civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - December 10, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Dec 10, 20256h 33m

than the pilot houses.

Similar wording

Now, grant you, you know,

Similar wording

our facade is going to appear higher

Similar wording

from the street level.

Similar wording

But when you step back

Similar wording

and you look at what's next door,

Similar wording

we're not really that much out of context.

Similar wording

And again, that's subject to interpretation, obviously.

Similar wording

uh remaining documents are the pro forma documents that you we typically see project

Similar wording

information indicating uh this document tax center no taxes are due sony map again you know we are in

Similar wording

rm1 district uh i think it's difficult to put a single family home on this lot never mind a

Similar wording

a duplex so i i don't i don't want to say it was an impossibility of performance but it really is

Similar wording

not a lot where you could put a multifamily.

Similar wording

Deed indicating ownership to the limited partnership.

Similar wording

Zoning notice out to

Similar wording

99 individuals.

Similar wording

And that's the presentation. So I have the client,

Similar wording

the clients that are occupying the property right now, as I say,

Similar wording

they're custom millwork. John Roderick is a

Similar wording

the general partner of the limited partnership

Similar wording

that owns the property.

Similar wording

He's worked in this building for a number of years

Similar wording

and he can give you a better description

Similar wording

of the interior than I can

Similar wording

if there's any questions about that steel beam

Similar wording

and why is the height so much?

Similar wording

We have 14 feet on the first floor

Similar wording

so we're already starting at a high level

Similar wording

and to get ample bedrooms in the property

Similar wording

necessitated us doing what we did

Similar wording

and to share this presentation with you.

Similar wording

So, Mr. Roderick, can you unmute yourself and jump on this call?

Similar wording

So Mr. Roderick, can you unmute yourself and jump on this call?

Similar wording

Hi, President here.

Similar wording

Hi, Mr. Roderick.

Similar wording

How are you, sir?

Similar wording

Could you please state your name as Belfort, a stenographer?

Similar wording

John Roderick, J-O-H-N, Roderick, R-O-D-E-R-I-C-K.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, sir?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Counsel?

Similar wording

Hey, John.

Similar wording

Good evening.

Similar wording

John, you were on the call, the entire call, when I presented your project, correct?

Similar wording

Correct.

Similar wording

And if you had a chance to testify, would you adopt my testimony as your own and as shown correct?

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

John, can you tell the board what you're using and have used this property for over any amount of years you've used it for?

Similar wording

Yeah, for almost 10 years, I've been doing custom woodwork out of there.

Similar wording

It's also been storage for a general contractor as well.

Similar wording

So we've been utilizing the space for just about 10 years now.

Similar wording

John, I mentioned this beam a couple of times.

Similar wording

Can you tell me what this building used to be used for and why there's such a heavy structural aspect to it?

Similar wording

Our best guess was maybe an auto repair shop of some sort.

Similar wording

We had a phase one environmental done, which turned up nothing significant.

Similar wording

but overhead right where the lintel for the overhead garage door is about 12 inches up from

Similar wording

that is the underside of a large I-beam which carries across the span and there's two of those

Similar wording

in the building and they're about 16 inches high so the parapet the very front of the front facade

Similar wording

that parapet wall is actually quite quite short to where the roof is

Similar wording

um so for us to start our um first floor uh it's it's actually not much lower than the extent of

Similar wording

the front facade you see there is there are there any comments or explanations you want to make with

Similar wording

regards to the renderings or do you think it was explained adequately i think you did a great job

Similar wording

I MEAN IT'S A VERY INTERESTING LOT SORT OF FULL OF DESIGN CHALLENGES I THINK YOU DID AN ADEQUATE

Similar wording

JOB OF EXPLAINING HOW WE'RE TRYING TO INCORPORATE MAKING A SINGLE FAMILY HOMEWORK HERE THANK YOU JOHN

Similar wording

QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD YES SO CURRENTLY THE STRUCTURE IS THE ENTIRE FOOTPRINT OF THE LOT

Similar wording

correct okay so the door at the rear what is it exiting to right uh that was one of the first

Similar wording

questions i asked when when i came upon this project john i'll go to an aerial photograph

Similar wording

john but you can you can speak to that i mean i understand what is there i actually lived around

Similar wording

the corner from there for 10 years so i know the physicality but like legally you're currently

Similar wording

showing an exit onto a property you don't own. Right. And that was existing. So, John, you've

Similar wording

actually, you know, if you want to go out and get some air, you actually use it. But when the time

Similar wording

comes for construction, you're probably going to have to close that up. Correct. Yeah, that's our

Similar wording

understanding. And we reached out, we tried to reach out. Our understanding is that the row home

Similar wording

with frontage on 15th street uh is the now rightful owner um but it was kind of confusing

Similar wording

for a while when sister mary scullion did the the uh development to the rear like it seemed possibly

Similar wording

that it was deeded to project home at one point so i had reached out prior to her passing um and

Similar wording

then they sort of said like we don't have any record that it's ours so that was the extent of

Similar wording

she's still alive oh she oh i'm so sorry yeah i was talking to her the other night i said oh my

Similar wording

god she came back to be honest it's it's getting late and i hear my kids screaming in the background

Similar wording

but i i'm so sorry i mean may she live long i think she retired is what she did yeah yeah i

Similar wording

think you're right that yes she she retired in a professional sense not in a different type of

Similar wording

that okay i'm sorry i mean i think like my main comment i i think you know i think the like

Similar wording

footprint all the refusals make sense to me for the but this is a it's a lot of height and it's

Similar wording

a very tight and compact space and i'm wondering with those single stairwell what's your what's

Similar wording

the plan if you know to get people off the fourth floor you don't have a lot of space there and then

Similar wording

And I think my second question for you is really about trash storage.

Similar wording

Yeah, I think I think our plan for trash is likely it would be in the garage and it would be wheeled out.

Similar wording

As far as egress, I mean, we haven't put any thought yet into any additional considerations aside from.

Similar wording

We haven't put any thought yet into any additional considerations aside from, you know, co-degress, but it is, there's a lot of verticality there for sure.

Similar wording

So.

Similar wording

There's a lot of verticality and there's a lot of luxury amenities.

Similar wording

There's a lot of like outdoor spaces that don't address sort of trash and laundry.

Similar wording

Is there a laundry unit in here?

Similar wording

Yeah, there's laundry.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

um yeah there's laundry in a drop zone for laundry okay right there's washer dryer and

Similar wording

off the hall there okay and this one i would argue you know by having so many open areas

Similar wording

roof decks and porches that you know if there is a situation i mean it certainly would be easy

Similar wording

easier to access for all the inhabitants and and or you know a fire ladder if that ever became

Similar wording

you know situation but i understand your point but just wanted to understand what the plan was

Similar wording

for the people that are going to live here okay thank you the questions no i think overall for a

Similar wording

tight lot i think you came up with a decent enough plan i mean it's a to put anything on that site

Similar wording

is pretty difficult and to sort of make a a single family dwelling uh work and get those outdoor

Similar wording

spaces, I think

Similar wording

is commendable for

Similar wording

this tight space. Although you still

Similar wording

throw that door out to the lot

Similar wording

that's not owned, but

Similar wording

you've got to deal with that

Similar wording

on the ground level. Yes.

Similar wording

Thank you. I think

Similar wording

the height does not look bad when you compare

Similar wording

the duplexes to the height.

Similar wording

It just really blends in nice.

Similar wording

Okay, other questions from the board?

Similar wording

Questions from our attorney, Hillary

Similar wording

Emerson. Not at this time,

Similar wording

Mr. Chair. Is there comments from the virtual audience?

Similar wording

I see no hands, Chair.

Similar wording

Planning Commission. Michael Gall with the Philadelphia City Planning Commission.

Similar wording

The comprehensive plan recommended no change to the former CMX2 commercial mixed-use zoning at

Similar wording

this location. In 2018, the parcel was intentionally remapped from CMX2 to RM1,

Similar wording

residential multifamily proposed rear yard depth reflects the existing conditions the appellant

Similar wording

has not demonstrated that there are unique physical circumstances or conditions of the

Similar wording

property that would prevent it from being used in conformance with the roof deck setback

Similar wording

requirements of the zoning code the city planning commission therefore recommends that the board

Similar wording

grant the requested variance for rear yard depth but recommend the board deny the requested variance

Similar wording

for roof deck setback okay thank you um mi 2025 002 448 1506 cambridge street i vote yes with

Similar wording

proviso revised plans one page stamp icba on december 10th 2025 michael johns my vote is yes

Similar wording

with proviso cheryl gaston my vote is yes with proviso tenetta graham my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

I am McAdams. My vote is yes with Proviso.

Similar wording

I am Wayne. My vote is yes with Proviso.

Similar wording

Thank you, counsel. That's

Similar wording

four in a row we did with you today.

Similar wording

Thank you very much. I really appreciate it.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Is there anyone in the

Similar wording

audience whose

Similar wording

330 case has not been called?

Similar wording

I see no handshare.

Similar wording

Thanks, everybody. Great deal of work

Similar wording

and we're done almost an hour

Similar wording

earlier than we were last week, if anybody's

Similar wording

interested. Thank you.

Similar wording

thank you take care good night all good night

Similar wording