civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - November 4, 2020

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Nov 4, 20207h 39m

Can you see that screen that I'm sharing now?

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Let me see if I can.

Similar wording

How do I share it?

Similar wording

Zoom.

Similar wording

Zoom.

Similar wording

Hang that back up.

Similar wording

Okay, here we go.

Similar wording

Okay, now are you seeing that?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Sorry about that.

Similar wording

I'm technically challenged.

Similar wording

And I even have help here today.

Similar wording

You're talking to the right guy.

Similar wording

So you'll have mercy on me.

Similar wording

So this is the exhibit pack that we had actually submitted back on February 12th.

Similar wording

So it has a lot of information, our application refusal, the plans at the time.

Similar wording

So that's part of the deal today as well.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay, our second exhibit pack is actually an exhibit binder that we've prepared specifically for the 1122 Oak Lane parcel for today's hearing.

Similar wording

Okay, this lists our witnesses.

Similar wording

We have the amended refusal I mentioned a minute ago.

Similar wording

We have the ZBA's revised proviso plans form, the RCO notice letter that we sent out, some posting photos.

Similar wording

The revised plan is at tab six.

Similar wording

We have a revised facade rendering.

Similar wording

also a key piece is that we did a traffic and parking study um so i have a witness who will

Similar wording

testify to the results of that traffic and and parking study and the last thing that i wanted to

Similar wording

point out in addition to the tax clearance certificate is that we now have a that we added

Similar wording

the uh hearing transcript from the february 12th 2020 hearing to the packet so you'll have that

Similar wording

at your convenience. The third exhibit pack looks like this, and Ms. Saletta I think should have

Similar wording

this one as well. And this is basically a packet of exhibits that Mr. Morgan pulled together. There

Similar wording

was an effort by the church and by Mr. Morgan to obtain support, indications of support from the

Similar wording

community. So this has a whole lot of, there's letters, there's emails, there's petitions in

Similar wording

here all of which support the property and then our last exhibit packet is is our zoning hearing

Similar wording

binder number four and this relates to the 1100 oak lane property again our same witnesses we have

Similar wording

the review refusal for that property we had a notice letter that went out to the rco we had a

Similar wording

meeting with the RCO. There are some posting photos and the plan for 1100, which is essentially

Similar wording

The plan for 1100, which is essentially the same, it's just focused on that property,

Similar wording

the same. It's just focused on that property.

Similar wording

except instead of the 1122 property, is there.

Similar wording

And again, our tax clearance certificate for that parcel.

Similar wording

So those are our exhibits that we have today.

Similar wording

And we're going to sort of jump back and forth between some of them as we go.

Similar wording

Just some additional key facts before I call Mr. Morgan as my first witness.

Similar wording

Or excuse me, the pastor, I'm going to call the pastor first.

Similar wording

Again, the church is located at 1100 Oak Lane.

Similar wording

It's at 11th and Oak Lane, right at the corner.

Similar wording

The development parcel is immediately adjacent, and that's at the corner of 12th and Oak Lane.

Similar wording

So they take up that whole block there.

Similar wording

From February, you may recall that we're proposing on the 1122 parcel to construct a 40-unit affordable housing complex for seniors.

Similar wording

Do you have visuals for us?

Similar wording

I do. I'll get to those in a minute.

Similar wording

I'm just giving you background, and I'm going to have the pastor testify, and then Mr. Morgan, and that's when we'll get your visuals.

Similar wording

It's to be constructed with financing from the Federal Low Income Housing Tax Credit Program.

Similar wording

The deadline for that application is early 2021, so we're anxious to move this forward today, if at all possible.

Similar wording

The city has indicated support for the project in addition to the support from the Councilwoman's Office.

Similar wording

The city last year committed $2 million in home funds for the project.

Similar wording

That has expired because we didn't get the approval, but we do intend to reapply for those home funds.

Similar wording

This will be a total of total project costs will be about $15 million.

Similar wording

We'll create two to three hundred temporary jobs.

Similar wording

So we believe it'll be a significant financial benefit to this neighborhood and to the city.

Similar wording

OK, so my first witness, I'd like to call Pastor Richardson, and he will just give you a brief background on his time in the neighborhood and his vision for this property.

Similar wording

Because this application, this effort really did flow out of his long-time vision for the property.

Similar wording

So could we admit or promote Pastor Richardson?

Similar wording

You should see him on the screen there somewhere.

Similar wording

He would have to raise his hand.

Similar wording

Pastor Richardson, could you raise your hand, please?

Similar wording

I have Janine.

Similar wording

Okay. That should be it. Promote Janine. I think the pastor is with Janine.

Similar wording

They can unmute themselves.

Similar wording

And pastor, are you under Janine Owens?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

I'm sure you can swear him in.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, pastor. Please identify yourself with the record. Spell your first and last name.

Similar wording

Wilbert Richardson, W-I-L-B-E-R-T-R-I-C-H-A-R-D-S-O-N.

Similar wording

And do you swear and affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Thank you, sir.

Similar wording

Okay, good afternoon, Pastor.

Similar wording

This is Bill Kerr.

Similar wording

Were you on the call, and did you hear my statements over the past few minutes regarding this project?

Similar wording

Yes, I did.

Similar wording

And were they accurate to your knowledge?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And do you adopt them as your own testimony?

Similar wording

Yes, I do.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

What we'd like you to do is just give the board a little bit of background on your time in this neighborhood and your genesis of this project.

Similar wording

Yes, thank you very much.

Similar wording

Chairman Frank DiCicco, and if it please, the members of the ZBA board, I covered just a few moments of your time, as stated, and I firmly rest on the letter.

Similar wording

we did send a letter, I did send a letter of my statement of my commitment to our program.

Similar wording

As I said, my name is Wilbert Richardson, pastor of the Refugee Evangelical Baptist Church

Similar wording

located at 1100 Oak Lane Avenue. I have lived and ministered in our neighborhood for the past 40

Similar wording

years. Seniors in East Oak Lane are in need of housing in this community. It is my goal and our

Similar wording

goal of the ministry to ensure that we can provide this community with safe quality and affordable

Similar wording

housing what have driven us and what have been our passion is 38 words of our mission statement

Similar wording

and i'll just quote them very quickly commit to service the tribe clans and families of refugee

Similar wording

evangelical baptist church through its internal and outreach ministries meeting needs and achieving

Similar wording

reconciliation i'll repeat that meeting needs and achieving reconciliation in our community

Similar wording

by loving god loving our neighbors and making disciples along the way we have since the very

Similar wording

beginning of our church existed to encourage and engage our community in cross-cultural

Similar wording

ministry, socially, economically, and spiritually.

Similar wording

We have moved our ministry.

Similar wording

We have started our ministry in 12th, 641 North 12th Street.

Similar wording

Started our ministry in 12th, 641 North 12th Street.

Similar wording

We later moved to 1220 Oak Lane Avenue across from Elwood School, which is east of the property that we're speaking of.

Similar wording

And right next to our 1220 Oak Lane rental property that we had there was a firehouse.

Similar wording

And right next to the firehouse was a library.

Similar wording

And when we purchased the Ronald Roof Nippon building, we were able to move our services currently, our ministry, to that location, 1100 Oak Lane Avenue.

Similar wording

After a dreadful fire that burned down the existing Ukrainian church in 2013, we were able to purchase a lot at 1100 Oak Lane, 1122 Oak Lane.

Similar wording

The initial use was turning the lot into a parking lot, which we did, and used for other church events.

Similar wording

And five years later, we were to erect a new building of housing complex.

Similar wording

Refugee Evangelical further engaged the help of Corniff Realty and LLC and BCM Affordable Housing.

Similar wording

We had initially had four different developers to come and to vet for the program that we had

Similar wording

in our vision. And we, after five to six weeks, we unanimously voted Cornish Realty LLC and BCM

Similar wording

Affordable Housing and found them to be credible in our way of stating a five-star developer.

Similar wording

We later had one of my close friends who had formerly used LLC and BCM, affordable housing in Jersey, and they came to a meeting and they referenced BCM and Cornish Realty as well.

Similar wording

And so we went into partnership with them.

Similar wording

We gave a brief presentation of our vision to our councilperson, Sherelle, the Honorable Sherelle Parker and her staff, who organized several community meetings, which included residents of East Oak Lane and the RCO.

Similar wording

We listened to them and heard their concerns and responded appropriately.

Similar wording

In closing, the 2,000 seniors in East Oak Lane are in need of seniors housing.

Similar wording

We would like to give them a choice.

Similar wording

When downsizing, we have large homes and large, wonderful, beautiful homes in East Oak Lane.

Similar wording

And the senior citizens there now, number 2,000.

Similar wording

And we would like to have given them a choice when they downsize and to stay in their community rather than having to move or live in some of the joining communities around.

Similar wording

And our commitment is to give them safe, quality, affordable housing in our own community.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you, Pastor.

Similar wording

Okay, that's all I have for the pastor.

Similar wording

if the uh the board has any questions uh i don't believe we do unless uh i don't know tom john uh

Similar wording

anyone no we're good mr chairman your bonnie yes thank you uh just again my name is paul bonnie

Similar wording

i'm an attorney and i represent the oak lane community action association who is a protestant

Similar wording

this matter and I also represent Yvette Young who is the next door neighbor to 1122 Oak Lane

Similar wording

in this matter and she's also a protestant. Before you begin Paul and let me interrupt

Similar wording

Mr. Kerr is there a way you can give us some visuals so because Mr. Bonney just raised an

Similar wording

issue about a adjoining neighbor and aerial shots or anything like that you can help us with.

Similar wording

This is where we'll have a better perspective.

Similar wording

Well, if you have any plan view, I'm happy to point out where McYoung lives.

Similar wording

Somebody, just give us some, the board.

Similar wording

Thank you very much.

Similar wording

Yeah, thank you.

Similar wording

So my second client is Yvette Young, and she lives in this house indicated at the bottom right-hand corner of this drawing that says single-family residential three-story.

Similar wording

Next to that to the left is the proposed senior apartment house. And above that is Pastor Richardson's existing church, the Refuge Evangelical Baptist Church.

Similar wording

uh existing church the refuge evangelical baptist church i believe i have the name correctly so

Similar wording

thank you i i appreciate it i just have a couple of questions for the pastor

Similar wording

um uh the first is that i think you mentioned this generally that um you your church moved to

Similar wording

1100 Oak Lane many years ago and I wanted to ask you if you were involved with that move.

Similar wording

1984-1985 we moved to 1220 Oak Lane Avenue that's right across the street from Elwood School

Similar wording

right next to the firehouse, which is right next to the library. We moved in 1985, and then

Similar wording

the building at 1100 became available. Ronald Bruce Nippon became available in 1992.

Similar wording

We moved from 1220 Oak Lane Avenue, which is east of the building, the lot that we're

Similar wording

speaking of now. We moved to 1100 Oak Lane Avenue. Thank you. Yes.

Similar wording

Let me understand the question.

Similar wording

Mr. Bonney, are you asking that the pastor, was he involved in the transaction of that or was it just his church?

Similar wording

Was he affiliated with the church at that time?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Yes, of course.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

And do you recall, Pastor Richardson, that at the time of 1992, when the church moved into 1100 Oak Lane, came to the Zoning Board of Adjustment to seek variances for the church and also for the seven parking spots?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay. Do you remember how many parking spots were required by code as compared to the seven

Similar wording

that you were allowed to have by variance?

Similar wording

No, I wasn't aware at the particular time because it was grandfathered in when we moved

Similar wording

to 1100 Oak Lane Avenue. So at the time that you're speaking of, we had seven parking spaces

Similar wording

that were, we have purchased along with the building.

Similar wording

Okay, that's your recollection?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay, thank you.

Similar wording

I guess it's safe to say that you were affiliated with the church,

Similar wording

you know, that you were the pastor there four years ago

Similar wording

when now we're talking about the subject property,

Similar wording

which is on the corner, which would be 1122 Oak Lane.

Similar wording

that the church came to this zoning board

Similar wording

and obtained a variance to use it as a parking lot.

Similar wording

I think you mentioned that generally.

Similar wording

So do you recall that generally?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And also that we said at that same time

Similar wording

that within the next three to five years,

Similar wording

we would be building on the property.

Similar wording

You're saying you told the zoning board that?

Similar wording

Yes, we did.

Similar wording

Were you at the zoning board hearing or did someone else from the church go there?

Similar wording

Both Ken Staley and I, who was representing us at this particular time as a PE,

Similar wording

we were both there at the time that they made the statement.

Similar wording

But he did the talking, not you. Is that correct?

Similar wording

Both he and I did the talking, but he initially stated that we would be,

Similar wording

and within three to five years, building a building on the lot after three to five years.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay. Well,

Similar wording

Mr. Chair, I'm wondering if I can share my screen.

Similar wording

There are some people talking in the background. I'm not sure if it's Mr. Kerr.

Similar wording

If you're talking, just put yourself on mute.

Similar wording

Okay, I apologize. I think I was not mute.

Similar wording

Yeah, no problem.

Similar wording

Mr. Bonney, you can now share your screen.

Similar wording

Okay, thank you. Thank you.

Similar wording

Okay, I'm getting the hang of this here. Share.

Similar wording