civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - June 24, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jun 24, 20251h 9m

and my last question is um is there uh i guess for the impact of the surrounding area is there

Similar wording

potential job numbers that are anticipated from this new regrowth um we have i can't give you

Similar wording

specific numbers but um you know part of the goal for everyone on campus is to have access to income

Similar wording

when you know when they're getting ready to exit into permanent housing um as part of that we are

Similar wording

leveraging resources from philadelphia works um and other you know providers of workforce development

Similar wording

to come on site um we are also working with our community advisory council around you know what

Similar wording

local businesses might have hiring needs and then with the different city departments whether that's

Similar wording

through the taking care of business program or um the same day work and pay program to um help folks

Similar wording

you know get into the community um and then the last thing i'll say is you know we are right now

Similar wording

we have an open RFP for food services, where we are intentionally looking to bring in a food

Similar wording

service vendor that not only will provide food, but also job training and connections to employers

Similar wording

in the surrounding community. Thank you. I have a number of questions. This is

Similar wording

almost doubling the number of people you can accommodate on the site. What data did you use

Similar wording

to support this need case?

Similar wording

I'm so glad you asked that

Similar wording

I'm so glad you asked that because I realized I wasn't as explicit as possible in my previous

Similar wording

because I realized I wasn't as explicit as possible.

Similar wording

testimony.

Similar wording

So when I mentioned the continuum of people going into inpatient treatment, what tends

Similar wording

to happen is there's 1,700 beds of inpatient treatment and only up until we opened Riverview,

Similar wording

only 500 beds of recovery house.

Similar wording

So what that means is for anyone who's experiencing homelessness at the point of entry into recovery or doesn't have a safe place to go home to that's conducive to their recovery, like they might be going back to a family that still has use in the household, et cetera, those folks would basically end up back on the street or in a non-safe place, which will lead to recidivism back into substance use disorder.

Similar wording

We have expanded the recovery house capacity by 66% with our existing footprint. That's not nearly enough to meet the needs of the population. We also, you know, are working collaboratively with the Office of Homeless Services and the Department of Behavioral Health to identify the needs for beds, you know, and different types of beds in this space of recovery-based housing to properly meet the demand.

Similar wording

And then what's the average tenure that you're expecting of the patients that would be in

Similar wording

the recovery housing?

Similar wording

Up to a year.

Similar wording

Up to a year.

Similar wording

And again, it's all very case by case.

Similar wording

The providers that we're working with have a lot of experience in this space around gauging

Similar wording

when someone might be ready to exit.

Similar wording

But again, you know, we want people to really take advantage of the time to heal and have

Similar wording

access to all of the resources on site so that, you know, it doesn't lead to any kind of relapse

Similar wording

when they leave. And then I guess, having worked with homeless populations before, oftentimes with

Similar wording

rapid rehousing, a year tends to not be enough time for people to get situated. What's the plan

Similar wording

for individuals that might need more than a year? And how does that affect sort of the

Similar wording

beds on site? Well, the year is a guideline and you're absolutely right. And a lot of rapid

Similar wording

rehousing vouchers don't come with the kinds of services that we're providing, right? So we've got

Similar wording

every social determinant of health covered on campus, but with the lens of it's, you know,

Similar wording

we want to help people, you know, gain the skills that they need and the resources that they need

Similar wording

so they can move on. The new building actually addresses that same question. Like there will be

Similar wording

people who probably will need to stay there longer and having the ability to have that next phase

Similar wording

of more private spaces, even, you know, essentially studio units on the campus will allow for maybe

Similar wording

folks who need a longer stay to be able to still be part of the supported environment that we're

Similar wording

creating. And then I want to shift a little bit to parking. So there's a lot of people that will

Similar wording

be on this site. And I guess currently the land that the new building will be on, what is it

Similar wording

currently being used for it's vacant vacant okay yes and and i will say you know with the population

Similar wording

we have now um the majority of our residents do not have vehicles and are not but it's really

Similar wording

staff and and other folks but other people i was just i mean it seems like for the number of staff

Similar wording

you would need to operate a facility of this size that while you've met parking minimums that the

Similar wording

parking seems small for the size of the site i mean looking at aerials with the prison next door

Similar wording

it seems like there's like way less maybe almost a third is less parking on this site than some of

Similar wording

the surrounding uses um and so just wanting to better understand how are most patients

Similar wording

getting to the site um and visitors and are visitors going to have a separate parking lot

Similar wording

i'll defer on the the parking to the architects and and and to mary but what i will say is that

Similar wording

we through our recovery house providers are providing you know transportation to and from

Similar wording

you know hubs of public transportation and to appointments in the community um

Similar wording

you know we we're meeting the needs of the residents through you know transportation

Similar wording

resources um but you know as far as the the spaces i'll turn that to sure can i steven do you mind

Similar wording

coming back up discuss parking just state your name again please stephen bartlett please proceed

Similar wording

counsel um stephen can you clarify the parking on the site i think this slide probably depicts it

Similar wording

fast yeah we we located two parking lots associated with this site and there and there are other

Similar wording

parking areas on the other portion of portions of the site that will serve those areas as well

Similar wording

and we locate we created two primary parking lot one is one is to the top of this image that is

Similar wording

One is to the top of this image that is towards a service building that the city uses on the backside of the site.

Similar wording

towards a service building that the city

Similar wording

you

Similar wording

That is about 20 spaces that would largely be staff parking.

Similar wording

And then we have on the right hand side, we have two parking areas and also a bus drop off or a van drop off area for residents there.

Similar wording

There's about 30 spaces over in that area.

Similar wording

That would be for staff, but also for visitors, because there will be a new entry directly into the new building.

Similar wording

That's the parking that's been provided.

Similar wording

No, that I just said, I was just more so wondering, do we think that's sufficient to the need?

Similar wording

How many staff on site at one time?

Similar wording

So, Isabel, could you answer that about how many staff members of staff would be on site?

Similar wording

Why don't you come up?

Similar wording

So, keeping in mind that we have multiple uses, I can't really give you an exact number,

Similar wording

especially as we keep adding different uses, but it is a 24-7 campus.

Similar wording

The general ratio between resident to staff member is 1 to 11 at this time, but that does not include the security staff or the facilities maintenance staff and groundskeeping.

Similar wording

um as far as programming during the sort of the the day um we will have additional additional

Similar wording

folks coming on campus um so i can't really give you a perfect number but again um you know with

Similar wording

the resident population um where we're trying to you know provide classroom training and things

Similar wording

like that i would say during the the day hours we might have an influx of you know maybe 20 more

Similar wording

staff for for some of that programming so it sounds like you could have anywhere from 60 to

Similar wording

80 staff people on on site at any given time not including visitors or vendors we could and we're

Similar wording

talking about so when we're talking about the site we're talking about just the riverview wellness

Similar wording

village but actually the address there's a couple of addresses for the site but 7999 covers the

Similar wording

correctional facility as well and when you look at the larger site you can kind of see it faded here

Similar wording

there's there's tons of parking there's like five seat tons yeah about 30 parking spaces which is

Similar wording

why i brought it up so there's parking and and i can i can provide more materials that illustrate

Similar wording

this but there's something like 400 parking spaces between the entire prison site and it's

Similar wording

all connected so you could get the prison site is not separated by fence because it did look like

Similar wording

there is a there is a fence but there's still there's still the ability to to have parking if

Similar wording

if we needed to um and we're also going to be providing uh and i think isabel talked about this

Similar wording

there's that we're providing people with the ability to use uh city transportation and

Similar wording

encouraging that um with stepta as well but i mean we're upstate road we've had the same issue

Similar wording

with multiple housing complexes that were proposed at this in this vicinity and near this prison is

Similar wording

that there's not a lot of septa transportation up there it's created issues in the past in fact

Similar wording

the mayor herself stopped a housing project that was going up there for this like one of these

Similar wording

reasons so I think my question is this is a big campus it's a big site I don't know if I was

Similar wording

coming to visit a family member that was in a recovery center I would want to walk what's

Similar wording

equivalent to probably a quarter of a mile from the prison and park my car at the prison and walk

Similar wording

over um and i think it also seems to kind of go against this idea of wellness because i think

Similar wording

when i think of a prison i think of a recovery center i think of two very different types of

Similar wording

environments and even visually they feel from the plan like two visually different environments so

Similar wording

um i think my my question around parking on the site and near the use that we're talking about

Similar wording

um it would be nice to better understand what the actual need is instead of just

Similar wording

meeting minimums absolutely and i also have pedro pinto here um he's from the department of

Similar wording

he's the project manager from uh capital programs office and he can talk more about the parking

Similar wording

at the site could you state your name please and spell for the start thank you uh pinto p-i-n-t-o

Similar wording

do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth i do please

Similar wording

proceed counsel. Pedro, can you please articulate for the board the additional parking options that

Similar wording

are available at the site? Sure. So, if you see at the top right of the picture,

Similar wording

if you see at the top right of the picture,

Similar wording

if you see at the top right of the picture, there's about 30 or 40 parking spaces around that.

Similar wording

there's about 30 or 40 parking spaces

Similar wording

around that maintenance building.

Similar wording

There's spaces right in front of the meeting house.

Similar wording

There's about 25 there.

Similar wording

There are spaces between above College B,

Similar wording

which is somewhere around 18, I think.

Similar wording

And then there's spaces to the left of College B,

Similar wording

which is about 30.

Similar wording

And of course, the 50 or 60 that we've testified.

Similar wording

So I think we're about 160 would be my guess,

Similar wording

total parking spaces.

Similar wording

And of course, you know,

Similar wording

Part of the reason we didn't want to just continue to increase parking is because we wanted to take advantage of what this central lawn and this exterior space also provides as part of the healing.

Similar wording

Other questions from the board?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Thanks, Pedro.

Similar wording

Okay. I guess I'm getting into the weeds a little bit, but I'm having trouble with the idea of the expansion of non-conforming use.

Similar wording

Okay. First, I'm not sure how the uses that you're talking about, the single room residence, the personal care home and hospital are non-conforming in an area that is zoned industrial in the first place.

Similar wording

so i'm not sure how we got to this being these being non-conforming uses

Similar wording

um but now you're talking about expanding so yeah yeah i'm sorry i'll let you finish i'm sorry

Similar wording

expansion the expansion piece goes into um expansion within the same facility so

Similar wording

as a zoning concept and this is all i'm going into um when you talk about expansion of a

Similar wording

non-conforming use it can't be a new or different use um it can't be an excessive expansion

Similar wording

and it can't be an expansion that's against the public interest right and if you're talking about

Similar wording

the 10 percent the 10 is not about use 10 is about um uh 10 within say the same facility and

Similar wording

here you're talking about an expansion into an entirely different building so i'm i i understand

Similar wording

what you're asking for i'm not sure if that's that that this is something where you can apply

Similar wording

the whole concept of expansion of the non-conforming use,

Similar wording

and it's really something that needs to be approved by variants.

Similar wording

So we are seeking variants today.

Similar wording

Yes, we are seeking a variance today.

Similar wording

So the basis for the variants that we're seeking

Similar wording

is the expansion of the three non-conforming uses

Similar wording

that we spoke about,

Similar wording

and then is the new use, the multifamily use.

Similar wording

So you're right, the underlying zoning is I-3,

Similar wording

but these uses existed prior to us having any zoning code

Similar wording

in the city of Philadelphia.

Similar wording

So that's what we're talking about

Similar wording

when we're talking about personal care home.

Similar wording

We're talking about single use.

Similar wording

Am I answering your question?

Similar wording

It's single room residence.

Similar wording

Single room residence, personal care home, hospital.

Similar wording

and hospital. Yes. So those uses existed since the early 1900s at that site. They were not

Similar wording

continually used that way, correct? It was continually used that way in one iteration

Similar wording

or another, all three of those uses. Yes. Even, you said that, when did this,

Similar wording

when did you start using it this way?

Similar wording

part of this property that you're using now when did you start doing that it started in the 1900s

Similar wording

and we started using the use that you are using now when did that start

Similar wording

the so the riverview wellness village is that your question when did that start

Similar wording

that started in january and prior to that was this property occupied and used in the ways

Similar wording

that we're talking about here.

Similar wording

Yes, it was occupied and it was used.

Similar wording

It was occupied by the Office of Homeless Services.

Similar wording

They were using and operating the property,

Similar wording

and that covers the single-room residence.

Similar wording

It was occupied by...

Similar wording

What time period?

Similar wording

For what time period?

Similar wording

I'm not sure.

Similar wording

That was before the Parker administration.

Similar wording

that was

Similar wording

I mean I'm sure

Similar wording

I'm not sure about that. I don't think that anyone that was running it during that time period still works for the city. So I couldn't tell you specifically how long we were using it for that. But we were also using it as, at one point, it was used as a home for the elderly and infirm, and that's the personal care home piece. And it was also being used, it had hospital uses in addition to that because of the level of care that was required.

Similar wording

I'm not sure about that

Similar wording

I don't think that anyone that was

Similar wording

running it during that time period

Similar wording

So when we submitted our application to L&I and they reviewed the application, that's what they came back with, that we were expanding these uses, and that would require the variance with the new building.

Similar wording

Yes, because you're expanding them into a totally different building.

Similar wording

Well, we're just expanding them beyond the 10%.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

that 10% applies within a building.

Similar wording

But you're talking about expanding a nonconforming use

Similar wording

into a totally different building.

Similar wording

Well, zoning doesn't just cover specific buildings.

Similar wording

It covers the parcel itself.

Similar wording

So that's what we're talking about.

Similar wording

We're talking about expanding the uses in the parcel itself.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

you put what you're doing you can't you can't do it that way either um but what you're doing is

Similar wording

you are basically doing a new and different use in a different building

Similar wording

we are also doing that yes we are also doing that with the multi-family as well which is why we need

Similar wording

a variance for that the multi-family to need it for these other two because that building okay

Similar wording

is a different building and the use that you can have in that building is has to be approved as

Similar wording

well right so i think we are saying the same thing we are here seeking a variance today i think we

Similar wording