civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - September 24, 2024

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Sep 24, 20241h 30m

We have done literally hundreds of projects in the Philadelphia area.

Similar wording

And we've also done several high-rise projects in Center City.

Similar wording

We did the Hyatt Centric, the Cambria Hotel at Bron and Locus, the Beacon at 16th and Walnut.

Similar wording

the Harper Project, the 19th and Sansom, the Granary, and others.

Similar wording

Thank you. All right, I'd like to walk you through some plans so you can share with the

Similar wording

Board the details of this proposal. So let's start first with Exhibit 5, which is up on the screen,

Similar wording

which is the site survey. Could you use this exhibit and just generally describe the site

Similar wording

in terms of its size and shape? Sure. As you noted, it's an L-shaped site with frontage on

Similar wording

Sansom Street and 7th Street to the right. It is a slight L and it's it's it consists of 12,440

Similar wording

square feet. When you were retained to design this project for Pearl Properties was the site vacant

Similar wording

or did it contain any structures? It was completely vacant actually excavation had already occurred.

Similar wording

All right. Let's start with Exhibit 7 here, which is the zoning site plan.

Similar wording

I believe you already mentioned this, but could you just recap? How big is this lot?

Similar wording

12,440 square feet.

Similar wording

And that also includes the full boundary of the master condominium parcel. Is that correct?

Similar wording

That's correct.

Similar wording

Can you just generally describe the proposed project that is reflected on the zoning plans?

Similar wording

And while you do that, please touch on the changes that were made since the original hearing date in June.

Similar wording

Sure. The building, it's a 34-story residential building, 403 feet, 6 inches tall. It'll contain 99 residential units, 50 parking spaces, and one interior loading space.

Similar wording

Sure. The building, it's a 34-story residence.

Similar wording

The changes, I think we'll talk more about the changes since the prior hearing in a moment, but in general, it was just really changing the garage to an elevator garage versus a ramped garage and providing access to residents from the lobby onto Sanson Street.

Similar wording

Thank you. What is the total proposed gross floor area and what does that translate to in terms of floor area ratio?

Similar wording

So the total area of the building is 185,688 square feet, and that calculates to 1,493%.

Similar wording

Now, aside from the items that are listed in the referral and the refusal, was the project otherwise designed to comply with all applicable provisions of the zoning code?

Similar wording

Yes, it is.

Similar wording

All right, turning to, and again, this is the revised proviso plan. So you can see here, this was the original plan, and this is the revised proviso plan reflecting that parking elevator, as well as that entrance. And we'll touch on some of these in an additional moment.

Similar wording

All right. So turning to the floor plates and parking diagrams, and again, I'll just bring up the revised version of these. Can you describe generally the interior floor breakdown, starting with the cellar level?

Similar wording

Sure. The cellar level, I don't know if you want to show that.

Similar wording

Yeah, you know what, I'll bring this up.

Similar wording

That's helpful.

Similar wording

As you can see, it's a fairly small, below-grade cellar space.

Similar wording

It's really to accommodate utilities and some storage, and of course, the building core.

Similar wording

We've pulled it back significantly from the neighboring properties to avoid underpinning any sort of risk to those buildings.

Similar wording

So it's much smaller than the actual property footprint.

Similar wording

All right, I'm moving along to the second floor.

Similar wording

So this is showing the problem.

Similar wording

Okay, this is the new version.

Similar wording

The garage now is going to be served by an elevator.

Similar wording

It is a completely valet garage.

Similar wording

It won't be open to the public.

Similar wording

And you can see there's valet spaces throughout.

Similar wording

throughout there's three levels of parking in the project and it will be completely valet.

Similar wording

So, so, Councilor, I have one question. Are these 11 parking spaces as well as the

Similar wording

three electrical parking spaces? Are they within side of the 50 or outside?

Similar wording

They are. They're included in the 50. So it's 50, it's 50 total spaces with, you know, with valet

Similar wording

spaces it's always a little bit strange in terms of space numbers because of course in practice

Similar wording

valet garages you know typically operate uh and and they they typically try and fill as many spaces

Similar wording

as they can but in this case it is 50 spaces that have been marked out to accommodate those valet

Similar wording

operations and that's also consistent with the requirement it's a little bit above the requirement

Similar wording

for this property, but I hope that answers the question. Yeah, sure. David, if you could,

Similar wording

right now I have up here the second floor plan. If you can generally talk about the third floor

Similar wording

and the fourth floor, if there's anything different or notable to mention to the board.

Similar wording

No, it still operates as a valet garage. We still have the core for the building and

Similar wording

And now that we do not have a ramp, we have a little bit extra storage and maintenance space that's provided.

Similar wording

Do you want to talk about the requirements for parking?

Similar wording

So I was going to just ask you, is parking required for the project?

Similar wording

Yes, parking is required.

Similar wording

The code requires 0.3 or 3 per 10 parking spaces per unit.

Similar wording

So that's equivalent to 30 spaces.

Similar wording

um we've provided 50 spaces in this proposal now do the drive aisles that are leading to the

Similar wording

parking spaces do those drive aisles comply with the minimum required dimensions in the code

Similar wording

so for example the drive aisle that would lead out of the vehicle elevator up to where the

Similar wording

parking spaces would begin yes they do it's a minimum of 18 feet which is what we're proposing

Similar wording

Yes, they do. It's a minimum of 18 feet, which is what we're proposing.

Similar wording

We'll see you next time.

Similar wording

Thank you. And I believe that you already mentioned this, but in addition to removing the ramp and adding the vehicle elevator, were there any other changes made to the parking layouts since the June hearing date?

Similar wording

I don't believe so.

Similar wording

now when designing the project did you conduct a review of tolls prior plans and approval for the

Similar wording

site we did yes did that project provide any on-site parking it did not it relied entirely

Similar wording

on off-site parking okay let me turn to exhibit 13 which provides a rendering of tolls prior

Similar wording

project for this site. David, were you familiar with this particular rendering?

Similar wording

I have seen it before, yes. Okay. And again, Board, this is just for informational purposes,

Similar wording

as we get into our own renderings, for you to see the quite significant difference between this

Similar wording

prior project that was approved for this site compared to Pearl Properties' version, which

Similar wording

has been substantially changed in terms of design all right if we can turn back to exhibit nine

Similar wording

briefly um can you just share with the board the breakdown of the units range of sizes and

Similar wording

amenities generally sure um the building is uh is as a small footprint it's a fairly narrow

Similar wording

high-rise building. The total residential units are 99 total units. They're larger units than

Similar wording

typically you find in a residential building, and most every unit has a corner,

Similar wording

which we thought was important, and you'll see a variety of balconies on the various corners of

Similar wording

the building. The unit sizes range from 700 square feet to 3,000 square feet, and so it's a one-bedroom

Similar wording

all the way up to a four-bedroom unit, and again, many of them have terraces.

Similar wording

And what about amenities? I just wanted to say at the very top of the building, there's

Similar wording

double penthouses with terraces. Yeah, there's amenities. If you can go back a few slides

Similar wording

to the amenity floor, which is floor five.

Similar wording

You can see, there you go.

Similar wording

You can see there's a 2,400 square foot amenity space,

Similar wording

which will be developed into a lounge

Similar wording

and kind of a game and relax area.

Similar wording

And then there is a three-sided wraparound terrace

Similar wording

that will be heavily landscaped.

Similar wording

And that's it, the fifth story of the building.

Similar wording

There will be views of the park, and that will be a primary amenity for the building.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

All right, turning to Exhibit 7, I'll bring up the skyplane diagram for this project.

Similar wording

Can you just briefly explain to the board what this diagram establishes in terms of zoning compliance?

Similar wording

Sure.

Similar wording

The sky plane offers an additional way to measure bulk and area in a building.

Similar wording

So just these are illustrations.

Similar wording

The far left is really a profile of the building from Sansom Street.

Similar wording

And you can see that the building has layers to it where we've created some character.

Similar wording

And the base of the building is in line with the adjoining properties, which you'll see more in a moment.

Similar wording

The middle diagram is kind of a section through the building with Sansom Street on the right.

Similar wording

And the way this is calculated, you plot the lines from the center of the street up to the building facade.

Similar wording

And on the far right is what the code provides in terms of blockage.

Similar wording

So up to 80 feet, you're allowed to have 100% blockage.

Similar wording

and we're providing 91%, so we're less.

Similar wording

And then up to 115 feet, the code allows 85% blockage.

Similar wording

Our proposal is 73%, again, less than.

Similar wording

And then up to 175 feet, you're allowed 80% blockage.

Similar wording

Our proposal is 73%.

Similar wording

And from there, up to 340 feet, you're allowed 70% blockage.

Similar wording

We're proposing 50% blockage.

Similar wording

So all in all, we're well within the skyplane requirements.

Similar wording

So even with the refusal that this project received for exceeding gross floor area or floor area ratio, this project still complies in

Similar wording

floor area ratio, this project still complies in terms of its overall sky, plane, and height. Is that right?

Similar wording

That's correct.

Similar wording

All right, so let's come back to the elevations.

Similar wording

All right, so let's look at the, let's first look at the rendered ground floor plan.

Similar wording

Sure.

Similar wording

And this, again, is the revised version.

Similar wording

The original version is up on the screen here.

Similar wording

So we can flip back and forth if it would be helpful to kind of visualize what has changed.

Similar wording

But just to direct your eye, you'll notice most of the changes in the areas surrounding the parking, as well as this retail space and entrance along Sansom Street.

Similar wording

So, David, could you just describe to the board, please, this ground floor design in detail?

Similar wording

and, again, hit on the changes that have been made?

Similar wording

Sure.

Similar wording

You can see there's a motor court or a motor lobby that's internal to the project,

Similar wording

and that will be treated as a very nice, highly finished space

Similar wording

because it's also how residents will return to their residences.

Similar wording

You'll see at the bottom left there's the elevator, the car elevator,

Similar wording

and then above that is a loading dock.

Similar wording

and then above that is the base building core.

Similar wording

So folks, as they return, they'll drop their cars off for valet,

Similar wording

and they'll walk through the lobby, which you can see.

Similar wording

It gets labeled lobby, and one of the things that's different in this version

Similar wording

is the lobby is now accessible to Sansom Street, so there's cross-circulation.

Similar wording

And then in the pink area, that's the retail space or potential cafe space.

Similar wording

And David, could you just briefly touch on trash storage location in this particular design here?

Similar wording

Sure. Behind the loading facility, there'll be storage containers for trash. Of course,

Similar wording

there'll be maintenance people that handle trash on a daily basis, and it will be wheeled out that

Similar wording

existing alleyway to pick up, private pickup on 7th Street.

Similar wording

Great. Thank you.

Similar wording

All right. All right. Let's turn back to exhibit nine, which will start to give you a more broad

Similar wording

scale view of this building. So exhibit nine, of course, are colored elevations of the buildings,

Similar wording

has all of the materials labeled, and we're certainly happy to come back to these if you

Similar wording

have any questions on the materials. I will note it is important that these renderings have not

Similar wording

been updated to reflect changes that were made to the Sansom Street facade since the June hearing,

Similar wording

but we can show you those changes visually in a moment. So I just want to make sure that it's

Similar wording

clear that the actual renderings were not updated. So at Exhibit 11, we have all of the detailed

Similar wording

renderings that were prepared for this project and you should already start to get a sense of

Similar wording

how significantly changed uh the the visual aspects of this project are from the one that

Similar wording

was previously approved uh so david if you could just uh generally talk about the aesthetics of

Similar wording

this design and you know we can walk them through these renderings as as you're talking about them

Similar wording

Certainly.

Similar wording

As you noted, the base of the building on Sanson Street has been changed, but has not yet been reflected in these renderings.

Similar wording

You can see at the fifth storyline, the building recesses.

Similar wording

There's a significant recess that honors the streetscape and the other buildings on the block.

Similar wording

And then that is also the amenity floor.

Similar wording

That's why there's trees and greenery at that level.

Similar wording

And then above that level, the building has different layers, so the building has interest.

Similar wording

But it's treated with a mahogany color vertical fins that would be made out of metal.

Similar wording

Horizontal trim would be in a dark bronze color.

Similar wording

So fairly muted earth tone colors that we think will blend with the area.

Similar wording

It's not a glass building that was proposed before.

Similar wording

This is really a building with much more character.

Similar wording

In fact, the building as designed, its profile changes as you view it from different sides

Similar wording

because of all the different layers of the building facade and the steps in the building

Similar wording

and the way the fenestration is handled.

Similar wording

You can see balconies are going to be prominent on the exterior as well as those vertical

Similar wording

are going to be prominent on the exterior, as well as those vertical fins will change how you

Similar wording

see the building. They'll also provide shadow and character as sunlight approaches it. And then you

Similar wording

can see that green terrace at the base of the building that will, you know, try to connect us

Similar wording

to the park, frankly. This is a bird's eye view, and you can kind of see it looking down. You can

Similar wording

again see how the building is layered and then at the very bottom how the building the base of the

Similar wording

building is in line with the property but then the building sets back substantially from the street

Similar wording

and we also did not develop this the 7th street side we wanted to keep the tower away from that

Similar wording

and use that as a more chance a more late entrance but there you go that's the motor lobby

Similar wording

It will be open frame, almost like a big pergola, so that light enters that area,

Similar wording

so it would be nice and bright, not a dark space at all. And then we're proposing an artistic

Similar wording

element, sort of a sculptural tree, at the center of that, that will give it some light

Similar wording

and make it unique. Those are, if you want to continue, those are the massing studies.

Similar wording

in the next slides, Mary, that we've done as part of our CDR presentation to just show

Similar wording

how the building relates to the context of the site.

Similar wording

Thank you, David.

Similar wording

And again, there's just another view of those massing studies from a different direction.

Similar wording

That's correct.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

So let's turn back then.

Similar wording

I do have a question.

Similar wording

Sure.

Similar wording

The parking, again, can we go back a little bit as to how the parking entrance is, the valet parking entrance is going to be?

Similar wording

Absolutely.

Similar wording

No, I just want to make a note so I don't lose track of where I am.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

So let's turn back.

Similar wording

Yeah, David, if you want to use the ground floor plan here and I can, we'll start with this.

Similar wording

and then let me flip back to that second floor

Similar wording

so that that board member Gaston

Similar wording