civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - October 6, 2020

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Oct 6, 20206h 49m

And I'm restoring.

Similar wording

I'm a 75-year-old person with a hammer in my hand.

Similar wording

Anyway, go ahead.

Similar wording

The first exhibit is notice of zoning application meeting for the neighbors.

Similar wording

I made a copy of the letter we sent out to 83 neighbors.

Similar wording

That's the copy.

Similar wording

And I believe I have all the information that's required.

Similar wording

second document yes it's just a little slow okay that's the refusal level let's go to the third

Similar wording

document I'm sort of getting the hang of this after listening to all this that was the application

Similar wording

I'll take a real quick brief we got into this situation because we had used the

Similar wording

um the quick planning guide and i guess we didn't interpret it correctly dealing with side yard

Similar wording

clearance um but as it was explained to me and i fully accept the law is the law

Similar wording

and the guidance is just a reference so present

Similar wording

that's just a blueprint of the second floor we'll get to the one on the front

Similar wording

of the house ceiling and I can explain where the addition is going to be any

Similar wording

questions just press ahead here yeah that's that's okay

Similar wording

Okay, if you're looking at the house in the bottom right corner, the front elevation,

Similar wording

that's standing on Lizzie Street looking at the front of the house, that addition off

Similar wording

to the left, which is two windows on the roof and two at the bottom is the front view of

Similar wording

the addition.

Similar wording

It's about 13 feet in width.

Similar wording

And of course, the other photo on the bottom left hand is the addition looking at it from

Similar wording

east to west.

Similar wording

It's a long, very long, and it has the two dormers, front dorm and the back dormer.

Similar wording

This next one is just a blueprint of the first floor, we can roll through that I guess.

Similar wording

Picture the deed.

Similar wording

now if you notice on the deed and i'm not sure how to handle this again but it was my mother's

Similar wording

name and myself with survivalship uh she has passed away and because of that i put two support

Similar wording

documents with this one is the death certificate and one's a short certificate just to prove that

Similar wording

i am the sole winner i don't know that's needed or not but uh you don't have to that's the support

Similar wording

documents as far as the signs go I was waiting for a package from I guess the

Similar wording

board for the science and I never got so I went to the zoning code and I made up

Similar wording

my own signs and I post them within the time frame and this is the verbiage of

Similar wording

the signs I also published a schedule of the of the hearings there it is there so

Similar wording

that anybody had would have the websites and I highlighted our our hearing okay

Similar wording

we're gonna roll through that I guess okay I think I must be doing something right here nobody's

Similar wording

asked some questions there's a project form just describes what we're doing we're basically adding

Similar wording

it for additional living space it had a very small kitchen probably about 12 by 12 and a little bit

Similar wording

of a family room on the side there it's not that big of an addition and a side

Similar wording

yard is where the problem is and I can explain that if you can see what done

Similar wording

exactly yeah oh yeah because I didn't get the letter on time I had a copy of

Similar wording

their minutes and I just highlighted there they said it was no absolutely no

Similar wording

opposition to it at all but you now have the letter from the ROC so just go to

Similar wording

sign verification okay um i just you know i read somewhere that i needed to take multi-wide

Similar wording

pictures of the sign just to make sure it was posted for the right amount of time and

Similar wording

this is the posting from 9 27 it was one on 9 15 i took a photo and 9 23 so i believe i met that

Similar wording

requirement site plan yeah this probably gives you an idea if you look at the site plan in the

Similar wording

middle of the plan at the bottom is 531 you'll see the l-shaped addition you'll see a common

Similar wording

driveway which is 10 feet wide and then the house 535 on one side and 527 on the other

Similar wording

and we're looking at a six foot i think the paper says five but it's actually to count the thickness

Similar wording

of the wall it's a six foot separation from the center of the driveway over instead of the required

Similar wording

10 feet i believe for our ds3 projects neighbor on that side nobody had any objections so

Similar wording

that was a tax clearance form now i have some photos

Similar wording

to give you a pretty good reference you have to go there that other that email

Similar wording

okay yeah and you can you'll have to scroll through that okay p1 uh well all right hold

Similar wording

pin again yeah that's the front with a sign that was taken 915 kind that's a

Similar wording

view of the driveway in the house and of course the addition would be between

Similar wording

the driveway and the side of that on the left side of the house going

Similar wording

driveway and the side of the on the left side of the house going that's the back which said

Similar wording

where it was required that's the east side where the addition will be it'll cover those

Similar wording

bottom bottom five windows and extend a little bit out into the porch area

Similar wording

and somewhat back toward the truck go ahead and the sign again

Similar wording

that's the west side which nothing is being done with the reason we chose the east side was because

Similar wording

if we did anything on the west side we'd have the bay window that would interfere there's a sidewalk

Similar wording

that goes around to the back of the house and there's a back shed so the west was the only

Similar wording

practical side to do it on it asks for adjacent houses so i have 535 which is on the east side

Similar wording

it's in the driveway then of course my addition and then 531 and the next photo will show the

Similar wording

house on the west side the trees hide my house but I marked it 531 527 go ahead uh just the sign

Similar wording

again I couldn't get the verbiage into the camera very well because of the glare of the glass that's

Similar wording

on the side but anyway it's I have a copy of that that's a problem and they'd ask for interior shots

Similar wording

and we're renovating the house the interior probably would have to be gutted uh so it's

Similar wording

right now it's a mess there's another mess inside um what was that oh that was sign verification i

Similar wording

called it okay and uh just to show that there are eight houses roughly i think eight or seven houses

Similar wording

on livesey street um that are were built back in the in the 40s and at the time the requirements

Similar wording

were different and this is the house on the west side and you can see there's probably only about

Similar wording

three feet property separation on that side um so in those days it you know it wasn't the same as

Similar wording

it is today and i just thought i'd point that out okay that's the end of the photos and that's the

Similar wording

end of my presentation questions i was going to ask you to summarize but i'm so impressed with

Similar wording

your presentation for a man who's not a lawyer. I apologize to my other board members. I just

Similar wording

was listening and you hit everything right on target, I'll be honest with you.

Similar wording

He said he wasn't an attorney. I thought he was an attorney.

Similar wording

I know. It's never too late, Mr. Black. And your assistant, you would hire her, obviously,

Similar wording

all right um any questions from the board no

Similar wording

anyone else wish to testify in this matter if so please raise your hand

Similar wording

no hands chair thank you very much planning commission

Similar wording

good afternoon board peter bernard for the planning commission

Similar wording

This property is indicated for single family residential in the comprehensive plan. The

Similar wording

proposed addition does not leave sufficient side yard on the east side of the house. However,

Similar wording

the side yard on the west side plus the remainder on the east exceeds the minimum required total

Similar wording

side yard. Additionally, there is no opposition from the RCO or neighboring affected property.

Similar wording

Accordingly, we have no objection to the granting of the variance at this location.

Similar wording

we would suggest a proviso that an addition not be added to the west side of the property in the future.

Similar wording

Mrs. Sharon, you can't add the kind of proviso for the future.

Similar wording

They'd have to come back.

Similar wording

It would have to be considered at the time it's proposed.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

They would have to come back.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

MI-2020-001214-531-Libsey, is that the way you pronounce it?

Similar wording

Libsey, yes.

Similar wording

Libsey Street, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

My vote is yes.

Similar wording

My vote is yes.

Similar wording

Congratulations to the Black family.

Similar wording

I think I better get my law degree.

Similar wording

You better go get it.

Similar wording

Hurry up.

Similar wording

Take care.

Similar wording

Good luck to you.

Similar wording

Thank you, folks.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Good night, all.

Similar wording

Good night.

Similar wording

good night uh tanya sharon anybody we have any unfinished business it's a wrap chair yes thank

Similar wording

goodness all right thank you thank you everybody good job good night we got executive session

Similar wording

tomorrow morning yes yes all right o'clock okay see you then bye-bye good job frank

Similar wording