civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - August 25, 2020

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Aug 25, 20203h 40m

This is where the retail sale of pet supplies will be.

Similar wording

There'll be a door right here.

Similar wording

You can see where my cursor is and a hallway, which will lead into the grooming section.

Similar wording

On the left, we have a cat condo for cat grooming.

Similar wording

And then we have an office on the right.

Similar wording

And we have a grooming station for dogs here.

Similar wording

That's grooming station number one.

Similar wording

And we have grooming station number two.

Similar wording

right here in addition to a bathroom. In the back of the building this section

Similar wording

will be the doggy daycare. There'll be, you can see my cursor on the right,

Similar wording

there'll be an entrance on Percy Street to enter that space. The entire space

Similar wording

will be sound mitigated and any dogs that are seem to be a problem with the

Similar wording

excessive barking we will be asked not to return pet snobs boutique has been in business for

Similar wording

several years they are on the 600 block of south street right now they have over a four star google

Similar wording

rating the community just loves them they've never had a problem and what they'd like to do now is

Similar wording

move into a much larger larger space

Similar wording

here's an interior photo sorry interior photo of the front and

Similar wording

there's the back on Percy Street we have our lease and I'll get to it's a very

Similar wording

there's the back on Percy Street

Similar wording

long lease get to our tax certs we met with the RCO we had certified mail 118

Similar wording

pieces of mail. The RCO for this particular property is the Bella Vista Neighbors Association

Similar wording

and they've sent a letter of non-opposition with unanimous vote to not oppose and or to support.

Similar wording

And with that, that's my case in chief. We respectfully request the granting of the

Similar wording

referral. Thank you. Thank you. Do you have any witnesses, Mr. Anastasio? I believe my clients,

Similar wording

at least one, JC and Dara, should be on the Zoom. If they are, I ask them to identify themselves at

Similar wording

this time. Raise your hand if you are. Can you hear us? Yes, please identify yourself. I'm Dara

Similar wording

Slott, D-A-R-A-S-L-O-T-T. And I'm Jacqueline Kelly, J-A-C-L-Y-N-K-E-L-L-Y. Okay, and you guys can

Similar wording

answer this. Do both of your ladies swear and affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and

Similar wording

nothing but the truth? Yes, I do. Please proceed. Thank you, Dara and JC. Did you hear my presentation

Similar wording

to the board today? Yes. Was it true and accurate to the best of your knowledge? Yes. And would you

Similar wording

both adopt it as your own testimony if the need arised. Yes. That was a yes, correct? Correct.

Similar wording

Thank you. And with that, I close my case. Thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone else

Similar wording

who wishes to testify on this case? If so, please raise your hand.

Similar wording

Cher, we have Andy. Andy, you can unmute yourself and wait to be sworn in.

Similar wording

Andy, when you get on, please identify yourself, full name and address.

Similar wording

Hi, my name is Andy Lau. Last name is spelled L-A-U. I live at 920 South Street, which is the building adjacent to this subject property.

Similar wording

You swear and affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Please proceed.

Similar wording

So I just have one concern, and I just saw that there was a public meeting posted,

Similar wording

so I just wanted to raise it to see how this would be addressed.

Similar wording

So Percy Street is really much of a small alley.

Similar wording

There's a lot of traffic, and a lot of people sometimes park in the middle of the alley,

Similar wording

so it's hard to get the vehicles out from the various parking spaces in Percy Street.

Similar wording

I was just wondering, with dog daycare, there's usually a lot of in and out, especially in the morning, how that would be addressed if I say I have to drive the work, whether the property would have some sort of policy or how they would address the barriers.

Similar wording

That's a good question. Two things. First, overwhelming majority of the folks who take their dogs to their daycare are folks who walk their dogs there. They're not coming from other neighborhoods to drop their dogs off.

Similar wording

This is a doggy daycare for Bella Vistas for the most part. And within three or four blocks, that's a large majority of their clientele. However, there will be a loading zone applied for in the front of the building so that folks can, if they do need to, to pull in to drop their dogs off for either daycare or grooming, we'll be able to do that in the loading zone.

Similar wording

And that loading zone did exist before, and we're just going to put that back in front of the property.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And so the loading zone, I guess for the people that are boarding, they could come from the 9th Street side rather than the 1st Street side in addition?

Similar wording

The loading zone will be on the 9th Street side.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Sorry, I guess to clarify, for the daycare services, they can come in from the 9th Street side as well?

Similar wording

the no they'll they would park at the loading zone and they would walk around the corner to

Similar wording

percy street okay thank you that's the end that'll be the percy street will have the be the entrance

Similar wording

for the daycare okay okay thank you anyone else wishes to testify please raise your hand

Similar wording

that's all i see chair

Similar wording

thank you planning commission

Similar wording

mr chairman and members of the board

Similar wording

Mr. Chairman and members of the board, this property is zoned for commercial mixed use.

Similar wording

this property is zoned for commercial

Similar wording

mixed use

Similar wording

The comprehensive plan recommends commercial mixed use.

Similar wording

We believe that using the property as a business is consistent with the uses on this block.

Similar wording

Accordingly, we have no objections.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Calendar number 39878, 604 South Main Street.

Similar wording

My vote is yes.

Similar wording

My vote is yes.

Similar wording

My vote is yes.

Similar wording

My vote is yes.

Similar wording

My vote is yes.

Similar wording

thank you thank you thank you all good luck to you um thanks any any unfinished business tanya

Similar wording

and or sharon not on my end chair not on mine either okay then we'll see everybody back at

Similar wording

two o'clock yes have a good one all right thank you and good afternoon everyone my name is frank

Similar wording

Chico I am the chair of the Zoning Board of Adjustment. I will be participating in

Similar wording

today's hearing along with with our Vice Chair Ms. Carol Tenere, Board

Similar wording

Secretary Confessor Plaza and board members Mr. Thomas Holloman and Mr.

Similar wording

James Snell. Board Administrator Tanya Sunkit and Board

Similar wording

Attorney Chanceleta are also in attendance. For those of you who haven't

Similar wording

yet participated in one of our virtual hearings, excuse me, for those of you who haven't yet

Similar wording

participated in one of our virtual hearings, I'll go through some basics of what you can expect.

Similar wording

First, we'll begin this afternoon's session by reading a list of cases to be continued.

Similar wording

If you believe any case announced is being continued in error, we will give you an opportunity

Similar wording

to respond. If they're reading the continuance list and receiving any feedback, we will then

Similar wording

take any additional continuance requests. Then once we've confirmed which hearings are being

Similar wording

continued, Vice Chair Carol Tenere will begin calling the remaining cases listed for this

Similar wording

session. When a case is called, we ask that attorneys representing applicants or other

Similar wording

interested parties in the matter identify themselves for the record. We will then hear

Similar wording

the appellant's presentation, followed by any participation by attorneys representing

Similar wording

other parties. Interested parties and members of the public not represented by counsel will

Similar wording

then be given an opportunity to testify. We will finally hear the recommendation of the

Similar wording

Planning Commission. At the hearing's conclusion, we will either vote the matter immediately

Similar wording

or hold it for discussion in executive session.

Similar wording

Any case held for discussion will be voted

Similar wording

at the next scheduled Wednesday morning session.

Similar wording

Please note the following changes related to the virtual format.

Similar wording

First, we will be administering oaths to individual participants

Similar wording

prior to their testimony.

Similar wording

Second, for the benefit of anyone participating by phone,

Similar wording

we ask that attorneys and witnesses identify themselves

Similar wording

prior to speaking or testifying. Third, we'd like to advise everyone that this proceeding is being

Similar wording

recorded and that by participating you acknowledge your agreement to be recorded. Fourth, for anyone

Similar wording

participating by phone, if you wish to testify, you must raise your hand by hitting star nine

Similar wording

and then star six to unmute yourself. I'll repeat, for anyone participating by phone,

Similar wording

If you wish to testify, you must raise your hand by hitting star nine and then star six to unmute yourself.

Similar wording

Finally, to enter an appearance statement, call Google 267-270-5548 and leave your email address and the address of the property at issue.

Similar wording

I'll repeat that also.

Similar wording

to enter an appearance statement call google 267-270-5548 and leave your email address

Similar wording

and the address of the property at issue with that said we can begin but before vice chair

Similar wording

tenere calls our first case we'd like to announce the following matters that are being continued

Similar wording

Calendar number 39079-650-East-Ontario-Street, calendar number MI2020-000765, 4815 Baltimore

Similar wording

Moore Avenue, MI2020-000774-3515 North 18th Street, and MI2020-0009405-3515.

Similar wording

2-0-2-0-0-0-9-4-4-1-9-5-9-Marshall Street.

Similar wording

Sharon, maybe, or Connie, you can clear it up.

Similar wording

I'm looking at the continuing sheet.

Similar wording

It doesn't go to item one.

Similar wording

It goes to item two, then goes to four, five, and then seven.

Similar wording

So one, three, and six aren't all my sheet.

Similar wording

Is that an accurate statement?

Similar wording

I'm not sure if Sharon is still not available, but on my slit sheet, I'm sorry, I have seven continuances on our combined summary sheet and continuance sheet.

Similar wording

Well, that's what I'm asking. I only had item two, four, five, and seven. So if there are the other three are to be continued, one of you, would one of you please read them into the record.

Similar wording

Okay. Calendar, am I on? Yes. Calendar number 39975350 Ogance Avenue. Calendar number 397081822 Benton Avenue and MI-2020-0008484457 Main Street.

Similar wording

Okay, thank you.

Similar wording

Sure.

Similar wording

Although for some reason it didn't come up on my sheet.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

For some reason I don't see our first attorney.

Similar wording

All right, before I get there though, I read the continuance list.

Similar wording

Is there anyone who believes the case may have been called in error for a continuance?

Similar wording

If so, please raise your hand.

Similar wording

And if anyone would like to request a continuance or withdrawal, please raise your hand at this time also.

Similar wording

I have Sloan Folks from the Councilperson's Office.

Similar wording

Sloan, you can unmute yourself and speak to the continuance.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, Chairman and ZPA Board.

Similar wording

I have a question regarding case number MI2020-000771, 2262 North 2nd Street.

Similar wording

That hasn't been requested for a continuous, but they haven't had a community meeting.

Similar wording

Is that going to be a hold in here or here and hold?

Similar wording

Has there been a request for that?

Similar wording

It's number four, Mr. Chairman.

Similar wording

Has Mr. Nothamson joined us yet?

Similar wording

No, I don't see him.

Similar wording

I can try to contact him, unusual for him not to be here.

Similar wording

Mr. Folks, would you mind if the board went on to the first case and then

Similar wording

Certainly ma'am, certainly. I don't want to hold the board up.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

We also have Cole Brodsky.

Similar wording

Cole, you can unmute yourself and speak to a continuance.

Similar wording

Hello, everyone.

Similar wording

Thank you for having me here.

Similar wording

Just like my correction, the name is Cole Brodsky.

Similar wording

And I believe my calendar number was stated correctly, but I heard the wrong address.

Similar wording

So I just wanted to confirm or deny whether or not it has been continued.

Similar wording

It is calendar number MI-2020-000944. Address is 1759 North Marshall Street.

Similar wording

That is correct. That was on our continuance list. Are you objecting to that?

Similar wording

No, sir. I believe you mispronounced the address at the time, so I wanted to confirm that it was continued.

Similar wording

Sorry about that, but thank you.

Similar wording

No problem.

Similar wording

any other requests for continuances or withdrawals or does anyone believe we

Similar wording

call the continuance in error

Similar wording

no other hands are up chair thank you uh carol calendar number three nine six nine four

Similar wording

6314 Wissahickon Street the pro se applicant is Brian Ames I do not have the refusal

Similar wording

strike that yes I do this is an application for proposing an addition to existing detached garage

Similar wording

for a family game room and future pool house this proposed use is refused for the following reasons

Similar wording

no more than one principal use is allowed per lot in rsd rs

Similar wording

No more than one principal use is allowed per lot in RSD, RSA, and RTA zoning districts.

Similar wording

The proposed family game room and pool house would constitute two uses on that lot.

Similar wording

Zoning is also refused because no more than one principal building is allowed per lot in RSD, RSA, and RTA zoning districts,

Similar wording

whereas this proposed family game room and pool house would constitute two buildings on the lot.

Similar wording

Brian Ames, you've been promoted to a panelist.

Similar wording

You can unmute yourself and you can share your screen as necessary.

Similar wording

Okay, can you hear me?

Similar wording

Yes, Mr. Ames, can you put your name and address on the record?

Similar wording

Sure, my name is Brian Ames. I'm the owner of 6314 Wissahickon Avenue.

Similar wording

Yeah. Okay. 9144. Okay. And can you, will you swear to, or affirm to tell the truth and nothing about the truth? Yes. Thank you. You may proceed.

Similar wording

um so my understanding is that uh the structure it's a it's a small modification to our existing

Similar wording

garage uh expanding it by 14 by 18 feet and i consider it to be a uh like a detached addition

Similar wording

so it's not an additional usage it's it's just for family it's for our family uh so it's not

Similar wording

doesn't really change and it's not an additional primary building it's really

Similar wording

in a detached addition does that make sense give plans yep all the plans are

Similar wording

here you want me to try to pull them up yeah if you could share that'd be helpful

Similar wording

I might need a little bit of a hand in doing that what do I do just how do I

Similar wording

share you suck it will direct you I'm sure okay so are you in the file is it

Similar wording

open on your screen I can open it right now so open your file and then you can

Similar wording

go to the bottom of your device and it should say share screen in green I'm on

Similar wording

computer mm-hmm so I have a PDF file right but in the zoom actually okay in

Similar wording

the zoom so when you're in the zoom it should be green share screen

Similar wording

I'm not seeing that so what are you looking at currently I see the zoom

Similar wording

screen i see the mute in the lower left corner okay so then take your mouse and hover over the

Similar wording

mute button yep and does any other buttons come out at the bottom participants uh select microphone

Similar wording

no all the way in the middle in the middle it says chat

Similar wording

raise hand and q a okay let me try to promote you again

Similar wording

okay i've promoted you to panelists

Similar wording

brian i've now promoted you to a panelist oh great might be something going on with uh

Similar wording

zoom fyi because alan knockinson having a problem getting into the system as well

Similar wording

uh can you hear me now yes and i'll try to see if you can share your screen i can now perfect

Similar wording

uh let's see here

Similar wording

so can you see that

Similar wording

yes we can okay the plans are coming right up just a moment please here we go

Similar wording

this is the plans so i don't know if you can you see my mouse

Similar wording