civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - October 14, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Oct 14, 20266h 39m

I have to have her close left, so she seems to be in a way that I do think it's wrong.

Similar wording

we ready okay um good morning chair we have 52 people in the virtual audience how many people

Similar wording

52 okay um does our executive director want to make a statement

Similar wording

good morning everyone welcome to the zoning board of adjustment just wanted to make a quick

Similar wording

announcement before we get started today there's likely to be a fire drill during this morning's

Similar wording

session if we do have to hold a fire drill um the meeting will be suspended until the uh

Similar wording

building staff gives us the all clear just wanted to make sure everyone knows there may be a

Similar wording

uh brief interruption in this morning's proceedings thank you chair

Similar wording

no we're just

Similar wording

it's illogical i said the same thing good morning everyone my name is bill bergman i will be

Similar wording

chairing this morning's meeting with me is our vice chair tenetta graham president mr chairman

Similar wording

board secretary cheryl l gaston president mr chairman board members michael johns president

Similar wording

mr chairman iowen who will be here any minute layla bb present mr chairman also here is our

Similar wording

attorney lynn reuter uber our executive director ian hagerty um this hearing is being recorded

Similar wording

and will be posted on the cba website by participating you consent to be recorded

Similar wording

this is an in-person meeting with remote participation whether in person or in zoom

Similar wording

if you are called to speak please state and spell your name then wait to be sworn in

Similar wording

after being sworn in each time you testify start by stating your name

Similar wording

to under your appearance indicate the address on your zoom webinar speak with a staff member

Similar wording

call this ebay office by the close of business tomorrow please call 215-686-2429 and provide

Similar wording

your name email and the case address with remote participation raise your virtual hand

Similar wording

when directed so that we can call you to speak when we call you ensure you click join as a

Similar wording

panelists button use the q a only for um only for uh questions not questions concerning the

Similar wording

individual case if you are joining by phone please please press star nine and raise your hand and

Similar wording

And then star six to unmute in in person participation.

Similar wording

If testifying, please state, please get close to the microphone so that all attendees and

Similar wording

the court stenographer can hear you.

Similar wording

No talking, eating or drinking during the hearings.

Similar wording

Aggressive behavior will not be tolerated in an emergency.

Similar wording

please follow staff instructions the the main exit is the double doors in the rear and also

Similar wording

the nearest stairwell is to the left if we evacuate go to Logan Park which is across

Similar wording

Art Street please remain here so that we can call on you so let's look at our schedule for this

Similar wording

morning number one mi 2026 002 135 854 corinthian avenue that case is continued until 2 10 27

Similar wording

at 9 30 a.m. number two mi 2026 002 593 5024 um c street um we have no exhibits for this case

Similar wording

um kuang long is the listed owner

Similar wording

good morning chair this is doreen and i will be co-hosting this morning and i see no hands

Similar wording

okay um so this is the first listing so this case will be continued until 2 10

Similar wording

So this is the first listing.

Similar wording

So this case will be continued until 2-10-27 at 9.30 a.m. and mark must be heard.

Similar wording

Number three, MI-2026-00258-459 East Walnut Lane.

Similar wording

This case is continued until 2-10-27 at 9.30.

Similar wording

Number four, MI 2026-002-639-6402-Walnut Lane, Wood Lane, Woodland Avenue.

Similar wording

This case is continued until 2-10-27 at 9.30 a.m.

Similar wording

Before the interruption, Chair, co-host, could you please promote interpreter Tram Lay to interpret that for Woodland Avenue?

Similar wording

Yes, give me one second.

Similar wording

Tram Lay?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Tram Lay has been promoted to panelists.

Similar wording

Good morning, sir.

Similar wording

Tran Lai, you're allowed to speak.

Similar wording

Hi, could you please state and spell your name for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm that you will interpret accurately, completely and impartially from English to Vietnamese and from Vietnamese to English?

Similar wording

Thank you very much.

Similar wording

So the results of this case is this case is continued until 2.10.27 at 9.30 a.m.

Similar wording

Thank you very much for your help.

Similar wording

We really appreciate it.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

thank you interpreter you're dismissed

Similar wording

thanks a lot for choosing our service your honor interpreter disconnect the line thank you all right

Similar wording

thank you very much yes number five mi2026 000 549 7343 well i'm colin pike this case is

Similar wording

contingent until 2-10-27 at 9 30 a.m. and number 6 MI 2026 002-447-1606 West Tioga this case has been withdrawn

Similar wording

we want to go to our add-ons

Similar wording

Number one, MI-2025-007-690-3301, grains back.

Similar wording

The vote in this matter has been rescheduled to October 28th at 9.30 a.m.

Similar wording

number um number two can we have a spanish interpreter

Similar wording

uh spanish interpreter will be promoted thank you very much yes mr chairman i am yeah

Similar wording

I'm trying to be better.

Similar wording

Good morning, your honor. Good morning, members. Good morning. How are you? Could you please state

Similar wording

and spell your name for the stenographer? Yes, sir. My name is Leonel Gillen,

Similar wording

spelled as a first name spelled as an L-E-O-N-E-L

Similar wording

last name Gillen spelled as a G-U-I-L-L-E-N

Similar wording

You swear or affirm that you will interpret

Similar wording

accurately, completely, and impartially

Similar wording

from English to Spanish, from Spanish to English?

Similar wording

I swear.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So case number two,

Similar wording

let's call the person on.

Similar wording

Mr. Ward?

Similar wording

Is that?

Similar wording

It's a vote only, though.

Similar wording

It's a vote only though. It's a vote only though. We're only voting.

Similar wording

It's a vote on.

Similar wording

Okay. All right. That's it. We're okay. So MI 2026 002 284 4063 North 6th Street.

Similar wording

Bien, entonces el caso MI2020-600228-44063. Norte, Sexta Calle.

Similar wording

Thank you. I vote yes and our council will read in a proviso.

Similar wording

Very good, I vote yes, and our vice president will read the conditions.

Similar wording

Lynn Weidelhubber Board Council. As the chairman indicated, the vote is yes with proviso. The proviso is the approved use. Vacant commercial space on first floor.

Similar wording

Muy bien, entonces, soy Lynn Weidler y como miembro del consejo se indica de que el voto es sí con condición.

Similar wording

La condición es que debe ser, es que es aprobado con el uso de un espacio vacante comercial, un espacio vacante comercial en el primer piso.

Similar wording

Use, registration required prior to occupancy. That relates to the commercial space.

Similar wording

Se debe tener un registro previo a que se ocupe el lugar.

Similar wording

Relacionado con el, y el registro debe estar relacionado con el espacio comercial.

Similar wording

and two household family

Similar wording

and a bar y un área de dos familias un área de vivienda de dos familias en la parte de arriba

Similar wording

michael

Similar wording

uh i thought that was that was the no on the commercial

Similar wording

it is she supposed to be a yes vote and you had no at the end am i correct no no this is the other

Similar wording

one michael this is just with a commercial on the first floor no michael solamente con

Similar wording

el con la parte comercial en el primer piso i'm confused i'm confused in it i'm sorry

Similar wording

So, so, so the vote is the vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Entonces la voto es sí, ok, la voto es, el voto es sí, pero con condición, ok.

Similar wording

With the, with commercial on the first floor in two household above it, that's all, you're saying yes.

Similar wording

Ok.

Similar wording

Sí, que es la parte comercial en la parte del primer piso y vivienda de dos familias en la parte de arriba, ok, sí.

Similar wording

All right, thank you.

Similar wording

are you voting I thought I did he said yes with proviso oh okay

Similar wording

wait Michael can you make sure that's on the record again I don't know if it can oh yes

Similar wording

michael johnson my vote is yes with proviso seeing michael johnson we vote to see a corn condition

Similar wording

cheryl gaston my vote is yes with proviso cheryl caston we want to seek a condition

Similar wording

tennetta graham my vote is yes supervisor tennetta winn

Similar wording

oh okay i'm sorry is this this i'm sorry because i'm still confused i know yes this this is the

Similar wording

one across from the school where we voted no on the commercial on the ground floor but okay for

Similar wording

the residential right no that that's another one that's different that's coming oh so this is not

Similar wording

the 20th street no no no okay okay all right okay because i have it i have a different on my list

Similar wording

sorry about that my apologies no no leila bb my vote is just with proviso i am when my brother

Similar wording

okay um number three mi 2026

Similar wording

zero zero two three two three 1733 west butler street i vote yes with proviso internal trash

Similar wording

storage muy bien ahora vamos con

Similar wording

thank you we appreciate your your help it's a pleasure uh may i be excuse your honor you can

Similar wording

it's a pleasure uh may i be excused your honor you can't sure thank you do you have uh one yes

Similar wording

start thank you we do have uh one yes

Similar wording

interpreter you're dismissed thank you michael johns my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

cheryl gaston my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

i win my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

okay number four mi 2026 002 485 1505 west gerrard avenue i vote yes

Similar wording

michael johns my vote is yes cheryl gaston my vote is yes iowen my vote is yes

Similar wording

number five mi 2025 006 um 000 622 64 41 20th street um

Similar wording

reviso i never mind we'll we'll come back to it in a minute

Similar wording

do not get online participants please stand by we're having a fire drill in the building

Similar wording

we'll resume shortly all right thank you everyone we appreciate your patience so we're going to move

Similar wording

to number six mi2026-009-460-3807 cambridge street our council has a comment here or announcement

Similar wording

lynn reidel huber board council

Similar wording

I'll go back our Council has comments relative

Similar wording

our so everyone knows we're on number six which is 3807 Cambridge Street our Council has an

Similar wording

announcement um yes lynn reidel huber board council the board is reopening the record in

Similar wording

this matter to conduct a resumption hearing on november 4th

Similar wording

um again i'll start the board is reopening this is in um 3807 cambridge street um the board is

Similar wording

reopening the record in this matter excuse me to conduct a resumption hearing on november 4th

Similar wording

2026 at 2 p.m. instead of the scheduled vote

Similar wording

i want to start over again okay i'll start over again lynn reidel huber board council

Similar wording

um this is an announcement uh the board is reopening the record in this matter to conduct

Similar wording

a resumption hearing on november 4th 2026 at 2 p.m instead of the scheduled vote the purpose

Similar wording

of the resumption hearing is to discuss any changes to the plans since the october 7th

Similar wording

hearing as well as to receive an update on any additional discussions with the community

Similar wording

regarding the project

Similar wording

Thank you. We're going to move to number seven. 2030 West Ontario Street. Candia Presley has filed a non-protunk hearing. Is she in the audience? We want to bring her on first.

Similar wording

No, I think we can just make it.

Similar wording

All right. So our counsel has a message for us relative to this case.

Similar wording

Yes. Candia Presley filed an appeal on behalf of 2030 West Ontario Street. I believe it's an LLC. The hearing in this matter will not go forward today. A new date for said hearing will be scheduled in the future.

Similar wording

Thank you very much. We're going to move to our regular list and we're going to start with

Similar wording

number seven and eight. So we'll hear this together. So MI 2026-002-514-4401 Silverwood

Similar wording

Street. And number eight is MI202600.

Similar wording

And number eight is MI-2026-002-534-4403 Silverwood Street.

Similar wording

John Hunter is a pro se for both, am I correct?

Similar wording

Correct.

Similar wording

Mr. Hunter.

Similar wording

John Hunter has been promoted to panelists.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

john hannah you're allowed to speak

Similar wording

thank you good morning good morning john let me see if i see your

Similar wording

john could you turn your video on

Similar wording

it is on it should be on okay um

Similar wording

I don't I don't think it's on John we just see it like a white basically spot in the middle

Similar wording

dark screen with a white spot in the middle

Similar wording

I see your name yeah um I'm sorry about this

Similar wording

also for some reason I'm getting a delay on when I speak

Similar wording

okay um do you want to take a look at it and i'll come back to you i'll um i'll be back in a short

Similar wording

period of time i'll um let me come back in about uh 10 15 minutes how's that that's fine i'll try

Similar wording

and correct it, but I don't know how. Thank you, John. Number 9, MI 2025, 007-219-828

Similar wording

Brooklyn Street. Vernon Anastasia was the attorney. This is a resumptive hearing.

Similar wording

we're going to have to clarify a couple things sure burn is coming in as a panelist thank you

Similar wording

morning mr chair morning vernon could you please state and spell your name for this

Similar wording

sonographer. Yes, it's Vern Anastasio, A-N-A-S-T-A-S-I-O. On behalf of Mr. Herbert Blackwood,

Similar wording

828 Brooklyn. Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do. Vern, before we start, our counsel has just a few questions she wants to ask. Sure.

Similar wording

Well, I have a couple others just because you indicated your client. We have your client as

Similar wording

foac investment holdings llc is that correct that's correct mr blackwood is the sole uh

Similar wording

member no problem i want to clarify that um but with regard to the actual hearing today

Similar wording

um it looks like we received some plans but it looks like this was held for you to submit revised

Similar wording

plans and it wasn't clear if these were plans were revised or not because you did not submit

Similar wording

a proviso form yeah these plans are revised it has the eight foot setback um which eliminates

Similar wording

the um one of the refusals the only other refusal being uh the use as a two-family dwelling

Similar wording

um the proviso form will be forthcoming and that was not submitted i i did ask the architect to

Similar wording

put that together for us but i don't think i've gotten it back yet so if we need to hold the vote

Similar wording

until then i'll be we'll make sure that that's forwarded to you this week

Similar wording

um the chairman will decide on that but yeah we do need the proviso form

Similar wording

yep thank you okay so this is this is a result of hearing um one of you um and where i see it is

Similar wording

you're going to make a presentation of additional evidence am i correct correct and the questions

Similar wording

from the board public and also planning so why don't you start understood uh this is uh this

Similar wording

is a lot in question uh 828 brooklyn street yeah this is the result this is the rendering of the

Similar wording

property it would be a two-story aligned with the cornices on the adjacent properties and

Similar wording

then the third story will be setback eight feet the plot plan has not changed but for the eight

Similar wording

foot setback pages 9 and 10 of the exhibit show the basement and the first

Similar wording

floor layout the change of course is the second and third floors the second floor

Similar wording

of course is the second and third floors the second floor had your living room with the

Similar wording

living room.

Similar wording

bedroom in the rear and then the primary bedroom with the um the eight foot setback here

Similar wording

we also were able to meet with the rco

Similar wording