civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - April 21, 2021

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Apr 21, 20218h 28m

ownership, the refusal, the tax clearance, the RCO meeting notes, and the drawings. I'm also here

Similar wording

today to request the building is currently zoned as a single-family residence. I am here to request

Similar wording

the variance changed to a two-family residence. I also want to note to the board that initially

Similar wording

back in 2013, the previous owner prior to me was approved for a five-unit variance in 2013.

Similar wording

So they were approved in 2013 for five units. I guess they didn't do any work to it. So then

Similar wording

and it reverted back to the single family residency.

Similar wording

single-family residency. The next document shows proof of ownership. I purchased a property

Similar wording

The next document shows

Similar wording

last year in my company name in October of 2020. Next document is the refusal document.

Similar wording

Next document is my tax clearance.

Similar wording

and the next document is is um so we had two separate meetings with the rco and the in the

Similar wording

community the first meeting when i presented the five units they actually declined it due to

Similar wording

parking um in that area so we negotiated and we agreed at a second meeting um to limit it down to

Similar wording

two units in the building and i have full support from the community as you can see here

Similar wording

hmc squared community association yes correct

Similar wording

okay can we see the drawings yes absolutely that's next okay absolutely um i'm going to

Similar wording

get the drawings

Similar wording

okay so the first page is a rendering of the front and the back of the property

Similar wording

to the left here is the front and then to the right is the back of the property

Similar wording

no no significant changes i'm just going to um update the front it's kind of it's kind

Similar wording

of dilapidated now it's it's out of date it's it's not it's not um it's not very appealing to

Similar wording

the visual eye so i'm just going to change it up a little bit just to spruce up and make it look

Similar wording

nice to um in order to improve the improve the area the back to the right no changes to the

Similar wording

back really i'm just going to cut this tree um because some of the neighbors um complained about

Similar wording

this tree leaning over into their property so i'm just going to cut the tree the next rendering is

Similar wording

the is the actual drawings sorry there's some technical difficulties

Similar wording

please. Okay. Okay. So from left to right, to the left, we have the basement. No change

Similar wording

we do not see the drawings oh i'm sorry that's okay um excuse me sir do you have

Similar wording

what you would have to do is to unshare and then click on your drawing so that they're open and

Similar wording

ready then share again and they should present on the screen okay okay and then

Similar wording

did you see the front and the back renderings or no

Similar wording

No, you're currently not sharing your presentation.

Similar wording

You just have to click on share screen again

Similar wording

with your documents already open.

Similar wording

Let's go back up and show both, Mr. Coburn.

Similar wording

All right, I'll back up and show both.

Similar wording

I apologize for the inconvenience.

Similar wording

So I need to go back.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Are you sharing this, Tom?

Similar wording

No, I need to share another document.

Similar wording

I need to share this.

Similar wording

my apologies for the delay that's okay sir so we still not seeing the um actual pictures you

Similar wording

have to click on your pictures first um and then click the um share screen

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

okay am i sharing now yes awesome perfect and now can you rotate the screen yes

Similar wording

i know it's one thing after another yeah yeah another 180 okay all right perfect there you go

Similar wording

perfect

Similar wording

I gotta rotate

Similar wording

some more

Similar wording

my apologies

Similar wording

rotate

Similar wording

rotate

Similar wording

rotate

Similar wording

all right

Similar wording

all right

Similar wording

okay here we go here we go thank you so much for your patience thank you all right so this

Similar wording

everybody has a problem you're not alone thank you so much um so again this is the front of the

Similar wording

property no no major changes to the front um we're probably just going to remove this graffiti

Similar wording

paint the front keep it pretty much the same we're also going to build a beautiful front porch as

Similar wording

well um and that's that's the changes to the front of the property and then to the right over here we

Similar wording

have the back of the property no major changes to the back of the property either we're just going

Similar wording

to cut this tree because i received some complaints from the neighbor next door to me that some of

Similar wording

the branches are falling over into her property so i'm going to remove this tree in order to

Similar wording

protect my property as well as the neighbor's property as well.

Similar wording

So now I'm going to attempt to go to the drawings. I'm going to stop share

Similar wording

and then share screen.

Similar wording

all right so these are the drawings of the of the building can everybody see the drawings

Similar wording

yes okay all right excellent so from left to right to the left is the basement no changes to the

Similar wording

basement that's going to continue to be it'll just be my utility room that have all the electrical

Similar wording

panels and all that all the utility things in the basement the next drawing represents the first

Similar wording

floor so it's a three-story building the building's about 2 000 square feet my initial plans were to

Similar wording

be five units. Then I try to get three units in there, but then I got back, I got pushed back

Similar wording

from the community. So we agreed to two units. So in order to execute two units, we're going to do

Similar wording

one unit on the first floor. That's apartment number one. It'll occupy the entire first floor

Similar wording

to be a two-bedroom unit on the first floor. And then on the second and third floor, we'll occupy

Similar wording

a bi-level second unit apartment. The bi-level apartment on the second floor will have two

Similar wording

bedrooms, beautiful living area, open space, and a bathroom and a kitchen. And then on the third

Similar wording

floor, it will be another full bathroom with a shower and a tub and another bedroom, as well as

Similar wording

a study hall as well like a study room a den on the third floor so again my my my request today

Similar wording

is to um convert this single family residence into a two-unit multi-unit residence the first

Similar wording

floor having one unit one apartment with two bedrooms and the second and third floor will

Similar wording

occupy the second unit with three total bedrooms plus a den plus two full bathrooms

Similar wording

any questions from from the board we do have a letter of support from the hmc squared community

Similar wording

association does the board have any questions no no is there anyone in the virtual audience

Similar wording

who has questions

Similar wording

yes chair we have a tina marie russell okay so you can unmute yourself

Similar wording

tina can you hear me

Similar wording

miss russell you just have to unmute yourself

Similar wording

LaKeisha did she raise her hand um yes she just um still muted not sure what if you want to go on

Similar wording

Yeah, it must be a technical problem.

Similar wording

uh tanya what do you recommend that i do we can move on if you wish

Similar wording

Tanya, what do you recommend that I do?

Similar wording

okay next uh next step is planning commission

Similar wording

ian you have to unmute yourself

Similar wording

my apologies thank you madam chair ian hegarty for the philadelphia city planning commission

Similar wording

this property is within an area um where we have an in-process zoning map amendment

Similar wording

that would make a change from rsa3 to rm1 the zoning bill has been referred favorably out of

Similar wording

the rules committee but has not been reflected on the zoning map yet um the proposed use is

Similar wording

consistent with the um use and the dwelling unit density that would be allowed as a matter of right

Similar wording

under the proposed zoning district and so we recommend that the board grant this variance

Similar wording

okay um tina are you are you there yet

Similar wording

i do have a question where is the trash going to be stored that's a great question um if i can go

Similar wording

back to the front i can show you the picture i can stop share and then share

Similar wording

this is a special trash room correct correct so to the left in the front of the building

Similar wording

to the left of the building um there is a gated area or the trash will be in that gated area

Similar wording

we can't see the building yes i will bring it up right now i'm sorry

Similar wording

okay i apologize but the picture is not is not really clear but if you can follow the arrow of

Similar wording

the mouse um this left area here is a gated area it's an alleyway all the trash should be kept in

Similar wording

the alleyway i will advise all of my tenants to keep the trash in that alleyway and on trash day

Similar wording

to put the trash out and then of course once the trash is picked up to to put the trash cans back

Similar wording

in this area here in this alleyway here you'll be the manager of this building i am yes i'm the

Similar wording

manager of i actually manage all of my properties i um i'm very active um the the community can

Similar wording

attest to it when like during the snow storms i was there shoveling myself personally um i visit

Similar wording

the property at least at a minimum once a week to make sure everything is clean and and um i just

Similar wording

be a part of the community and i want to add value to that add value to that area thank you

Similar wording

i've been representing mr nobren in this capacity for the last 12 years

Similar wording

he's a hands-on manager visits his properties a couple times a month

Similar wording

and is very very responsive to city

Similar wording

that's great is tina

Similar wording

tina are you on

Similar wording

Tanya, I'm going to move forward and vote the case.

Similar wording

Does that sound reasonable?

Similar wording

Sharon?

Similar wording

Yes, actually, can I ask Mr. Haggerty one question?

Similar wording

Hi.

Similar wording

You know any youth looking for work?

Similar wording

Oh, no, boys.

Similar wording

If you do...

Similar wording

I don't know who's speaking.

Similar wording

I think that was Tina Marie Russell.

Similar wording

If she's going to testify, that's fine.

Similar wording

Okay, Tina?

Similar wording

I'm sorry, that was a mistake.

Similar wording

Okay, are you going to testify?

Similar wording

For this particular case?

Similar wording

No, that was a mistake on my hand.

Similar wording

My fingers were on my phone.

Similar wording

I'm sorry about that.

Similar wording

Okay. Ms. Saletta, do you still have a question for Mr. Haggerty?

Similar wording

Yes. Can I ask one question? Given that this has been reported favorably out of committee,

Similar wording

would you agree that the applicant could go in and get a buy-write permit at this point?

Similar wording

I'm sorry. That's unfair to ask you.

Similar wording

um i uh i i can confirm that that's that's a legal decision

Similar wording

I can confirm that's a legal decision and I know it involves other factors so you don't have to

Similar wording

scratch that question sorry she didn't say that strike that I'm going to vote the case calendar

Similar wording

number 3317 5924 Master Street my vote is yes my vote is yes my vote is yes my vote is yes

Similar wording

Thank you. Welcome to the virtual world, Mr. Levy. Calendar number 3267-6900 Chester Avenue.

Similar wording

Mr. Tariq, you can unmute yourself.

Similar wording

Tariq, can you put your name and address on the record and spell your last name?

Similar wording

You have to unmute yourself.

Similar wording

Tariq, can you speak?

Similar wording

I don't see a speaker.

Similar wording

Can you put a thumbs up?

Similar wording

Tariq, can you hear us?

Similar wording

Yeah, don't see audio.

Similar wording

Yeah, maybe Mr. Wright needs to go out and come back in.

Similar wording

Or he might need to call in on the phone.

Similar wording

Right.

Similar wording

I see another device under his name.

Similar wording

can you guys hear me now

Similar wording

can you put your name and address on the record

Similar wording

and spell your name please and then I'll swear you in

Similar wording

can you hear me

Similar wording

uh it's technical you guys hear me now i'm sorry okay uh yeah now now i can clearly

Similar wording

sir do you have more than one device on in the same

Similar wording

yes may you uh turn one of the devices off okay

Similar wording

can i make a suggestion kari if you are you using a computer

Similar wording

if you're using a computer mute the computer and then put the volume on the device you need to use

Similar wording

to speak but you can't have both volumes on so if your computer doesn't have speakers mute that

Similar wording

or turn the volume all the way down then try to speak through whatever device you're using

Similar wording

to hit the audio let's try our audio test

Similar wording

nope it doesn't appear clear you guys hear me clearly now okay now that's better

Similar wording

Yeah, that's great.

Similar wording

Tariq, can you put your name and address on the phone?

Similar wording

It keeps coming on.

Similar wording

Ryan, we're still seeing you as two different connections.

Similar wording

I think we might have to continue this because of technology.

Similar wording

I think it is Sharon.

Similar wording

um excuse me this is sharon um i know that i i believe the applicant and the property owner and

Similar wording

his wife were planning to testify is it possible that she is in the same room with another

Similar wording

device on or somewhere in the house would that affect it

Similar wording

Yes, that could be.

Similar wording

Tariq, can you do a slow audio test?

Similar wording

Tariq, are you there?

Similar wording

yeah so that we don't prolong things madam chair it's your call

Similar wording

okay i think we have to can we perhaps move this back one case since the applicant's wife did

Similar wording

Can we perhaps move this back one case since the applicant's wife did call yesterday to ask about procedural questions?

Similar wording

I'll try giving her a call now.

Similar wording

There is one more case on the list.

Similar wording

There is one more case.

Similar wording

Calendar number 0386716 North Shedwick Street.

Similar wording

Meredith Verliger is the attorney.

Similar wording

I do not see Meredith at this time.

Similar wording

Do we give her a few seconds?

Similar wording

Can we just call the case again, Chair, to see if anyone is here?

Similar wording

Calendar number, sure.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Calendar number 0386-716 North Shedwick Street.

Similar wording

The attorney listed is Meredith Verliger.

Similar wording