civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - August 16, 2023

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Aug 16, 20233h 50m

zoned industrially, but there is no industry in the immediate vicinity. That's one of our refusals

Similar wording

though. The zoning calls for another industrial use. It also calls for 10 parking spaces given

Similar wording

the number of units we'd like to develop, but we don't feel given the triangular shape of the

Similar wording

parcel that that's practical without going underground, which we're not willing to do

Similar wording

because of the history of the property and for economic reasons. So I'll just show you an aerial

Similar wording

photograph really quickly. This is the property with the red arrows. So it's adjacent to the

Similar wording

um this is the property with the red arrows so it's adjacent to the septa railroad tracks which

Similar wording

receptor

Similar wording

are elevated here um it's across the street from the temple uh football practice facility

Similar wording

my client actually developed um which i'll show you in one minute a building on this side of 11th

Similar wording

street uh which has been received very well um and also um is almost finished developing some

Similar wording

buy right sort of row home properties here. So there's only one other on this sort of funny

Similar wording

block, residential homeowner. And we've been in contact with her, actually helped her get an L&I

Similar wording

violation removed from her property and sort of assisted her with some repairs on her home.

Similar wording

Just to say that, you know, we don't feel that this project, given sort of the strange location,

Similar wording

is interrupting anybody's lifestyle, so to speak, and is going to enhance what's already there.

Similar wording

This is the letter from Senator Street that I mentioned. And this is a letter, I think we heard

Similar wording

opposition at the last hearing from two parties. One was a non-resident property owner from nearby

Similar wording

who actually didn't oppose the project, aside from the lack of parking. We also heard from

Similar wording

the planning commission who wanted another residential use on the property, or so they

Similar wording

said in that hearing. And what we had done is we contacted a commercial real estate brokerage firm

Similar wording

and asked them, essentially, would you market this property for non-residential use,

Similar wording

for commercial or industrial use.

Similar wording

So it was really in their interest to say yes to that

Similar wording

because if they let us sell it, they'd get a commission.

Similar wording

And basically instead they said no.

Similar wording

And we ended up with this letter from them

Similar wording

declining to market the property

Similar wording

for anything but residential use.

Similar wording

And speaking to how given the shape

Similar wording

and the railroad track next door,

Similar wording

It's just, it is not possible to build a ground up new construction industrial property that would be marketable. That's sort of the gist of this letter. And he encouraged us to allow him to sell it for residential purposes, but we don't want to do that because Philip is a residential developer.

Similar wording

So, you know, we're going to do this ourselves and we're excited to. And then here, just to wrap up, this is one image on the right here. This is what we're here proposing today. This is the building. That's the ground floor commercial space.

Similar wording

The football complex would be directly across the street.

Similar wording

And Philip is currently constructing this sort of series of row home buildings that I mentioned.

Similar wording

So if we're able to get the approval today, there would actually be a really nice courtyard between the two properties, which he gave the moniker Philicon Square.

Similar wording

And then finally, just to show you a finished product, this is the 11th Street, sort of much more modest project that I mentioned, but a guy stopped me on the street, I kid you not, telling me that he was so thrilled with how this came out as a neighbor and how clean the site was kept after construction.

Similar wording

So anyway, that's it for me. I would ask that if it's possible, Philip Michael, the made-up

Similar wording

panelist, because he has a couple additional slides he'd like to present.

Similar wording

Sure, sure. Let's get that on. Can we raise his hand so we can get him in, please?

Similar wording

Philip, can you use the raise hand feature on Zoom?

Similar wording

You said, Mr. Severin, he has slides he's going to present?

Similar wording

Yes. And I can put them up. Otherwise, it'd be a little easier if he can present them, though.

Similar wording

Okay. He's been promoted to paid list.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Phillip? Okay. Hello, Phillip.

Similar wording

Hello, Brandon. Thank you for the nice intro. Thank you, everyone, for the time.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, sir. Please state your name and spell it for the record.

Similar wording

Yes, Philip Michael, P-H-I-L-I-P, Michael, M-I-C-H-A-E-L.

Similar wording

You swear to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.

Similar wording

Yes, I do.

Similar wording

Proceed, can I ask you?

Similar wording

Thank you, Mr. Vice Chair.

Similar wording

So, Philip, just as a preliminary matter, what I've said so far, was that true and accurate to the best of your knowledge, information, and belief?

Similar wording

Absolutely.

Similar wording

And would you adopt it as if it were your own testimony?

Similar wording

Yes. And you are the principal of the property owning company and can speak for the property

Similar wording

owning company. Is that correct? Yes, I am. Yes, I am. Okay. Go ahead. I know you wanted to make

Similar wording

Yes, I am.

Similar wording

Okay, go ahead.

Similar wording

I know you wanted to make a couple remarks.

Similar wording

a couple of remarks.

Similar wording

Okay, yes.

Similar wording

Number one, I want to thank you guys once again for considering this.

Similar wording

And one of the things that I would like to show you all is, in addition to building and

Similar wording

developing, it is not just in the self-interest of the economic self-interest of what we

Similar wording

do.

Similar wording

The reason what we've done, as Brandon alluded to, is that we've created a project that has

Similar wording

a long-term vision to, we labeled it sort of informally, hashtag reverse gentrification.

Similar wording

So of course, it's a traditional and historically African-American neighborhood.

Similar wording

Then there's the very esteemed Temple University, which is growing and has people coming in.

Similar wording

And these things happen.

Similar wording

People develop, they add value to the neighborhood, and often people get pushed out.

Similar wording

What we've wanted to do and what we've pledged to do, and I would love for the honor and

Similar wording

the privilege to show you this in a few slides, is to give people access to ownership so they can

Similar wording

partake in the value appreciation. That's number one. Two, being able to improve the aesthetics

Similar wording

and the cleanliness and everything of the neighborhood. And this is something that we

Similar wording

take pride in with the first phase that we built. We hire external people to come and keep it clean.

Similar wording

And it's a thing that we're very big on. So if it is okay with everyone to share my slides.

Similar wording

go ahead philip yep that's fine so let me do this here so i'm gonna go through this quickly

Similar wording

and i'm happy to take any questions so this was when we started uh everything that we're doing

Similar wording

back in in 2020 this is an interview that i gave for forbes and this is our stated mission myself

Similar wording

and we started as a small shop we don't have big venture capital money hedge funds family offices

Similar wording

behind us this is all self-funded to show other people that they could do the same thing that

Similar wording

we're doing. And we're doing a number of things in addition to building, in addition to giving

Similar wording

access that I'm going to get to in a second, to help the community and, again, elevate the value

Similar wording

and bring more wealth to people that haven't had access to it before. So this is, again,

Similar wording

the number one driver behind the wealth gap. Let's say, for instance, right now,

Similar wording

homeownership in minority communities is lower now than it was 50 years ago when discrimination

Similar wording

was legal. And there are a number of factors that caused this. But one of the things that

Similar wording

I'd like to focus on is a solution. How can we actually reverse that? So when we had our

Similar wording

groundbreaking ceremony for phase two, this is, as Brandon alluded to, we had a letter of support

Similar wording

from Senator Street. He came out on his birthday, as a matter of fact, three days before mine,

Similar wording

and helped us break ground. And these are some of the community members that co-owned the project

Similar wording

and also some of the team members. Here's the project in and of itself. The idea, the reason

Similar wording

we call it Silicon Square is similar to Silicon Valley, sort of underscored and highlighted a

Similar wording

renaissance, a resurgence of creativity, entrepreneurship, ownership. I can't quite

Similar wording

call it a valley. I don't own that much. So we call it a square to Silicon Square to sort of

Similar wording

bring that energy where people can create jobs, bring jobs back to the community, ownership and

Similar wording

showing people. They don't teach this in school. So this is one of the things that we do. So here's

Similar wording

where we built an app where people can own a piece of each property with as little as $100.

Similar wording

And just for the first one, people invested at a price at about half of what it appraised at, doubling their money.

Similar wording

It's currently trading, so people can actually own a piece of that with $1.

Similar wording

So this is one of the solutions that we like to bring.

Similar wording

This is what we've done.

Similar wording

Of course, as mentioned, it was a family shop.

Similar wording

It was myself, my father, and my nephew.

Similar wording

This is my nephew who is actually in a different life and a different dimension as a soccer star.

Similar wording

And this is a partner of mine and other projects.

Similar wording

So we've got a lot of attention and traction and we've helped to date over 10,000 people of color become first time real estate owners, which is one of the things I'm more proud of, more so than returns and all this other stuff for myself, that is.

Similar wording

So this space here, I would like to mention one of the things that we've done in terms of community support is we hosted a financial literacy conference out of our own pocket at Temple University where Senator Street and Senator Hughes came out and hosted it with us.

Similar wording

And this space right here, which is in the property that we have in mind, we have a nonprofit that will give access to financial literacy tools, support, help people start investing.

Similar wording

I don't really care if people invest with us just as long as they start going on that financial journey.

Similar wording

I believe it's a net positive to the community, to society, if more people have.

Similar wording

so and it's one of the most of people's issues can be traced out traced back in some form of fashion

Similar wording

to not having enough so and i believe i believe in the sanctity and the integrity of human beings

Similar wording

i believe if more people have i grew up as a as a child in denmark where no one is really poor and

Similar wording

it had and there's the lowest rate of corruption and lowest rate of crime because i believe human

Similar wording

beings if if you're not hungry you don't need you can you'll you'll have you'll have better

Similar wording

things. So this is from the, we call it WealthCon. This is Senator Street and Senator Hughes. And

Similar wording

these are some of the courses that we have where people can learn about how to invest in the stock

Similar wording

market. Our community manager managed over 10,000 retirement portfolios for the government before

Similar wording

managed over 10,000 retirement portfolios for the government before she retired.

Similar wording

she retired. She's a black lady.

Similar wording

She's a Black lady. Most of it is Black-owned, although I wish it just so happened to be that

Similar wording

way. And that's what we really want to bring down to the community, build a better community,

Similar wording

allow people to take part in the value out of the community, and also giving the pathway to

Similar wording

the tool so they can do the same thing. And that's essentially what it is that we do,

Similar wording

just bringing empowerment, community empowerment, and resources back to where it is instead of

Similar wording

coming in, invading the neighborhood, building it, extracting wealth, and just running away.

Similar wording

So that is why we do it, just as much as the practical logistics of residential, I feel, and we truly believe would fit better in that area, but also what it represents.

Similar wording

And we've seen so many, heard so many stories about people that even if they own with $1, $100, you go from consumer to investor to owner.

Similar wording

It shifts your mindset completely, and it has a net positive effect.

Similar wording

And we see this day in and day out inside our community.

Similar wording

So I hope this wasn't too long-winded, but this is the why, why we're doing it.

Similar wording

in addition to wanting to create a better aesthetic building for the neighborhood,

Similar wording

but also something people can be proud of and wanting to continue.

Similar wording

And we hope to continue and build more affordable housing if, you know,

Similar wording

that's something we've discussed and I would very much like to do.

Similar wording

And this is a lifetime mission.

Similar wording

This is not just In-N-Out.

Similar wording

It's something I've devoted my life to for the past three and a half years.

Similar wording

So that's it for me, Brandon.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you, Mr. Phil.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

Um, members of the board, um, sorry, Mr. Vice Chair, would you say on the board?

Similar wording

Yep.

Similar wording

No, no, no, Mr. Chairman.

Similar wording

No, Mr. Chairman.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Can you hear me, Mr. Vice Chair?

Similar wording

Yes, I can hear you, Tom.

Similar wording

Okay, I have no questions.

Similar wording

Any questions from the virtual audience?

Similar wording

Yes, we have Robert.

Similar wording

They have been allowed to speak.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Good afternoon.

Similar wording

Hi, my name is Rob Cashin.

Similar wording

I'm a neighbor on Susquehanna.

Similar wording

Can you state your name and spell it

Similar wording

for the court reporter, please?

Similar wording

Yes, it's Robert Cashin, C-A-S-H-I-O-N.

Similar wording

uh you swear to tell the truth and the whole truth or nothing but i do

Similar wording

please proceed okay uh i live on susquehanna i bought a house around five years ago

Similar wording

on a street that had less homes on it so that it'd be more chance for parking and quiet but i also

Similar wording

know that there are properties that are going to be developed and i do support them being developed

Similar wording

and this one certainly looks like a nice one my concern is that the consideration for not having

Similar wording

any parking or even a loading dock the identical property at the other end of this block triangle

Similar wording

has one old building and is getting a new building so the same size lot and they came to this meeting

Similar wording

and asked to go from 10 to zero.

Similar wording

They got denied and decided to go 10 to five.

Similar wording

So they're putting in five parking spaces.

Similar wording

So it seems like it would be possible

Similar wording

to put in parking spaces.

Similar wording

That's basically my concern.

Similar wording

I understand.

Similar wording

And do you support the project?

Similar wording

If it comes with parking, yes.

Similar wording

Okay, it's duly noted.

Similar wording

Anyone else in the virtual audience?

Similar wording

Thank you, sir.

Similar wording

i see no hands planning commission this uh ron bednar city planning the city planning commission

Similar wording

um has no change to its original recommendation

Similar wording

thanks ron uh so we're going to take this and table this with the rest of the commissioners

Similar wording

um and we'll vote on this next week um what time will we do this hillary we'll vote on this um

Similar wording

next week at 2 p.m so uh the record is closed on on this case um no additional comments but we

Similar wording

will vote on it next week at 2 p.m thank you mr vice chairman thank you thank you ish is there

Similar wording

anyone in the virtual audience who's three has the case on the 330 list their case has not been

Similar wording

I see no hands

Similar wording

Thank you

Similar wording

Thank you everyone

Similar wording

Good week

Similar wording

Thank you Mr. Kiesha

Similar wording

Thank you, Mr. Kiesha.

Similar wording

Thank you Mr. Chairman

Similar wording

Thank you, Mr. Chairman.

Similar wording

Thank you

Similar wording

Hold on one minute.

Similar wording