civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - August 4, 2020

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Aug 4, 20201h 21m

Thank you. Mr. Floyd, please describe the current building at the time of your purchase.

Similar wording

The property at 2803-05 West Allegheny was a staple in the community for a long time. It was the old Thomas Funeral Home.

Similar wording

This property is two contiguous parcels together that had some penetrations made previously

Similar wording

and a great center entrance for the funeral home.

Similar wording

for the funeral home what i purchased was a vacant dilapidated property

Similar wording

What I purchased was a vacant...

Similar wording

that we're looking to rehab that property is three stories the first floor level ground level

Similar wording

is a joint commercial space the second floor which uses office space and also funeral proceedings

Similar wording

And then the third floor on both sides were used as residential apartments.

Similar wording

And excuse me for interrupting.

Similar wording

Mr. Marcel, do you have plans you can share with us?

Similar wording

Yes, they are on page 54 of the packet I sent you.

Similar wording

Are you able to share them on the screen with us?

Similar wording

I can try.

Similar wording

Yeah, we've all been trying a lot of things lately, so don't worry about it.

Similar wording

If it doesn't work, we can understand that.

Similar wording

Let me see what I can do here, sir.

Similar wording

Just a moment.

Similar wording

All right, take your time.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Functions are worked.

Similar wording

uh it is right now not letting me pull this up um let me try share screens hold on thank you

Similar wording

can you see that yep we got it thank you yes we can okay um

Similar wording

Seth are you on the the copy of the plans I can see it okay very well then

Similar wording

Seth I'm going to walk you through the plans and at the same time ask you

Similar wording

questions regarding your proposal

Similar wording

there we go all right as you'll see on the plans the first page there's an

Similar wording

existing plot plan and then there's a proposed plot plan the backyard spaces

Similar wording

between the two halves of the building are slightly different part of the

Similar wording

proposed plan was actually on the second and third floor apartments to add a deck

Similar wording

on the shorter of the two halves that would bring the backs even and then via

Similar wording

that deck which is very small yeah probably you could probably only put a

Similar wording

lounge chair on it uh but it evens up the two backs and it provides additional access to light

Similar wording

and air for the tenants uh on the uh same for the third floor there was a deck uh proposed in the

Similar wording

middle in the small section between the two buildings uh call it the the building's um

Similar wording

little interior alley area that proposed part of the proposal has been removed

Similar wording

that is no longer going to be placed there that area and space between the

Similar wording

two halves of the building is going to remain open from ground to sky the

Similar wording

second portion on the second page of the plans you will see the proposed four

Similar wording

floor plans so the first floor is the area that has already had a section

Similar wording

opened up between the two halves that is the proposed daycare area that area will

Similar wording

remain open in its current configuration pending approval the tenants will will

Similar wording

move in and get their appropriate business licenses and and permits to move forward

Similar wording

with that portion of the project if you look at the front area of the building on the proposed

Similar wording

first floor plan you'll notice that the entry stairs to the second and third floors have been

Similar wording

moved all the way over to the right side the entry stairs if you look at if you look at the original

Similar wording

building were centered in the middle and the doorway to the first floor commercial

Similar wording

area was actually behind them so this leaves the doorway to the commercial

Similar wording

so this leaves the doorway to the commercial area fully exposed to the

Similar wording

area fully exposed

Similar wording

street and open for the proposed second floor plan you will know that there are

Similar wording

two apartments a one-bedroom and an efficiency on each side and then again

Similar wording

same for the third floor plan I believe on the third floor plan they are both

Similar wording

one bedrooms apartments mr. Floyd yes sir okay

Similar wording

I'm sorry just one correction the second and third floor are both the same to one

Similar wording

bedroom apartments two efficiency apartments okay I'm sorry I misread that

Similar wording

and is that on each side 2803 and 2805 yes ma'am they mirror each other there

Similar wording

would be mirror images of each other thank you

Similar wording

mr. Floyd yes sir please describe how you derive this plan and your

Similar wording

interaction with the local RCO. The RCO we have been told to contact and we have been dealing with

Similar wording

is Community Action Group. And we had our meeting with Community Action Group

Similar wording

approximately three weeks ago. We did a Zoom meeting with them and they were the,

Similar wording

we were the first Zoom meeting we were able to accomplish with them

Similar wording

since the appeal process began

Similar wording

and the COVID-19 restrictions were put in place

Similar wording

immediately thereafter.

Similar wording

Mr. Floyd.

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

I'm sorry for interrupting you.

Similar wording

Please describe your project.

Similar wording

You asked me two different questions.

Similar wording

Do you want me to answer how we derived this?

Similar wording

Yes, I'm sorry.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Um, so, uh, this property, um, we made an assessment on the, started off with making

Similar wording

an assessment on the square footage of the property, which is, uh, approximately 5,256

Similar wording

square feet, uh, in total.

Similar wording

And we, um, attended a, uh, unofficial community meeting with the community action group, the

Similar wording

Neighborhood Association, the RCO, for this property.

Similar wording

During that meeting, we encountered comments about the housing in the neighborhood, as

Similar wording

well as rooming housing issues in the area.

Similar wording

we were originally looking to put apartments here and through discussions also with

Similar wording

the council men for this council person curtis jones's office that we were instructed to

Similar wording

try to make something at this location that would be affordable and in line with the

Similar wording

current rental prices. Our history for renovation work in the city has been taking dilapidated

Similar wording

properties and overly renovating them into a luxury level rentals with very high rents.

Similar wording

That's the brand that I've built and that is what we have done consistently and successfully.

Similar wording

Knowing that history, I was asked not to do that here at 28th and Allegheny just because of the rental rates that we have attracted in the past and that the need was more for something that could be afforded.

Similar wording

And so what we did was we've taken that input and we've matched it with our past and what our strengths are, which are making luxury units.

Similar wording

And we did the math and figured out what we would need to do to give someone at this location the same feel that we've given our other clients in the past, but also to put that in their budget.

Similar wording

And we designed a property here, which will still be a high end luxury units, but smaller sized units, which allowed us to still make the number and meet the.

Similar wording

which allowed us to still make the number and meet the need for the area,

Similar wording

really targeting younger clients as well as older downsizing clients and walkable clients.

Similar wording

After our unofficial meeting with the RCO, this is again before we filed, we did get a confirmation.

Similar wording

about the price point for these units, which we're targeting around $750 a month.

Similar wording

And we made modifications to our plans, which we then submitted. And again, we had the presentation

Similar wording

with the Community Association in reference to this property. The one thing that I would like

Similar wording

to say in reference to this we had a couple goals here one to meet the needs of the community

Similar wording

the second one is as me and my partner are both engineers and me specifically an environmental

Similar wording

engineer was to combine my two passions which was providing housing as well as improving everyone's

Similar wording

relationship with the earth and so incorporated in this project is a $100,000 approximately $100,000

Similar wording

solar panel project which will be on the roof. That is not a part of the zoning conversation

Similar wording

at this point. That is a permit job but I just think for the audience here listening

Similar wording

that you understand what type of property this is going to be and what our vision was.

Similar wording

We currently have a proposal which will not involve any natural gas.

Similar wording

This property will be 100% electric and high efficient.

Similar wording

The proposal for the solar panel system, which spans both roofs, almost around 100% coverage

Similar wording

of the two roofs is projected to supply about 94 percent of this property's electrical usage

Similar wording

therefore reducing our carbon footprint on this property projected down to only six percent

Similar wording

of any of the adjacent and joining properties

Similar wording

Through building mechanisms, we plan to use high-efficiency windows, high-efficiency

Similar wording

insulation, high-efficiency equipment, air conditioning, high-efficiency light bulbs,

Similar wording

and we're going to try to beat that 94 percent projection of energy production and try to get

Similar wording

this building to 100%, creating a zero carbon, zero fossil fuel building right at 28th and

Similar wording

Allegheny. Mr. Floyd, can you please describe the standard amenities proposed for each apartment?

Similar wording

Our buildings have been consistent, which are natural bamboo flooring. Again, not using hardwood

Similar wording

flooring which cuts down trees all of the apartments would be

Similar wording

high quality nail down bamboo flooring high efficiency energy efficient windows

Similar wording

high energy efficient central air and heating

Similar wording

granite countertops recessed lights ceiling fans to reduce air conditioning

Similar wording

usage

Similar wording

full bathrooms and we're normally some version of a marble tile

Similar wording

Again, granite countertops, and a very luxurious feel to the property.

Similar wording

Commercial glass entrance doors, intercom buzzers, security cameras.

Similar wording

That's really like the feel of the building.

Similar wording

Very modern coloring and schemes and very natural feelings of the property.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Mr. Floyd, the current proposal includes waste management in context of an apartment building. Could you please describe that?

Similar wording

Well, one of the things that was asked of us when our first refusal was to articulate and define an area for refuse for this building.

Similar wording

And so part of our staircase moving, which was originally blocking the commercial entrance doors from the first floor, was a two purpose.

Similar wording

was a two-purpose. One, that the commercial space would be clearly visible and accessible to the

Similar wording

One, that the commercial space would be clearly.

Similar wording

street. The second part is also to create a place in a way for us to contain the refuse

Similar wording

fence in the front of the property, also not make them very visible and allow us the way to be able

Similar wording

to put them in the fencing and chain them without being an obstruction and also still

Similar wording

maintain the curb appeal of the property and so part of the trash and refuge storage here

Similar wording

will be underneath the grand entrance to the right and then adjacent to it to the left of it

Similar wording

Mr. Floyd describe your management plan going forward

Similar wording

property management or trash management I'm sorry property management

Similar wording

so i someone else speaking

Similar wording

in reference to property management i first disclosed that i am a pennsylvania and new

Similar wording

jersey licensed real estate broker i'm also a part of the association so i'm there for a realtor

Similar wording

and of course being as a licensed real estate broker for the last 10 years license sales for

Similar wording

15 for the state of Pennsylvania and a realtor. I adhere to the highest code of conduct, ethics,

Similar wording

management, training, and retraining biannually for the state of Pennsylvania.

Similar wording

We own a sales and rental management company. And this, as I am part half of 50% owner of this,

Similar wording

my full-time 100% company that does property management will be managing this particular

Similar wording

property and all the tenants and including the commercial tenant. So very experienced

Similar wording

and legal professional management. Mr. Floyd, please describe the parking in the area.

Similar wording

I'll preface this by saying that this area is a high density mixed residential commercial area

Similar wording

and the parking in the area is is congested specifically this parcel which actually is only

Similar wording

a row of four properties, which is then connected to a commercial outfit, which actually is

Similar wording

the closed off street of 28th Street.

Similar wording

But our particular row is four properties and with commercial on the bottom, residential

Similar wording

upstairs.

Similar wording

In reference to the parking in front of these four parcels, I believe it was because of

Similar wording

the funeral home being there before.

Similar wording

it's a the entire stretch is a no no parking sign and so the entire lane in front of the four

Similar wording

parcels on west allegheny are always open and that lane is open across the street is the technical

Similar wording

school the catholic technical school and a church and that entire two block stretch is also a no

Similar wording

parking during school hours, except for, I believe, school visits or students coming in or pickup

Similar wording

drop-offs. And that really makes up the main block of parking. It essentially creates a pickup drop-off

Similar wording

area in front of our parcel and our adjacent property parcels. On the side streets and rear

Similar wording

are all one-way streets with one lane, one directional traffic, and those blocks appear

Similar wording

to have a congested parking on those blocks. This seems to have been a neighborhood created

Similar wording

to be a walkable area. It's also two blocks up from the SEPTA bus depot, which is only

Similar wording

at 27th and Allegheny through 26th and Allegheny and the bus stop actually one of the bus stops is

Similar wording

four or five doors down from our parcel but it does not stop directly in front of our parcel

Similar wording

our front of our parcel I think right now you're showing where the white vehicle is is that

Similar wording

pickup drop-off lane and then the bike lane and then the Allegheny traffic

Similar wording

the photos I'm referencing right now on the in the packet start on page 61

Similar wording

If you wish to look at them yourself. The second one where it says 27th Street, the large building there is the SEPTA station.

Similar wording

if you wish to look at them yourself the second one where it says 27

Similar wording

This building is the school across the street from the subject property.

Similar wording

and then that's a view down to the church which is next door to the school

Similar wording

the referenced closed off street you'll see the photo there with the two red lines one above one

Similar wording

below that would be the subject property the front right now as it currently exists

Similar wording

and if you look straight down the center that is where um the street is closed off

Similar wording

with the commercial neighbor behind that it's completely blocked off and gated

Similar wording

the following photo is newkirk street which goes down the side of the block

Similar wording

the next photo shows uh very clearly how the center stairs block off the commercial

Similar wording

entrance area well hide it from view they don't block it off but they hide it from view

Similar wording

and then this the view after that is the view down behind the building if you're standing on

Similar wording

Newkirk Street. The following two views are the back of the building and as

Similar wording

previously noted on the last photo there's a bump out on the 2805 side of

Similar wording

the building the proposed decks for the second and third floors of the 2803 side

Similar wording

of the building would be even with that bump out and of course there would be a

Similar wording

deck for the second and third floor above that bump-out board members I

Similar wording

believe that concludes the majority of our testimony for today it is our

Similar wording

believe that the proposals are de minimis they do maintain the character of the community

Similar wording

they do address the community needs for affordable housing in the area which has become

Similar wording

a stark issue not just in this neighborhood but in many neighborhoods in philadelphia

Similar wording

and they do maintain a respectable and high quality of living

Similar wording

i open the floor to questions thank you but before we begin i just want the record to reflect that

Similar wording

board member james snell has been on this call for about 20 minutes maybe even a little bit

Similar wording

longer than that so let the board the record reflect that he's in attendance as well

Similar wording

uh questions from the board no no no

Similar wording

planning commission

Similar wording

yes um both um 2803 2805 west allegheny are indicated for commercial mixed juice on the

Similar wording

City plan. We support the granting of the daycare center special exception and have

Similar wording