civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - April 30, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Apr 30, 20257h 43m

All right. Can I share my screen?

Similar wording

Can I share my screen?

Similar wording

Let me know when I'm live.

Similar wording

Am I okay to go?

Similar wording

It has not come up yet.

Similar wording

No worries. Thank you.

Similar wording

I have a PowerPoint presentation here

Similar wording

I'd like to show

Similar wording

I see you've been promoted

Similar wording

yeah

Similar wording

Do we think we're having

Similar wording

technical issues again?

Similar wording

I think a presentation is helpful, you know, for some reason.

Similar wording

Can you share it or you're unable to share it?

Similar wording

No, my screen is shared.

Similar wording

Well, I'm showing it on my laptop.

Similar wording

Can you see it or no?

Similar wording

No, we can't share it.

Similar wording

We can't see it.

Similar wording

Yeah, I got it screened up.

Similar wording

You try closing it and opening it again.

Similar wording

Yeah, why don't you close and come back in?

Similar wording

Why don't you close out and then come back in?

Similar wording

Oh, get out of the logout, you mean come back in?

Similar wording

yeah so if you

Similar wording

check down the

Similar wording

presentation and then reopen it please

Similar wording

yeah I did that I'm opening

Similar wording

up right now

Similar wording

can you

Similar wording

see anything

Similar wording

now

Similar wording

there'll be a green button at the bottom

Similar wording

of the screen

Similar wording

yeah I see it say starting

Similar wording

coach

Similar wording

no

Similar wording

once you hit that green share button at the bottom

Similar wording

it should ask you what documents

Similar wording

do you want to share

Similar wording

oh you know what that is my fault

Similar wording

alright let me share my whole window

Similar wording

there we go

Similar wording

my apologies

Similar wording

I'm off the 2020 time

Similar wording

I forgot my fault

Similar wording

thanks Lakeisha

Similar wording

alright thank you

Similar wording

so I think I won't be too long on this

Similar wording

so my name is Mokslin Islam

Similar wording

I'm an attorney for Green Eagle Properties

Similar wording

this property is regarding 900

Similar wording

and Shelton

Similar wording

just to tell you a couple of things about the properties

Similar wording

historically this property has been vacant

Similar wording

excuse me I'm sorry this is Hillary

Similar wording

one of the things that we need to see

Similar wording

before we can proceed

Similar wording

is proof of posting for today's hearing

Similar wording

the photo that was provided

Similar wording

was from a poster from a year ago

Similar wording

So we need to see proof of posting for today's hearing.

Similar wording

I thought I'd provide at least

Similar wording

Give me one second.

Similar wording

I found that in my location, in my office.

Similar wording

i know we've had hearings for this at least two or three times and i wasn't involved but

Similar wording

i do not have the actual one on my computer here well why don't we do this why don't we come why

Similar wording

don't we come back and that way and see if you can find it and i'll be back with you in 45 minutes

Similar wording

all right thank you okay thank you thank you mr knockamson

Similar wording

it's knockamson uh as you're aware we have several cases of you today what i'm going to try to do is

Similar wording

you're aware we have several cases of you today what i'm going to try to do is do two or three

Similar wording

then come back um and um you've already been sworn in if i remember correctly right that's

Similar wording

great so one of the things we want to try to do today is that um when you present yeah go to the

Similar wording

refusal yeah tell us what the refusal is and then go right into your presentation okay so why don't

Similar wording

we do this just for the record state your name alan knockamson right and it's mi20240043206560

Similar wording

north povere street could you identify your client and the relationship to the property

Similar wording

uh yes my client is uh vantium llc uh the owner of the property and then the virtual audience

Similar wording

should be sam clifton right and our our uh vice chair has a few questions council do you agree

Similar wording

away the reading of the refusal or stipulate to

Similar wording

his accuracy. I do. Have you emailed

Similar wording

all the required documents and exhibits that's needed

Similar wording

to proceed with this case five days in advance

Similar wording

of his hearing? Yes, we have.

Similar wording

Thank you, counsel. Please proceed and share his screen.

Similar wording

Well, I can't share my screen, but

Similar wording

I do have my legal assistant

Similar wording

online, Nicholas Slatov.

Similar wording

The promoter? Promote him, yes.

Similar wording

Please.

Similar wording

Me? Nicholas Slatov.

Similar wording

Can we

Similar wording

promote Nicholas Natov?

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Nicholas is coming in as a panelist.

Similar wording

So, Nick, if you can go straight to the notice of refusal.

Similar wording

All right. Just as it from the outset, at the request of the council member's office,

Similar wording

um we're asking the board to hold the votes to give us my client additional time uh to meet with

Similar wording

the community i would ask um only for two weeks um as you can see from the notice of refusal the

Similar wording

date of the notices of refusal is june 20th of 2024 so it's been some time since we've had this

Similar wording

matter we've met with the community twice um and uh i think it's appropriate just to hold it for

Similar wording

two weeks uh so let's see can we do that hillary just just to clarify just one are we holding it

Similar wording

just to give them a chance to send in the letter and then any response from you you don't need are

Similar wording

you are you asking for an additional opportunity to present no just just to for them to present

Similar wording

whatever letter and then for us to respond um we're not having another or another certified

Similar wording

rco meeting it's just to give my client additional time to so you know solicit neighbors and nearby

Similar wording

and and make the the rco feel more comfortable okay so so basically you just like to submit

Similar wording

supple you and the rco would like to submit supplemental information but have the case

Similar wording

voted in two weeks that's right okay thank you bye all right so this is an rsa 5 property

Similar wording

um it's thirteen hundred and fifty three square feet um and what we're looking to do here is make

Similar wording

this into a two-family dwelling and the one refusal we have is because it's an rsa5 property

Similar wording

next nick so the correspondence exhibit two we we don't have any um we're waiting for that and i

Similar wording

think that's part of the community input next nick so there are multiple nearby multifamily

Similar wording

structures on 66th avenue um can you go to the exhibit three nick uh so 6601 north grass street

Similar wording

is multi-family in nature 6551 north grass street is also multi-family in nature

Similar wording

6600 north grass street is also multi-family in nature 6550 north grass street is multi-family

Similar wording

continue so again maps of the area i mean we're just a corner property on the corner of 66th

Similar wording

and uh avenue and bouvier next again you see from a google maps perspective next

Similar wording

photographs of the property uh so this is looking from bouvier street there's a front door can't

Similar wording

really see it behind the tree but there is next and then to the side on 66th avenue there's a

Similar wording

separate front door on the side for the lower level unit. While what you should pay attention

Similar wording

to is there's no lower, like below grade living here. Next. And then this is from the rear of the

Similar wording

property. As you can see, there's two separate doors, one for the lower level unit, one for the

Similar wording

upper level unit. Again, so that means there's two forms of regress. My client purchased this

Similar wording

property uh this way from the exterior point of view the intention is once if we get you know

Similar wording

zoning approval for the two units he is going to replace those steps um they're pretty shabby uh

Similar wording

uh next uh these are proof of our orange notice posters being posted for from both public streets

Similar wording

next uh these are proof of our orange note

Similar wording

next and again i guess a closer view of that as well next so again my client purchased it as two

Similar wording

units um and he made cosmetic changes which would not require any um permits so he didn't do any

Similar wording

plumbing work or electrical work it was all cosmetic in nature so and it was advertised in

Similar wording

this way as well but you can see there's two electrical uh meters here uh for two units really

Similar wording

should be three but i guess there's so one of the units is taking the common area electric as well

Similar wording

next and then there's two hot water heaters which were there before next and then this is north

Similar wording

barbier street to the right of the property to the left of the property 66th avenue to the right

Similar wording

of the property until left of the property.

Similar wording

And then interior photos, again, he made cosmetic changes only.

Similar wording

He did not need any permits for that. But you can see

Similar wording

put a nice product in there. No one's living there.

Similar wording

My understanding, we can ask my client that. But these are just interior photos.

Similar wording

Now, so the second floor.

Similar wording

And then, again, simple floor plans, next.

Similar wording

So if you look at it, it's kind of reversed, but the basement is really the first floor because there's no below grade living.

Similar wording

But if you go to the top, that's, you know, it looks like you can get in that side entrance on top top and you go and there's a separate exit.

Similar wording

Remember in the rear that's on the left hand side.

Similar wording

But, you know, I can't even see it's like kind of small for me.

Similar wording

but it looks like a living room kitchen uh looks like a bedroom there with a with a bath and then

Similar wording

if you go up a flight of the steps um that's you know basically the first floor unit which is

Similar wording

you know on the first floor and the second floor which is a bi-level and there are multiple living

Similar wording

areas and then upstairs are the bedrooms so it's a little tough for me to see but there are multiple

Similar wording

forms of egress and things like that next so the last time we met with the community was april 17th

Similar wording

at 6 p.m again we have no issue with the coordinating rco and that i think everything

Similar wording

has been done with in good faith i think we just have had challenges meeting with them like twice

Similar wording

we've we've had meetings where the meetings have been started for a half an hour to an hour late

Similar wording

and i think there's been some miscommunication in terms of the neighborhood in that

Similar wording

respect where it's been challenging for us that's why we're asking for one more time but just two

Similar wording

weeks application for appeal that we filed along with you know the notice of refusal and then most

Similar wording

importantly the tax clearance certificate the deed to the property and then a tax clearance

Similar wording

certificate with that being said i would ask that mr clifton virtually raise his hand

Similar wording

who's the person that we're looking for

Similar wording

uh samuel clifton he should be in the virtual audience

Similar wording

Okay, Mr. Chair

Similar wording

Mr. Nakamson, I do not see the individual

Similar wording

in the virtual audience

Similar wording

Okay, so Mr. Nakamson, you're an officer of the court

Similar wording

We'll take your testimony

Similar wording

Questions from the board

Similar wording

Yeah, do you know if your

Similar wording

client has spoken to

Similar wording

the contiguous neighbor?

Similar wording

They have

Similar wording

um and they actually attended the last community meeting that was the only person that attended the

Similar wording

last community meeting i think they asked about uh trash storage and we stated and actually that

Similar wording

would be a proviso we would agree to to be trash stored in rear but that was the only question

Similar wording

that was asked of us by that neighbor all the questions from the board yes are there other um

Similar wording

two family dwellings in the area or is this just

Similar wording

that's assuming you know in the i mean legal ones not well we only show the legal ones so we showed

Similar wording

i think four or five instances on on the on the presentation at the beginning so we have a separate

Similar wording

exhibit for that so again corner properties we focus on corner properties because corner properties

Similar wording

tend to be multi-unit in nature and these are all properties nearby which are multi-family structures

Similar wording

So you have 6601 Northgrass Street, 6551.

Similar wording

So you have 6601 North Grass Street, 6551 North Grass Street, 6600 North Grass Street, 6550 North Grass Street, and that's it.

Similar wording

Other questions from the board?

Similar wording

Welcome.

Similar wording

Actually, I have one more question.

Similar wording

Could you pull up the basement or the first floor plan again?

Similar wording

I was just, where is the entrance?

Similar wording

I think the pictures would be helpful.

Similar wording

i think because i can't really see my eyes i think it's been something a little more so

Similar wording

let's uh nick why don't you go to the the pictures of the exterior of the property

Similar wording

because i think it will kind of help you a little bit more i'm just trying to understand

Similar wording

like where is the first yeah go go next one more yeah one more so that's the lower level entrance

Similar wording

right there you see that one that's on 66th avenue that looked different than what was drawn

Similar wording

that was because because they flipped it like if you go to the drug and by the way nick want to go

Similar wording

to the first picture which shows the picture of the front door door for yeah yeah you can't really

Similar wording

see it and then if you go to the third picture down there nick these that's the end exit for

Similar wording

both of the users rear entrance which i saw on the plans but the side entrance did not look like

Similar wording

that it flipped here nick why don't you go to uh the floor plans that was what was that was

Similar wording

it it got me for a loop too it was so the yeah um so if you kind of flip this around

Similar wording

it would make more sense i get it okay yeah i i got confused when i was reading the plans too

Similar wording

yeah all the questions from the board questions from our attorney not at this time mr chair

Similar wording