civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - August 14, 2024

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Aug 14, 20242h 43m

There you go. It's coming up. Yep.

Similar wording

So this is the front of the property.

Similar wording

I purchased the property in 2019.

Similar wording

It was listed as a four-family dwelling.

Similar wording

So I rented the property as a four-family dwelling through Bay Management.

Similar wording

there is no changes opposed or required for it i just need a because i used to live there so i

Similar wording

was able to get a rental license in the beginning and then when i moved it got denied because it

Similar wording

says that because i don't live there it doesn't i'm not able to get a rental license um so there's

Similar wording

Um, so there's absolutely no changes that need to be made, uh, to the property.

Similar wording

absolutely no changes that need to be made

Similar wording

need.

Similar wording

It just needs the approval due to the fact that it's in a commercial, it's in a commercial

Similar wording

zone.

Similar wording

This is my, um, approval from the civic association, seeing it.

Similar wording

How many units do you have there?

Similar wording

Four.

Similar wording

And all four are rented?

Similar wording

Currently.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Do you live there?

Similar wording

I was.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

So you got four units in the property.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Do you have photos of the inside or you don't have any photos of the inside?

Similar wording

So these are both photos of the inside.

Similar wording

I did get.

Similar wording

And when you bought this, it was all, it was all, had electric meters and all for four units?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And when did you buy the property?

Similar wording

2021.

Similar wording

I mean, 2019 originally.

Similar wording

It was.

Similar wording

I refinanced in 2021, sorry.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Questions from the board?

Similar wording

Questions or comments from our attorney, Hillary Emerson?

Similar wording

Not at this time, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

Questions or comments from the virtual audience?

Similar wording

I see no hands.

Similar wording

Planning commission.

Similar wording

Good morning, Dan.

Similar wording

powers with the city planning commission the comprehensive plan recommends a change in zoning

Similar wording

at this location from ca1 to cmx 2.5 the proposed use is consistent with documented prior use

Similar wording

the city planning commission recommends that the board grant the proposed variance for multi-family

Similar wording

residents thank you mi 2023 zero zero six four six six four twenty two fountain street i vote yes

Similar wording

Michael Johns, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Tanetta Graham, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Sayowin, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Ishmael Shaheed, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Sir, you have your votes.

Similar wording

Thank you, counsel.

Similar wording

Have a good one.

Similar wording

So, number eight, MI 2023-006-304-503 Woodland Avenue.

Similar wording

Darlene Treat is the attorney.

Similar wording

good morning counsel good morning counsel i think i already swore you once today am i correct

Similar wording

yes but you did not swear me in i didn't okay do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the

Similar wording

whole truth, nothing but the truth. Yes, I do. Could you identify your client, the relationship

Similar wording

to the property? My client is Mr. Jerry Sanders, the president of Mount Zion CDC.

Similar wording

Our vice chair has a few questions. Good morning, counsel. Do you agree to

Similar wording

weigh the reading of the refusal or stipulate to its accuracy? I'd like to make a comment on that.

Similar wording

Originally, the refusal indicated that it was business use on the first floor and a one-family dwelling on the second floor.

Similar wording

That was incorrect, and I had the refusal amended.

Similar wording

It now reads business on the first floor, two-family dwelling on the second floor, and I have updated that amendment in a separate submission.

Similar wording

All right. Did you have to update the drawings on that?

Similar wording

No, I did not.

Similar wording

it was just incorrectly sorry miss three um the refusal that was in the exhibit packet

Similar wording

only indicated the business and professional office and single family dwelling can you please

Similar wording

forward a copy of the amended refusal because i have not seen it yes um i apologize i did believe

Similar wording

i uploaded it as a additional um exhibit after my original um exhibits were uploaded but i will

Similar wording

send it to you today ms emerson okay i'll i'll look for it now because the board will need the

Similar wording

date on the refusal um in order to vote on this case thank you have you emailed in all the required

Similar wording

documents and exhibits that needed to proceed this case okay thank you please proceed to share your

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

just give me one second sure i'm on a new computer today and i'm not 100 familiar with it

Similar wording

I can't click my sources of it, let me get it on.

Similar wording

You can see them.

Similar wording

I need just to move out the chain.

Similar wording

The person, yeah, so then we can put it all the way up now.

Similar wording

It's not normal.

Similar wording

let's see if it just started number one

Similar wording

okay thank you

Similar wording

Commissioners, I apologize.

Similar wording

No, no, we're fine.

Similar wording

My computer died today, and I'm on my sons, and I'm not familiar with it.

Similar wording

So, Commissioners, we applied to the Zoning Board of Adjustment for the Mount Zion CDC.

Similar wording

Frankly, they want office, business, and professional use for their organization on the first floor

Similar wording

and a two-family dwelling on the second floor.

Similar wording

This was the original refusal.

Similar wording

I did again amend it

Similar wording

and I have submitted it but I will send

Similar wording

the amended refusal to you

Similar wording

again today

Similar wording

Isaiah

Similar wording

you just make that a little bit

Similar wording

bigger so we could it's just a little

Similar wording

hard if you can

Similar wording

that's it

Similar wording

that's fine

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

that's your tax information

Similar wording

how's that gonna

Similar wording

Commissioners, here is our tax information to show you that our taxes are clear.

Similar wording

Here's the deed.

Similar wording

Commissioners, here are the plans.

Similar wording

This property sits almost near the corner

Similar wording

of 50th and Woodland Avenue.

Similar wording

Here is the site plan of how it's laid out.

Similar wording

It's a three-story dwelling here.

Similar wording

Over here are actually the plans.

Similar wording

Basically, we are asking for office use on the first floor.

Similar wording

You come in through the front here, there's a reception area.

Similar wording

Over here, we have one office here.

Similar wording

We have a second office in the back.

Similar wording

We have a lavatory for the individuals who work in the organization, and then there's a little lounge area for the staff, and there's a patio outside.

Similar wording

and then there's a little lounge area for the staff and there's a patio outside in the back.

Similar wording

I'll show you pictures of the rear yard in a minute. Frankly, the CDC would like to use this

Similar wording

for their organization. They would like to use it for community meetings and also offer the space

Similar wording

out to members of the community for meetings and information sessions which would benefit

Similar wording

their members. The office will be open from Monday to Saturday, from 8 to 10, and it'll just be used

Similar wording

by the community. We are proposing to have two apartments on the top. Basically, they're

Similar wording

two two-bedroom apartments. We have a bedroom in the front, a bedroom in the back, a laboratory,

Similar wording

in a kitchen area. In the back is just the roof below. On the third floor is

Similar wording

pretty much the same setup. We have a bedroom in the front, a laboratory in the

Similar wording

middle, a kitchen and a living area, and another bedroom on the third floor. I took

Similar wording

numerous pictures here's the posting of the property next door to this property is also a

Similar wording

multifamily it's a second picture of the property that's the rear yard of the property where the

Similar wording

the trash will be stored until Trash Day.

Similar wording

That just shows the area between the properties.

Similar wording

And the place is studded out.

Similar wording

It's not fitted out.

Similar wording

We are waiting for zoning to be approved.

Similar wording

And I just took a picture of all three floors,

Similar wording

which are currently studded out.

Similar wording

Here is a picture of the property at the intersection of 50th and Woodland Avenue.

Similar wording

It's another picture of the property. It's a picture of the property next door,

Similar wording

which I believe is a four-family dwelling.

Similar wording

That's a picture of across the street, Catacorna, which is Mount Zion Church.

Similar wording

right across the street is the SEPTA bus terminal.

Similar wording

That's a picture of a Woodland Avenue looking west.

Similar wording

An additional picture looking east.

Similar wording

That's directly across the street is a health center

Similar wording

directly across the street from the building.

Similar wording

just some additional pictures of the block there are multi-families along the block a lot of them

Similar wording

are vacant though and they need development that's our next door you can see there's a duplex you see

Similar wording

the mailboxes additional multi-family are next door to our property these all were multi-families

Similar wording

but they're all vacant now and they're all in need of renovation.

Similar wording

I did notice a meeting with the CDC for June 5th

Similar wording

and we met with the community organization.

Similar wording

I sent out 62 notices.

Similar wording

The meeting was attended

Similar wording

not by a lot of people, but it was attended.

Similar wording

And we did get a letter of support

Similar wording

from the Southwest CDC.

Similar wording

Let me see if I can open that up.

Similar wording

Yeah, I'm not able to open the letter, but I believe you have a copy of it.

Similar wording

And I'm open for...

Similar wording

It says unanimous support, am I correct?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

You want to bring your client on?

Similar wording

Mr. Sanders, can you raise your hand, please?

Similar wording

They haven't allowed to speak.

Similar wording

Mr. Sanders, could you please state your name and spell for the court stenographer?

Similar wording

Jerry Sanders, please unmute yourself.

Similar wording

my name is jerry sanders j-e-r-r-y s-a-n-d-e-r-s you swear or affirm to tell the truth

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

the whole truth is nothing but the truth yes

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Please proceed, counsel.

Similar wording

Good morning, Mr. Sanders.

Similar wording

What is your relationship to the Mount Zion CDC?

Similar wording

I am the president of the nonprofit.

Similar wording

And are you guys the owner of 5003 Woodland Avenue?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Have you heard my testimony as presented to the board today?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And if you were to testify today, would you adopt my testimony as true and correct?

Similar wording

yes that's all i have commissioner the questions from the board i have no question

Similar wording

i have a question how many entrances was it for for the unit for the units is it separate

Similar wording

interest for the units in the business uh space yes uh let me see if i can go back down to the plans

Similar wording

uh-oh it's working well do you want to wait till

Similar wording

So, we've got one o'clock.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So basically, there is a separate entrance.

Similar wording

This stairs will take you into the first.

Similar wording

You can traverse up these stairs

Similar wording

and take you to the second unit.

Similar wording

And then you traverse up the stairs

Similar wording

and it'll take you to the third unit.

Similar wording

So there's a separate entrance

Similar wording

for every use on this diagram.

Similar wording

That's where?

Similar wording

Any other questions?

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Yeah, I do have one comment.

Similar wording

I'm sorry.

Similar wording