civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - March 3, 2021

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Mar 3, 20214h 25m

this viable. So my concerns, my concerns are the, the residents on Ruffner Street concerns. Those

Similar wording

are the ones that were at the meeting. It was a lively meeting for Gussie who was online and the

Similar wording

owners. We were like, in our letter, we have some opposition and we're asking for this to

Similar wording

stay at um 11 units well are you are you aware of any provisos that um that's coming from um

Similar wording

swamp poodle um uh that's that's one of the affected rcos they couldn't attend i i know

Similar wording

so my my question to you mr karn are you aware of those provisors

Similar wording

those provisos we say they'll support the yes or no with the following provisos

Similar wording

no so let's hear the provisos sure thank you

Similar wording

is adrian

Similar wording

adrian please unmute yourself

Similar wording

Adrienne, please unmute yourself.

Similar wording

Adrienne, are you there?

Similar wording

Adrienne, are you still present?

Similar wording

don't like her to just leave and i'd just like to know what the provisors are because generally

Similar wording

provisors mean we'll support it with the following provisor i don't i don't know she is here and

Similar wording

she's unmuted i'm not sure what the problem is maybe she needs to leave again as well and come

Similar wording

back in. She's on the phone. Oh, I'm sorry. Two o'clock list, the bewitching list. Yeah, I would

Similar wording

just add Mr. Chairman, we actually thought that, you know, the concerns about parking and overuse

Similar wording

that three additional units would be so much better than a 3,000 square foot restaurant or

Similar wording

any of the other CMX2 uses here. Let me ask you, Brett, are you aware of any of the provisos?

Similar wording

Uh, I know, I know, I know so much of the focus was on this sewer issue.

Similar wording

Um, you know, I don't know if it had something to do with, you know, us, us having to tie

Similar wording

it, make sure we tie into a public sewer, um, which we certainly would agree to that.

Similar wording

That's what will happen.

Similar wording

Um, you know, we don't have any roof decks here.

Similar wording

Um, we're not looking to do anything other than just, uh, just nice, nice adaptive reuse,

Similar wording

uh, with a couple of units here.

Similar wording

Um, it's really, you know, minimum impact.

Similar wording

um you know if there's street trees if there's street trees we're certainly willing to look at

Similar wording

that the trash is stored inside maybe that's a proviso typically we're willing to do that

Similar wording

we've got a bike room inside um any of those tanya

Similar wording

um chair um can you hear me okay yes so i do have the list of provisos that in the letter

Similar wording

that was sent if you wish i can relay them please

Similar wording

limit of 11 unit occupancy no basement living all trash and recycling stored inside building

Similar wording

no roof deck collet house or roof structures all bicycle parking structures installed inside

Similar wording

property lines all financial slash monetary contributions to sewer and other shared

Similar wording

infrastructures. Calculate this address as 11 separate addresses on this 100th block.

Similar wording

Certificate of occupancy in 12 months. And just so it's clear, this letter was submitted,

Similar wording

but it is opposition, but those were the provisos. Thank you.

Similar wording

We certainly would agree to no roof deck. We would certainly agree to trash

Similar wording

storage inside that's that's we we created a trash storage room inside we agreed to a bike storage

Similar wording

room inside um the again the sewer is is public it's out on lab and street it's not on ruffner

Similar wording

it should have no impact on them it's a separate line um we we we we will agree to as a proviso

Similar wording

the number of units being reduced from 15 to 14 um i think what else was in there i i know they're

Similar wording

what they're saying is we should just not have any additional units that seem it sounds like

Similar wording

that's the only still that you guys can't address uh we gotta we have to we have we're gonna have

Similar wording

to redo all the sidewalks here street trees i mean there's a um but i know you know we made

Similar wording

sure we initially had the trash outside trash is now inside let me ask you about the trash is that

Similar wording

commercial pickup or is that uh commercial commercial yeah all right uh what i'd like

Similar wording

is i'd like to get a copy of uh the provisos that tanya has uh and unless there's any other

Similar wording

questions from the board i'll i'm going to go to the planning commission no no questions

Similar wording

any commission uh ron bednar city planning on bednar city planning uh while this property

Similar wording

currently indicated for commercial mixed use on the city plan given our recommended draft nice

Similar wording

town remapping bill envisioned residential reuse therefore we support the granting of the variance

Similar wording

okay i'm uh i just want to make a statement i'm going to close this uh because i'd like to see

Similar wording

those provisos the understanding everyone is if they if we only limit it to 11 and they keep that

Similar wording

If we only limit it to 11 and they keep that first floor as a commercial space, I heard that there was concerns about parking.

Similar wording

first floor as a commercial.

Similar wording

You might want to think about that because a commercial space will generate a lot more traffic.

Similar wording

So having said that, I'm closing the record on this for the time being, and the board will make a decision at next Wednesday's executive session.

Similar wording

okay thank you come across everybody hear me yes mr chairman the only mr chairman can i just add

Similar wording

one more thing yes the only thing i would add and it's in our plan change form um which maybe i can

Similar wording

i can submit to uh again submit to uh mr letter but um we wanted to make sure that um they there's

Similar wording

the second floor there's a portion of the second floor that we wanted to make sure it's documented

Similar wording

as as existing and if it's not to have it be reconstructed okay but you'll send that revision

Similar wording

over to uh sharon or uh tanya please okay okay we'll we'll do it we'll do it that way but uh

Similar wording

well that way the board will have a little more time to digest some of these provisors okay great

Similar wording

i just want to make sure that ellen i you know however whatever happens with the case we wanted

Similar wording

to make sure that that that there's no confusion in that that's good thank you yes if i could

Similar wording

mention i'm sorry um charles richardson from the council person's office what i'm here with

Similar wording

the pra sorry if we could allow him to speak yep sorry about that mr richardson

Similar wording

please identify yourself you're still under oath from this morning i was i was gonna get a complex

Similar wording

here i'm sorry i'm sorry uh charles richardson from the office of councilwoman cindy bass room

Similar wording

312 City Hall. The councilwoman is supporting the community in their desire to have 11 units

Similar wording

and, you know, and have commercial on the first floor. Commercialism is very important to the

Similar wording

community. You know, they could create jobs, things along those lines. And that's, you know,

Similar wording

one of the major things that the RCO have brought to light. So the councilwoman does support the

Similar wording

community, the RCO and their desire to have 11 in the community and their desire to have 11 units

Similar wording

only and to remain with commercial on the first floor. Again, we will, the board will review this

Similar wording

and make a decision next Wednesday's executive session. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you for

Similar wording

your time and consideration. Be well, everyone. Thank you. Also, Mr. Chair, if I may, there was

Similar wording

also, I'm sorry to being able to appoint, but there was also a Ms. Jackie Williams with her

Similar wording

hand raised. Oh, okay. I apologize. I got ahead of everybody.

Similar wording

We'll hear from Ms. Williams and then we'll move on.

Similar wording

There's something new and different, please.

Similar wording

Ms. Williams? Yes, I'm here. Can you hear me?

Similar wording

Yes, please identify yourself, name and address. My name is Jacqueline

Similar wording

Williams. My address is 2117

Similar wording

Ruffner Street. I'm the block captain for the block.

Similar wording

Do you swear and affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Thank you, ma'am. Please proceed.

Similar wording

Okay. And I heard what you just said. So a couple of the concerns that we had as neighbors, you're already addressing the sewer, though I still don't understand.

Similar wording

I'd like to see that myself because this block has tried to get connected to the main sewer for the 40 years that I've lived here, and we've been unable to do so.

Similar wording

So I would like to know how that's being done.

Similar wording

You heard the board direct Mr. Feldman to get a copy of that to you and or the other residents on Ruffner Street.

Similar wording

A copy of what the water department's decision is.

Similar wording

Okay, I hear that.

Similar wording

And I'm not going to go into parking.

Similar wording

Everyone deserves a place to park.

Similar wording

That's fine.

Similar wording

But what I do want to make note of those pictures that were taken up that Blayvon Street at this particular time, that's because of COVID-19, and that's because of the huge bar that's on the corner has been closed through COVID-19.

Similar wording

Now, when that's open, that parking situation is totally, totally different.

Similar wording

So to say that a commercial place could not be there is not true because the place that's up the street right next to it is a commercial place.

Similar wording

And people come in there all the time.

Similar wording

The other hardship is Ruffin Street is a two-way street, even though it's only one lane.

Similar wording

So, you know, Blade Line Street is used for a number of different services.

Similar wording

It's used for the police to park down there.

Similar wording

It's used for firemen to park down there.

Similar wording

They've been parking near where they are because bars are closed and they have parking lots.

Similar wording

But as soon as COVID-19 is over, that whole situation is going to look different.

Similar wording

that whole situation is going to look different and so yeah and i respect that and i think you

Similar wording

and I respect that

Similar wording

and I think

Similar wording

you know

Similar wording

you may have heard me i just said sometimes you know it's kind of like be careful what you wish

Similar wording

I think

Similar wording

for commercial space could generate a lot more traffic is all i was trying to say yeah and i

Similar wording

and i agree but that would be nine to five and not overnight well we don't know you don't know

Similar wording

what kind of commercial it is that's true that's true okay i'm not making the argument for the

Similar wording

developer i'm just making that case for us uh it could be a not maybe not a 24 hour it could be

Similar wording

uh 9 to 10 p.m who knows depends on that all right okay thank you for your time i apologize

Similar wording

for not recognizing you sooner yeah this is our transportation map that we put together also just

Similar wording

showing the hunting parks right here the bus goes right here to broad street right all right uh so

Similar wording

don't mess up again anyone else would like to testify in this case we will send we we will

Similar wording

send the just just just so there's no confusion we will send a the correspondence and the map

Similar wording

of the sewer line to uh the rcos that attended that meeting um i'll have mr rolla do that and

Similar wording

uh miss o'neill um just so we're all on the same page because apparently that that is a major issue

Similar wording

and we want it to get to the bottom of that.

Similar wording

We'll have that done today.

Similar wording

Okay, thank you.

Similar wording

Chair, we do have Guy Halperin as well,

Similar wording

who has not testified yet.

Similar wording

He's part of the development team.

Similar wording

I think we're fine.

Similar wording

Okay, we don't need him on then, right?

Similar wording

Anyone else?

Similar wording

No one else, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

Okay, Carol, move on.

Similar wording

Okay, yes, sir.

Similar wording

calendar number 3388-2220

Similar wording

frankfurt avenue the attorney is joe consul

Similar wording

mr consul has been promoted to panelists mr chair

Similar wording

okay mr consul

Similar wording

mr consul are you available i'm here yeah name and address name and address on the record please

Similar wording

and spell your last name, please. Hi, everyone. Joseph Consol, that's C-O-N-S-O-L-E, Consol

Similar wording

Madison, LLP, 1 West 3rd Street, Suite 204, Media, Pennsylvania, 19063. Do you swear

Similar wording

or affirm to tell the whole truth and nothing but the truth? I do. Do you also agree to

Similar wording

wait the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy? I do. Have you emailed the

Similar wording

exhibit packet with proof of ownership tax compliance refusal referral photos and plans

Similar wording

of the property five days before this hearing and have you met with the rco and do you have

Similar wording

a letter yes we met with them and we have a letter okay great you may proceed hello everyone

Similar wording

again joe console here on uh 2020 3388 uh i'm here on uh the property at 2220 frankford

Similar wording

avenue that is this property right here let's see the applicant is bolt back bolt brow llc

Similar wording

and is represented by evelyn ramos she is on this call and will be available in a minute

Similar wording

she's seeking to use the property as a beauty parlor with a microblading cosmetic tattooing

Similar wording

component, along with traditional beauty power services, including hairstyling, waxing, et cetera.

Similar wording

The, it's Miss Evelyn. Here are some examples of her work.

Similar wording

microblading is considered a form of body art which gets a similar refusal as a tattoo

Similar wording

power does there is no traditional tattooing occurring here

Similar wording

we have a layout showing how her collar is going to be set up

Similar wording

currently she has a three-year lease that ends in march of 2024

Similar wording

she has an option to renew uh it's expected that at max she'll have four employees

Similar wording

four stations uh with at most eight total people in the room four employees four customers uh

Similar wording

uh miss ramos has four uh five years experience the hours are going to be nine to four uh she's

Similar wording

miss ramos has four five years experience the hour

Similar wording

arranged for commercial trash pickup and uh we met with the fishtown rco uh fishtown neighborhood

Similar wording

association rco and we got unanimous support for her to use the property uh as as that use

Similar wording

uh with that i'll uh ask miss ramos to raise her hand so she can adopt my testimony

Similar wording

Good afternoon, Ms. Ramos. When you get on, please identify yourself with a record, and I'll swear you in.

Similar wording

Hello, my name is Evelyn Ramos.

Similar wording

Where am I from? To tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I swear.

Similar wording

Thank you, Mr. Council.

Similar wording

Ms. Ramos, did you hear the testimony that I just gave regarding your property and your lease and

Similar wording

your intended use? I did. Do you adopt that testimony as your own? Yes. Do you have any

Similar wording

questions or concerns? I'm not going to do hairstyling. That's the only thing.

Similar wording

I apologize. I see in my notes that you asked me to remove that once and I didn't do it. I

Similar wording

apologize. With that, we'll, we'll close our testimony.

Similar wording

Questions from the board? No, no, no.

Similar wording

Anyone else would like to testify in this case, please raise your hand.

Similar wording

no hands at this time thank you uh planning commission uh this property is indicated for

Similar wording

commercial business use on the city plan you have no objection to the grounding

Similar wording

thank you mi 2020-003388 2220 frankfort avenue my vote is yes my vote is yes

Similar wording

my vote is yes my vote is yes my vote is yes my vote is yes thank you board

Similar wording

calendar number 3390 2316 south street the attorney is rachel pritzker

Similar wording

Ms. Pritzker has been promoted to panelists, sir.

Similar wording

Good afternoon.

Similar wording

Good afternoon.

Similar wording

Rachel, you're still under oath from earlier?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Carol?

Similar wording

Do you...

Similar wording

I know it's somewhere else.

Similar wording

Can you put your name and address on the record and spell your last name, please?

Similar wording

Sure.

Similar wording

Rachel, R-A-C-H-A-E-L, Pritzker, P-R-I-T-Z-K-E-R, 1635 Market Street, Suite 1600, Philadelphia, PA, 19103.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the whole truth and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Do you also agree to wait the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy?

Similar wording