civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - June 11, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jun 11, 20253h 23m

three-bath with access to the roof deck for the upper unit. Does that help, Ms. Gaston? Okay,

Similar wording

Mr. Brigham. Okay. Again, the letter from ProPAC that you should have in your file, but I included

Similar wording

it right here, and you can see that they're in support. They voted 37 to 3 in support of the

Similar wording

project, again, with the addition of the 12 surface parking spaces. And with that, I don't

Similar wording

have any more to present. Sure. Bob, could you please introduce yourself? Robert Huttenlock.

Similar wording

Hold that real close to you, if you could, please. Robert Huttenlock. You pulled all the

Similar wording

could you state your name is spelled robert hutton lock r-o-b-e-r-t h-u-t-t-e-n-l-o-c-k

Similar wording

do you swear or affirm to tell the truth told truth and not to put the truth yes please proceed

Similar wording

counsel uh bob what's your uh relationship to the owner of the property best choice ventures llc

Similar wording

i'm the owner of the llc okay and did you hear the statements that i made to the zoning board

Similar wording

today yes and they true and correct to the best of your knowledge yes and would you adopt them

Similar wording

as your own? Yes. Brendan Marsh, I believe, is on from Nome Architecture. Would you like them to

Similar wording

adopt my statements regarding the architecture for the project? You're an officer of the court.

Similar wording

If anybody needs him, we'll do that. Questions for the board.

Similar wording

Yes, I have a question about trash storage. So in the plans, I saw there was a lot of common

Similar wording

areas in the building for different things, and I did not see one for trash. That's a good

Similar wording

question so um we are planning we haven't set on an exact location yet more than likely it would

Similar wording

be in that area that exits towards the rear like between the duplex and the existing convent we

Similar wording

just have the water the old tower yeah right into the city it may be toward in the base of that or

Similar wording

it may be up against that um while we're still working on the landscaping with the planning

Similar wording

commission we weren't exactly sure but it's going to be blocked from view from the street by either

Similar wording

by the duplex and the convent and by the church on the one side and our single families on East

Similar wording

Madden Street on the other. And then I know you're still working through landscaping but just walk

Similar wording

me through what the like intent because right now it's a pretty hard scaped space it looks like it's

Similar wording

almost all asphalt currently around the convent and there's like an existing parking lot so

Similar wording

are there going to be any outdoor spaces for the tenants in the building? Well we'll have a we'll

Similar wording

have outdoor space some outdoor space between the rear of the convent and um where you see that

Similar wording

smokestack the smokestack is uh part of the church still but it's on it's on this property is it still

Similar wording

in commission or is it a decommission no it's still used okay they have an easement to use the

Similar wording

for that smokestack okay but there's an area between you know there's a kind of a courtyard

Similar wording

area there and then there's also an area between the as you can see there between the uh the stair

Similar wording

tower and the duplex okay and is the plan that it's going to be vegetated or paved it's

Similar wording

Okay. And is the plan that it's going to be vegetated or paved?

Similar wording

It's vegetated between the stair tower and the duplex.

Similar wording

We're showing now.

Similar wording

The buffer for the parking.

Similar wording

We're planning on putting potted plants back in the other area.

Similar wording

We can't excavate that area because the church's boiler room protrudes underneath of that area.

Similar wording

okay and then the side yard on the other side of the convent building and the duplex building

Similar wording

that's currently paved and the church has a has an easement there okay yeah there's a drive that

Similar wording

actually extends that kind of comes through here and kind of comes underneath so they that's still

Similar wording

maintained and that's so that's the easement that the church has that was part of the deal

Similar wording

so we actually don't really even control that it's even though it's on our property they used it and

Similar wording

it's just the way the properties had to be divvied up in order to try to maintain dimensional

Similar wording

compliance for the church and then for the building understood and then for clarity there's

Similar wording

14 parking spaces total yeah and 14 units so one to one is you know originally it was 14 and two

Similar wording

and luckily we were able to do that and again there's there's a little bit of green space in

Similar wording

the front here it's overgrown right now and this area back here will probably be some type of patio

Similar wording

or area where they can people can utilize and the easement for the drive aisle for the new parking

Similar wording

that's in the footprint of the current parking lot that's on the site yes right yeah yeah when

Similar wording

you say current parking lot like you mean historically or that where the school there's

Similar wording

a lot there now yeah yeah okay so it used to be a school and that was demolished and then it was

Similar wording

and then that was turned into a parking lot and that's where the single families are going right

Similar wording

and david we're going to see your final landscape plan once you work through it yes correct okay

Similar wording

Yes. Other questions from the board? Yes. So you are going to demolish the existing rear building?

Similar wording

Yes. Because of the engineering issue? Yes.

Similar wording

Structural engineering issue.

Similar wording

It was always going to be deemed a complete demolition because more than two-thirds of the joists were going to be removed.

Similar wording

The only joists are in the roof, and it's otherwise on slab.

Similar wording

So it was going to kind of look like an addition or maybe be an addition, but technically by code, it was going to be a complete demolition.

Similar wording

And now we're just going to take it all the way down to the foundation.

Similar wording

It was going to be it's going to be very expensive and it's going to be a lot of work.

Similar wording

So ultimately, it's it's better all around to just build a clean building from the ground up.

Similar wording

OK. And what about accessibility with respect to the property?

Similar wording

For the accessibility? Yes.

Similar wording

I would have to have Brenna come on and address that and have her be sworn.

Similar wording

I don't know what the existing building code has to say regarding that.

Similar wording

Why don't we bring her on, please?

Similar wording

And I can bring up the floor plans.

Similar wording

I think one of the units might be type B units, which were discussed earlier today with one of the other presentations.

Similar wording

Her name is Brenna?

Similar wording

Yeah, Brenna Marsh.

Similar wording

Mark, M-A-R-C-H.

Similar wording

Brenna Marsh, please accept the promotion to panelists.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

and i would just say as a comment i mean with an old building like this i'm not sure

Similar wording

how we're gonna handle that i mean i'd imagine i mean even if i look at unit four i mean obviously

Similar wording

this is going to have to be addressed at building if not here i mean in some way but you do have

Similar wording

access to this rear unit back here um there are steps here but there is an opportunity for a ramp

Similar wording

obviously to come up or some type of lift um a lift obviously i think you'd have to go to the

Similar wording

ada board in harrisburg for that as opposed to a ramp but i mean there's space it's not like you're

Similar wording

limited miss marsh

Similar wording

you see the architects is she being seen hello hi hi could you please state your name is spelled

Similar wording

for the court stenographer brenna march b-r-e-n-n-a-m-a-r-c-h do you swear or firm to tell

Similar wording

the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth i do please proceed counsel

Similar wording

BRENDA, COULD YOU PLEASE ADDRESS THE QUESTION BY BOARD MEMBER GASTON REGARDING ADA ACCESS

Similar wording

TO THE BUILDING SINCE WE DO HAVE FOUR UNITS. FOR THE FRONT BUILDING, THIS BUILDING IS

Similar wording

TECHNICALLY BEING SPLIT INTO TWO BUILDINGS, BUILDING A AND BUILDING B. THE FRONT WILL BE

Similar wording

four units on the first floor which are all bi-level units so once you have a bi-level unit

Similar wording

you're exempt from the ADA type B units and we cannot we're not providing an elevator in this

Similar wording

and we cannot we're not providing an elevator in this portion of the building so none of the

Similar wording

portion of the building so none of the units up

Similar wording

units upstairs will need to be accessible at the rear there are only three units in that portion

Similar wording

of the building technically building b at the rear with this uh two-hour separation they have

Similar wording

their own entry at the rear here so since there are only three units there we are under the number

Similar wording

of units that require a type b unit okay all right so you don't need it i mean i think if you did

Similar wording

there is a opportunity to provide it there is the opportunity for unit four at the rear here

Similar wording

yeah okay how's the building legally being subdivided are you subdividing the lot i know

Similar wording

there's existing two there's two lots or is you just no no there's only one lot here there's only

Similar wording

one lot so it was consolidated well so no so originally it was all one lot and they subdivided

Similar wording

this lot and then the single families that are in east madison so you have two buildings

Similar wording

on on this one lot and as one of the things that i did point out to the examiner throughout this

Similar wording

process is i think that the original refusal should have had a multiple um principal structures

Similar wording

when it was converted from a garage and they are going to make that correction on the new

Similar wording

amended refusal i think it's city city records so the city records are still showing it in

Similar wording

pwd is two separate lots so that might be why as 32 for which one 32 30

Similar wording

because i can click on both yeah it's never 3230 has always been one lot so i'm not sure i'll have

Similar wording

to take a look at that because it's showing the archdiocese for one and it's showing them for

Similar wording

the parking for the other two right well the archdiocese still does own the church

Similar wording

they still do so that's 3200 still we're 3230 yeah i didn't click on 3200 i think yeah so

Similar wording

that's the archdiocese so they kept the church and the rect rectory and then you have the all

Similar wording

the east madison street lots the single families that you have there any other questions questions

Similar wording

or comments from the uh our attorney no sir questions or comments from the uh audience

Similar wording

the current or the virtual audience chair we have one hand up stan sawinski okay and they are going

Similar wording

be promoted to panelists. Sure.

Similar wording

Good morning, Stan.

Similar wording

Good morning. Good morning, Stan. Could you spell your name,

Similar wording

please, for the court stenographer? My name is Stan

Similar wording

Stan Sawinski, S-T-A-N-C-Y-W-I-N-S-K-I.

Similar wording

I am the zoning director for the Sixth Council District,

Similar wording

and the Sixth Council District supports this project.

Similar wording

Hold on, hold on, hold on, hold on, just one minute.

Similar wording

I know you get to the good stuff right away.

Similar wording

I know you get to the point, but do you swear or affirm to tell the truth,

Similar wording

the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

And what's your comments, Stan?

Similar wording

My comment is that the Sixth Council District, along with ProPAC, we support this project.

Similar wording

Thank you very much for taking the time.

Similar wording

Is there anyone else in the audience?

Similar wording

Ian, are we giving this a date?

Similar wording

No, is this one of the ones you have a date with?

Similar wording

Oh, just the normal resumptive.

Similar wording

The resumptive.

Similar wording

Okay, so we'll have a resumptive hearing on this on August 6th at 2 p.m.

Similar wording

And that's when planning will make their comments.

Similar wording

Okay, we'll have them advance on that.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you very much.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Appreciate it.

Similar wording

Let's hear one more case before we go back.

Similar wording

number

Similar wording

number 16 mi 2025 001 555 1224 frankfurt avenue adam labor is the attorney

Similar wording

the labor could you please state your name is spelled for the stenographer

Similar wording

Good morning, Mr. Chairman and members of the board. Adam Laver, L-A-V-E-R, Blank Rome, LLP. On behalf of Leopard, Real Estate Partners, LP, owner of the subject property.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, Mr. Chairman, I do.

Similar wording

Do you waive the reading and the refusal and do you agree with its accuracy?

Similar wording

Yes, Mr. Chairman, I do.

Similar wording

Why don't you please proceed, sir?

Similar wording

Thank you very much.

Similar wording

and we have a letter of support from fishtown kensington business a letter of support from

Similar wording

fishtown neighbors and also a letter of non-opposition from councilmember young thank you

Similar wording

thank you

Similar wording

i'm just looking to uh

Similar wording

oh here we go green show bear with me for a moment

Similar wording

technology is coming right up

Similar wording

there we go

Similar wording

mr chairman and members of the board as i had stated i'm here on behalf of leopard real estate

Similar wording

partners lp which does business as the fishtown collective uh uh this entity owns the property

Similar wording

at 1224 frankfort avenue which goes through to leopard street it's an important property

Similar wording

in the fishtown neighborhood what's up on the screen right now i call it teaser that's that's

Similar wording

what we believe we can transform this important site to and here you have some aerials for context

Similar wording

showing what i just mentioned uh in that salmon color that says site that were between frankfurt

Similar wording

and a leopard and some additional photographs showing that it is currently an unimproved uh

Similar wording

property a vacant property principals in the development team include roland cassis

Similar wording

Jason Nussbaum and Tom Hallinan,

Similar wording

who's right behind me here in the actual hearing room,

Similar wording

along with our hospitality partner,

Similar wording

Archway and Archway operating partner, Catherine Lundberg.

Similar wording

Catherine, thank you for being with us this morning.

Similar wording

Also participating virtually from

Similar wording

Nome Architects is Brenna March.

Similar wording

The development team's projects are well-known,

Similar wording

I know to this board,

Similar wording

but also well-regarded within the community.

Similar wording

Here you can see the photographs of the subject property if we were to walk by today. It's a

Similar wording

large empty lot. It was once home when there were structures on there. It was once home to a brewery,

Similar wording

a pickle factory, and then an ice storage building going back in time. A little bit of interesting

Similar wording

Fishtown history. Prior to the pandemic, earlier zoning boards, I don't think anyone who's sitting

Similar wording

right now was on the board at that time, nor was I, but prior to the pandemic, the zoning board

Similar wording

approved a visitor accommodations proposal at this site. And that proposal was for a 125-room

Similar wording

new construction hotel. And here you can see actually the permit that was issued

Similar wording

back at that time. So the zoning board had found a hardship at this site for the same

Similar wording

use that we're here for today. What had occurred? What occurred in the interim?

Similar wording

Basically, we were stymied by the pandemic, financing issues, and the original proposal

Similar wording

expired. But the good thing that occurred during that time was also that Roland and Jason and Tom

Similar wording

and the team realized that a better proposal made sense for this site. One which happens,

Similar wording

as you'll see shortly, to be reduced in size and scale, but with the same visitor accommodations

Similar wording

use. And I would also submit to the board the potential to bring diversity to the nature of

Similar wording

the commercial properties along the Frankfurt Avenue corridor. What do I mean by that? There

Similar wording

are amazing restaurants in Fishtown. Everybody loves the restaurants in Fishtown, but there's

Similar wording

a mix of other commercial that's needed. And I know that Mr. Everett from Fishtown Neighbors

Similar wording

Association is here today, and he'll speak directly on behalf of the coordinating RCO

Similar wording

in the community.

Similar wording

But Roland Cassis is someone who is invested in a really direct way in this neighborhood

Similar wording

and wants to bring that diversity of commercial.

Similar wording