civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - June 11, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jun 11, 20253h 23m

yeah i gotta go through the kitchen yeah get to the bathroom i i i'm just i understand

Similar wording

that you are trying to work with the space that you have.

Similar wording

I understand that, but I really have a problem with it.

Similar wording

And this was when I did the cases with the health department.

Similar wording

You cannot have people going through to get to the bathroom,

Similar wording

they get to go through the kitchen in some way you know i i just and this is different it's a living situation

Similar wording

You know, I, I just, and this is different. It's a living situation, but still, um, I, I just really have a problem with that. It, it just seems like, you know, again, whoever's living there is going to, again, when they, when they want to shower, they want to take a bath or whatever.

Similar wording

They got to gather up all of those stuff to, you know, go to this bathroom and then come back through the kitchen to get to the bedroom.

Similar wording

I just I really don't like those kind of layouts.

Similar wording

And I don't think they're good.

Similar wording

That's a good living arrangement.

Similar wording

OK, so that's my comment.

Similar wording

I understand.

Similar wording

That's my comment.

Similar wording

I appreciate that. And thank you for recognizing the unique physical condition of the property.

Similar wording

I understand that.

Similar wording

Yeah. And by the way, this is already...

Similar wording

This isn't the only one that I've seen.

Similar wording

Yep. And this is how the building presented itself to Mr. Ingram. It's not like he did it,

Similar wording

right? So we're just trying to sort of...

Similar wording

That's my comment. My question is about what is all this in the basement with all these

Similar wording

wires and things

Similar wording

that I see in these pictures.

Similar wording

Let me take a look.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Mr. Engram can speak on us.

Similar wording

That's up

Similar wording

above the basement level.

Similar wording

But when we got to the

Similar wording

basement

Similar wording

level...

Similar wording

Right here?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

That looks like a fan.

Similar wording

That was done

Similar wording

that was a lot of that stuff was oh i'm sorry yeah what's all this wire a lot of that was in

Similar wording

the basement already um so i guess that's still the wiring for the for the building some of it

Similar wording

is probably inactive um which can be removed and uh tightened up aren't you the property owner and

Similar wording

manager yeah well it can be it can be please understand that he's going to have to go through

Similar wording

the co process understandable but i just like i think my my question is like this there's a lot

Similar wording

happening here a lot of this was done not without permits i think it's obvious that it was done

Similar wording

without permits and i just want to know for you when your llc purchased this what was your plan

Similar wording

and what is your plan moving forward because it's like the basement's a mess there's an extra water

Similar wording

heater. There's a room down there. There's a lot of uses happening. There was work that was clearly

Similar wording

done since purchase, all done without permits. What is your plan and intention?

Similar wording

May I speak? I can answer the question. The question was for Mr. Ingram.

Similar wording

Vern, you represent. Go ahead. Oh, thank you. Only because I spent the last 10 months with him,

Similar wording

I know what his plan is. The plan is to hopefully secure a use permit for a three-family dwelling,

Similar wording

at which time engage an architect and an engineer to go through the CO process, schedule the

Similar wording

inspections, clean up the electric and all the major systems that need to be cleaned and up to

Similar wording

par, and also put in a sprinkler system, which is going to be required by the building code

Similar wording

uh examiner so we've got a lot of work to do still even though it looks nice uh first second

Similar wording

and third floor there's a lot of stuff behind the scenes that needs to happen before he can

Similar wording

have this uh you know fully occupied okay and the only use will be a three-family dwelling

Similar wording

questions from our attorney no mr chair questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

i see no hands planning commission amy boyd with the planning commission the comprehensive plan

Similar wording

recommends no change and zoning at this location from the existing residential single family rsa 5

Similar wording

the property has a history of commercial use and the proposal for residential is more aligned with

Similar wording

residential zoning however three family is not the least minimum and the conversion was created

Similar wording

without the benefit of permits the planning commission recommends that the board grant

Similar wording

their press variance for a multifamily with proviso max two units. So we're going to hold

Similar wording

this now, right? And it's two weeks enough. It's enough for me. I've been trying to get a meeting

Similar wording

for eight months. So what's the date two weeks? The date in two weeks would be June 25th. Right.

Similar wording

so we'll we'll come back june 25th at 9 30 a.m um i don't want to make it a resumptive hearing

Similar wording

we'll just you just vote on it everything's closed but we would need an update from you on where

Similar wording

just you just vote on it everything's closed

Similar wording

but we would need an update from you on where we stand but everything else is

Similar wording

closed thank you all right thank you

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

number 13 mi 2024 006 823 53 29 north 13th street natasha watson um sir i believe this one

Similar wording

wasn't this one continued must be heard

Similar wording

we may be on number 15 oh here it is here octavia brown yeah octavia brown number 15

Similar wording

mi 2025 000 491 555 van kirk street this is the one we had questions i heard in the beginning

Similar wording

i i may still have questions about that well that's okay thank you octavia hi hello good

Similar wording

Good morning, Octavia. I swore you in once before, just for the record, state your name.

Similar wording

Octavia, O-C-T-A-V-I-A, and my last name is Brown, B-R-O-W-N.

Similar wording

Counsel, do you have questions, Counsel?

Similar wording

Yes, I just wanted to make sure that I had this correct.

Similar wording

The photograph initially to prove posting only showed a refusal,

Similar wording

and then there was a photograph submitted more recently

Similar wording

that showed the poster in compliance with the code.

Similar wording

How long ago was that picture taken?

Similar wording

Can I answer the question in the beginning?

Similar wording

You remember?

Similar wording

You did.

Similar wording

The only thing we got was 21 days.

Similar wording

I asked for 21 days.

Similar wording

So was that poster up there 21 days?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Why don't you, I swore you in once,

Similar wording

why don't you start your presentation?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Give me one second.

Similar wording

I just got to make sure I'm doing this right.

Similar wording

I'm going to share my screen.

Similar wording

Sure.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

This is the file.

Similar wording

This application is for use as a group child care on the first floor of an existing attached

Similar wording

structure with existing group child care on the ground floor, creating totally two group

Similar wording

child care uses in the same structure and single family household living on the second

Similar wording

floor.

Similar wording

Are you guys able to see my screen?

Similar wording

Well, you have to then go to each one individual, right?

Similar wording

Yes, I will. I just want to make sure you guys can see.

Similar wording

Okay, I'm sorry.

Similar wording

So this, let me make this bigger.

Similar wording

So just to give you guys some pictures, that's the front of the building.

Similar wording

And this is the location that we're hoping to expand.

Similar wording

And I'm just going to explain myself while I'm talking.

Similar wording

And let me know if I'm-

Similar wording

Why don't you talk about what you're doing?

Similar wording

So you already have a child care center.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

So I have a child-

Similar wording

Do you want to put a second one there?

Similar wording

So I want to, sorry, I have a child care center on the bottom floor, which is, quote unquote, the basement level of the building.

Similar wording

What I want to do is I want to move that to, well, the classroom aspect of it to this floor here.

Similar wording

And I want to use the space that we're in as the indoor play space, as well as the space for we have a lot of, well, I won't say a lot.

Similar wording

We don't have a lot of youth in general, but we have a good amount of youth in our center.

Similar wording

I want to say roughly 40%. And I believe it will increase based on my observation. They are utilizing early intervention services, child link services, if you will. So that means we have speech, speech coming in, we have OT coming in. We also have physical therapy coming in. And the space that we are in now, I would like to utilize that space for when they do come in to service our youth, as well as an indoor play space for those youth as well.

Similar wording

um in the space that i'm showing you guys this is the bag um the space that i'm showing you guys

Similar wording

i would like for to be where we have our center our classrooms um so that's so i mean i'm calling

Similar wording

an expansion but it's definitely a change of use for the location um i also have how many children

Similar wording

do you already have so we are licensed for seven um i think with this expansion because of i just

Similar wording

read through like regs and things like that I think the most that group can have in that particular

Similar wording

area based on RSA 5 and different things is 12. 12 and both? No just so I would maintain the 12

Similar wording

kids upstairs that we're talking about on the first floor and those are the same 12 kids that

Similar wording

we would bring down to the play space which is will be the indoor place. So it's the same kids

Similar wording

you're going back and forth between places? Yes. Create a play space? Yes because right now in our

Similar wording

Yes, because right now in our center now, we utilize the we have an indoor play space, but it's very small.

Similar wording

center now we utilize the we have an indoor

Similar wording

So we have our classroom area and we also have an indoor play space.

Similar wording

That's what we're licensed for. But this will allow us to have a bigger play space, which would be great for our youth.

Similar wording

And these I'm sorry, I'll go slow. These are letters of support from our parents.

Similar wording

so show us what you have now and then you should go back and show us where you're moving to okay

Similar wording

okay let me make sure i have a picture of that

Similar wording

um can you give me one second i'm going to pull up some pictures of our current

Similar wording

of the current unit but this is the one we're moving to

Similar wording

when you say you're moving to this is all in the same building though right this is not

Similar wording

moving to this is just space within the yeah it's just a change in space everything is in the same

Similar wording

building and on the third floor is where you live no so the third floor is empty i want to utilize

Similar wording

the third floor as an office space for myself. I don't want any tenants or anything in there.

Similar wording

I don't want to do that anymore at all, as well as a potential break room for the staff.

Similar wording

So you're going from 7 to 12?

Similar wording

Yes, and that's the, from what I know, that's the maximum that we can have.

Similar wording

Because there are other, there are, there's also other daycares in the area that I've consulted with and asked questions, as well as ELRC, who basically gives us our funding and licensing and things like that.

Similar wording

Joe, do you think you have photos of the first floor, the basement level?

Similar wording

I'm looking for it now.

Similar wording

did i downloaded the photos for this exactly why it's not coming up okay take your time sorry

Similar wording

okay i'm going to share it right now i'm just sending it to myself

Similar wording

folder and i'm sorry i'm in the front of this picture but um

Similar wording

So let me ask you this.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

We can do this case at 2 o'clock.

Similar wording

Are you guys able to see my screen?

Similar wording

We don't.

Similar wording

We just see it.

Similar wording

Oh, I just shared it again.

Similar wording

Hold on.

Similar wording

Okay, so this is the location.

Similar wording

Can you see it now?

Similar wording

This is the first floor?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

So as you can see, that's the front area of the center right there where we have our classroom.

Similar wording

And then that door.

Similar wording

You have seven children there.

Similar wording

Yep.

Similar wording

And you see that door here.

Similar wording

That's our play area.

Similar wording

That's our area that we utilize for play.

Similar wording

We have two bathrooms on that side where you see the two doorknobs.

Similar wording

There's two bathrooms and one is utilized for the youth and one is for the staff.

Similar wording

So now you want to move upstairs.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

To have more play space.

Similar wording

yeah so this area here would be the complete play space and the upstairs with where we would

Similar wording

utilize the classrooms yes and and how would you get up there we would take the stairs so

Similar wording

we would just walk up this the stairs that's in front of the house okay all right now could

Similar wording

you show us what that's going to look like so there's two bathrooms in the basement yes so

Similar wording

do you want to go back to the pictures of the upstairs back to the other pictures okay sorry

Similar wording

about that no no no no okay um so this is the front exactly where you come in um let me pull

Similar wording

up another one and this is the front area um we will have when you first come in that's your

Similar wording

that's your base yeah no no this is up this is upstairs no i'm not seeing that i'm seeing you

Similar wording

oh my god all right let me share again sorry about that all right i'm going back okay

Similar wording

All right, let me share again. Sorry about that. All right, I'm going back. Okay. Are we here? You guys can see all the photos that I need to increase in size?

Similar wording

Okay, so that's right now a kitchen, am I right?

Similar wording

Yes, but I'm sorry, you cannot see. When you first walk in, there is a space that was normally utilized for a living room, and that's enough space that we can utilize for tables and chairs as well.

Similar wording

and we were going to utilize this area here

Similar wording

for the Eaton area for the youth

Similar wording

and then we

Similar wording

Which area? The existing kitchen?

Similar wording

Yes

Similar wording

Oh, let me close that out

Similar wording

I'm sorry

Similar wording

How old are the children?

Similar wording

They range from

Similar wording