civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - October 7, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Oct 7, 20265h 59m

The three exits on the first floor and the one in the basement.

Similar wording

The fire escape.

Similar wording

All right, give me a moment.

Similar wording

I'm sorry.

Similar wording

How many children are you looking to have?

Similar wording

I'm not sure what I'm entitled to.

Similar wording

Right now my certificate says 10, so I'm pretty sure that's probably what I can have.

Similar wording

The entire structure will be geared for the daycare center.

Similar wording

The RCO is in favor of you, am I correct?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

okay all right why don't you tell us this this is the exit to the basement the basement

Similar wording

is almost finished that's just the stairway to the basement

Similar wording

that's the kitchen there's an exit right there next to the stove going to the backyard

Similar wording

that's the fire escape it should be finished this weekend just with the covering

Similar wording

from the second floor yes that's the egress there's the door all for the second floor

Similar wording

That's just the backyard. It's just been enclosed.

Similar wording

Again, that's that egress off of the second floor.

Similar wording

That's just the front of the property. I changed it. I colored it all over.

Similar wording

I'm just going for more of a professional look versus all of the pretty bright bright colors.

Similar wording

that's the first exit the second is on right under that egress and there's one in the backyard

Similar wording

how many bathrooms are there there's one and a half so i have a half on the first floor yes

Similar wording

i have a full on the first on the second does this change then oh sorry we're not

Similar wording

okay does this change the number of children that you can have on site based on the conversation we

Similar wording

had at your first hearing um prior to yeah just because i didn't have that egress on that second

Similar wording

floor they were not trying to hear it so you told me to go through license i did all that

Similar wording

good stuff is ready to be issued it's just waiting to hear what you guys have to say um yeah and

Similar wording

again i'm not sure what what i was initially told was 10 but since i have all of those as it i'm

Similar wording

not sure if they're going to revamp it, but I'll definitely find out. Do you know if 10 still

Similar wording

works with the number of bathrooms that you have? No, I don't.

Similar wording

I don't, but I will talk to DHS, yes. And then your plan is still to have

Similar wording

the food brought in, because I see you have a full kitchen,

Similar wording

but is that just for, like, staff? That's just for an emergency? Okay.

Similar wording

Yes. We'll provide food and things and snacks and things like that.

Similar wording

Are you guys making the snacks and the food on site? Are you

Similar wording

working with a service that's delivering them we will work with a service that'll be okay you are

Similar wording

any other questions

Similar wording

um questions or comments from our attorney i just wanted to clarify did you submit any

Similar wording

revised plans or floor plans or um initially when i um requested this yes the floor plans

Similar wording

were approved through l and i so it um i didn't need to revise the plan because it wasn't well

Similar wording

um I didn't need to revise the plan it wasn't well with the change in the um the second floor egress

Similar wording

with the change.

Similar wording

yes we sent them the last one okay did you submit that I just want to make sure the board reviews

Similar wording

everything that you wanted them to review because there were various continuations of this so you've

Similar wording

only showed them the photographs is there any plans you want to show them um the plans that I

Similar wording

initially had they were revised and I uploaded them to the folder to the portal I'm sorry okay

Similar wording

Did you want to? Yeah, can you show them?

Similar wording

Because my mic was on. You have the plans, Ian.

Similar wording

I'm going to try and find those. There's a lot of submissions. Just give me a minute.

Similar wording

But you did add to the exit out of the stairway. You've got the exit from the second floor.

Similar wording

Absolutely. And I actually have the plan as well if you need it.

Similar wording

Is this the door of the, where the fire escape is?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Just just not for nothing, but it looks like that door actually swings the wrong way.

Similar wording

It's a it's actually a right hand opening because when you come out, the fire snake is on the left side. So, um, according to L and I.

Similar wording

That's what they propose in terms of exiting.

Similar wording

That was a right hand door, so they accept they accepted it swinging in.

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

Interesting.

Similar wording

Yeah, and just follow them.

Similar wording

I, they usually they ask for you to have at least one door for exit that's like has a panic bar on it. Like from inside, you can push it as an emergency.

Similar wording

Yeah. So in case of an emergency, people can get out easily. They don't have to reach for doorknobs and things. And so the idea that this door opens in is not good. Is there an exit with the panic bar where the fire escape actually is?

Similar wording

No, this is it. That's why I asked the question. And the door swings in. That's why I asked the question. So there may be something that they'll have to deal with when the inspector comes, because that's...

Similar wording

State NL. Yeah. Fire code requirements. Yeah. I actually have an aspiring fire inspector that's supposed to come out in two weeks. So if they're requesting for me to add those additional things, I definitely do it. Right. Okay. Yeah. And they, um, so what age children?

Similar wording

It's 0 to 12, but if I'm allowed to have aftercare, once I correspond with DHS, and if they give me the okay, then I do, I, the basement is finished. The floor hasn't been done, but that will be for the older kids. When they come in, they can have that computer room.

Similar wording

Yeah. All right. Thank you.

Similar wording

i'm sorry for the delay that's that that's all right ian i think i think if she you

Similar wording

you flip through the photos i think i'm okay okay um any other questions

Similar wording

no hands at this time chair um questions from our attorney no questions at this time

Similar wording

questions or comments from the virtual audience no hands at this time um planning commission

Similar wording

thank you chairman and good morning david vecto with the city planning commission

Similar wording

chairman and board members the comprehensive plan recommends no change to the rsa5 residential

Similar wording

single-family zoning at this location there are no unique physical cert conditions or circumstances

Similar wording

of this property that would prevent it from being used in conformance with the zoning code

Similar wording

the city planning commission recommends that the board deny the request variance for a child care

Similar wording

center so number seven mi 2025 004 101 5944 cali hill street i vote yes with proviso certificate

Similar wording

of occupancy to be obtained johns my vote is yes with proviso cheryl gaston my vote is yes with

Similar wording

proviso ryan mcadams my vote is yes with proviso hi i win my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

thank you thank you for your time have a good day

Similar wording

all right number eight mi 2026 002 282 2208 north 29th street alan knockamson or alex goldberg

Similar wording

Mr. Goldberg is here.

Similar wording

did we have anything come in from the rco today with this

Similar wording

not from this one we came in for the next one okay i i unless council has something

Similar wording

it's the next one okay lehigh we did okay mr goldberg could you please state and spell your

Similar wording

name for the sonographer alex goldberg a-l-e-x g-o-l-d-b-e-r-g you swear or affirm to tell

Similar wording

the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth i do could you identify your client the relationship

Similar wording

to the property sure my client is making prosperity llc and its member deanna macon jones is sitting

Similar wording

to my left sure and our board secretary has a few questions for you uh good morning counsel

Similar wording

did you submit your documents and exhibits 14 days before this hearing i did and do you avoid

Similar wording

the reading of the refusal oh yeah refusal and stipulate to its accuracy i waive the reading

Similar wording

but we've um we're going to ask for proviso maximum two units today so i don't stipulate

Similar wording

to its accuracy all right thank you um then you can share your screen and begin your presentation

Similar wording

thank you okay so i'm sharing my screen um let's see if it comes up there we go uh this is an

Similar wording

enormous building structure it stretches the entire depth of the lot and width of the lot

Similar wording

almost and the lot is 110 feet deep so we have an enormous building structure here

Similar wording

my client originally was representing herself and represented herself at the rco meeting

Similar wording

um was asking for three units and i'm sure the board will ask questions about this after my

Similar wording

presentation but my understanding is that the meeting went pretty well there were neighbors

Similar wording

that said you know i'd be supportive of this if this was two units instead of three units

Similar wording

and that's what we did i tried reaching out to the coordinating rco i sent them the revised floor

Similar wording

plans showing the two units we haven't heard from them um we you know there are no changes

Similar wording

to the building structure because it's an existing structure we would ask the board to

Similar wording

vote today if they're so inclined um but again it sounds like we don't have a letter from the rco

Similar wording

so i don't know what their final position would be on this application maybe pastor williams will

Similar wording

be in the virtual audience and can opine about that. Okay, so here's the notice of refusal. Again,

Similar wording

originally three-family we would ask today for a proviso, among other things, for maximum two

Similar wording

units, and the only variance we're receiving, we're asking for today is for multifamily household

Similar wording

living in RSA 5. This is kind of a unique block, a mix of uses, a few duplexes, a mixed-use

Similar wording

property a couple churches a handful of single families and then a handful of vacant lots

Similar wording

not including our property um so kind of a mixed bag here uh and and again we you know we don't

Similar wording

think two units would be out of character and we think it's appropriate specific to this building

Similar wording

structure which has almost 3 000 square feet of gross floor area and was renovated prior to my

Similar wording

client's purchase of the property last year to include seven bedrooms um so we have uh you know

Similar wording

a placeholder here for the for the cdc's letter here's a zillow listing again my client purchased

Similar wording

the property this is how it was advertised when she purchased it in september of 2025

Similar wording

with seven bedrooms four bathrooms and 310 square feet of interior space you'll see the photos of

Similar wording

work that was done which i don't believe was with the benefit of permits so of course um to the

Similar wording

extent that any permits are necessary for the work that was done prior to her ownership we would

Similar wording

need to obtain a co and we accept that um and then the description is interesting here they

Similar wording

they sort of describe the property as renovated top to bottom um designed to be easily converted

Similar wording

into a duplex with city approval seems like this person did all the work and kind of made it someone

Similar wording

else's problem my client purchased it understanding that you know she may have she would have to go

Similar wording

through this process if she wanted to use it as a duplex which seven bedroom home would be tough

Similar wording

to rent as a single family because it is enormous and and you'll see the plans you know we have two

Similar wording

very spacious units that were recently renovated obviously l and i is going to have to agree that

Similar wording

it was the work was done properly and and we'll have to make changes if necessary um here's a

Similar wording

zoning map and a google map photographs so this is the front of the property it actually has a

Similar wording

breezeway to the left here that grants access to a side yard which is where we would agree to store

Similar wording

trash you'll see it's sort of like a little carve out on the side the benefit there is that

Similar wording

there's a lot of natural light running down the side of the property because that breezeway doesn't

Similar wording

there's a lot of natural light running down the side of the property because that breezeway doesn't

Similar wording

go all the way down so there's a bit of a side yard setback the building is also structured

Similar wording

where you have a two-story structure at the front then it drops down to a one-story structure and

Similar wording

then back up to a two-story structure so kind of like a little bit of a staircase the good you know

Similar wording

it's weird uh you have a bi-level unit in the back but the benefit there is that you have more

Similar wording

opportunity for windows and there's a lot of natural light in this property the notice posting

Similar wording

here's to the right of the property and the left you can see these churches that are next to us

Similar wording

across the street from each other there's a duplex right down there where my mouse is

Similar wording

interior photos so this is what the inside looks like you have a four bed two bath

Similar wording

and a two bed one bath so we we see it more appropriately being used as with six total

Similar wording

bedrooms instead of seven um plans and drawings this is a site plan so there here's this this

Similar wording

partial breezeway is right here where my mouse is hovering and then it's just open space all along

Similar wording

the side where we'll have trash storage and where you have again the benefit of a lot of natural

Similar wording

light and then this portion right here is where the building shrinks back down to a one-story

Similar wording

structure. And then in the back right here, it jumps back up to a two-story structure. And I'll

Similar wording

show you what that looks like on these floor plans. So let me zoom in right here. The pink

Similar wording

unit is the first floor. So you would enter in this common foyer, which is convenient for mail

Similar wording

and packages. If you go straight, you enter a hallway to the first unit, which is a four bed,

Similar wording

two bath you have a bathroom at the front and some storage you have a living space a very large

Similar wording

bedroom a laundry room moving back a kitchen a dining room and a bedroom there's also i'd point

Similar wording

out two in addition to the front entry point there's two side doors right here all this is

Similar wording

existing and then at the back of the building structure there's a an additional two bedrooms

Similar wording

in that sort of rear two-story portion.

Similar wording

So this unit is a little over 1,800 square feet.

Similar wording

It's enormous.

Similar wording

And then going back to the front, you have a hallway.

Similar wording

Again, this foyer, you go up the stairs,

Similar wording

and then you have a large two-bed, one-bath

Similar wording

that has a big bedroom at the front of the property,

Similar wording

in-unit laundry, bathroom, and then a bedroom at the rear.

Similar wording

and again like i mentioned because of this first floor portion here you you have some nice

Similar wording

extra natural light that's coming into these these bedrooms for these two units

Similar wording

my client's going to self-manage the property it's currently vacant she hasn't had anyone live

Similar wording

there since she purchased it part of the reason why you know if the board is inclined to approve

Similar wording

the variance we would ask them to vote today because it costs money to have an empty property

Similar wording

And, you know, we'd like to delay any further or we'd like to avoid any further delays.

Similar wording

And sort of that's that's the conclusion of my presentation.

Similar wording

At this point, I'd like to call Deanna to adopt my testimony.

Similar wording

Hi, could you get close to the mic?

Similar wording

Could you please state and spell your name for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Deanna Macon Jones, D-E-A-N-N-A, Macon, M-A-C-O-N hyphen Jones, J-O-N-E-S.

Similar wording

do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth yes counsel

Similar wording

deanna did you hear my testimony today yeah was it true and correct yeah and do you adopt it as

Similar wording

your own yes thank you questions from the board yes i have a question about the property running

Similar wording

the full length of the the building structure do we know how long that has been the case so good

Similar wording

question i looked back on atlas you know the aerial images 1996 is a little foggy because

Similar wording

there's a tree that's overhanging the property but it looks to me like it as far back as then

Similar wording

and the city's mapping system recognizes that the building structure is the shape that it is just

Similar wording

i feel like this is just speaking from my experience if you have an illegal addition

Similar wording

it doesn't show up on the mapping system that could be untrue i don't know but it's been there

Similar wording

for i would say at least 30 years okay um and then my second question is are you opposed to

Similar wording

proviso for interior trash storage because while i understand there's a breezeway with the two

Similar wording

entrances down that side it's only three feet wide sure and that if the bins are obstructing

Similar wording

the walkway the people won't be able to actually use the two side doors that were outlined on them

Similar wording

is that something you'd be okay with yeah you still have enough space yeah so all the questions

Similar wording

I'm sorry. Can I see the floor plan?

Similar wording

can we do the floor plan of course please

Similar wording

Of course.

Similar wording

Please.

Similar wording

i know what you're about to say they're they're large they're they're large units but they're

Similar wording

very poorly laid out exactly yeah listen that that's that's what i said here strange it is

Similar wording

i'm not gonna lie he said weird yeah there there are some funky things here um i don't think it's

Similar wording

way that deanna would have designed the layout if she was starting from scratch maybe there's

Similar wording

an opportunity to move some things but um board member gaston i'm curious what caught your eye

Similar wording

bathrooms well bathrooms of course yeah yeah i i got that you know that's my little pet peeve you

Similar wording

know you shouldn't have to wander through wherever but well well in this wait wait a minute in this

Similar wording

case you're going to have to wander from the second floor rear all the way to the front of the front

Similar wording

of the unit to go to the bathroom to a bathroom yeah i mean that you could use the one in the

Similar wording

kitchen well one of the back yeah there's two bedrooms in that downstairs you know it is odd

Similar wording

you know right um right and the and the and the bedrooms are like tiny and i don't understand

Similar wording