civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - October 1, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Oct 1, 20252h 39m

there were actually two cases that were filed one by a prior attorney which was withdrawn this

Similar wording

morning and this one is finally being presented before the board we did have a hearing scheduled

Similar wording

previously this is the vacant lot that in question as you can see the application

Similar wording

by the way the exhibit packet is that 46 pages the application is for brand new construction

Similar wording

of multi-family dwelling

Similar wording

on the corner lot the proposed use i'm sorry two-family dwelling the proposed use to have a

Similar wording

two-family dwelling is uh requires a variance because the lot is still zoned rsa 5

Similar wording

application went in and we do have ping design here online i will be calling him and he can

Similar wording

go over the property details with respect to design it's a three-story home

Similar wording

you can see here we've removed all basement bedrooms

Similar wording

And let's take a look at the interior.

Similar wording

These are two housing products that are going to be in excess of 750 square feet.

Similar wording

In excess of 750 square feet, as you can see here, this is one unit.

Similar wording

Here's the other.

Similar wording

I misspoke about basement bedrooms, by the way.

Similar wording

That's my other project.

Similar wording

But you can see here on the first floor, you have one unit of 1,615 square feet,

Similar wording

large living space large eating kitchen the lower level with various access wells will have the

Similar wording

bedrooms and the baths and then the second and third floor again you have a study in the front

Similar wording

you'll have a large kitchen and living in area and then the top floor you have your bedrooms and

Similar wording

your baths. We did meet with Strawberry Mansion Community Concern, and they do approve of the

Similar wording

project, realizing that a brand new construction of a single family home on this lot would price

Similar wording

just about anybody out of the market in the area. This way, we are allowed to build

Similar wording

to quality new construction homes that are family-sustaining size,

Similar wording

which was very important to the RCO, but at approachable price points,

Similar wording

which is increasingly more difficult these days, as you all know.

Similar wording

Here's the proof of mailing, proof of posting.

Similar wording

Vern, did you see their provisos?

Similar wording

I did.

Similar wording

Oh, but we have signatures from those few people who live on that block that we could get.

Similar wording

And do you agree, before we go on, do you agree with the provisos?

Similar wording

Because, I mean, I'm seeing the provisos, no household living in the basement, no roof deck or roof deck access.

Similar wording

Well, the roof deck was one that we did agree to.

Similar wording

The basement is what the basement is.

Similar wording

I mean, obviously, you can't have two units without use of the basement.

Similar wording

But the roof deck was not necessarily a deal breaker, as I explained to Benita Cummings, who is the head, and I believe she's on because I did speak to her this morning.

Similar wording

And most of the other provisos we do are in agreement with.

Similar wording

The one that obviously we have to have bedrooms at that second unit, and they do need to be in the basement.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Please proceed.

Similar wording

Anyway, we had some signatures from folks who live on Montgomery, as well as around the corner on 26th.

Similar wording

And I do believe you've also received the council letter of non-opposition as well.

Similar wording

Because we're offering two family-sustaining units, that in fact can provide quality living products at approachable price points as compared to if my client was forced to build a single-family home.

Similar wording

we do ask respectfully that the variance for the two-family dwelling on this corner

Similar wording

be granted. And with that, I'd like to bring my client, Kemet Hassa, on to adopt my testimony.

Similar wording

morning chair this is jason hand i'll be stepping in momentarily um thank you so what is the name

Similar wording

of the person you wish to see k-i-m-e-t hasa h-a-s-a he should be on as should uh ping p-i-n-g

Similar wording

design the architect

Similar wording

you said ping correct yes i see a twin ping one in your virtual audience okay

Similar wording

i have allowed them to speak thank you

Similar wording

Mr. Chair, since we can't seem to get Mr. Hassa on, I ask that the board take my presentation

Similar wording

as his testimony.

Similar wording

You're an officer of the court.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

And if Ping is here, I ask him to identify himself.

Similar wording

From Ping Wang, please unmute and wait to be sworn in.

Similar wording

Peng Peng Wang, please unmute, wait to be sworn in.

Similar wording

We could circle back to him, Mr.

Similar wording

We could circle back to him, Mr. Chair, if he's having difficulty, if Ms. Cumming wanted to get on.

Similar wording

All right, so let's see.

Similar wording

Questions from the board, and Vern, you'll answer the questions, please.

Similar wording

Do my best.

Similar wording

Can you go to your building section again?

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

This here?

Similar wording

No, the building section.

Similar wording

Not that.

Similar wording

Yeah, that's it.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So zoom into, you know, my question is about the basement and depth below basement, but I can tell from your section that I think you've done a good job.

Similar wording

I'm back, Jay.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

I think your depth below the grade, I think, works.

Similar wording

It looks like it's hard to tell.

Similar wording

I can't really tell, but it looks like you're four feet to the first floor, which makes your basement below not such a bad depth below grade.

Similar wording

so i think it actually that was our intention actually works the basement has eight foot

Similar wording

ceilings right so you so you get a six foot five foot so below grade which is not bad because your

Similar wording

windows get to be above the pavement which is correct yeah so you get a lot more light so

Similar wording

thank you yes sir other than that i thought the layout the layout was was worked for me i don't

Similar wording

know what the issues are around the the um the penthouse and all that that's i guess the

Similar wording

community's concern around that, but I'm fine with the layout. Yeah, the roof deck itself is not a

Similar wording

deal breaker. Again, it was important for us to, you know, to offer enough bedrooms for this to

Similar wording

be family sustaining. That's all. The neighbors were very clear about that. Most of the smaller,

Similar wording

single, older single family homes are three and four bedrooms, sometimes more. So we wanted to

Similar wording

give that kind of space, but in a modern amenity. Thank you. Other questions from the board?

Similar wording

Yes. So was there a community meeting for this or? Ms. Cummings is here to testify. And the RCO

Similar wording

sent a letter of non-opposition, provisos, most of which we, I believe, signed off on. And the

Similar wording

council office also provided that. So you didn't answer the question. There was a community meeting

Similar wording

where people were able to weigh in yes okay all right thank you i'm sorry all the questions and

Similar wording

what's the plan for trash because it doesn't look like there's designated trash storage inside the

Similar wording

units well the yard is for the first floor unit and the top unit has ample space for trash storage

Similar wording

interior okay is there going to be a plan to add like a ventilated trash closet yes okay yeah the

Similar wording

first that whole first floor of the second unit which would be uh you know the uh uh second floor

Similar wording

that's just living there was space it's not currently drawn not drawn in there yep correct

Similar wording

then it's trash closet for that second unit is is the plan is the plan okay all the questions

Similar wording

questions or comments from our attorney um just briefly mr anastasio just wanted to to clarify

Similar wording

the because there were a number of provisals which ones were agreed to and which ones weren't

Similar wording

so the first one was no roof deck or roof deck access structure and i believe you indicated you

Similar wording

were um certainly not a deal breaker you know yeah i mean i i'm sure you would prefer to keep

Similar wording

that but that one's that we would yeah okay and then no household living in the basement we have

Similar wording

discussed um maximum two dwelling units that's what you're asking for so i assume that's fine

Similar wording

um trash stored in the rear yard for both units that can be uh if that's i mean if the rco wants

Similar wording

that uh because it's a corner property both units can have access uh and that's we could agree to

Similar wording

that easily okay but it's also part of the plan to have whoever lives on the second floor to be

Similar wording

able to store their trash internally okay all right and then the last the the last proviso was

Similar wording

for certificate of occupancy which obviously would be part since this is a new construction

Similar wording

would be part of the process.

Similar wording

So I thank you so much.

Similar wording

Questions or comments from the virtual audience?

Similar wording

Yeah, we have

Similar wording

Pastor Tyrone Williams.

Similar wording

He's coming back in as a panelist now.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Good morning.

Similar wording

Good morning, Reverend. How are you?

Similar wording

Hi. I have some questions.

Similar wording

Hold up, hold up, hold up.

Similar wording

Could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Sure, Tyrone Williams.

Similar wording

Sure. Tyrone Williams, spelled T-Y-R-O-N-E, Williams, W-I-L-L-I-A-M-S.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, I do.

Similar wording

Please proceed.

Similar wording

I guess my first question was, who were the affected RCOs for this property?

Similar wording

Byrne, do you want to answer that?

Similar wording

Oh, okay, if the question's for me.

Similar wording

Okay. Strawberry Mansion Community Concern is the RCO that I believe held the meeting and presented the letter.

Similar wording

The affected RCOs other than Strawberry Mansion Community Concerns for this property.

Similar wording

Okay. Well, it's page 12 of my exhibit. I'm sure it lists all the RCOs that would have been contacted.

Similar wording

We have 32nd Ward and we have Strawberry Mansion Community Concern.

Similar wording

Before that, second, where was the meeting held or how was the meeting held?

Similar wording

All of that information would be in the RCO letter.

Similar wording

No, but I'm asking a question now for this purpose right now.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

You know, respectfully.

Similar wording

Mr. Chair, am I being questioned here?

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

I think he was on Zoom.

Similar wording

Do I see a Zoom link?

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

I don't want you to be questioned, but if you can offer some information.

Similar wording

Of course.

Similar wording

That's fine. I see the journal.

Similar wording

That's been answered. And lastly,

Similar wording

what was the results of the meeting?

Similar wording

Well, if you can answer that,

Similar wording

I would defer

Similar wording

everyone to Ms. Cummings and her

Similar wording

letter. Okay. Thank you very much.

Similar wording

Thank you, Reverend. Anyone

Similar wording

else in the virtual audience?

Similar wording

Chair, we have Strawberry Mansion Community

Similar wording

Concerns. They're giving me back

Similar wording

in as a panelist now.

Similar wording

Good morning, Ms. Cummings.

Similar wording

Ms. Cummings

Similar wording

It looks like it's taken a while to come back over

Similar wording

Okay, all right, we'll wait

Similar wording

Can you hear me?

Similar wording

I can. Could you please state your name and spell for the sonographer?

Similar wording

Good morning

Similar wording

our Chairman Bergman and the board.

Similar wording

My name is Bonita Cummings,

Similar wording

B-O-N-I-T-A, C-U-M-M-I-N-G-S.

Similar wording

Right.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth,

Similar wording

the whole truth and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Please proceed.

Similar wording

I first want to address these constant,

Similar wording

I guess, inquiries of affected entities.

Similar wording

This case goes back a while.

Similar wording

It started out with a different attorney, Sean Ward. And at that time, the only RSEO affected was Strawberry Mansion Community Concern, which is why I believe we were assigned this matter.

Similar wording

um also for people to be clear there there was a representation of the 32nd ward which was

Similar wording

suspended due to i believe the then ward leader um suspending his own ward for for personal

Similar wording

reasons around who they like and who they don't like yeah i think um since that time i think the

Similar wording

32nd ward may have been uh you know restored as it relates to um whatever geographical boundaries

Similar wording

they would be assigned to so and you know as so that the record is clear as to uh you know what

Similar wording

i'm doing as a rco or my committee is doing as an rco we are following the rules we are following

Similar wording

what is required we do um the letters we we have the meetings um we notify who is supposed to be

Similar wording

notified so um strawberry mansion community development corporation mr tyrone williams

Similar wording

um was not a coordinating or effective rco in this matter in this location this 2600 west

Similar wording

montgomery avenue so i just wanted to set the record straight i think i understand that right

Similar wording

because people are always trying to imply but what instead of listen to me but in terms of the

Similar wording

project itself um what's in the um the letter that was written um is our understanding um that there

Similar wording

was to be no basement living but if that's something different at this time um you all

Similar wording

are deciding that's one thing there was no no rooftop deck no rooftop deck access but we also

Similar wording

just for the record um i know she didn't uh attorney hillary didn't read it as one of the

Similar wording

But we did talk about them putting more brick or some other material on the sidewall so it's not just that all. So they did agree to that. So I just wanted to state that for them.

Similar wording

um all so they did agree to that so i just wanted to state that for the also for the record

Similar wording

and i can i can confirm that mr chair in the affirmative yeah sure well i i think hillary

Similar wording

knew that but it was not right it was not a proviso right so but but explain to me what

Similar wording

are your provisos um i have from the letter no roof deck or roof deck access no household living

Similar wording

in the basement. Is that your proviso? That was what we understood, but I think now something

Similar wording

else is being said. I wouldn't have put it there if it wasn't part of the agreement, but at this

Similar wording

point, Mr. Anastasio is saying something else. I don't know how that's going to be handled,

Similar wording

But in terms of what we left as the community understanding was what was put in the provisos.

Similar wording

And this record was really ready to go a few weeks back, but because they had to repost, the letter is a little, you know, dated.

Similar wording