civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - January 29, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jan 29, 20256h 11m

is really part of the new hospital tower. And there was a Silverstein Pavilion sign here

Similar wording

for recognition of that entrance. So if I go to, I'm going to skip past a couple of these to one

Similar wording

that's probably easier to see. Current condition. So now zooming in, you can see where that new

Similar wording

bridge construction occurs, where the former sign was here at this location. So that sign,

Similar wording

in order to achieve the construction needed to be displaced.

Similar wording

And our wish is to erect a new sign

Similar wording

for building identification, really,

Similar wording

at this location, at this scale.

Similar wording

So there's a couple of things here.

Similar wording

The sign is slightly larger than previous,

Similar wording

and part of our reasoning there is just that it is higher above the sidewalk,

Similar wording

so we want to make sure it's still legible from street level.

Similar wording

And then the addition of Penn Medicine, which was not part of the original sign, really just because as this whole neighborhood has evolved in that time since 1978, you know, it's a very dense area.

Similar wording

And there are a lot of Penn and CHOP and other folks kind of intertwined here.

Similar wording

So it's important that people understand which building they're coming to.

Similar wording

And below here, where the emergency department formerly was, this is a secondary entrance that some visitors are encouraged to utilize.

Similar wording

So it's important for them to understand which building they're trying to locate.

Similar wording

And I think that is the description, unless I can add to that.

Similar wording

So that's your request, that one sign?

Similar wording

This sign here, yeah.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Questions from the board.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Will there be any lights around the illuminating of the...

Similar wording

It is not illuminated.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

It's...

Similar wording

Other questions?

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

yeah just i'm trying to know is it individual letters it's individual yeah what we call

Similar wording

aluminum pin letters it's individual letters fixed to the facade and they are not illuminated so we

Similar wording

just be very visible during the day and we rely on the ambient light of the neighborhood it's a

Similar wording

pretty pretty bright even in the evening just due to all the activity anyone else with questions

Similar wording

questions from our attorney no mr chair questions from the audience questions from the virtual

Similar wording

audience i do not see any hands mr chair planning commission

Similar wording

amy boyd with the planning commission the comprehensive plan recommends no change in

Similar wording

zoning from the existing special purpose institutional spin the proposal is to relocate

Similar wording

signage to accommodate the addition of a pedestrian bridge the planning commission recommends a board

Similar wording

grant their requested variance for sign location and max area. Thank you. MI 2024-006-403-3400

Similar wording

Spruce Street, I vote yes. Michael Johns, my vote is yes. Cheryl Gaston, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Tanetta Graham, my vote is yes. Taya Nguyen, my vote is yes. Ishmael Shaheed, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Thank you. Thank you very much. Appreciate it very much.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Say that again.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Pardon me?

Similar wording

so the 3 30 list mi 2024 001 938 2091 bridge street we have an interpreter for this

Similar wording

counsel you don't have the i gotta i gotta let me go get the interpreter

Similar wording

so

Similar wording

did you need the interpreter

Similar wording

hello can you hear me now

Similar wording

hello we can hear you sir okay thank you very much hello my name is ronel and i'm going to be

Similar wording

the spanish interpreter and of course everything is uh everything is confidential ready when you

Similar wording

are hi could you please state your name again and spell for the interpreter

Similar wording

Yes, my name is Leonel, spelled L-E-O-N, as in Nancy, E-L.

Similar wording

Last name is Gillen, G-U-I-L-L-E-N.

Similar wording

Do you solemnly swear or affirm that you will interpret accurately, completely, and impartially

Similar wording

from English to Spanish and from Spanish to English, to the best of your ability?

Similar wording

Yes, I swear.

Similar wording

Okay, could you please...

Similar wording

Call for us.

Similar wording

Marley Hidalgo Perez.

Similar wording

¿Está presente Marley Hidalgo Perez?

Similar wording

¿Está presente Marley Hidalgo Perez?

Similar wording

Una vez más, Marley Hidalgo Perez.

Similar wording

Yes, they have been promoted to panelists. They should be rejoining shortly.

Similar wording

Do we have her paperwork and all?

Similar wording

Okay, all right. Interpreter, could you please wait until she comes on and I'll swear her in?

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

an interpreter can you ask her to unmute please yes sir yes ma'am

Similar wording

uh marley hidalgo perez puede encender su micrófono por favor

Similar wording

okay somebody's got their something on the back yes could you please tell her to spell her name

Similar wording

for the

Similar wording

And I will ask her if she can

Similar wording

because there's a lot of background noise

Similar wording

Marley Hidalgo Pérez

Similar wording

Señorita, por favor, puede

Similar wording

deletrar su nombre y puede

Similar wording

ver la forma de que

Similar wording

no haya tanto ruido de fondo

Similar wording

por favor, I have asked her

Similar wording

if she can move to a place where there's no

Similar wording

background noise

Similar wording

Thank you, interpreter, see how she responds

Similar wording

Yes, sir

Similar wording

my interpreter could you ask her do you swear or affirm that tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

señorita usted jura decir la verdad toda la verdad y nada más que la verdad

Similar wording

yes interpreter could you please tell her that we do not have all her documents

Similar wording

and that we are going to continue this case until six eight twenty five

Similar wording

until six yeah interpreter could you please tell her that we're going to continue her case

Similar wording

until seven nine twenty five because we don't have all her documents

Similar wording

señorita entonces ya que no tenemos todos los documentos vamos a continuar su caso hasta el 7

Similar wording

9 del 25 no todos los documentos se le ha mandado para absent

Similar wording

no but i have sent all the documents we have sent all the documents and we have the packages

Similar wording

for months this is the second time they continue this case

Similar wording

we have the tax here we have the pictures everything you guys asked for

Similar wording

listen uh interpreter please tell her we received her documents yesterday we need to have them at

Similar wording

five days prior and that we're going to continue the case and it'll become back up seven oh nine

Similar wording

twenty-five at three thirty p.m. si recibimos su documento

Similar wording

recibimos todos sus documentos ayer pero necesitamos tener los cinco días previo a la cita

Similar wording

así que vamos a continuar su caso de nuevo el 7 del 9 del 25 a las 3 30

Similar wording

Thank you very much, please tell her that the case will be in July and we will have an interpreter at that time too. Thank you very much, sir.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Muy bien, señorita, entonces vamos a darle a continuar hasta julio y vamos a tener un intérprete para usted en ese momento. Muchas gracias por su tiempo.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Gracias.

Similar wording

Number 11, MI 2024-006-532-1141-South 13th Street.

Similar wording

Vern Anastasio is the attorney.

Similar wording

No, no, we're two.

Similar wording

We're two left.

Similar wording

We'll be back in as a panelist shortly, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

good evening mr hi verne you've already been sworn um could you just state your name for the

Similar wording

record yeah it's verne anastasio on behalf of dr vicky borgia of radiance medical group right

Similar wording

and could you um all right our vice chair has a few questions thank you good afternoon council

Similar wording

do you agree to weigh the reading of the refusal or stipulate to its accuracy yes sir have you

Similar wording

emailed in all the required documents and exhibits as needed and required to proceed with this case

Similar wording

five days in advance of this hearing yes sir thank you council please proceed you've already

Similar wording

the passion square civic associations in non-opposition as well as council members

Similar wording

Correct. And we also submitted signatures of immediate neighbors, 145 signatures of folks who live within the immediate neighborhood and support.

Similar wording

1141 South 13th Street. We've got a 94 page exhibit packet. I won't go over everything, but I'll go over the most important parts.

Similar wording

The application is for two solo practices for medical and one group practice.

Similar wording

Solo practices are by right use.

Similar wording

The one group medical practice is why we're here.

Similar wording

As you can see here, the group medical practice is prohibited in RSA 5.

Similar wording

and my client currently is a sole practitioner but she would like the opportunity to bring

Similar wording

another practitioner on when and if the time arises there's certainly plenty of space there

Similar wording

so as you can see the long history of granting uh different sorts of uh of uh of uses and

Similar wording

And as you're going to see here at page 76 of the exhibit packet, you're going to see a very long history going back decades of the first floor being a studio for drama and voice.

Similar wording

Before that, it was a cooking school. So the first floor hasn't been single family residential in a very, very long time.

Similar wording

Our proposal is just a continuation of the use as we propose it to be, continuing in the tradition of commercial.

Similar wording

Here's the plans, and I will zoom in a little bit.

Similar wording

It's a corner property.

Similar wording

Enter right here where my cursor is.

Similar wording

There's a reception immediately to someone's left.

Similar wording

And then there's a waiting area here along, I guess that's along this side here.

Similar wording

Yep. Along this side here. And then as you can see, one, two, three, four examination rooms with some lab and some storage, a restroom and a kitchenette for some breaks. Trash area in the rear.

Similar wording

And then as you can see, one, two.

Similar wording

there are the plans let me show you some photos

Similar wording

this is the property in question it's been vacant for a very very long time

Similar wording

uh i have passed this property myself um at least you know five or six dozen times in the

Similar wording

past few years and it's been vacant for for quite some time so but it's in you know relatively good

Similar wording

shape on the exterior it hasn't been hacked up over the years with bad materials inside does

Similar wording

need some work you can see here and my client is committed to bringing it back to life

Similar wording

nice big windows. I think it's really ideal for commercial use, and the medical offices

Similar wording

will be a real asset to the community. As part of the 94-page exhibit packet, we have Google

Similar wording

reviews, all five stars for Dr. Borgia. And of course, we also have information about our

Similar wording

practice. It's a unique practice. It's a general practice that focuses on accessibility

Similar wording

and affordability. And here's the letter that went out to all immediate neighbors,

Similar wording

inviting them not only to the RCO meeting

Similar wording

but to the zoning hearing up today on the

Similar wording

29th. Passion Square at Philly

Similar wording

Foot and Washington Avenue have all been mailed as have all of these

Similar wording

addresses.

Similar wording

As you can see, it's a pretty

Similar wording

tight neighborhood with lots of homes.

Similar wording

and we have proof of mailing from vista 192 households

Similar wording

which is kind of high so at this point i want to show you the uh after the presentation before

Similar wording

during and after actually we've collected signatures from 145 immediate neighbors on 13th

Similar wording

on peters on federal on wharton latona ellsworth

Similar wording

my client circulated these petitions

Similar wording

most of them secured in december and january

Similar wording

we have a letter of support from william and valerie cohen of 1165 south 13th which is

Similar wording

literally right you know right there there we are 1141

Similar wording

we have a letter of non-opposition from councilman squilla

Similar wording

and a letter of non-opposition unanimous support from passion square civic association

Similar wording

Again, here's some information on the practice itself.

Similar wording

And because of the long history of commercial use on this first floor, because my client is bringing a much needed amenity of medical services to the community,

Similar wording

and because she has support from over 145 folks who signed her petition of support in addition

Similar wording

to three separate letters, one being from the district council member and the other being from

Similar wording

the RCO, I respectfully request the granting of the variance. Thank you.

Similar wording

Do you want to bring your client on? I would like to if she's still available. She did have to seek

Similar wording

clients um about 30 minutes ago but dr vicky one quick question before she comes on this is first

Similar wording

floor only first floor only yeah so bern there's a note here no amplified sound on the second floor

Similar wording

No amplified sound on the second floor.

Similar wording

what's what's that mean

Similar wording

What's that mean?

Similar wording

screen.

Similar wording

I have no idea.

Similar wording

Who's that from?

Similar wording

Passion Square.

Similar wording

Two lists.

Similar wording

Proviso.

Similar wording

Close at 8 p.m.

Similar wording

And no amplified sound on the second floor.

Similar wording

I can't speak to that.

Similar wording

This application is for first floor only.

Similar wording

All right, good.

Similar wording

Is your client here?

Similar wording

Yeah, she should be.

Similar wording

Dr. Vicki Borgia, please raise your hand.

Similar wording

yeah our interior layout is exclusive to the first floor

Similar wording

and that's where the offices will be here

Similar wording

they're coming back in as the panelist chair

Similar wording

thank you very much

Similar wording

let's do this again

Similar wording

hi could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer

Similar wording

uh my name is victoria borgia b as in boy o r g i a we swear or affirm to tell the truth the

Similar wording

whole truth and nothing but the truth yes please proceed counsel thank you vicky did you hear my

Similar wording