civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - October 28, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Oct 28, 20266h 49m

How many, how many bathrooms are in the home?

Similar wording

There's only one bathroom.

Similar wording

one for that is there a half bath somewhere or is that a do you intend to install a half bath

Similar wording

that is the intention yes okay and where would the what do you think the half bath will be installed

Similar wording

so um there's a couple of suggestions that i was given um i was given to place it where the front

Similar wording

office is take some of the space from the front office and put it there or they said i could take

Similar wording

some of the space from the kitchen i prefer the front office i want to keep the kitchen area

Similar wording

just a little more open, you know, just for community, you know, gatherings as, you know,

Similar wording

the youth eating, celebrations, different things like that. I really want to create a very home-like

Similar wording

atmosphere. I don't want it to feel like a shelter. I just want it to be somewhere where,

Similar wording

you know, kids can rest, ease their mind and focus on what needs to be moved forward to

Similar wording

to support them and whatever their better living situation could be or their home or family life.

Similar wording

okay and can you tell us what's going on with the basement so the basement is not finished

Similar wording

um but moving forward that is part of the ultimate goal is to finish the basement but um right now

Similar wording

it's in fine condition it's just unfinished okay so for right now you would use it for storage

Similar wording

right now it's going to be used for storage yes and and is there a rear yard um in the open space

Similar wording

There is a small rear yard. I'm not exactly sure what we are going to do with it because it is very small. I can't foresee what we could do with it other than just maintaining it. But it is a very small rear yard, maybe additional storage, a little shed or something back there.

Similar wording

Okay. And my last question is something that you kind of mentioned. Is this a temporary, like, uh, how, how long would the residents stay there? Cause you said something about a shelter. So yes, I didn't want it term stays or we will, I will, um, keep kids if until they age out, but the ultimate goal is to find permanent housing or family reunification.

Similar wording

However, if that's not, you know, happening, um, I will keep kids until they age out just

Similar wording

to continue to keep that, you know, support, um, home stability for home.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

You're welcome.

Similar wording

Other questions.

Similar wording

I have a question about staffing.

Similar wording

Um, and I don't know, did we see a photo of the office?

Similar wording

I did.

Similar wording

You want me to share it again?

Similar wording

Yes, please.

Similar wording

So the office.

Similar wording

Is my screen still sharing?

Similar wording

It is.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

so this is what will serve as the office is this their form the original living room the whole

Similar wording

space so no this um house was originally used um it was a rooming home like yeah yeah people

Similar wording

rented rooms um but when i took it over i wanted to do something different okay um so your staff

Similar wording

will be here how many staff do you plan to have on site so just based on the ratio i know i'm

Similar wording

going to have to have, um, my plan is two full-time, two part-time just so I can stagger

Similar wording

and have the site supervised 24 hours. Okay. And then are your staff going to be responsible

Similar wording

for all cooking? Yes, I will have a staff, have staff that is responsible for cooking,

Similar wording

maintaining meals, following whatever nutritional guidelines and safety requirements. Um, even if

Similar wording

that includes like safe, safe serve of some form, but yes. Okay. And then is there a sort of, I mean,

Similar wording

other than the kitchen area and it is a larger kitchen, is there any other sort of public area

Similar wording

that the youth could congregate in just to, you know, hang out? Yes. So that intake room is also

Similar wording

going to serve as an intake. If they have visitors, like family visitors, counselors,

Similar wording

or what have you, that intake room will be used for that as well. This room right here, that's

Similar wording

the office um no i have there's another room let me show you hold on my backwards right here

Similar wording

and this is on the first floor it's on the first floor between the what's going to be the office

Similar wording

and the kitchen okay so it's like in the middle dining room of the house okay understood and are

Similar wording

the youth going to have access to this room when there isn't a visit or intake happening yes it's

Similar wording

more administrative like closed off no this is going to be um open access for the youth the

Similar wording

office is what's going to be um specifically for admin and yes all right uh questions yeah so um

Similar wording

Right. Questions. Yeah. So are you so are you going to have boys and girls or just boys or just girls?

Similar wording

are you so

Similar wording

And what's the youngest age? So I want to just have girls because this is my first time.

Similar wording

I'm not sure how to maneuver that co-ed. So it will just be girls.

Similar wording

And I'm saying 11 to 16. But quite honestly, if I have the space, then I'll I can go under 11.

Similar wording

I don't want to go to up to 18 beyond that. Then that's like a whole different whole different situation.

Similar wording

OK, you said you were an educator. What what is what did you do? What was that?

Similar wording

So I'm currently an eighth grade middle school teacher with the Philadelphia School District. I teach English language arts.

Similar wording

okay and do you plan to continue to teach and use and do this facility or are you going to

Similar wording

leave and i do i do plan to continue um with the school district which is why um i'm going to be

Similar wording

very intentional about staffing and um who will be responsible for maintaining things um i know

Similar wording

there's also a certain amount of hours that I have to make sure that I'm there. So I plan to

Similar wording

incorporate that in my schedule to make sure that I'm following, you know, the proper policies and

Similar wording

protocols. And programming, what kind of programs do you, are you, are you planning for the youth?

Similar wording

So I have a partnership with a nonprofit organization that does social emotional learning,

Similar wording

um extracurricular activities um small group therapy individual therapy so we already have

Similar wording

a partnership and i've been partnering with them for the last four years so i plan to incorporate

Similar wording

um that whole non-profit and all their programming into um the youth or the youth home as well

Similar wording

and last question where you plan to get the uh young girls from so the area of the home

Similar wording

is surrounded by a few different schools. So I plan to reach out to the schools and maybe form

Similar wording

some partnerships with the schools, reaching out to DHS to form a partnership with them and within

Similar wording

the Philadelphia County and Montgomery County if the need is there. So I do have a few options that

Similar wording

I plan once things are approved to reach out and make some connections with.

Similar wording

But I do know that specific area, there was about three or four schools in that area, for sure three.

Similar wording

Cheryl?

Similar wording

How many children?

Similar wording

The house is seven.

Similar wording

Seven would be the maximum that I'll be able to.

Similar wording

Seven?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

How many bedrooms?

Similar wording

It's three bedrooms.

Similar wording

The master bedroom will hold three.

Similar wording

The other two bedrooms will only be two each.

Similar wording

but i think that's assumption because do you know what the square footage of the front bedroom is

Similar wording

i do not have that offhand um i know that i had to when i had someone to come and look at the

Similar wording

property um that was a suggestion those numbers was a suggestion based on um the contractor

Similar wording

looking and looking and someone who's already familiar with the process so based on the sizes

Similar wording

as that was the suggestion. Occupancy is based on square footage to some extent, but

Similar wording

you're talking seven with just one bathroom? Yes, and the plan is to also, as a suggestion

Similar wording

from the contractor, to incorporate that half bath downstairs, which we're considering either

Similar wording

using part of the office, taking some of the space from the office for the half bath,

Similar wording

or maybe a little space from the kitchen. Okay, thank you. You're welcome.

Similar wording

questions from our attorney no questions at this questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

yes mr chair i have a hand up from

Similar wording

three five five two i will allow them to speak

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

hello good morning

Similar wording

adrian adrian yes good morning could you please spell your name for the stenographer

Similar wording

yes adrian my last name is spelled fernandez f-e-r-n-a-n-d-e-z

Similar wording

right do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

yes please proceed okay um overall we are opposed to boarding houses of any type because

Similar wording

we've had a lot of problems with them especially with people who are formally adjudicated or coming

Similar wording

formally adjudicated or coming from being incarcerated, whether they're minors or adults.

Similar wording

from um being incarcerated

Similar wording

read it.

Similar wording

I'm a little confused about the owner is listed as a different person than the applicant,

Similar wording

so I'm a little confused about who would be the ultimate responsible person for this address

Similar wording

and if the owner is even at the hearing.

Similar wording

Overall, we're requesting a two-year temporary variance for this.

Similar wording

This proposal, one problem is we don't know where the occupants are coming from and if any are adjudicated.

Similar wording

We have a lot of problems we've had this year with truancy with young children, as young as 3 to 14.

Similar wording

The older children tend not to be a problem with that.

Similar wording

um we currently have we currently have um police roll call complaints for ongoing problems with

Similar wording

um running around till late at night and also damaging um damages to property that are

Similar wording

significant cars and homes um we're asking for the temporary two-year variance for special

Similar wording

exception and also if the occupants can be limited to just three occupants based on the fact that

Similar wording

The owner is not running the business, and also these houses usually are about, even on the outside, 14 feet wide, so usually the largest bedroom is going to be something like 13 by 12.

Similar wording

there should be one child per bedroom for children who do not know each other especially in a case

Similar wording

where sexual assault is a problem in these boarding houses for children. So if there's

Similar wording

three bedrooms there should be one child per bedroom for respect and safety of the child

Similar wording

and also the experience the lack of experience of the operator. I didn't hear a trash management

Similar wording

plan because another problem we have is um children who are supervised just throwing trash

Similar wording

through the neighborhood and this has been um problematic because the mayor has done a lot

Similar wording

to increase um street cleaning trash collection in this neighborhood it's working but our problem

Similar wording

is that as soon as the city finishes sometimes going through a street five times to clean

Similar wording

sidewalks alleys everything the unsupervised children come right behind them go to corner

Similar wording

stores and just throw trash all through the neighborhood including spent scooters and things

Similar wording

that are dangerous for people to trip over um so once again asking for a temporary two-year

Similar wording

variance the limit of occupants to three minor children all right thank you very much thank you

Similar wording

um you're welcome um anybody else in the virtual audience no further hands mr chair go ahead i have

Similar wording

quick question um do you have the support of the neighbors adjacent to you on both sides yes i do

Similar wording

okay questions from our planning commission comments

Similar wording

uh madison matera planning commission staff comprehensive plan recommends no change to the

Similar wording

RSA 5 residential single family

Similar wording

zoning at this location.

Similar wording

The city changed the zoning in this neighborhood in

Similar wording

2006 and a council requested map change.

Similar wording

The appellant has shown that the proposed

Similar wording

group living will have no detrimental impact

Similar wording

beyond what might be expected.

Similar wording

City Planning Commission recommends the board grant

Similar wording

the proposed special exception.

Similar wording

Cherise, what I'm going

Similar wording

to do is we're going to hold the vote on this because

Similar wording

some of the issues are involved and just try to work it

Similar wording

out in our heads, but we will vote on this

Similar wording

the 4th, next Wednesday

Similar wording

at 9.30 a.m., okay?

Similar wording

Okay. So I don't need to respond to any of the concerns. It's all up to you guys from this point.

Similar wording

Okay. To point it's up to us and we're going to try to find what's right. Okay. Okay. Thank you

Similar wording

very much. And thanks for getting on the phone. We appreciate it. All right. Thank you for your

Similar wording

flexibility with my little technology issue. Okay. All right. All right.

Similar wording

it's your first case right yes all right so mi2026 002 963 1300 market street adam laver

Similar wording

is the attorney mr laver could you please state and spell your name for the stenographer

Similar wording

good morning chairman bergman and members of the board adam laver la v as in victor er

Similar wording

of Blank Rome, LLP, One Logan Square.

Similar wording

Do you swear a firm to tell the truth, the whole truth,

Similar wording

nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, Chairman Bergman, I do.

Similar wording

Could you identify your client and relationship to the property?

Similar wording

Certainly.

Similar wording

Blank Rome represents Wanamaker Market, LLC,

Similar wording

and 1300 Market Owner, LLC,

Similar wording

owners of the condominium units that collectively comprise the historic John Wanamaker building.

Similar wording

owners of the condominium units

Similar wording

that collectively comprise the historic...

Similar wording

Okay. We have a letter of unanimous support from Washington Square Civic Association,

Similar wording

and we also have a letter of non-opposition from Council Member Squilla. Our vice chair has a few

Similar wording

questions for you, sir. Thank you. Good morning. Have you submitted your documents and exhibits 14

Similar wording

days in advance of this hearing? Good morning, Madam Vice Chair. Yes, we have.

Similar wording

And do you wait the reading of your, oh, you have referrals?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Yep, you have referrals.

Similar wording

Do you wait the reading of your referrals and stipulate to the accuracy?

Similar wording

Yes, ma'am.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

You can share your screen and proceed.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

I'm really excited about discussing this project with you today.

Similar wording

the Wanamaker building is at the heart of the Philadelphia being those of us who are Philadelphians

Similar wording

and those who are new everybody loves the John Wanamaker building it is in the process of an

Similar wording

exciting mixed-use transformation including members of the board prior permitted approvals

Similar wording

for multi-family residential living which will comprise over 600 apartments this is cmx5 zoning

Similar wording

and most of what makes sense is is already approved and we're happy to share with you

Similar wording

and others who who have an interest regarding the two entities that i mentioned that i represent

Similar wording

They are special purpose entities that are affiliated with TF Cornerstone, but I'd also like to mention that TF Cornerstone is partnering with local partner Altera Property Group on the transformation of the building.

Similar wording

And Connor Burke is sitting here with us in the hearing room.

Similar wording

He is a principal at Altera Property Group.

Similar wording

I also believe that virtually we have Jonathan Brough, principal of JKRP Architects, who has worked with us on this project.

Similar wording

It almost seems silly to share some photographs of the property with you.

Similar wording

However, the importance of this property speaks to the critical nature of the site, the center.

Similar wording

It truly is right at the center of Philadelphia, just across from City Hall on Center Square.

Similar wording

And it's a magnificent treasure of a building.

Similar wording

And we are very fortunate to have the investment of these developers who have the experience coming in and putting before you a really amazing transformation.

Similar wording

so all of these photographs no doubt look familiar to you but maybe like me you're missing

Similar wording

what i'm about to show you in a moment where's the eagle the eagle thank you mr chairman

Similar wording