civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - September 2, 2020

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Sep 2, 20205h 34m

All right.

Similar wording

Let's see.

Similar wording

Hold on one second.

Similar wording

Let me just get some help here.

Similar wording

I don't know why.

Similar wording

By the time I got back on, we were down to, like, the fifth case.

Similar wording

What?

Similar wording

Control W?

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Let's see what that works.

Similar wording

No, it's not.

Similar wording

Let's see.

Similar wording

control w hold on a second let me uh just let me control w i'm just trying to get out this one oh

Similar wording

there we go why is it not getting up though hold on sorry what oh yeah all right there we go sorry

Similar wording

about that um i'm going to share my screen i have 6600 let's see oh i got out of all of them hold

Similar wording

in one second. I apologize. Let's see, 6600. Okay, share a screen.

Similar wording

All right, so in front of you should be a packet of eight exhibits for 6600 Cornelia Street.

Similar wording

The first exhibit is the deed to the property, showing that Urban Renewal LLC owns the property.

Similar wording

The second exhibit is the certificate of tax clearance, showing that they're in good standing.

Similar wording

Third exhibit is the notice of refusal.

Similar wording

So this is an RSA 5 property, but if you look at the history of this property, it has had

Similar wording

a multi-use history up to three units. Currently there are two residential units and there's

Similar wording

a vacant commercial space. We're only trying to swap out the commercial space with a residential

Similar wording

space and we're here to also legalize the parking that's been there for some time. I

Similar wording

know the board's listened to the previous owner for such a long time, so I'm just going

Similar wording

make this pretty short and sweet you'll see here here's the parking that's been in there in the

Similar wording

past and is legal curb cut or just trying to legalize this curb cut here in this parking here

Similar wording

we're just trying to legalize this curb cut here and this parking here and as you can see in 2011

Similar wording

and as you can see in 2011

Similar wording

from google maps you'll see that three cars are parked here and you'll see that you know there's

Similar wording

off-street parking allowed on the common driveway so it's a very simple project again each floor

Similar wording

will have its own unit and most importantly we met with the neighborhood and they were unanimously

Similar wording

in support of this project so they had 23 people there all voted in support of

Similar wording

this project I have the owner's representative Carl Klossbach here Carl

Similar wording

can you virtually raise your hand

Similar wording

Carl you can unmute yourself and wait to be sworn

Similar wording

I'm unmuted. All right uh Carl can you state your full name and address for the record?

Similar wording

Carl Klotzbach 6266 West Valley Green Road Flower Town PA 19031

Similar wording

i didn't hear his address sorry uh 6266 west valley green road flower town pa 19031

Similar wording

chair can you swear him in please

Similar wording

i think he's on mute i'm frozen i'm sorry hold on okay a court reporter i'm sorry i really think

Similar wording

it might be something with zoom because everybody's having problems okay so if it works for you as

Similar wording

well i will have you receive the video so anything you lose now you can get through the video

Similar wording

and now she's on oh she's on mute okay

Similar wording

all right you good quick reporter

Similar wording

i'm good thank you tanya you're welcome frank you can proceed

Similar wording

he's on mute he's somehow lost his volume

Similar wording

no i have him not muted no i know i just i'm seeing his mouth move

Similar wording

okay yeah something happened with the device

Similar wording

how about this i don't think um can any uh secretary plaza

Similar wording

are you available to swear in yes um carl klotzbach

Similar wording

yep thank you

Similar wording

sir you affirm and swear to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Can you please identify yourself for the record, name and address?

Similar wording

Yes, my name is Carl Klotzbach.

Similar wording

My address is 6266 West Valley Green Road, Flower Town, PA, 19031.

Similar wording

Hi, Carl.

Similar wording

You heard everything I stated today with regards to your Sony matter.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Yes, I did.

Similar wording

i'm sorry because i'm just looking at the chairman like having like some words on the screen um

Similar wording

and everything you uh everything i said is true and correct right that is correct and you were

Similar wording

adopted as your own testimony yes okay including the fact that the community was unanimously in

Similar wording

supportive of this project? Yes, they were very supportive. Okay. I have no further

Similar wording

questions or presentation materials. Okay. Is there anyone that would like to speak in this

Similar wording

manner? Secretary Plaza, we have Hillary Emerson from the Councilwoman's office. Hillary,

Similar wording

You can unmute yourself

Similar wording

And wait to be sworn in

Similar wording

Good afternoon, Mr. Chair

Similar wording

Members of the board, can you hear me?

Similar wording

Good afternoon, yes we can, Hillary

Similar wording

Hillary, you swear and affirm to tell the truth

Similar wording

The whole truth and nothing but the truth

Similar wording

I do

Similar wording

Thank you

Similar wording

For the record, Hilary Emerson, H-I-L-A-R-Y, Emerson, E-M-E-R-S-O-N, from Councilwoman

Similar wording

For the record, Hillary Emerson

Similar wording

H-I-L-A-R-Y

Similar wording

Cheryl Parker's office, regarding 6600 Cornelius Street.

Similar wording

The Councilwoman is not opposed to the variances requested in this case.

Similar wording

Sorry, I have a helper.

Similar wording

um yeah this property has a clear history as a multi-family use um in addition to having some

Similar wording

commercial in the basement and there are three units each with their own um their own entrance

Similar wording

um and the the basement unit is is above grade um which uh addresses safety concerns that we

Similar wording

typically have with um basement apartments i did attend the community meeting um and the community

Similar wording

was not opposed and would ask for a proviso that a certificate of occupancy be obtained within

Similar wording

nine months okay thank you um that's all secretary plaza you can proceed okay uh does the board has

Similar wording

any questions no no frank your audio is still off

Similar wording

frankie there yeah he's putting up a paper that i can't see let me just try to i'm gonna get rid

Similar wording

put it up frank it's backwards i hear here's my hear me no we can't hear you frank okay uh

Similar wording

Planning Commission?

Similar wording

Chairman and members of the board, this property is indicated for a single

Similar wording

family residential in the comprehensive plan.

Similar wording

Given non-opposition from the community and the council person's office as well

Similar wording

as the history of multi-family use here, staff does not oppose the granting of

Similar wording

the variances. Okay, thank you. Tanya,

Similar wording

anybody else you see? No hands? That's all.

Similar wording

Tanya that's all secretary okay okay so calendar number am i two zero two zero zero zero zero six

Similar wording

seven four sixty six hundred Cornelia Street my vote is yes with the proviso that a certificate

Similar wording

get over it. Occupancy must be obtained within nine months. Yes, with proviso. Yes, with proviso.

Similar wording

Okay, good luck. Thank you. Calendar number 39448416 Poplar Street. Again, Alan,

Similar wording

are you still under oath? Do you agree to waive the reading of his refusal and stipulate to

Similar wording

I'm going to share my screen.

Similar wording

Just given the technical difficulties, I'll try to streamline this presentation as well.

Similar wording

416 Poplar Street was in front of the board in February of 2020.

Similar wording

We were here for 414 and 418 Poplar Street, and, you know, we made some changes to the drawings at the behest of the community with regards to the rear yard and items like that, and there was concern with regard to 416 Poplar Street that we may have accidentally increased the variance where we want to make sure that we dealt with all variances, you know, through this process.

Similar wording

So, and this is a single-family structure with a front-loading garage.

Similar wording

If you see Exhibit 3, this was the original notice of refusal, you know, to have a single-family

Similar wording

house with a front-loading garage on the block that doesn't allow on-street parking.

Similar wording

So we're not taking any public parking.

Similar wording

So in February, the following day after the hearing, I asked the permission of the Zoning

Similar wording

Board of Adjustment to allow for amending my zoning permit appeal, which was granted,

Similar wording

and we obtained a new notice of refusal. Again, it's the same exact drawings that were approved

Similar wording

on 414, as well as 418 Palmer Street, which were also supported by the community as well.

Similar wording

so we're here just as you know to just you know follow up to also get a you know a decision from

Similar wording

this board but as you can see there is no parking allowed on this on this street and it's actually

Similar wording

There is no parking allowed on this street, and it's actually quite common to have off-street parking.

Similar wording

quite common to have

Similar wording

So, and these are the drawings, and this is our letter of support from the board,

Similar wording

the RCO, and proof of mailing of that community meeting,

Similar wording

as well as the permits that were granted for 414 and 418.

Similar wording

I have Tomer Alon on the line.

Similar wording

Tomer, can you virtually raise your hand?

Similar wording

He's available.

Similar wording

Tomer, can you state your full name and address for the records?

Similar wording

Before you start, do you swear and affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I affirm.

Similar wording

Tomer, can you state your full name and address for the record?

Similar wording

Tomer Alon, 921 Alborger Avenue, Philadelphia, PA, 19115.

Similar wording

Can you spell your first and last name for the synopsis?

Similar wording

T-O-M-E-R-A-L-O-N.

Similar wording

So, Tomer, you heard everything I stated today.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And is it true and correct?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And would you adopt it as your own testimony?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

I'm done with my presentation.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Is there anyone else that would like to speak in this matter?

Similar wording

No hands.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Does the board have any questions?

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

Whatever you think.

Similar wording

no okay planning commission

Similar wording

chairman and members of the board this property is zoned for single family residential on the

Similar wording

comprehensive plan staff is not opposed to the granting of the variances thank you calendar

Similar wording

Number three nine four one six. My vote is yes. My vote is yes. My vote is yes. Okay good luck.

Similar wording

Calendar number three six seven two nine five twenty one dash five three one West Susquehanna

Similar wording

Avenue and 2209-15

Similar wording

Fairhill Street. Mr. Clinton?

Similar wording

I'm sorry, confessor. Yes.

Similar wording

So I have Frank on the line here. Okay. If at all

Similar wording

possible, we're requesting a brief recess. Okay. Everyone's having technical

Similar wording

difficulty sharing, all of us. So if we could kind of

Similar wording

pause for five to seven minutes and then reconnect

Similar wording

as necessary chairman did you want to say something no let's say we'll be back at 3 45

Similar wording

for now we'll be back at 3 45. yep tanya can we try to shut everything off and then you know

Similar wording

restart uh um dpv zoom let's check with dpc zoom bill yes since we're all having major issues

Similar wording

um yes you can certainly try that uh the only problem is i can't really stop and restart

Similar wording

the webinar no not you i'm talking about all the panelists who are having issues and concerns

Similar wording

come back in yeah well at least i don't force zoom to reconnect them so hopefully i'll reconnect

Similar wording

them properly or you know through a better channel this time all right okay awesome so

Similar wording

So the IT person has said that if we can go out and come back in, that's fine.

Similar wording

But Frank, we're now at the 3.20 mark, and you're suggesting we return back at what time?

Similar wording

I don't know how long.

Similar wording

Let's say 10, 15 minutes.

Similar wording

All right?

Similar wording

We'll try.

Similar wording

If we get on, then we can start.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Let's try 10 minutes, all right?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

so to all listening the board is going to recess until 3 35 and try to reconnect hopefully we'll

Similar wording

have better uh reception thank you all

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

You

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

No, I can't hear you.

Similar wording

Frank how's your audio Tanya you have feedback

Similar wording

Sorry about that, okay, Frank, you still don't have audio.

Similar wording

So here's an option if you wanted to call in using your cell phone and keep your video

Similar wording

on and talk through your cell audio.

Similar wording

Okay, Frank, that's what you've got.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Can you hear me?

Similar wording

I hear you, Fred.

Similar wording

I can hear you.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

I can hear Jim.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Tanya can you hear me yes chair very well okay

Similar wording

wait for confessor

Similar wording

Sharon, can you hear us?

Similar wording

I can, yes.

Similar wording