civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - September 30, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Sep 30, 20266h 10m

Michael Johns, my vote is yes with Proviso.

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston, my vote is yes with Proviso.

Similar wording

tanetta graham my vote is yes with proviso ryan mcadams my vote is yes with proviso tyowin my

Similar wording

vote is yes with proviso rayla bibi my vote is yes with proviso and number seven mi2025

Similar wording

007 578 1537 north franklin street i vote yes michael johns my vote is yes cheryl gaston my

Similar wording

vote is yes tanetta graham my vote is yes ryan mcadams my vote is yes hi when my vote is yes

Similar wording

Laila Beebe, my vote is yes. Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you so much. Thank you so much.

Similar wording

I just want to say it's so interesting.

Similar wording

I did the Hope 6 for PHA in Ludlow

Similar wording

and those other houses that have the garages were ours.

Similar wording

And so it's interesting, years, years later,

Similar wording

we couldn't get people to move in that neighborhood.

Similar wording

And now it's just so different. It's just so changed.

Similar wording

i i live here since i live here since 2008 and i love this neighborhood that's why i'm

Similar wording

yes we literally had to convince people to move there yeah that's how the city progress

Similar wording

right there you go which is great thank you so much i thank you number eight mi2026

Similar wording

6-0-0-3-0-1-2-24-20 East Somerset Street, Mary Ann Finger is Fingal, Fingan, is the

Similar wording

council.

Similar wording

Mary Ann Hujan Finnegan, M-A-R-Y-A-N-N-E-H-U-H-A-F-I-N-I-G-A-N.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, I do.

Similar wording

could you identify your client a relationship to the property my client is the owner of the

Similar wording

property kazim nabavi he's present here okay in the back yep um our vice chair uh has a few

Similar wording

questions good afternoon have you submitted your documents and exhibits 14 days in advance of this

Similar wording

hearing yes i have okay and do you waive the reading of your refusals to stipulate to their

Similar wording

accuracy yes okay okay all right thank you you can see your screen before you before you start

Similar wording

there is a letter of support from the southport richmond civic association the vote was 16 and

Similar wording

two in opposition and there's also non-opposition from council member squillman yes that's correct

Similar wording

your honor start your presentation yes at this time i'd like to introduce my co-counsel an attorney

Similar wording

philip g italiano who's also entered his appearance and he's going to present our case okay could you

Similar wording

please state your name and spell for the stenographer philip with one l last name italiano

Similar wording

i-t-a-l-i-a-n-o do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

yes i do do you have a computers we do not we had it in previously asked for assistance with

Similar wording

it now are you are you ready yes sir it's displayed now okay thank you i understand we have all your

Similar wording

paperwork so what i would try to do is concentrate on your plans and photos yes sir all right well

Similar wording

what i'd like to tell the board today is what we propose who we are the history of the property

Similar wording

how the neighborhood views our proposed use and the character of the current use of the neighborhood

Similar wording

first who we are to my left we have the property owner chasm nabavi a resident of port richmond

Similar wording

since 1965. Kaz is a fixture in local community in the business and civic scene. He lives directly

Similar wording

across from the subject property, probably closer from where I'm sitting to the hallway.

Similar wording

There you go. Okay. Next is Ali Nabava, Kaz's son, also a Port Richmond resident. He represents the

Similar wording

next generation, if you will, committed to strengthening and growing the community and

Similar wording

adding to the richness of Port Richmond's shared urban experience. And finally, we have Valdemar

Similar wording

Strajusku. He's not here today. He's our chef who learned his trade in the world-renowned kitchens

Similar wording

of Georges Perrier, and he's excited to be bringing to Port Richmond our blend of fine dining,

Similar wording

and he's excited to be bringing to port richmond our blend of fine dining and as he describes it

Similar wording

and as he described

Similar wording

some new takes on some old favorites what we propose is a unique locally sourced locally

Similar wording

staffed dine-in takeout restaurant featuring special cuisine and some local favorite dishes

Similar wording

seating for approximately 40 guests this will be exhibit a6 page 13 showing the seating operations

Similar wording

would be from 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. five days a week close monday and tuesday it would be be worthwhile

Similar wording

if we could look at the ian could you bring up the photos of the property of what it looks like and

Similar wording

then maybe where we're going to go with it right because you're going to design yes right okay well

Similar wording

what you can see on the screen now is the side of the property the side yard where the ada access

Similar wording

ramp will be and the adjacent property which as you can see here it also illustrates the ample all

Similar wording

street parking in the neighborhood it also demonstrates the to the immediate west is the

Similar wording

tire center actually owned by mr nabavi showing the mixed residential and commercial use of the

Similar wording

neighborhood and again a demonstration of the ample all street parking and where the location

Similar wording

is at the end of the block right before the tire center okay now if i could that's the

Similar wording

block there that's the that's the rear of the property which by the way when we're talking

Similar wording

about mixed use this could arguably be industrial directly behind this yard and all the backyards

Similar wording

on this block of somerset are the operating tracks for freight freight trains that go by

Similar wording

as part of the railroad that's been there since probably the beginning of the last century

Similar wording

right if i made the history of this property unless we'd like to look at this this is more

Similar wording

of the side yard all of which will be cleared out and the ada ramp will be installed there

Similar wording

okay all righty now exhibit a11 which we had submitted with some 40 pages in length but let

Similar wording

me just summarize it three parts here in 1951 this property was acquired by the tetsy reitz

Similar wording

foreign war veterans home association and for some 29 years they operated as vfw post 250.

Similar wording

it was approved by the board as a private club for that time and then in 1980 it was acquired

Similar wording

by the polish police association of philadelphia they held it for another 36 years with similar

Similar wording

use as a social and gathering hall with various use and various expansions approved by the boards

Similar wording

over the decades the current owner mr nabavi acquired the property in 2016 that's exhibit a1

Similar wording

and in fact a use variance was approved by the board for takeout restaurant in 2019 a cheesesteak

Similar wording

shop i believe but the permit was allowed to elapse that's exhibit a12 page 7 showing the

Similar wording

grant of that residence so in short since at least 1951 or three quarters of the century

Similar wording

This property has never been or been used as a residence.

Similar wording

Now, as to how the community views us, we had our meeting with the RCO on August 12th of 2026, met with overwhelming and I may say enthusiastic approval.

Similar wording

You have the letter for Exhibit A3 showing the support of the RCO, the Southport Richmond Civic Association.

Similar wording

Councilman Squilla's letter shows his letter of non-opposition.

Similar wording

he of course is the councilman for this district since posting the property and that's exhibits

Similar wording

a4 pages 1114 showing the posting numerous neighbors have expressed approval including

Similar wording

our nearest next door neighbor who personally expressed her approval and support to cad uh

Similar wording

mr nabavi okay now i'd like to talk about the character of the neighborhood per the photographs

Similar wording

that we've already seen uh it demonstrates that this is a mixed use of residential and commercial

Similar wording

The immediate next-door neighbor is the tire center, which Mr. Nabavi has operated since 1977. Before that, it was apparently a car wash and used car lot. And, as I mentioned, the railroad, which indicates the even arguably industrial use. And the next main street to the west is Aramingo Avenue, which is, of course, a major commercial thoroughfare.

Similar wording

Now, if we may, I'd like the board to hear from the owner, Mr. Nabavi.

Similar wording

Why don't you show what you think it's going to look like?

Similar wording

Okay, if we can go to exhibit a 6, yes, we have the drawings on do that. I think. Okay. You should probably say, hey, this is what we're going to do. And you're not changing a lot. But no, if we go to a 6 people where the seats aren't there.

Similar wording

Okay, are we in a 6? Excuse me. Maybe you try to just make that a little bit. All right.

Similar wording

All right, and this this shows the, uh, the seating plan on the 1st floor.

Similar wording

as you can see there the tables this is where the servers would be the second the proposed

Similar wording

seating on the second floor the basement for storage and for the utilities basement storage

Similar wording

yes second floor is what that's the additional restroom and

Similar wording

Yes. Second floor is what? That's the additional restroom and propose. If there's overflow seating, the main seating is the first floor. Tell me this will be a sit down restaurant. Yes. Okay. And what kind of like, I mean, just food in general or? Yes. As I had mentioned before, it's a trying to bring a kind of unique dining experience to Port Richmond. Okay. Sure.

Similar wording

so some some wonderful food in fact when i was at the rco and the chef testified

Similar wording

i wanted to make a reservation that night they didn't take it yeah i didn't have a tie at the

Similar wording

time all right okay and if i may can you scroll so that we can see the kitchen please it's a sit

Similar wording

down and take out you're asking i'm sorry did i not say that i apologize go back and show the kitchen

Similar wording

Yes. Okay, so this is our kitchen showing where the service, the food prep stations are the sanitation as well as the main cooking stations at the rear of the property.

Similar wording

If we want to scroll forward, we can see you think you'll vent to right? Yes, everything will be properly vented. Yes, exactly.

Similar wording

all right and then you can see on the second floor the overflow seating if that becomes

Similar wording

necessary and the um and the additional restroom upstairs as well as some additional storage

Similar wording

okay all right okay if i may i'd like to call mr bobby yeah sure okay why don't you get close

Similar wording

to the mic if you can sir all right yeah just state your name and spell it for the stenographer

Similar wording

K-A-Z-E-M, that's a K-A-Z-E-M, last name is N-A-B-A-V-I-A.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

You do? Okay. You said I do?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

All right. Counsel? Mr. Nabavi, you heard and saw everything about which I testified before the

Similar wording

zoning board this afternoon. Did you not? Okay. Is everything? Yes, sir. Okay. Yes, sir. Is everything

Similar wording

I said all true and correct? Yes. Mr. Nabavi, do you now adopt all of that as your testimony to

Similar wording

the board yes mr bobby how long have you lived in the neighborhood it's 1965 i don't know how long

Similar wording

about 60 years how long have you operated kaz's tire center

Similar wording

last 50 okay 50 actually june 15 1977. okay and as the owner of 2420 east somerset can you verify

Similar wording

that this property has never been used as a residence since you've owned it and since you

Similar wording

have lived in the neighborhood oh it has not been used it has not been used as a residence

Similar wording

is that correct yes thank you all right all right all right uh i have mr nabavi's son ali to be

Similar wording

sworn in sure questions there with the board's permission as the younger mr bobby is a physician

Similar wording

and to avoid confusion the record may i address him as dr nabavi you can whatever you want to do

Similar wording

okay council could you please uh council please state and spell your name for the stenographer

Similar wording

Good afternoon.

Similar wording

It's Ali Nabavi, A-L-I-N-A-B-A-V-I.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Counsel?

Similar wording

Dr. Nabavi, you've had extensive interaction with the architect.

Similar wording

You're familiar with the electrical, plumbing, mechanical drawings that we put up on the screen?

Similar wording

I am.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Now, you know our proposed use of the building is overall takeout, dine-in, and I did walk the board through the proposed use of each floor.

Similar wording

Is what I said correct and true?

Similar wording

Everything's correct. I do want to add the ventilation.

Similar wording

I just wanted to correct everything else was correct that the ventilation would be through

Similar wording

the back as opposed to up through the roof. Just to clarify that.

Similar wording

Okay. Dr. Mbavi, is there any roof deck or roof access plan here?

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

Okay. And did everything I say about the use of each floor, was that all correct and true?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

That's all I have.

Similar wording

Question on the board.

Similar wording

Real quick question.

Similar wording

So there was space on the side of the building.

Similar wording

You said that was for the ADA accessible ramp.

Similar wording

Is there any plan for outdoor seating?

Similar wording

Or is this not enough room?

Similar wording

i don't know they have it yet yeah something you might think about but not now if we can do it we

Similar wording

I don't know they have it yet.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

Something you might think about, but not now.

Similar wording

If we can do it.

Similar wording

all happily do it and if we need to apply for a variance then we will you might need to apply for

Similar wording

a variant most likely so it's not included in these plans just so you know okay okay thank you

Similar wording

all the questions i have a question about storage just because it doesn't seem to be specifically

Similar wording

listed in the kitchen or the basement and like where are you planning to store your dry goods

Similar wording

and have deliveries uh dry goods and deliveries you know obviously we'll have refrigeration in

Similar wording

the in the kitchen so some of that will be in there um i believe on dry goods aren't in the

Similar wording

fridge which is correct uh some of that will be in the basement uh any shelving units in the kitchen

Similar wording

and then we also have plans uh you can see on the proposed first floor plan in the backyard there

Similar wording

there is space for a uh a walk-in uh refrigeration unit and you know a rugged storage that's not

Similar wording

existing correct got it okay and then are you planning to have take out services like uber

Similar wording

eats deliver uh doordash and grubhub we do what's going to be the plan to sort of manage pickup for

Similar wording

that um as far as just like some places have a dedicated door some places have a dedicated table

Similar wording

um the way that your first floor is laid out there's not necessarily like a maitre d stand

Similar wording

in the front so like how are you what's going to be the plan to have them because sometimes

Similar wording

they have to wait yeah we don't we don't have a fixed space for that but it would either be

Similar wording

through the side door there through the uh ada access they can come in or through the front

Similar wording

uh and then we'll you know make space for as much as we need hopefully we're too busy to turn the

Similar wording

apps on it's okay questions more attorney um wait a minute oh go ahead i'm sorry um you said that

Similar wording

you were gonna have a uh freezer say in the back it's like a standalone unit is that what you said

Similar wording

uh i believe i believe that's included on the plans there uh you can uh on the uh and you asked

Similar wording

for you asked for permission for that as part of this plan yes i think we did i think that's one

Similar wording

of two that's one of the proposed submitted plans that is on those plans uh on the mep plans uh there

Similar wording

okay well this is the floor plans not the map plans um yeah sorry right yeah but i mean showing

Similar wording

the floor plans yes all the plans were submitted including the electrical and the plumbing we can

Similar wording

go to that if we need to well i don't i'm not but usually like a standalone kind of unit like that

Similar wording

is considered a structure of some sort i think um so i was just submitted del and i yes

Similar wording

as part of your your site plan and your other plans yes it was submitted with with all the plans

Similar wording

that's correct okay okay all right thank you thank you thank you our attorney

Similar wording

you no question but i just want to put on the record that a missing refusal for multiple

Similar wording

principal uses um is missing for an rsa lot just it's nothing you need to do putting it on the

Similar wording

record questions or comments from the virtual audience there are no hands planning commission

Similar wording

good afternoon liz fuselay on behalf of the philadelphia planning commission the comprehensive

Similar wording

plan recommends no change to the RSA five residential single-family zoning at this location

Similar wording

prior approvals occurred in 2019 for a similar use as well as other use types over the past 50 years

Similar wording

there have been no recent clip or failed inspections at this location the city planning

Similar wording

commission recommends that the board grant the proposed use variants for sit down and take out

Similar wording

restaurant mi 2026 003012 2420 east somerset street i vote yes

Similar wording

so guest in my body chest yeah it's not a gram i recuse yes

Similar wording

ryan mcadams my vote is yes tyo in my vote is yes wait would be my vote is yes

Similar wording

but just to clarify is did board member board member john's vote or not no i'm i'm recusing

Similar wording

i'm recusing from this i didn't hear that sorry about that yep sorry about that i sent a text

Similar wording

i just realized okay thank you very much thank you thank you everyone thank you all right number nine

Similar wording

All right, number nine, MI 2026-003-065, 1640 Pine Street.

Similar wording

MI 2026-003-003.

Similar wording

Brandon Saverin is the attorney.

Similar wording

We have everything we need with this.

Similar wording

Brandon Saverin is coming in as a panelist.

Similar wording