civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - August 3, 2022

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Aug 3, 20223h 46m

Number 11, MI-2022, 002166-3811 Lancaster Avenue, Norman Wakes is the listed owner.

Similar wording

Mr. Chair, there's a change in ownership at this location when we got the exhibit, we learned of it.

Similar wording

The owner is now, or the owners, Monique Greenwood and Glenn Hogue, and the case is pro se.

Similar wording

If you'd like, I can read the refusal into the record.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Application is for assembly and entertainment at first floor in an existing structure on the same lot with all other uses as previously approved.

Similar wording

No sign this application.

Similar wording

There is one use refusal.

Similar wording

the proposed assembly and entertainment is prohibited in this zoning district.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Will the owners please raise their hand?

Similar wording

Ms. Monique Greenwood.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Hi, could you state your name please and spell for the court reporter?

Similar wording

yes my name is monique greenwood m-o-n-i-q-u-e greenwood g-r-e-e-n w-o-o-d right do you swear

Similar wording

affirm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth i do okay our vice chair has a few

Similar wording

questions for you yes hi have you emailed the exhibit packet with proof of ownership

Similar wording

tax compliance a copy of the refusal or referral photos under plans of the property five days in

Similar wording

advance of this hearing and have you met with the rco and do you have a letter yes we've done all

Similar wording

of those things we do not have the actual tax clearance but we do have evidence that taxes

Similar wording

the tax has been paid we're waiting on the clearance letter okay thank you you may proceed

Similar wording

and share your screen.

Similar wording

I need to ask my architect

Similar wording

if they could come on to share the screen.

Similar wording

Is that possible?

Similar wording

He can share the screen.

Similar wording

He just cannot testify.

Similar wording

You'll have to do the testifying.

Similar wording

Okay, sure.

Similar wording

What do we have to do to have them do that?

Similar wording

What's the name of the person?

Similar wording

Monique McRae.

Similar wording

Jason, you can put more hearts of panelists.

Similar wording

It's already been done.

Similar wording

Would you share your screen, please?

Similar wording

Monique?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay, Monique, I was asking you to share the first slideshow.

Similar wording

Okay, so let me just first start out by introducing myself and thanking you for allowing me to present.

Similar wording

My name is Monique Greenwood. I am not an attorney. I'm a passionate owner who is excited about starting a business in a building that I recently purchased at 3811 Lancaster.

Similar wording

I am currently the owner of a building right down the street at 3709 Bering, where I operate a bed and breakfast called Aquaba.

Similar wording

where I operate a bed and breakfast called Aquava.

Similar wording

We've been there.

Similar wording

We've been there for three years.

Similar wording

It's one of three ends that I own.

Similar wording

We're also in Brooklyn, New York, and the Poconos in Pennsylvania.

Similar wording

So we are in the hospitality business now for 28 years

Similar wording

and really saw the need to bring something unique to Lancaster Avenue,

Similar wording

which is a commercial thoroughbred.

Similar wording

In all honesty, because of my ignorance starting out,

Similar wording

I assumed that it was as use right because it is on a commercial street that is surrounded by

Similar wording

office buildings, restaurants, coffee houses. But I was later told that I needed the special

Similar wording

use variance. So that's where we're here for today. The next slide kind of just shows you

Similar wording

the property. It is a corner property. It's a very narrow property. It has two entrances,

Similar wording

is one right at the corner of Bering and Lancaster.

Similar wording

And the second is right on Lancaster.

Similar wording

It's a cute little building.

Similar wording

And the next slide will show what we're proposing to do.

Similar wording

It will be a upscale tea salon and private event space

Similar wording

where we can do baby shower tea parties

Similar wording

and bridal shower tea parties and that type of thing.

Similar wording

If you look at the vantage point from Lancaster on the next slide, our immediate next door neighbor is Alpacare.

Similar wording

We have been in talks with them.

Similar wording

They're very excited that we're there because we will have a component of what we do where we allow community-based organizations to meet in our space once a month.

Similar wording

So they will be meeting with the mothers that they serve there once a month.

Similar wording

We have received a letter of support from Alpacare.

Similar wording

They were also on the call with the community organization, which voted in full support of the project.

Similar wording

We are not changing the exterior of the building at all.

Similar wording

You know, we've already cleaned the brick.

Similar wording

We're putting back the shutters that were original to the property.

Similar wording

And there's a very small sign and we're changing the front door.

Similar wording

But no change to the exterior of the building at all on the inside. We're also not doing any structural changes.

Similar wording

The downstairs have been used, I believe, as an office prior.

Similar wording

So if you advance the next slide, please, you'll see that on the inside.

Similar wording

We're just going to be adding the tables and chairs needed to to offer the high T service.

Similar wording

We are not doing any cooking on premises.

Similar wording

You can advance the slide please again.

Similar wording

So this is the inspiration for what we're doing.

Similar wording

We currently serve high tea at our bed and breakfast

Similar wording

in the Poconos is very successful.

Similar wording

That's the, those are the pictures that you see

Similar wording

that were taken at that property.

Similar wording

You see the tea tray that's there.

Similar wording

All of those items are cold items

Similar wording

and they will not be prepared on property.

Similar wording

We are partnering with several other local businesses,

Similar wording

if you can go to the next slide.

Similar wording

Victoria's Kitchen, which is a restaurant on Ogons,

Similar wording

will be providing all of the savory items,

Similar wording

the sandwiches, the tea sandwiches, all of that.

Similar wording

And then Brooklyn Tea is our tea provider.

Similar wording

And we're sourcing right now with a local bakery

Similar wording

that will make the patisserie.

Similar wording

So we are just plating it on premises

Similar wording

and serving it on premises.

Similar wording

The next slide.

Similar wording

And so that's what I was talking about, that we are going to have monthly community events

Similar wording

where we're hosting space for nonprofit organizations in the community.

Similar wording

We are only open by reservation for high tea.

Similar wording

We'll be open on Fridays, Saturdays and Sundays, three seatings, 90 minutes of pure bliss,

Similar wording

where guests can come in and have their high tea.

Similar wording

And if you go to the second presentation, we'll show you what we submitted with our application.

Similar wording

So the proper plans were submitted.

Similar wording

The architects can jump in if you have any specific questions, but you can see that the building is a triangular shape.

Similar wording

It's on two floors and we are not changing anything.

Similar wording

we're kind of refitting out the kitchen because we don't we're not going to have the

Similar wording

residential stove that was there because we're not doing any cooking. It's a small

Similar wording

small kitchen space that you'll see. The next the next one

Similar wording

I'm going to go through these very quickly, these plans.

Similar wording

I'm going to go through these very quickly these plans.

Similar wording

Guys, if you can just get to the part of the application that we can show, because these are all the elevations and everything is here.

Similar wording

But we did receive the letter of refusal, I believe it's called.

Similar wording

And we also mailed out a notice for the public meeting that was held.

Similar wording

That public meeting was held.

Similar wording

We received the letter of full support.

Similar wording

Where's the letter?

Similar wording

Can you go to the letter?

Similar wording

Yeah, from the People's Emergency Center.

Similar wording

It was a unanimous vote in support.

Similar wording

We felt very honored and blessed that all of our neighbors came out and expressed their excitement for what we intend to do.

Similar wording

So let's see.

Similar wording

That's a copy of our deed.

Similar wording

so we purchased it at the end of the year. This is proof of the mailing to all of the

Similar wording

local residents. I think you have it. If you like, I could email the receipt from

Similar wording

the payment of the taxes on this property. It has happened, and I think

Similar wording

I'd be happy to, at this time, answer any questions you might have.

Similar wording

Hillary, are we okay with the taxes?

Similar wording

If she has a receipt to show payment, I would prefer that we just hold to receive that.

Similar wording

I can send it right now.

Similar wording

I can email it to you right now.

Similar wording

You give me the email address where I can send it.

Similar wording

Give me, once you do the planning commission, give me one second, Mr. Chair, just to look

Similar wording

and see if there's any questions any questions any questions from the board no mr chairman

Similar wording

no mr questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

i see no hands mr chairman thank you planning commission planning commission thank you sir

Similar wording

good afternoon uh ladies and gentlemen of the board david fecto city planning commission

Similar wording

the comprehensive plan recommends a more intense commercial mixed use zoning at this location

Similar wording

which is commercial mixed use 2.5 in the proposed zoning district assembly and entertainment would

Similar wording

be allowed with a special exception so the city planning commission recommends the board grant

Similar wording

the use variance thank you just hold one minute here yeah mr chair this is hillary um the from

Similar wording

And what I can see on the the revenue website is still showing a balance for the taxes.

Similar wording

So we will need to see proof of payment before we can vote on this matter.

Similar wording

OK, so.

Similar wording

Can I email that to you now or.

Similar wording

So, Miss Greenwood, here's what we're going to do.

Similar wording

We're going to hold the vote until next Wednesday.

Similar wording

By Wednesday, we'll have everything straight and we'll have your vote.

Similar wording

OK, yes.

Similar wording

Thank you very much.

Similar wording

Would I tune in on Wednesday?

Similar wording

Pardon me?

Similar wording

Will I tune in on Wednesday?

Similar wording

You can tune in, but it'll be strictly a vote.

Similar wording

Everything's going to be closed, except the case is closed, except for receiving the information.

Similar wording

Perfect.

Similar wording

You can tune in.

Similar wording

You'll see your vote, okay?

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

And thank you very much for your presentation.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Number 12, MI 2022, 002-168-528-West Burke Street.

Similar wording

Alan Nockamson is the attorney.

Similar wording

Letter of support from Old Kentington Neighbors Association.

Similar wording

Letter of non-opposition from Councilwoman Sanchez.

Similar wording

Petition of support signed by approximately 12 neighbors.

Similar wording

and five letters of support, mostly from the 500 block of Bourke Street. Mr. Nockamson.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, Alan Nockamson, Nockamson PC.

Similar wording

Mr. Nockamson, you've already been sworn. Could you identify your client in relationship to the

Similar wording

property? Yes, my client is Norris Square Holdings LLC, and the virtual audience is Chris Steele,

Similar wording

the member of that limited liability property okay our vice president has a few questions

Similar wording

our vice chair i'm sorry hi do you agree to wave the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its

Similar wording

accuracy i do have you emailed the exhibit packet with proof of ownership tax compliance refusal

Similar wording

referral copies of photos a copy of the refusal referral photos under plans of the property five

Similar wording

days in advance of this hearing and if you met with your co and do you have a letter yes

Similar wording

and if you met with your co and you have a letter yes no respects okay you may proceed

Similar wording

please share ring sure thanks

Similar wording

all right so i'm here to present 528 west berk street uh we are in the old kids in uh section of

Similar wording

Philadelphia. During my presentation, I will be going over the notice of refusal, then the letter

Similar wording

of support from the whole Kensington Neighborhood Association, the letter of non-opposition from the

Similar wording

district council member, Maria Quinonez Sanchez. We did make great efforts to meet with nearby

Similar wording

neighbors. I believe we even have either a letter of support or a petition signed by our next door

Similar wording

neighbor but we have a petition signed letters to support from nearby neighbors my client actually

Similar wording

lives nearby as well or my client's representative chris steel maps of the area photographs of the

Similar wording

property in the surrounding area our plans and drawings our community meeting notice and proof

Similar wording

of mail event notice to the affected properties our application for appeal to cba or deeds of

Similar wording

property showing in north square holdings llc is the owner of the property and their certificate of

Similar wording

tax clearance. Again, in the virtual audience is Chris Steele, the member of the corporate

Similar wording

property owner, who at the end of my presentation, I'll ask to virtually raise his hand to be sworn

Similar wording

in and to adopt. My testimony has no interest in his own. Notice of refusal. So we're seeking

Similar wording

a three-family dwelling in this CMX2 property. Ultimately, we're being refused because we're

Similar wording

swapping out the commercial component with the residential. Not out of character for this section

Similar wording

of the city. First of all, there's a CMX2 property on this block, 520 Westbrook Street,

Similar wording

which is also solely residential in nature. And you'll see from the photographs of the property

Similar wording

in the maps of the area that this is a residential section of philadelphia other than across the

Similar wording

street there is a shopping center where the cousin's supermarket is and our goal is to

Similar wording

support that shopping center and the shops that are in there as well as close by there's a

Similar wording

commercial border or germantown avenue but there really is no commercial component on our side of

Similar wording

street or nearby, other than those, you know, obviously two instances which should be supported

Similar wording