.

Similar wording

And when I was in a war, I would have to die. When I went to, I did everything right. I sent 72

Similar wording

certified letter to my husband,

Similar wording

as it was supposed to be.

Similar wording

My husband can't come to RCO.

Similar wording

I took a picture,

Similar wording

I took a picture,

Similar wording

and for the last one,

Similar wording

and for the last one.

Similar wording

I don't know, what to do.

Similar wording

The only goal I want to do is

Similar wording

I want to leave them in peace.

Similar wording

I need a variance.

Similar wording

And then I'll finish everything until the end.

Similar wording

Everything will be clean and I'll live safely.

Similar wording

That's the only thing I want.

Similar wording

If I break this stuff, I don't know who it will.

Similar wording

Hold on.

Similar wording

You have to let him say you can't keep blowing water, right?

Similar wording

Thank you, sir.

Similar wording

Right. So secondly, I'm afraid if I'm going to do that,

Similar wording

my basement will be flooded.

Similar wording

I will be living in this constant fear

Similar wording

that my house will catch a fire or be flooded in case of fire it it won't be only me who's

Similar wording

going to suffer from that but also my neighbors are going to suffer from that i have sent 72

Similar wording

different letters to neighborhoods to every neighbor with certification and unfortunately

Similar wording

my neighbors cannot participate the rco meeting i have everything every document every single

Similar wording

document signed and now i don't know what to do my goal is to have the agencies to leave me alone

Similar wording

and let me finish everything okay all right good so questions from the board

Similar wording

i have a question what other work needs to be done

Similar wording

I said finish.

Similar wording

Backyard, frontyard, the finish, the work outside.

Similar wording

Everything is done inside.

Similar wording

I cleaned all the walls after the leak, everything that was covered.

Similar wording

I can show the pictures of the basement where I was covered.

Similar wording

So mostly all around the house.

Similar wording

I mean, my backyard, the frontyard, everything outside.

Similar wording

because inside everything is already done.

Similar wording

I have completed all the necessary works inside.

Similar wording

Now the exterior, everything that is outside requires the work that should be done.

Similar wording

I mean, I have all the necessary photographs of my basement being flooded.

Similar wording

I can provide those photographs.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you. Any other questions from the board?

Similar wording

Any other questions from the board?

Similar wording

You

Similar wording

going to stop the water going into the basement.

Similar wording

I'm a little confused as to how this is going to address that condition.

Similar wording

on the weight. How can you stop the water in the bed?

Similar wording

This part is not quite clear.

Similar wording

Just answer the question.

Similar wording

Just answer the question.

Similar wording

One of the things that the water prevents the water,

Similar wording

and here I built a wall.

Similar wording

this is 2-3 feet

Similar wording

this is the floor

Similar wording

this is the earth

Similar wording

if the water falls from the roof

Similar wording

then it falls on the earth

Similar wording

but it falls to the house

Similar wording

but with the other side

Similar wording

where I could

Similar wording

I put

Similar wording

I don't know

Similar wording

how it's called

Similar wording

the pump

Similar wording

where it's all out of the house

Similar wording

it's the other side of the house

Similar wording

So, from one side, the water is blocked by the gazebo.

Similar wording

And there is another wall that I built, which is two or three feet tall.

Similar wording

So, if the water gets in, it gets only into the ground.

Similar wording

but not into the basement and from the other side i have this i don't remember how exactly

Similar wording

it should be called but something like a pump i mean on the other side of the house i sold

Similar wording

this pump that i can install on this part of the house

Similar wording

Any other questions? Thank you.

Similar wording

Do you know if you have a perimeter drain or a sump pump in your basement?

Similar wording

This is pump. I don't know what it is.

Similar wording

Скажите, пожалуйста, у вас имеется дренаж по периметру или что-то вроде этого?

Similar wording

Yes, I just don't know how it's called.

Similar wording

I have this special pump that drains it into the pump, and the pump throws it out.

Similar wording

but from the other side of the house

Similar wording

I have the crawling space

Similar wording

that does not allow me to install

Similar wording

this device

Similar wording

Questions or comments

Similar wording

from our attorney?

Similar wording

Not at this time Mr. Chair

Similar wording

Questions or comments from the

Similar wording

in room audience?

Similar wording

Questions or comments

Similar wording

from the virtual audience?

Similar wording

Yes Chair

Similar wording

there's Joe Carson

Similar wording

will be allowed to speak

Similar wording

could you please state your name

Similar wording

and spell for the court stenographer

Similar wording

Joe Carson

Similar wording

you're free to speak

Similar wording

Joe

Similar wording

can you hear me now

Similar wording