civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - October 13, 2020

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Oct 13, 20205h 3m

It's dark.

Similar wording

It's not very comfortable.

Similar wording

So they have requested lighting on this side, which my client is already intending to do,

Similar wording

and also security cameras, whether they would be positioned on the various corners around

Similar wording

building that is is part of the proposal as well as hiring um security staff to be a part of the

Similar wording

project going forward and i'd like to pull up some of the floor plans so as we went through the the

Similar wording

So, as we went through the ground floor plan previously, there is also a cell or a basement

Similar wording

space attached to the building that's divided between the commercial area and the residential.

Similar wording

So it's about 60% commercial and maybe 30% residential and the rest is mechanicals to

Similar wording

service the building. And the plan as of now, as the layout is set up, we do have, I'm going to

Similar wording

zoom in just so you can see a little better. There is a mix of apartments proposed for this

Similar wording

development. We have 56 studios proposed, 24 one-bedroom units, and 19 two-bedroom units that

Similar wording

will range from various sizes to try to give a good mix of tenants that would be able to

Similar wording

live at the building, not pure students. We want members from the community to also be able to

Similar wording

see this as a place to live long-term, and that's why there's a decent number of two-bedroom units

Similar wording

with two bedrooms, two baths. And the floor plans basically mirror each other as we go

Similar wording

up over the five stories. So on the screen, members of the board currently at page 112

Similar wording

are just typical studios, one bedroom, two bedroom units that would populate the various

Similar wording

spaces throughout the building. And for the most part, they're really good sized units.

Similar wording

The studios start at 475 and go up to 575, and the one bedrooms are between 750 up to

Similar wording

950, and the two bedrooms are around 1,000, 1050 at this point on the models at this point.

Similar wording

And we did have a truck of rendering of the turning plan just to make sure the turning radius to service the commercial space would be accessible and safe.

Similar wording

And if Diamond Street is wide enough, large enough that that should be easily accessible to service the building.

Similar wording

So, those are the main points of the project. As I've mentioned previously, the hardship

Similar wording

here really is the characteristics of this neighborhood and specifically along the I2

Similar wording

train track corridor has transitioned into this commercial residential mixed-use development,

Similar wording

And this is in keeping with the neighborhood where this property is currently located.

Similar wording

The auto use is kind of outdated.

Similar wording

And if you look at the surrounding properties, it's mainly we're dealing with RM1 properties all around us, residential over here and Temple's campus is to the west.

Similar wording

So it makes sense.

Similar wording

It's a logical spot to bring in commercial mixed use.

Similar wording

one of the big feedbacks from the community was what type of commercial tenant would service that

Similar wording

main commercial space and we do not have a tenant my clients has different tenants in mind like a

Similar wording

target express and one of the comments from the community was to try to focus on fresh food type

Similar wording

options a giant heirloom store we discussed like a river words produce type idea something that

Similar wording

um brings fresh food to that as they reference on the call like that side of the tracks um

Similar wording

so that is something we're definitely looking into and on the second floor commercial space

Similar wording

there was discussions about coffee shops um maybe like a fedex kinko's type store like a

Similar wording

post post depot that's low impact but would service the members of the community

Similar wording

um close by not having to walk up get all over to broad street but we're in communications and

Similar wording

will be on gun with the near neighbors to get further impact or further input on those commercial

Similar wording

tenants. All right, you summarize? Yeah, so in summary, we have a full letter of support from

Similar wording

the registered community groups. I believe Councilman Clark's office is either not taking

Similar wording

a position or hopefully supports. My client feels that this is a great use for this location and

Similar wording

would be a benefit to the community,

Similar wording

and the community seems to support that idea as well.

Similar wording

The hardship here is that the community has transitioned,

Similar wording

the neighborhood has transitioned from this I2 use,

Similar wording

and that creates a hardship for the subject property.

Similar wording

And we would request that the board grant this use variance

Similar wording

so that the property can be developed

Similar wording

and better the community.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you. Do you have anyone to bring on as a witness?

Similar wording

Do you have anyone to bring on as a witness?

Similar wording

I would, yes and no.

Similar wording

I would. Yes, Mr. Chair. I would like to call Gary Murray to raise his hand to see if we can bring him on.

Similar wording

You can unmute, Gary.

Similar wording

Can you hear me?

Similar wording

Yes, sir. Please identify yourself for the record. Spell your first and last name.

Similar wording

Good evening. I'm Gary Murray, the owner of Mazel Tov Development.

Similar wording

Mr. Murray. Oh, sorry. What about your last name, please?

Similar wording

M-U-R-R-A-Y.

Similar wording

You swear and affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Thank you. Please proceed.

Similar wording

Mr. Murray, did you hear the factual presentation that I just presented to the board?

Similar wording

I did. I did.

Similar wording

and were my statements true and correct uh to the best of your your knowledge uh yes they were

Similar wording

and would you adopt those statements that were put on the record as your own

Similar wording

yes i would thank you sorry i'm trying to get my uh my video together for some reason i can't

Similar wording

that's okay we can hear you that's fine all right uh any questions from the board no

Similar wording

no anyone else wish to testify in this case if so please raise your hand um i would like to

Similar wording

who i just wanted to let everybody know and put on record it was definitely because i know that

Similar wording

there are some members of the community that are on here today um i definitely want to i'm sorry

Similar wording

Who's speaking?

Similar wording

Is that who you're speaking?

Similar wording

Gary.

Similar wording

Oh, okay.

Similar wording

I'm sorry.

Similar wording

I just wanted to put it on record that we've worked with the community for some time.

Similar wording

After multiple meetings with the community, we've met three times with APM as well as

Similar wording

another RCO intern.

Similar wording

In turn, it's been a pleasure to work with the community and putting together the best use for this site.

Similar wording

We have definitely taken into consideration a lot of the different requests that were made of us, including a parking resolution community benefits package

Similar wording

that would include some support for parking for some residents that are near and that are

Similar wording

in need of assistance. But it's definitely been a pleasure. We're looking forward to being able to

Similar wording

bring something fresh to the community there. We just actually had a cleanup benefit in the area,

Similar wording

which is something that we're looking to continue on as well as this property is going to be

Similar wording

managed and have its own maintenance and cleaning detail, which will keep the area and location at

Similar wording

all times at its best shape as possible, to keep it as clean as possible. And we're just looking

Similar wording

forward to being a part of the community. We have gotten some input in regards to the commercial

Similar wording

spaces. We have plans to try to get a UPS store in there where members of the community can go

Similar wording

there to get copies made, use computers, have P.O. boxes, etc. It's a great type of business for

Similar wording

people that have small businesses in the area or looking to create small businesses where they can

Similar wording

have access to it um as well we're looking to put in a uh i have a friend who has um a very popular

Similar wording

um breakfast brunch uh company it's called green eggs we're looking to bring him to the location

Similar wording

as well um so we're definitely looking to have a number of things that would definitely benefit

Similar wording

the community in a number of ways um so we're really excited about this um i did earlier um kind

Similar wording

to miss the point on the balconies. So if I could get some clarity on what the discrepancy

Similar wording

was with that, that would be helpful. The project as it's being viewed and the renderings

Similar wording

is exactly the way that we presented it to the CDR committee. And it was very, very,

Similar wording

very well received as is. So I guess, you know, whatever we need to do to kind of keep

Similar wording

things the way that they are definitely open for discussions on that I'm not sure if there is some

Similar wording

type of a proviso but we've we've definitely been at this for a very long time like I said we've met

Similar wording

But we've definitely been at this for a very long time.

Similar wording

Like I said, we've met with community groups multiple times.

Similar wording

And Mr. Murray, Mr. Murray, with all due respect, we appreciate your comments.

Similar wording

But I think most of everything you have stated has already been covered by your counsel.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Any questions from the board?

Similar wording

no no no okay i'll try again anyone else would like to testify in this case if so please raise

Similar wording

your hand no hey thank you planning commission good afternoon this is greg waldman from the

Similar wording

planning commission this property is indicated for um oh sorry she is

Similar wording

This property is indicated for residential multifamily in the comprehensive plan and

Similar wording

has not yet been remapped.

Similar wording

The proposal was reviewed by the Civic Design Review on March 3 of 2020 and had support

Similar wording

from the committee.

Similar wording

While we have concerns that the proposed commercial space is larger than can reasonably be supported

Similar wording

in this area, we have no objection to the granting of the variance.

Similar wording

Thank you. Sharon, I'm going to read this off. And what was it we agreed to do regarding the balconies?

Similar wording

I believe that you're going to hold it for a week or two weeks, and he will come back and make a decision on whether to remove the balconies or to perhaps submit a revised application to L&I.

Similar wording

We'll have to check with Tanya.

Similar wording

Tanya, do you have a date?

Similar wording

Oh, that's perfectly fine because we're just going to have a resumption hearing with revised plans, if I'm understanding correctly.

Similar wording

So he can come back the 27th, October 27th.

Similar wording

That works fine.

Similar wording

930 works well.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

mi-2020-000719 919 diamond street this hearing will be resumed on october the 27th at 9 30 a.m

Similar wording

at which time we will know whether there's any revision as it relates to

Similar wording

the balconies that have been presented in today's plan does that make sense

Similar wording

yes yes and i would recommend mr mckelhanie that you um email or call me in the meantime

Similar wording

yes i will do thank you okay uh i think that concludes the 3 30 session

Similar wording

yes chair it does any unfinished business tanya sharon anyone no chair

Similar wording

we're all good

Similar wording

okay everyone have a safe night

Similar wording

likewise

Similar wording

send all your

Similar wording

thank yous to Rudy Giuliani

Similar wording

thank you

Similar wording

thanks Frank

Similar wording