civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - August 18, 2020

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Aug 18, 20205h 15m

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Getting a guess for Raju, if either of them can unmute themselves, have they?

Similar wording

have they

Similar wording

i guess not um

Similar wording

Guess not.

Similar wording

you conclude yeah i'll conclude okay thank you uh questions from the board no no so just so you

Similar wording

know nagesh has texted me and said he's not able to unmute so no problem yeah no problem is there

Similar wording

For anyone else who wishes to testify in this matter, please raise your hand.

Similar wording

Chair I have Debra McCarty, Debra, you can unmute yourself, wait to be sworn in to testify.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, Ms. McCarty, would you please identify yourself with a record, spell your

Similar wording

name?

Similar wording

yes good afternoon my name is debra mccarty d-e-b-r-a m-c-c-a-r-t-y i live at 3608

Similar wording

hamilton street debra do you swear and affirm to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing

Similar wording

but the truth i do thank you please proceed so i just wanted to uh reaffirm the civic association

Similar wording

the RCO's position, on this reuse of the church, and we appreciate that they have worked with us

Similar wording

and made some revisions to the plans. We believe this would be a really good project for the

Similar wording

community and look forward to working with the property owners on making it a good place for

Similar wording

folks to live. And that's about it. Thank you. Thank you, Debra, and good to hear from you.

Similar wording

Anyone else who wishes to testify, please raise your hand.

Similar wording

Nijaru, now you have it. Yeah, hi, this is Negesh Ribikanti, one of the owners.

Similar wording

you need to identify yourself sir spell your name for the for the

Similar wording

stenographer my name is Nagesh Ravikanti N-A-G-E-S-H is the first name the last

Similar wording

name is Ravikanti R-A-B-I-K-A-N-T-I I live at 43 Zaits Farm Road

Similar wording

West Windsor New Jersey 08550

Similar wording

though. He was, I'm sorry, he was sworn, correct? We're in the firm to tell the truth, the whole

Similar wording

truth, and nothing but the truth? I do. Thank you, I'm sorry. Nikesh, did you hear the statements

Similar wording

that I made to the board this afternoon? Every single thing. The only one correction, David,

Similar wording

at one point you said we have reduced the number of units from 25 to 20. I just want to show for

Similar wording

the record it's it's going down from 25 to 22 22 correct but you misspoke okay thank you for that

Similar wording

early on he said 22 later in this presentation he may have said 20. you got it right you got

Similar wording

it right the first time first time all right i was batting 500 so at least we take that any day

Similar wording

right now but um nagesh did uh other than that that that correction is uh was everything else

Similar wording

that i stated true and correct that is correct yes we adopted as adopt me statements as your

Similar wording

own i do and is there anything you would like to add for the board um no we're uh we're just

Similar wording

thankful we're looking forward to you know moving ahead with this project if it's approved thank you

Similar wording

anyone else wishes to testify please raise your hand

Similar wording

no hands at this time chair thank you planning commission

Similar wording

this property is indicated for residential use on the city plan we support the conversion of

Similar wording

this church into multi-family based on the changes made to the plans and the reduction

Similar wording

of units we have no objection to the granting of the revised variances thank you uh how many pages

Similar wording

david three calendar number three nine nine six two three seven two seven baring street

Similar wording

my vote is yes with proviso revised plan three pages approved today my vote is yes proviso

Similar wording

yes with proviso yes with proviso yes with proviso all right this concludes the three

Similar wording

excuse me chairman chico i'm sorry um

Similar wording

ms sunken believes that you did not add the proviso to the ellsworth street decision if you could

Similar wording

revote that

Similar wording

i'm sorry have the dog reloaded with proviso one page one revised plans one page

Similar wording

have the dog

Similar wording

revote

Similar wording

uh hold on let me get my uh okay all right that's the alarm to let you know that you didn't

Similar wording

it wasn't fun david if you keep talking that we're going to sig that dog on you so

Similar wording

wouldn't be the first time calendar number three nine nine five six

Similar wording

one zero one two ellsworth street my vote is yes with the proviso one page stand approved today

Similar wording

my vote is just proviso yes with proviso yes with proviso yes with proviso

Similar wording

okay we'll take a 15 minute break be back at four o'clock to start our 3 30 session

Similar wording

can i ask a question sure um sharon did we put on a continuance for fairmount

Similar wording

oh my god sharon you there

Similar wording

are you speaking fairmount on 3 30 we don't have it no two o'clock

Similar wording

Did we put that on record

Similar wording

that it was continued?

Similar wording

If not,

Similar wording

could we state it?

Similar wording

Yeah, I think we should.

Similar wording

Yeah, we should state it.

Similar wording

I have it on my list.

Similar wording

So what is the...

Similar wording

I apologize.

Similar wording

I missed that one.

Similar wording

It is...

Similar wording

No problem.

Similar wording

Just give me the calendar number

Similar wording

and the...

Similar wording

Sure.

Similar wording

calendar number 39429 387 3857 north fair hill street

Similar wording

correct i'm sorry sharon um if i could mention that this address of question is calendar number

Similar wording

3883 1714 washington avenue we were waiting to see if the attorney showed up uh because we didn't

Similar wording

get exhibit packages so we're going to state that it's continued at this time that's right

Similar wording

all right thank you kindly all right be back around 405 thank you chair and vice chair thank

Similar wording

you thank you tanya okay

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Hey, it's a scan.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Let's see. All the board members are here. Tanya, Sharon. Yep. Everybody's here.

Similar wording

we ready you can shake your head then you affirm it thank you

Similar wording

okay good afternoon everyone my name is frank di chico i'm the chair of the zoning board of

Similar wording

adjustment i'll be participating in today's hearing along with our vice chair miss carol

Similar wording

tenere our board secretary confessor plaza and board members thomas holloman and james snell

Similar wording

along with board member board administrator tanya sunken and board attorney sharon saletta

Similar wording

will also be in attendance for those of you who haven't yeah haven't excuse me for those of you

Similar wording

who haven't participated in one of our virtual hearings i will go through some of the basics of

Similar wording

what you can expect first we'll begin this afternoon session by reading a list of cases

Similar wording

to be continued if you believe any announced case is being continued in error we will give

Similar wording

you an opportunity to respond after reading the continuance list and receiving any feedback

Similar wording

we will take any additional continuance request then once we've confirmed which hearings are

Similar wording

being continued vice chair carol tenere will begin calling the remaining cases listed for this session

Similar wording

When a case is called, we ask that attorneys representing applicants or other interested

Similar wording

parties in the matter identify themselves for the record. We will then hear the applicant's

Similar wording

presentation followed by any presentation by attorneys representing other parties.

Similar wording

Interested parties and members of the public not represented by counsel will then be given

Similar wording

an opportunity to testify we will finally hear the recommendation of the planning commission

Similar wording

at the hearing's conclusion we will either vote the matter immediately or hold it for discussion

Similar wording

in executive session any case held for discussion will be voted at the next scheduled wednesday

Similar wording

meeting wednesday morning meeting 9 30 a.m please note the following changes related to the

Similar wording

9.30 a.m. Please note the following changes related to the virtual format. First, we will

Similar wording

be administering oaths to individuals' participants prior to their testimony. Second, for the benefit

Similar wording

of anyone participating by phone, we ask that attorneys and witnesses identify themselves

Similar wording

prior to speaking or testifying. Third, we'd like to advise everyone that this proceeding

Similar wording

is being recorded, and that by participating, you acknowledge your agreement to be recorded.

Similar wording

Fourth, anyone participating by phone, if you wish to testify, you must raise your hand by hitting

Similar wording

star nine and then star six to unmute yourself. I repeat, anyone participating by phone,

Similar wording

If you wish to testify, you must raise your hand by hitting star 9 and then star 6 to unmute yourself.

Similar wording

Finally, to enter an appearance statement, call Google pound 267-270-5548 and leave your email address and the address of the property at issue.

Similar wording

Again, that is Google pound 267-270-5548 and leave your email address and the address of the property at issue.

Similar wording

With that said, we'll begin.

Similar wording

But before Vice Chair Tenere recalls our first case, we'd like to announce the following matters as being continued.

Similar wording

calendar number 39462 1410 alden street no exhibits calendar number 39427 1501 south 12th

Similar wording

street calendar number four excuse me calendar number four zero zero six five one one nine three

Similar wording

four stevens road i would ask at this time if anyone believes that a case is being continued

Similar wording

in error please raise your hand mr chairman yes on calendar three nine nine five nine twenty

Similar wording

21 north randolph street this is one of five properties on the same block of randolph that

Similar wording

are going to be heard if it could be continued until two o'clock tomorrow all the properties

Similar wording

could be considered together thank you thank you for clearing that thank you for clearing that up

Similar wording

and is there anyone who has any objection to that um statement that has just been read

Similar wording

it read into the record by Ms. Saleta if so raise your hand I just want to mention Sharon it should

Similar wording

be 3 30 right

Similar wording

While we're waiting for Sharon to get back on, is there anyone who believes that a case

Similar wording

is being continued in error.

Similar wording

If so, please raise your hand.

Similar wording

I believe that it's

Similar wording

2 o'clock. There's a

Similar wording

Randstead rather than Randolph.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

That's being heard at 3.30,

Similar wording

but Randolph is at 2.

Similar wording

Tanya, I believe Leonard

Similar wording

wants to be on mute.

Similar wording

Sorry, confessor, I didn't

Similar wording

hear that.

Similar wording

yeah not at the spot he's for pine street okay i'm sorry no worries no worries i just have

Similar wording

isaac slepner with his hand up isaac yes uh good afternoon board um sharon slay is

Similar wording

isaac excuse me identify yourself for the record please uh sure thing isaac slepner uh with

Similar wording

matione limited 100 north independence mall west suite 5a northwest philadelphia pa 19106

Similar wording

um you swear for him to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Similar wording

i do um i i spoke with miss saletta this morning about 2021 north randolph street and she is

Similar wording

correct it um it was going to be continued to uh tomorrow august 19th at two o'clock

Similar wording

thank you i'm counsel on that i just wanted to uh chime in on that but thank you

Similar wording

so i have nothing further today thank you all right thank you okay one more time is there

Similar wording

anyone else out there who believes the case as was called in continuance as as being an error

Similar wording

anyone wishes at this time to request a continuance or withdrawal please raise your hand

Similar wording

Please raise your hand.

Similar wording

There's no hands up, but Chair, if you could,

Similar wording

could we hold one second while I speak to legal counsel?

Similar wording

Sure.

Similar wording

Yep.

Similar wording

This goes here.

Similar wording

Thanks, Chair. We're ready.

Similar wording

Thank you. Carol?

Similar wording

Calendar number 38817, 221 Pine Street.

Similar wording

This is an appeal against L&I filed by the Society Hill Civic Association.

Similar wording

I believe the attorneys are Vern Anastasio and Paul Bonney.

Similar wording

also leonard reuter for the city you know carol if you don't mind just before we begin

Similar wording

i think there's another case that wasn't on our schedule 1408 reed street calendar number three

Similar wording

nine nine five one i'm just wondering if that would be we should take that first because

Similar wording

generally appeals against an online take a little bit longer yes that's why i wanted to

Similar wording

ask our attorney if we could do that it would also allow the planning commission um representative

Similar wording

to leave after this is an excuse so uh mr bonnie and mr anastasia we'll get to you next we'll get

Similar wording

this other case out of the way all right thank you thank you okay calendar number three nine

Similar wording

nine five one 1408 reed street um darwin are you here for that it's darwin and i think meredith

Similar wording