civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - November 29, 2023

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Nov 29, 20235h 16m

I'm just going to allow the people, the attendees to enter.

Similar wording

chair we have 31 attendees you can proceed as you wish thank you good morning everyone

Similar wording

my name is bill bergman and i will be sharing this morning's eba hearings with me as our vice

Similar wording

chair ismail shaheed president mr chairman and our board member james snell president mr chairman

Similar wording

Also, present is Hillary Emerson, our attorney, and our executive director, Tanya Sunkett.

Similar wording

Here's a virtual format.

Similar wording

Be advised, the proceedings are being recorded.

Similar wording

Video will be available by contacting Tanya Sunkett.

Similar wording

Hello?

Similar wording

We can still hear you, Chair.

Similar wording

Can you hear me?

Similar wording

We can hear you, Bill.

Similar wording

Yeah, I'm good.

Similar wording

I'm good.

Similar wording

Good. I keep losing my screen.

Similar wording

We can see and hear you.

Similar wording

Okay, good. All right. Be advised to proceedings are being recorded.

Similar wording

Your video will be available by contacting Tanya Sunkett at phil.gov.

Similar wording

For the benefit of our court stenographer, we ask attorneys and witnesses to identify themselves before testify.

Similar wording

If you're participating by phone and you wish to testify, press star 9 to raise your hand and star 6 to unmute.

Similar wording

To enter an appearance statement, call 267-270-5548.

Similar wording

Leave your email and the address of the property in question.

Similar wording

And lastly, the question and answer box on the screen is not for testifying or comments.

Similar wording

All comments should be directed to our Executive Director, Tanya Sunken.

Similar wording

Let's look at our schedule for today.

Similar wording

Number four, MI 2023-002-572-2029-39 North 2nd Street. That case is continued.

Similar wording

Number seven, MI 2023, 002-575-6531 North 7th Street, that case is continued.

Similar wording

Number nine, MI 2023, 1250 Wagner Avenue, that case is continued.

Similar wording

Number 10, MI 2023-002-569-2036-48 North 2nd Street, that case is continued.

Similar wording

Number 12, MI 2023-002-587-525 West Roosevelt Boulevard, that case is continued.

Similar wording

number 14

Similar wording

mi

Similar wording

2022 001 391 5221 haverford avenue verna anastasio is the attorney

Similar wording

um there's a request for continuance from council member got the a's office

Similar wording

good morning chair this is doreen blakey and i will be your co-host today

Similar wording

thank you and i will allow mr anastasio to speak okay

Similar wording

morning mr chair good morning verne could you state your name for the record and spell for

Similar wording

the court scenario yes sir it's verne anastasio v-e-r-n last name is a-n-a-s-t-a-s-i-o

Similar wording

Do you swear for him to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

I see the council person would request a continuance.

Similar wording

Yeah, and I do appreciate that.

Similar wording

Yeah, I know this is several listings in.

Similar wording

I came in sort of midstream.

Similar wording

We are just about there.

Similar wording

We've met with the RCO.

Similar wording

We just need to do proper posting, and I'll make sure that I request that from the zoning board.

Similar wording

Okay, thank you.

Similar wording

MI-2022-001-391-5221, Haverford Avenue.

Similar wording

Case is continued.

Similar wording

Mark must be tried.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Number 15, MI 2023-002-607-3336 North 17th Street at Case's Continued Attorney Moving Party.

Similar wording

Number 15.

Similar wording

MI-2022-001-391-5221, Haverford Avenue.

Similar wording

And number 16, MI2023-001-120-530 South Street.

Similar wording

Vern Anastasio is the attorney.

Similar wording

Paul Bonney is also representing, I believe, the RCO.

Similar wording

Could both please come on?

Similar wording

uh mr chair i just wanted the address um is 520 south street just the okay thank you

Similar wording

morning mr chair very you've already been sworn let's let's get the other council on

Similar wording

good morning mr chairman good morning sir could you state your name please and spell for the court

Similar wording

sonographer yes it's paul it's paul bonnie b-o-n-i right you should tell the truth the whole truth

Similar wording

and nothing but the truth yes i do um uh mr anastasio is requesting a a uh a continuance

Similar wording

to return to the rco this is the second listing burn one of you yes mr chair uh i appreciate paul

Similar wording

being here i understand he represents society hill civic i've been working directly with

Similar wording

south street head house district which is the coordinating rco and did in fact host a meeting

Similar wording

for all of us including society hill one time my client then fell ill and we were unable to follow

Similar wording

up it's it was the request of the coordinating rco that we have a second community meeting

Similar wording

and we are willing to do that but of course we were not able to get that in before today's

Similar wording

hearing. So, accordingly, I'm asking for a continuance so that we can

Similar wording

return to the community. Paul?

Similar wording

Yes. So, there are three RCOs

Similar wording

that are interested in this matter. The first is the coordinating

Similar wording

RCO, which is the South Street Headhouse District.

Similar wording

I don't know if Allison or anyone else from the

Similar wording

South Street Headhouse District is on Zoom

Similar wording

right now but I would welcome Allison Hinman Harvey has her hand raised okay well why don't

Similar wording

we let her go first if you don't mind because they're the coordinating RCO

Similar wording

Allison is allowed to speak good morning could you state your name please and spell for the

Similar wording

courts in Oxford. Yes, my name is Allison Hinman Harvey. That is A-L-L-I-S-O-N-H-I-N-D-M-A-N-H-A-R-V-Y.

Similar wording

All right. Do you swear or firm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes. Could you proceed, please, with your testimony?

Similar wording

so it is uh true we had a follow-up rco meeting i believe in august um with verne and the applicant

Similar wording

however then we did not have any communication um about rescheduling another one except for that

Similar wording

that Byrne did not have his party's schedule, basically.

Similar wording

And now we have, because we did not hear anything,

Similar wording

we have opposed, but if they wanna come back

Similar wording

and they wanna hold another RCO with us,

Similar wording

we can do that as well.

Similar wording

But I would like to schedule that immediately.

Similar wording

Yeah, I appreciate that, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

It was always our intention,

Similar wording

once my client got back on his feet,

Similar wording

to uh enter into you know an accord uh which was the intention of the you know first two meetings

Similar wording

we just never got a chance to do it before today's hearing so we'll be happy to meet again

Similar wording

mr money yes verne have you heard from your client in the past several weeks

Similar wording

and i remind you that you're under oath of course first of all i'm insulted by the question

Similar wording

and the indication that I wouldn't be anything less than truthful.

Similar wording

Second of all, I don't usually take questions from opposing counsel.

Similar wording

I take them from the chair.

Similar wording

With that said, Mr. Chair, I ask you if we could have this request addressed.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Okay, thank you.

Similar wording

So my understanding is that the client disappeared,

Similar wording

but the Board can infer what it would like from the colloquy.

Similar wording

This referral was from January 10th of this year.

Similar wording

It's been continued multiple times.

Similar wording

The last time was continued for the purpose of having a meeting which never was, you know,

Similar wording

the purpose of having a meeting, which never was, you know, the applicant never surfaced.

Similar wording

So we understand the Board has discretion, and we just would like to ask that the case

Similar wording

be dismissed. I do point to the Board's attention that all three interested RCOs are on the

Similar wording

record as being opposed to this project.

Similar wording

Mr. Chair, the business is vacant. It doesn't, you know, continuing this matter so that the

Similar wording

original intent, which was to enter into an agreement with the coordinating RCO and my client

Similar wording

is still the goal. Continuing it does not adversely impact anyone. He has ceased operations

Similar wording

until he can get his special exception and that's all it is it's just a special exception

Similar wording

no so mi2023001120520 south street um this case is continued mark must be tried

Similar wording

thank you sir thank you have a good day we're going to go to a few cases we have with no exhibits

Similar wording

Number one

Similar wording

MI2022

Similar wording

000649

Similar wording

2717

Similar wording

Federal Street

Similar wording

John McCrilley is the listed

Similar wording

Owner

Similar wording

CGI Construction

Similar wording

Is the listed

Similar wording

Applicant, there are no exhibits

Similar wording

This is the fourth listing

Similar wording

Mark must be

Similar wording

Heard the last time

Similar wording

yeah i see no hands okay thank you so mi 2022 000 649 2717 federal street

Similar wording

fourth listing no exhibits i vote to dismiss

Similar wording

jim snow snow i vote to dismiss ishmael shaheed my vote is to dismiss thank you

Similar wording

number three mi 2022 003 306 15 13 widener place kajija apqua apda is the owner applicant

Similar wording

it's pro se there are no exhibits this is the third listing case was marked must be heard

Similar wording

again chair no hands raised so mi 2022 003 306 1513 weiner place third listing no exhibits

Similar wording

i vote to dismiss james snell my vote is to dismiss

Similar wording

ishmael shaheed my vote is to dismiss thank you

Similar wording

okay thank you um i'm going to go to a few cases that have been withdrawn

Similar wording

number two mi 2023 001082 2045 to 49 north 2nd street that case has been withdrawn

Similar wording

number five mi 2022 003 289 303 brown street uh number b uh mr anastasio are you in the audience

Similar wording

still yes i will allow mr anastasio to speak mr anastasio you've you've already been uh

Similar wording

sworn um just for the record state your name and burn anastasio uh on behalf of uh the owner of 303

Similar wording

brown street uh david braggler number b is this case being withdrawn yes sir okay thank you very

Similar wording

much appreciate you again so mi 2022 003 289 303 brown street number b the case has been withdrawn

Similar wording

And number 17

Similar wording

MI 2021-001-959-2349

Similar wording

North 20th Street

Similar wording

Donald Benedetto is the attorney

Similar wording

No exhibit, six listing

Similar wording

Mr. Benedetto, are you in the audience?

Similar wording

Mr. Chair, we did receive a written request for withdrawal on this case this morning.

Similar wording

Thank you very much.

Similar wording

So MI 2021-001-959-2349 North 20th Street, that case has been withdrawn.

Similar wording

20th Street, that case has been withdrawn.

Similar wording

Are there any other requests for continuances?

Similar wording

Are there any other requests?

Similar wording

No hands, Chair.

Similar wording

We're going to go to number 13 first.

Similar wording

Hold on a minute.

Similar wording

Be right with you.

Similar wording

number 13

Similar wording

pick right with you

Similar wording

number 13

Similar wording

MI 2023

Similar wording

002-596-3023

Similar wording

3 welsh road salima sanders is the owner this is a pro se

Similar wording

salima sanders i will promote her to panelist okay thank you

Similar wording

she has been promoted good morning could you state your name please and spell for the court

Similar wording

stenographer good morning unmute okay good morning could you state your name please and spell for the

Similar wording

court stenographer yes my name is salima sanders s-a-l-e-e-m-a-h sanders s-a-n-d-e-r-s

Similar wording

right do you swear or affirm to tell the truth to hold you nothing but the truth

Similar wording

yes all right this application for the creation of accessory off street surface parking space

Similar wording

on the same lot as an existing semi-detached structure parking accessory to an existing

Similar wording

single-family household. Service parking spaces and detached garages and carports are prohibited

Similar wording

in the required front side and rear yards. The proposed off-street accessory parking space

Similar wording

is within the required rear yard. Our Vice Chair has just a few questions. Okay. Good morning, Ms.

Similar wording

Sanders. Have you emailed in all the required documents and exhibits that is needed and are

Similar wording

required to proceed with this case today? Yes, but there's just one document I received the email

Similar wording

from someone from the ZBA last night requesting the tax form. However, I've been in continuous

Similar wording

conversation with the, I guess, to tax a revenue for that document because the link that I followed

Similar wording

through the email from the ZBA, it is taking me to the wrong department. I just actually got off

Similar wording

the phone with them this morning and they stated that a lot of people are being forwarded there

Similar wording

and they're not they're not in charge of releasing those tax clearances okay no problem um we can

Similar wording

hear the case but we may not be able to vote on it until the last document is in okay

Similar wording

and are you able to like uh are you would you be able to provide me to the right uh

Similar wording

department you have to call our office oh i've been trying i've even tried to call this morning

Similar wording

is not i left a few messages as well i haven't been able to get into it to anyone live

Similar wording

all right uh tanya sir we will take care of it no problem mr shaheed thank you

Similar wording

mr chair before we proceed um there was i had asked um miss sanders to provide proof that she

Similar wording

had met with the rco i have not received that and that is required in order to hear the case

Similar wording

Ms. Sanders, did you meet with the coordinating RCO?

Similar wording

Is it for when I actually scheduled this actual hearing?

Similar wording

Is that what you're referring to?

Similar wording

No, there's a community organization that you're required to meet with prior to the hearing.

Similar wording

When you got the email from the RCO notification email, it would have told you who your coordinating RCO was and how to contact them.

Similar wording

okay well then unfortunately we are going to need to continue this

Similar wording

this hearing so that you can have that meeting okay

Similar wording

so you're you're you're going to be aware that you have to get a hold of the rco and have a

Similar wording

meeting okay okay all right so mi2023 002 596 3023 welsh road this case has been continued

Similar wording

thank you one two three we're going to move to number six mi 2023 002 636 2507 manton street

Similar wording

leo movahill is the attorney there is a letter of opposition from residents organized for

Similar wording

there is a letter of opposition from residents organized for advice advocacy and direction

Similar wording

advocacy and

Similar wording

And I'll see you next time.

Similar wording

no explanation given there was a vote of three to zero and we're also waiting i believe for

Similar wording

tax compliance mr mulvihill leo mulvihill is coming in as a panelist chair thank you

Similar wording

mr chair i can confirm that we receive the tax certificate this morning thank you thank you

Similar wording

there we go good morning could you state your name please spell for the court stenographer

Similar wording

good morning it's leo l-e-o last name mulvihill m-u-l-v as in victor i-h-i-l-l

Similar wording

um do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

i do um could you identify your client the relationship to this property

Similar wording

certainly my client is j as in james p as in paul a as an alpha 2507 manthon street

Similar wording

and my client is on my the principal of the company is on the line as well that's mr johnson

Similar wording

thank you our uh vice chair has just a few questions sir good morning counsel do you agree

Similar wording

to weigh the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy yes have you emailed in all the

Similar wording

required documents and exhibits it is needed and required to proceed with this case five days in

Similar wording

advance of this hearing not in five days in advance i received the my client's commercial

Similar wording

activity license and tax clearance yesterday those were forwarded this morning and i do have

Similar wording

in my presentation packet as well i believe we received that please proceed um and you have

Similar wording

already shared your screen i believe yes so good morning members of the board we're here today for

Similar wording

property that's currently a vacant lot on the 2500 block of manton street it runs right in

Similar wording

the graceberry neighborhood uh right a couple houses in or lots in rather from the viaduct

Similar wording

that runs along 25th street we received the for purposes of the record the refusal appeal and

Similar wording

project information form are at page one area zoning maps are at two my client's deed is at eight

Similar wording

Zoning notice to our neighbors is at 17.

Similar wording

Proof of mailing is at 24.

Similar wording

The RCO letter is at 25.

Similar wording

Commercial activity license and tax information are in this packet,

Similar wording

but they were sent in separately to the Zoning Board Council.

Similar wording

Photos of the property are 27 and plans are at 38 of this presentation packet.

Similar wording

So going to page one of the presentation packet,

Similar wording

we received the refusal, members of the board,

Similar wording

solely because this property is zoned industrial.

Similar wording

The rest of the lot is zoned commercial,

Similar wording

pardon me, residential multifamily.

Similar wording

But for some reason, at the end of our side,

Similar wording

probably because we run the next to the train tracks,

Similar wording

our lot was zoned industrial.

Similar wording

When we get to the zoning map,

Similar wording

we'll see exactly what I'm talking about.

Similar wording

So my client was proposing to have multifamily dwelling

Similar wording

where there currently is a vacant lot.

Similar wording

That's the only reason that we have the refusal is because of the industrial nature of the zoning.

Similar wording

I'll go through our appeal.

Similar wording

There we go.

Similar wording

So now getting to what has been marked as page two for purposes of my submission, we can see, indicated by my cursor in the center, this blue parcel is our parcel.

Similar wording

You can see exactly here's the 25th Street Viaduct.

Similar wording

We've all had the pleasure of driving under that from time to time, I'm sure, if you found yourself in the neighborhood.

Similar wording

What a mess that is. But you can see we have all industrial that's owned along there.

Similar wording

And as we get to the photographs of the block, you will see that the block itself is not industrial in any way.

Similar wording

It is, in fact, residential. There are new residential construction on the block.

Similar wording

I believe some are multifamily as you approach 26th Street.

Similar wording

And we're only looking to stay within the character of the rest of the block, because this seems like it's an aberration of a prior time in zoning that this would have been industrial.

Similar wording

There's no feasible use for this lot as it is, you know, 17 feet wide, however many feet deep for industrial purposes.

Similar wording

And nobody at our community meeting mentioned that they would like to have any sort of industrial use on the property.

Similar wording

In fact, as the chair noted, there was no explanation given in the letter from the RCO as to why there was opposition, but voiced to us at the community meeting, and my client will be happy to verify this, was that the immediate neighbors didn't appear for the meeting.

Similar wording

Why that is, I don't know.

Similar wording

My client had personally reached out to them.

Similar wording

We did send out the letter ahead of time so they were aware of the meeting.

Similar wording

We had postings that were put up on the property.

Similar wording

I'm not sure if any of the immediate neighbors have shown up.

Similar wording

But that was the only reason that there was any opposition to this at all, because the neighbors didn't show up to the online community meeting.

Similar wording

But that was the only reason that there was any opposition to this at all because the neighbors didn't.

Similar wording

But that's our parcel.

Similar wording

This is the overhead Google Maps version of it.

Similar wording

And I'll just zoom in on that a little bit.

Similar wording

So this is our vacant lot right here.

Similar wording

There is a tree there that's being taken care of shortly by my client to ensure that it doesn't cause any damage to the adjacent properties.

Similar wording

He's been in consultation with an arborist.

Similar wording

Along these empty lots here, my understanding is since this photo has been taken, when we get to the more recent photographs that I have, there is new construction here as well.

Similar wording

And we'll get to that in a moment.

Similar wording

This is just a little bit more zoomed in view of the block itself, taken directly from Google Maps at page four of my presentation packet.

Similar wording

This is taken from Google Maps as well.

Similar wording

This is looking westbound onto Manton Street from 25th Street.

Similar wording

There is new construction. Actually, it's already occurred in this corner lot here.

Similar wording

This is looking eastbound towards the viaduct that I was discussing earlier.

Similar wording

The subject lot, you can see where this tree is. It's off to the left.

Similar wording

And the houses you can see are generally elevated as you approach 25th Street,

Similar wording

whether that's due to the slope of the street and necessary drainage for the properties,

Similar wording

I'm not entirely sure, but as we approach Mantons, the steps for these houses do get higher.

Similar wording

And there's just another Google view of the property itself. Page eight, this is my client's

Similar wording

deed. This is the notification letter at page 17 that was sent out to all of the neighbors,

Similar wording

including a copy of the refusal page 19 we have a list of all the rcos and neighbors that received

Similar wording

a copy of the letter and there's the proof of mailing at page 24 page 25 as the chair noted

Similar wording

we do have this letter of opposition my recollection was initially it was one in favor to

Similar wording

oppose i'm i'm guessing that after there was additional discussion once we had left the

Similar wording

meeting. They changed the vote to three, no, zero, yes, but I'm not entirely sure why other than

Similar wording

the reasons that were told to us at the meeting, which were to the best of my recollection,

Similar wording

hey, our neighbors didn't show up. What's going on with that?

Similar wording

That's my client's commercial activity license, which we sent over this morning and I received

Similar wording

yesterday. That's a tax clearance for the property as well. Here's a photograph of the

Similar wording

property and the posting. There's the tree that we were discussing earlier. This is the new

Similar wording

construction that I was talking about. That's looking eastbound. I'm doing a 360 degree. This

Similar wording

is a recently converted factory, which I believe is a mix of commercial and residential uses.

Similar wording

this is new multi-family construction closer to the 26th street side of the block as you can see

Similar wording

same thing here and so we're not really seeking anything other than what already has existed

Similar wording

is existing on the block in terms of new construction the only difference between

Similar wording

these properties and the ones that we have is this towards the 26th street side of the block

Similar wording

is zoned residential multifamily, and we are zoned industrial. Otherwise, we wouldn't even

Similar wording

have to have gone through the zoning process. So what we're proposing is three stories with

Similar wording

the mezzanine with the sunken rear yard that's going to be accessed by the first floor unit.

Similar wording

We can go through the floor plans as well. We don't exceed 38 feet. We do have a roof deck

Similar wording

and pilot house. Those all comply with the setback requirements under the code.

Similar wording

so we'll start first with the first story and basement floor plans so there will be two front

Similar wording

doors in order to get to the first unit because this is a proposed three-unit building you would

Similar wording

enter through a door on the right entering through that door gets you into your living room

Similar wording

kitchen area dining room balcony and set us that's down lets you get into an office area

Similar wording

bathroom to the front, laundry across, mechanicals, another bathroom to the rear with a bedroom,

Similar wording

a full sliding door to a rear yard with steps to allow you to get the grade,

Similar wording

and that'll get you to this balcony area. In order to get to the units two and three,

Similar wording

there's going to be another door off to the left of the building.

Similar wording

You would enter into there and go up a set of stairs and go to the next page.

Similar wording

so you come up those stairs hang a right to get into unit two

Similar wording

this is also a one-bedroom unit kitchen to the front dining room living room area

Similar wording

mechanicals bathroom bedroom to the rear with a nice big window big closets

Similar wording

The third story has a mezzanine in addition to the third story as well, so that is going to be a two-bedroom unit with access to the roof deck.

Similar wording

the third story has a mezzanine in addition to

Similar wording

The balcony is going to be in the front here.

Similar wording

There's a bedroom, laundry, bathroom, living room, dining, and kitchen to the rear.

Similar wording

Then to get upstairs to that mezzanine level, you'd follow this little L-shaped staircase.

Similar wording

getting up into bedroom unit two and the ceiling would be open to the stories below

Similar wording

otherwise so there's a nice open ceiling area going from the second pardon me third story up

Similar wording

to the mezzanine area but this would otherwise be blocked off for some nice privacy for the

Similar wording

second bedroom area to get up to the roof deck you go up these stairs and here's our roof deck

Similar wording

pilot house again setback from the rear we have our five foot setback as required by code as well

Similar wording

so members of the board i would suggest to you that the reasons that we have presented for

Similar wording

our hardship in this matter namely the fact that this is a 17 foot wide parcel on a residential

Similar wording

block that is zoned industrial which is on a block that is otherwise residential multifamily presents

Similar wording

a hardship for development and what we're proposing would essentially be a by right proposal but for

Similar wording

the fact that we are zoned industrial on this residential multi-family block so my request would

Similar wording

be is that you find that we have presented evidence of hardship that you grant our request for

Similar wording

variances to build this residential multi-family building on a residential multi-family block

Similar wording

i would ask that my client be called so that we could get him to testify and adopt my testimony

Similar wording

he has his own thank you uh mr johnson would you please raise your hand if you're in the audience

Similar wording

and then they can get you in swear you in and then i can ask you a few questions

Similar wording

mr johnson has been allowed to speak please unmute yourself morning mr johnson could you

Similar wording

please state your name and spell for the course stenographer good morning uh my name is jamin

Similar wording

johnson j-a-m-i-n johnson j-o-h-n-s-o-n do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth

Similar wording

is nothing but the truth i do counsel proceed please now mr johnson you've heard my testimony

Similar wording

today with respect to your parcel at 2507 manton street is that true that is true and the testimony

Similar wording

that you've heard today regarding that parcel and what happened at the community meeting

Similar wording

is that correct as well that is correct is there anything you'd like to add to my testimony at this

Similar wording

point in time with respect to either the parcel itself the arborist that you've hired or the

Similar wording

community meeting that we had with the community organization and grace ferry

Similar wording

only that uh the testimony that you presented was in fact true and i do also ask for the granting

Similar wording

of this this by right scenario that unfortunately is not by right due to the industrial zoning

Similar wording

thank you one final question for you you've had the chance to speak with the neighbors on the

Similar wording

block about your proposal is that true and that is correct okay i have no further questions

Similar wording

thank you all the new construction areas multifamily that's my understanding members

Similar wording

of the board at least towards the 26th street ends um i'll admit the new construction at the

Similar wording

25th street end i don't recall off the top of my head what that was but i could look that up right

Similar wording

away if your chair would like to know that's fine that's fine questions from the board no

Similar wording

questions or comments from our attorney hillary emerson

Similar wording

not at this time mr chair questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

there are no hands chair um planning commission please good morning chair bergman this is ian

Similar wording

hegarty representing the philadelphia city planning commission last name is spelled h-e-g-a-r-t-y

Similar wording

do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Similar wording

yes sir please proceed thank you chair good morning board members the comprehensive plan

Similar wording

recommends a zoning map change from i2 to rsa 5 for this in the surrounding properties on this

Similar wording

block the proposed use doesn't conform to either the existing or the proposed zoning however the

Similar wording

lot size does we agree present a hardship for industrial use and the proposed use is consistent

Similar wording

with recent bioreg construction on this block face which is predominantly zoned for multifamily use

Similar wording

today. And so the city planning recommends that the board grant the variance.

Similar wording

thank you mi2023 002 636 2507 main street i vote yes

Similar wording

james snell my vote is yes ishmael shaheed my vote is yes

Similar wording

thank you members of the board have a great day

Similar wording

thank you take care everybody okay number eight mi2023 002 excuse me mr chair um can we just

Similar wording

jump we uh jump to number 11 quickly because that that matter needs to be um i believe we have a

Similar wording

request for continuance on that one because the rco meeting is not held okay thank you mi 2022

Similar wording

00672 8107 bradford street dan lee is the the owner applicant this is a pro se this is the fourth

Similar wording

flesh thing i have a hand up by the name of lee horn okay okay i will allow i believe that's the

Similar wording

rco um and we can and the rco is absolutely welcome to speak but i would like to hear from

Similar wording

um dan lee first i do see him okay in the audience yeah there's dan lee right there i will promote

Similar wording

okay thank you you're welcome

Similar wording

dan lee has been promoted mr lee state your name please and spell for the court stenographer

Similar wording

hello testing yes hi could you state your name and spell it please for the court stenographer

Similar wording

uh my name is dan lee first name b-a-n last name l-i right do you swear or affirm to tell

Similar wording

the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth i do could you put on your video please uh

Similar wording

okay thank you um mr lee this is the fourth listing of your case yes sure um and

Similar wording

we can't go on much more like this i mean it's just you know you you you haven't got the hold

Similar wording

of the rco until very late and um we will continue this but i would tell you that it'll be the fifth

Similar wording

listing if you're not ready this case is going to be dismissed you can't go on like this you you

Similar wording

you have your obligation is to get a hold of the rco yes okay and and and so what we're going to

Similar wording

do is i'm going to continue this one more time but after that that's it you understand all right

Similar wording

thank you all right hillary do we need to have the rco one um we can have them yeah we can i think

Similar wording

it will be helpful to have them come on to make sure that they are connected if the rco representative

Similar wording

is on please please read they're here hello hi good morning could you state your name please

Similar wording

and spell for the court stenographer lee horn l-e-e h-o-r-n-e right do you swear a firm to

Similar wording

tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth i do sir mr horn could you give us your

Similar wording

comments on this case uh i am the zoning chairman for ronhurst civic association yes i know that

Similar wording

you would receive the letter from me state uh a statement of no contact with the applicant

Similar wording

we have subsequent to that letter the applicant has reached out to the rco and affirmed their

Similar wording

desire to get this straightened out in the proper way the rco is willing to work with them to make

Similar wording

sure this gets done properly and that they can proceed with a proper zba hearing mr horn thank

Similar wording

you for taking the time the calls in we appreciate it you're welcome your time you you have to get

Similar wording

a hold of them work with them if not this case will be dismissed yes i will so mi 2022 000 672

Similar wording

8107 bradford street this case continued and is marked must be tried all right thank you guys thank

Similar wording

you okay let's go back here to number eight mi 2023 002 602 62 35 lancaster avenue

Similar wording

verne anastasio is the attorney

Similar wording

mr anastasio is coming back in as a panelist

Similar wording

good morning verne we've talked to you several times today uh you don't have to be sworn in

Similar wording

could you just state your name for the record yes sir verne anastasio on behalf of valerie todd

Similar wording

Yes, sir. Fern Anastasio, on behalf of Valerie Todd, agent for the property.

Similar wording

But he didn't.

Similar wording

Okay. And I take it she's the owner of the property?

Similar wording

She's the agent for the property.

Similar wording

Okay. Our vice chair has just a few questions.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Good morning, counsel. Do you agree to wave the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Have you emailed in all the required documents and exhibits that is needed and required to proceed with this case five days in advance of this hearing?

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Vern, just before you start, there's a chance I'm told from Hillary that we may have to have a corrected refusal referral for this?

Similar wording

Yeah, I mean, Mr. Chair, my position is, as it is often, that L&I does have the discretion to grant the relief that we'll be ultimately seeking.

Similar wording

However, I understand that Attorney Emerson does think that we should perhaps hold the vote

Similar wording

so that the change in the relief sought is actually documented by L&I.

Similar wording

I have no objection to that.

Similar wording

I just, you know.

Similar wording

Sure.

Similar wording

And Vern, that's where we'll be, okay?

Similar wording

We won't vote.

Similar wording

Yep.

Similar wording

Please proceed.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

I just want to note under separate cover, my office forwarded a memo brief that is going

Similar wording

to be part of the record, and I'm entering that into evidence as well this morning.

Similar wording

In addition to this binder of 6235 Lancaster Avenue, it's a 37-page binder.

Similar wording

The application is for event space. And the examiner, we believe the examiner, Ellen and I, erred in issuing this refusal. So no, I do not stipulate to the accuracy of this document because it's my understanding that based on the information and gleaned with my client, that this is going to be an event space for life events.

Similar wording

baby showers, funeral luncheons, and it's going to be for less than 50 people at any one time

Similar wording

in this commercial space. As a result, I believe this should be a referral and not a refusal

Similar wording

for a special exception because it is within the discretion of L&I to place this category

Similar wording

category outside of the nightclub and private club category, which is, in fact, where it is.

Similar wording

So that's the issue that we're dealing with. So if I said yes to the initial question,

Similar wording

whether I waive and stip, I do not waive and stip. But I do want to make sure that

Similar wording

we put it on the record that what we're seeking is just a special exception.

Similar wording

And on top of that, my client is seeking a temporary special exception of three years.

Similar wording

After having communication with the RCO, they obviously want to take a wait and see sort of attitude to make sure that this facility is going to be a benefit to the community.

Similar wording

And as a result, my client is looking for 49 folks, banquet event space, not open to the public whatsoever, no nightclub or private club or anything like that for no more than three years.

Similar wording

And with that, I want to show you the exterior space.

Similar wording

Can I ask, Vern, before you start, can I ask a question?

Similar wording

Is this also for two units above?

Similar wording

Well, which we believe were previously approved.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So, yeah, my client is focusing on the first floor, but yes,

Similar wording

we believe the two units above were previously approved.

Similar wording

Okay, thank you.

Similar wording

Yep.

Similar wording

So this is the commercial space on the, as you know,

Similar wording

lancaster avenue is a commercial uh corridor uh typically during the day it's very active

Similar wording

at night it is not as you can see here this is after five o'clock not a whole lot of action

Similar wording

going on in fact there's lots of parking spaces that are available on the street

Similar wording

you can see here the same and this is six seven o'clock in the evening

Similar wording

this is the interior of the space my client purchased the property and prior to her purchase

Similar wording

it was occupied as event space uh when she purchased the property she renovated it and

Similar wording

began to operate it again as event space uh for things like baby showers and wedding showers

Similar wording

again luncheons after uh funerals thinking that and being told by the seller that it in fact was

Similar wording

a legal permitted use it was not but she did operate for several months

Similar wording

It was not, but she did operate for several months with not one 3-1-1 call, not one 9-1-1 call, absolutely no incident, and it was a real benefit to the community.

Similar wording

Upon learning through LNI that she could not have this space without a use permit, she closed immediately, contacted my office, and we began the process.

Similar wording

when she made the application pro se i believe there may have been a miscommunication which

Similar wording

uh it ended up with a refusal when in fact uh we believe it was an error and it should have been a

Similar wording

referral as the space will never hold more than 49 people and again she's looking for

Similar wording

temporary variants we have commercial trash pickup lighting and security cameras surrounding

Similar wording

the entire property as you know as i said before lancaster avenue is in fact a commercial

Similar wording

corridor and we believe based on the history of the use and no instances during that time

Similar wording

that this use will not pose any detrimental impact to the community anymore

Similar wording

than a similarly situated facility of this kind here is the proof of mailing that my client did

Similar wording

herself. And we've submitted everything else as well.

Similar wording

Again, we also have a memo brief that we've submitted in advance. I'd like to move all

Similar wording

37 pages of this exhibit binder plus the memo brief into the record. And with that, I'd

Similar wording

like miss valerie todd to raise our virtual hand thank you thank you

Similar wording

miss todd will be allowed to speak good morning could you please state your name

Similar wording

and spell for the court stenographer good morning valerie v-a-l-a-r-i-e todd t-o-d-d

Similar wording

we're affirmed to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

yes i do please proceed counsel thank you mr chair miss todd did you hear the presentation i

Similar wording

made this morning to the board yes they're true and accurate to the best of your knowledge yes

Similar wording

and do you adopt it as your own testimony yes the true that your hours of operation will all be

Similar wording

in the afternoon like after 2 p.m uh and most events will be even after 4 or 5 p.m is that

Similar wording

right yes and you'll never be open later than midnight is that correct yes okay and during

Similar wording

that time those hours most of lancaster avenue is closed up is that correct yes okay with plenty

Similar wording

of ample on street parking about as the evidence suggests is that correct yes i have no further

Similar wording

questions thank you questions from the board no chair questions or comments from our attorney

Similar wording

hillary emerson um just briefly mr chair mr anastasio i couldn't find anything in the zoning

Similar wording

records or rental license history that indicated this property has been approved for two units

Similar wording

so i think it um it's the refusal should go back for both that and um to evaluate whether there

Similar wording

should it should be a referral for the assembling entertainment use um so i will i will reach out

Similar wording

to ellen i see if they want to review it on a correct basis or if we need to submit a formal

Similar wording

request for amendment and i will let you know i appreciate that thank you questions or comments

Similar wording

from the virtual audience yes chair i have a hand by the name of gregory allen and i will allow to

Similar wording

feet sure good morning mr allen good morning sir could you please state your name and spell for

Similar wording

the court stenographer mr allen mr allen can you unmute

Similar wording

i'm having a problem okay could you state your name please and spell for the court

Similar wording

sonographer okay just a second i'm having problems hearing you have two devices on

Similar wording

yes yes but i wasn't able to let me see if i can hear you

Similar wording

can you hear me we hear you now sir okay i can't hear you that's why i logged in the phone

Similar wording

can you hear us now can you hear us now and um on my laptop so um my name is gregory allen

Similar wording

so um my name is gregory allen i'm the chair of the overbrook west neighbors rco okay hold on

Similar wording

i'm the chair of the overbrook weather

Similar wording

hold on hold on do you swear for him to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

mr chair i can't hear you my laptop okay so reason that's why i'm gonna have to find a way

Similar wording

for you okay you're gonna have to call back in if you can

Similar wording

we got we have to be able to hear you um mr chair hi this is tanya if i may suggest

Similar wording

it's okay if they would submit something that we could accept your meeting id

Similar wording

if he wants to do that but we're having problems with him and we have to turn off

Similar wording

let me try to leave and come back and see if it would let me to be hers mr chair i have no

Similar wording

objection to permitting the witness to testify in writing uh subsequent to this okay since the

Similar wording

you can't vote on it anyway so it's fine by me i agree

Similar wording

let's see if he comes back on

Similar wording

i'll leave and log right back in see if that works then what mr allen can you hear us

Similar wording

I don't think he's been able to hear us.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Hillary, Tanya, is there a way that we could send him a message to do a written statement?

Similar wording

I would ask the ZBA staff to please reach out to him by text if that's possible and let him know when he comes back in.

Similar wording

Thank you, Kyrie Chair, for your service.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Thank you very much.

Similar wording

Is there anyone else in the virtual audience?

Similar wording

There are no hands, Chair.

Similar wording

Hillary, can we have Planning take a position?

Similar wording

If they wish, unless they want to hold for a practice.

Similar wording

Ian, are you comfortable with taking a position on this?

Similar wording

Yeah, thank you, Chair, for the opportunity.

Similar wording

I think that the facts of the case have been sufficiently demonstrated to the point where we would be comfortable going on record with a position here.

Similar wording

So, if that's all right, I'll proceed with that.

Similar wording

Yeah, Ian Hegarty for the Philadelphia City Planning Commission.

Similar wording

In 2018, the zoning map was amended here from CMX2 to CMX2.5 in accord with recommendations from the comprehensive plan.

Similar wording

The use that L&I has identified is not permitted under CMX2.5.

Similar wording

Specifically, that's assembly and entertainment.

Similar wording

And then a special specific category within assembly and entertainment for nightclubs and private clubs, which are defined in part by having more than 50 people attend.

Similar wording

And given that the given the size of the space and the applicant's intention, and we don't believe that more than 50 people would congregate here and that this would be more appropriately classified as assembly and entertainment without that special designation as nightclubs and private clubs, which, as counsel has indicated, would be a lower bar for approval by the board would be a special exception instead of a variant.

Similar wording

so in this case if the board is going to hold on this for an amended refusal we'll

Similar wording

take it from there but even with the facts that have been presented today the city planning

Similar wording

commission would recommend granting the variance with the stipulation that the use be limited to

Similar wording

assembly and entertainment for no more than 50 people okay um we'll close the record except for a

Similar wording

written document from the RCO

Similar wording

and everything else

Similar wording

is closed on it, and then we'll have the

Similar wording

amended refusal. Is that okay, Hillary?

Similar wording

Yes, that is fine.

Similar wording

Also, Mr. Anastasio, a chance to

Similar wording

respond to the written

Similar wording

document. Correct. Yes.

Similar wording

Okay. From the RCO. Yep.

Similar wording

Thank you, Mr. Anastasio. Thank you all.

Similar wording

Bye now.

Similar wording

Number

Similar wording

Number 18, MI 2023-001-044-2853 North Bailey Street.

Similar wording

Lynn Nichols is the attorney.

Similar wording

Letter of support from the Swamp Poodle Neighborhood Parcels Association with Provisors.

Similar wording

lynn nichols has been promoted to panelists good morning counsel could you state your name

Similar wording

please and spell for the court's sonography good morning lynn nichols l-y-n-n last name nichols

Similar wording

n-i-c-h-o-l-s right do you swear or firm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

yes i do could you identify your client in relationship to the property yes christopher

Similar wording

Keir is on the line and he is

Similar wording

the owner of the property.

Similar wording

And our vice chair has

Similar wording

just a few questions for you.

Similar wording

Good morning, Counselor. Do you agree to waive the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy?

Similar wording

Good morning, counsel. Do you agree to

Similar wording

waive the reading of the refusal and stipulate

Similar wording

to its accuracy?

Similar wording

Yes, I agree. With one caveat, we are reducing our requests from three to two units.

Similar wording

Understood. Have you emailed in all the required documents and exhibits that is needed and required to proceed with this case five days in advance of this hearing?

Similar wording

yes and my understanding is the rco did submit their letter of support and i know that um they

Similar wording

may be on the call also no problem please proceed thank you good morning can everyone see the screen

Similar wording

that i'm sharing now we can okay so in the packet we have our petition of appeal form

Similar wording

L&I project information form, deed, tax clearance, the list of impacted neighbors that were notified, proof of mailing, community letter, L&I refusal, photographs, zoning notice, site plan.

Similar wording

We submitted a sanitation plan after the meeting with the RCO.

Similar wording

We are in agreement completely with the stipulations that they're asking for with regard to sanitation.

Similar wording

So our plan is in here, but we're not asking for the board to approve it at all.

Similar wording

It's just in here because we already had it in the part of the packet and our meeting was on Monday.

Similar wording

So, you know, we didn't submit an amended packet.

Similar wording

Our appeal here is for property that was already developed as a duplex when Mr.

Similar wording

Keir purchased it. The hardship is that he economically, it would be a hardship for him to not have this as it's already been developed as a duplex.

Similar wording

Here we have the notice, I'm sorry, the site plan, which I will turn around for everyone to see.

Similar wording

Okay. Can everyone see that?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay. So on the first floor, when you enter the property, there's a one-bedroom apartment with a bathroom, a living room, and a kitchen.

Similar wording

it's a separate entrance already developed on the second floor when you walk up and what we

Similar wording

learned from the rco is that this is a trinity property which is property that um mostly you

Similar wording

see in south philadelphia but you have a second floor entrance separate entrance up the steps

Similar wording

into the um kitchen there's a bathroom there's a living room um on the second floor

Similar wording

as well as um what could be a bedroom here but it's not um here we have two bedrooms and a

Similar wording

bathroom on the um third floor so this property again was already developed as um a duplex before

Similar wording

mr care purchased it this is the front of the property it's a three-story building and it's

Similar wording

the only three-story on this block historically it's already been a three-story building again

Similar wording

we learned from the community that this is the way the property has been not um developed

Similar wording

but already you know having three stories this is a view looking to the left this is a view looking

Similar wording

to the right this is a view looking across from the property and this is the zoning notice that

Similar wording

was posted again we've submitted this trash plan but we're not asking the board to adopt it because

Similar wording

we're in agreement completely with the recommendation of the RCO with regard to all of the provisals

Similar wording

that they're asking for the board to append to this property.

Similar wording

At this time, I would like to call my client, Christopher Keir, to adopt the testimony that

Similar wording

I've provided.

Similar wording

Is this here?

Similar wording

Oh, yeah, there he is.

Similar wording

i will allow him to i will allow him to speak thank you you're welcome good morning sir could

Similar wording

you please state your name and spell for the court stenographer uh can you see me yes

Similar wording

my name is first name is christopher c-h-r-r-s-t-o-p-h-e-r last name is kia k as in kite e-a-r

Similar wording

Ross and Roberts. Do you swear or affirm

Similar wording

to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth? Yes.

Similar wording

Thank you. Mr. Keir, are you

Similar wording

the owner of the property at 2853 North Bailey Street?

Similar wording

Yes. And we attended an RCO meeting on Monday,

Similar wording

November 27th at 6 p.m., correct? Yes.

Similar wording

And at that time, you agreed to accept the provisos

Similar wording

and at that time you agreed to accept the provisos that the rco would recommend to the board

Similar wording

that the RCO

Similar wording

yes and are you in agreement with the testimony that i've given here today with regard to this

Similar wording

project at the property yes thank you i have nothing further questions from the board no chair

Similar wording

questions or comments from our attorney hillary emerson

Similar wording

yes mr chair i just wanted to to clarify um ms nichols the provisos that um are enforceable

Similar wording

by the board that were requested by the rco are maximum two dwelling units which you already

Similar wording

indicated was what what the ask was for relief now um interior storage of trash and recycling

Similar wording

no household living in the basement and no rooftop access structures are those all okay with your

Similar wording

client absolutely okay thank you so much questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

yes chair i have a hand up with the phone number last four numbers three five five two

Similar wording

and i will now to speak

Similar wording

good morning

Similar wording

good morning

Similar wording

morning

Similar wording

they're not muted hello i'm sorry i was muted good morning good morning could you state your

Similar wording

name and spell please for the court stenographer yes adrian fernandez my last name is spelled f-e-r-n-a-n-d-e-z

Similar wording

swamp little neighborhood parcels association rco right do you swear or affirm to tell the truth

Similar wording

the whole truth nothing but the truth yes please proceed um we um we submitted our written letter

Similar wording

of support with five provisos. And I understand that

Similar wording

four of them are enforceable. And the fifth

Similar wording

request, I understand that Attorney

Similar wording

Nichols will put that information into the lease

Similar wording

and probably email it to us. And that's everything

Similar wording

for this appeal address. Ms. Fernandez, thank you for taking the time

Similar wording

to call in. We appreciate it. Thank you, Ms. Fernandez. You're welcome.

Similar wording

do you hear anyone else in the virtual audience there are no hands here

Similar wording

planning commission thank you chair bergman ian hegarty for the philadelphia city planning

Similar wording

commission members of the board the comprehensive plan recommends no change to the existing rsa

Similar wording

five single family zoning at this location however we agreed the proposed use is consistent

Similar wording

with the existing bill condition of the property city planning commission recommends that the

Similar wording

board grant the variance including the proviso that no more than two dwelling units be permitted

Similar wording

thank you so mi2023 001 044 2853 north bailey street i vote yes with proviso maximum two dwelling

Similar wording

units interior trash and recycling interior storage of trash and recycling no household

Similar wording

living in the basement no rooftop access structures game snow my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

ishmael shaheed my vote is yes with proviso thank you council you have your votes thank you okay

Similar wording

is there anyone in the virtual audience who their 9 30 case has not been called

Similar wording

no hands chair thanks everyone see everyone at 2 p.m all right thanks

Similar wording

hey chair we have 48 attendees you can proceed as you wish

Similar wording

I'm sorry, Chair.

Similar wording

We have 48 attendees.

Similar wording

You can proceed as you wish.

Similar wording

Mr. Chair, can you hear us?

Similar wording

Let me try to call him. I don't think he can hear us.

Similar wording

yes there's something hey bill bill can you hear us

Similar wording

Yes, it's up.

Similar wording

Bill, can you hear us?

Similar wording

hello oh geez hold on okay all right

Similar wording

now we can hear you yeah perfect ish can you hear me yes yeah we can hear you now can hear you

Similar wording

can hear you you can proceed

Similar wording

hey yes yes yes i hung up already we can hear you

Similar wording

oh he can't hear us chair are you able to hear us

Similar wording

i'm not hearing anybody here oh wow

Similar wording

we're talking to log out and log back in yes please thank you

Similar wording

we're ready

Similar wording

chair we have 54 attendees you can proceed as you wish okay good afternoon everyone my name

Similar wording

is bill bergman and i will be chairing this afternoon's eba hearings with me as our vice

Similar wording

chair ismail shaheed president mr chairman our board member thomas hallman president mr chairman

Similar wording

or board member james snell president mr chairman we also have le baron leonard palmer who will be

Similar wording

serving as an auditor board member to vote on one matter this afternoon here's our and also present

Similar wording

is hillary emerson our attorney and our executive director tanya sunkin be advised the proceedings

Similar wording

are being recorded. The video will be available by contacting TanyaSunkit at phil.gov. For the

Similar wording

benefit of our court stenography, we ask attorneys and witnesses to identify themselves before

Similar wording

testifying. If you're participating by phone and you wish to testify, press star nine to raise your

Similar wording

hand and star six to unmute. To enter the period of statement, call 267-270-5548. Leave your email

Similar wording

and the address of the property in question and finally the question answer box on the screen is

Similar wording

not for comments or testimony all comments should be directed to our executive director tanya sunken

Similar wording

let's look at this afternoon schedule

Similar wording

number four on our list

Similar wording

number four mi2023 004 373 2242 to 50 north 9th street that case is continued

Similar wording

Number 5

Similar wording

MI 2022-001-797-2600 Montgomery Avenue

Similar wording

That case is continued, attorney moving party

Similar wording

And number 15

Similar wording

Number 15

Similar wording

MI-2023-004-440-2117

Similar wording

North 17th Street. That case is continued. Is there any other

Similar wording

requests for continuance?

Similar wording

Good afternoon, Chair. This is Doreen Blakely and I will co-host this afternoon. I have

Similar wording

Sean Ward with his hand up and I will allow him to speak.

Similar wording

Mr. Ward, for the record, could you state your name, please, and spell for the court stenographer?

Similar wording

Yes. Good afternoon, Mr. Chairman. Sean Ward, S-H-A-W-N-W-A-R-D, Esquire Attorney for Applicant on 2600 West Montgomery Avenue.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, I do.

Similar wording

Let me see the number. What number is that, Hillary?

Similar wording

that's number five mr chair you just continued that one cases continue it says attorney moving

Similar wording

party mr ward oh okay i'm sorry i missed that thank you very much and uh it's good to uh be

Similar wording

back i'm glad you're glad to see you back thank you very much bye-bye thank you

Similar wording

so case number 14 here excuse me chair um there were two other hands up

Similar wording

Okay, sure. Krista Stefkovic, I will allow her to speak.

Similar wording

Hi, could you state your name, please, and spell for the court stenographer?

Similar wording

Hi, yes. My name is Krista Stepkovic, K-R-I-S-T-A-S-T-E-F-K-O-V-I-C.

Similar wording

Hi, yes. My name is Krista Stefkovic, K-R-I-S-T-H.

Similar wording

Right. Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

What case are you interested in?

Similar wording

1807 Pine Street, which is 2023-005-230.

Similar wording

I see it here. Yes?

Similar wording

I represent 1809 Pine Street Associates, who is the owner of that property.

Similar wording

I'm from Eckert Seaman, Sharon and Mellott.

Similar wording

My address is 50 South 16th Street.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm, tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth, correct?

Similar wording

Correct.

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

So that case will be called eventually.

Similar wording

Do you have a comment about it now?

Similar wording

Yes, we are requesting a continuance.

Similar wording

Mr. Whalen is also an attorney in that matter? Am I right?

Similar wording

Yes, that's correct, Mr. Chair. He's the attorney for the owners.

Similar wording

Mr. Whalen?

Similar wording

I see his hand is raised.

Similar wording

Okay. Mr. Whalen?

Similar wording

Yes. Good afternoon, Chairman.

Similar wording

Could you state your name, Mr. Whalen, and spell for the courts?

Similar wording

Certainly. Sean Whalen, W-H-A-L-E-N, here today from Vintage Law on behalf of the

Similar wording

owner and applicant at 1807 pine street do you swear a firm to tell the truth the whole truth

Similar wording

nothing but the truth yes i do so why don't we let the first council go first and say why

Similar wording

they need a continuance great thank you um i represent 1809 pine street associates who is

Similar wording

the owner of the property located at 1809 pine street which is immediately adjacent to the

Similar wording

property for which the variance is being sought i'm requesting a continuance as my client just

Similar wording

found out about this from the ccra newsletter this past monday november 27th my client didn't

Similar wording

receive any notice and there was a defect in the posting on the property we know that this wasn't

Similar wording

posted on the back of the property as required on panama street and that wasn't posted for at

Similar wording

least some period of time as we have photos from monday and yesterday the 28th that show no posting

Similar wording

my client has been at the property in the past three weeks and has not once seen a posting on

Similar wording

the back he wouldn't have seen the front door as he enters from the back parks in the back

Similar wording

and all of the parking um on the street is in the back so perhaps the posting fell down or was

Similar wording

ripped down but the photos we have show no posting um would you like me to share my screen

Similar wording

to show those photos why don't why don't we let mr whalen speak first okay mr whalen thank you

Similar wording

chairman i'm i'm happy to address this in full and was prepared for this uh this matter actually went

Similar wording

it was uh properly noticed through ccra um in fact we had a first here at first meeting with ccra

Similar wording

back in september there was a second meeting last night where we made changes relevant to ccra's

Similar wording

questions. Mr. Rosenblum is the owner at 1809 that I apologize miss I missed your name is

Similar wording

representing and he appeared last night. He admitted that he saw his address on the address

Similar wording

list of notification but stated he didn't receive it. He has been in contact with the owner and

Similar wording

through CCRA. There's no basis here for not proceeding. We will address that the property

Similar wording

was properly posted both in the front and the rear timely. The photo that Mr. Rosenblum has

Similar wording

shared with me earlier this week is post that large Thanksgiving storm, and the property was

Similar wording

reposted as soon as we realized that the posting in the rear was done on a door, which does not

Similar wording

have an overhang or a covering and was cleared off and so i will have a third party expediter

Similar wording

ready to testify she's not on the call yet but i told her we're number 16 on the list so she wasn't

Similar wording

she'll jump on soon so uh counsel we're going to go on with this and um you'll have a chance um

Similar wording

stephan kovic you'll have a chance to make your case okay okay thank you we are going to go on

Similar wording

this today okay thank you thank you is there anyone else with your hand up i do see martin

Similar wording

rosen bloom with a hand up he's i believe he's a part of what y'all was just talking about yeah i

Similar wording

think i think he he will have his opportunity at appropriate time okay thank you is there

Similar wording

anyone else with their hand up for continuance no more handshare and i have mi 2022

Similar wording

no more handshare and i have mi 2022 005 303 4140 poplar street jeffrey young is the attorney

Similar wording

uh this is the fourth listing and the council member has uh

Similar wording

um has uh requested a continuance or a dismissal uh is mr young in the audience

Similar wording

i do not see jeffrey young in the audience i understand mr young is in the process of

Similar wording

transitioning his cases this case here we will uh list must be tried one more time

Similar wording

so mi 2022 005 303 4140 poplar street this case is continued mark must be tried

Similar wording

we're going to go to our add-on list

Similar wording

Number one, MI 2023-000-461-186-Willa Grove Avenue.

Similar wording

I vote yes.

Similar wording

Permended refusal dated 10-11-23.

Similar wording

Commercial trash pickup, no limited lodging.

Similar wording

james snell my vote is yes proviso ishmael shahi my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

tom okay we have three votes there he wasn't present for that case mr chair thank you

Similar wording

number two mi 2023 001 382 1919 west hunting park avenue i vote yes with proviso hours of operation

Similar wording

682p thomas holloman my vote is yes with provisos james snell my vote is yes with provisos

Similar wording

Number three, MI 2022-003-989-2851, Bodine Street, my vote is yes for reconsideration and hearing.

Similar wording

James Snell, my vote is yes to reconsideration and rehearing.

Similar wording

Ishmael Shaheed, my vote is yes for reconsideration and rehearing.

Similar wording

Number four, MI 2023-002-766-11 Schurz Lane, I vote no to reconsideration and hearing.

Similar wording

Thomas Holloman, my vote is no to reconsideration and rehearing.

Similar wording

James Snell, my vote is no to reconsideration and rehearing.

Similar wording

Ishmael Shaheed, my vote is no for reconsideration and rehearing.

Similar wording

Thank you. Number five, MI 2022-007-291-430 West Berks. At the request of the applicant, the vote in this matter is being rescheduled to Wednesday, January 10th, 2024 at 2 p.m.

Similar wording

number six mi2023 003 241 1607 209 ridge avenue

Similar wording

i vote yes temporary variance expires 12-1-26

Similar wording

thomas holloman my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

james snell my vote is yes with proviso ishmael shaheed my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

number seven mi 2023 38 49 fairmount avenue i vote yes thomas hallman is also vent and also leonard

Similar wording

James Snell my vote is yes

Similar wording

Ishmael Shaheed my vote is yes

Similar wording

Thomas Holloman

Similar wording

Thomas Holloman my vote is yes

Similar wording

Leonard

Similar wording

excuse me

Similar wording

my vote is yes

Similar wording

thank you

Similar wording

Mr. Chair I just wanted to note that

Similar wording

Mr. Shaheed was accused on this matter

Similar wording

and Mr. Snell wasn't present for the hearing

Similar wording

So we needed you, LeBaron, and Mr. Hallibank to vote.

Similar wording

We have the three votes.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Yes, thank you.

Similar wording

So MI 2023-002-463-7811 Frankfurt Avenue.

Similar wording

I vote yes.

Similar wording

i vote yes temporary variance expires 12-1-26 use limited to ultrasound testing

Similar wording

Temporary variance expires.

Similar wording

thomas holliman my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

james snell my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

thank you we have our vote

Similar wording

Mr. Chair, we need Mr. Shahid to vote on the last one because Mr. Snell wasn't present

Similar wording

for the hearing.

Similar wording

Ishmael Shahid, my vote is yes, we're provisor.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

We're going to go to our regular list.

Similar wording

We're going to start with number seven and number 12 at the same time, MI 2023, 004-449-2706

Similar wording

Next, Federal Street, and number 12 is MI 2023-004-445-2708 Federal Street.

Similar wording

Henry Clinton is the attorney.

Similar wording

There is a letter of support from residents organized for adequacy and direction, and the applicant provided a petition in support by approximately 13 neighbors.

Similar wording

henry clinton has been promoted to panelists

Similar wording

mr clinton could you please state your name is spelled for the court stenographer

Similar wording

mr clinton

Similar wording

i did i saw his name there and i put it on is this is this might be his number here six ones

Similar wording

Yeah, so this phone number is him calling in, and then his paralegal is going to be

Similar wording

running the presentations because he is out of the country right now.

Similar wording

So she may be under his name.

Similar wording

Okay, I did promote his name.

Similar wording

Okay, that would be Margie.

Similar wording

Should I promote this phone number, Hillary, please?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Yes, yes, please.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

you both should be allowed to speak hi mr clinton

Similar wording

i believe it's star six to unmute yourself

Similar wording

mr clinton

Similar wording

the name henry clinton has disappeared off the the list let's see if he calls back

Similar wording

mr clinton

Similar wording

hello mr chairman i hear you hello mr chairman henry just for the record and please spell for

Similar wording

the court stenographer sure henry clinton uh h-e-n-r-y clinton c-l-i-n-t-o-n right do you

Similar wording

swear for him to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth i do would you identify

Similar wording

your client and the relationship to the property sure i represent three clients uh it's a father

Similar wording

and two children father is angelo tartaglini t-a-r-t-a-g-l-i-n-i daniel tartaglini and erica

Similar wording

e-r-i-k-a tartaglini today daniel tartaglini will be my witness and uh our vice chair has

Similar wording

just a few questions sir uh this is one of them i had to refuse myself once i think uh

Similar wording

tom could you do a time please yes mr chairman

Similar wording

good afternoon council do you agree to waive the reading of the refusal

Similar wording

and stipulate to his accuracy i do mr holliman did you email all of the exhibits and documents

Similar wording

as required five days in the pants to this hearing

Similar wording

i did the rco letter came in late and then our petition we added a couple more signatures

Similar wording

rather than what was submitted originally other than that yes thank you please proceed and share

Similar wording

please proceed and share your screen thank you mr

Similar wording

your screen thank you mr hollman

Similar wording

your paralegals online henry yes he's sharing the screen now okay thank you

Similar wording

and thank you for the accommodation mr chairman that's well appreciated

Similar wording

And there will be that green share button at the bottom of your screen on Zoom.

Similar wording

And just make sure you have the documents open before you hit that green share button.

Similar wording

Should be shared?

Similar wording

It's not shared.

Similar wording

once you click that green button it should ask you uh what document

Similar wording

you would like to share and then you'll click on that and hit that share button

Similar wording

um yep and it's up now thank you thank you so much you're welcome please proceed henry

Similar wording

thank you sir chairman again henry clinton for the tardiglini family angelo daniel and erica

Similar wording

uh and this concerns two properties on federal street and we have two presentations today mr

Similar wording

chairman 2706 and 2708 federal they both have separate mi numbers but the refusals are the same

Similar wording

and the projects are the same so what i'd like to do with your permission is to present 2706

Similar wording

and indicate that it's also the same as 2708.

Similar wording

It's basically presentations, or rather than doing two,

Similar wording

I'll do one and incorporate everything from 26 into 2708,

Similar wording

if that's okay with the chairman.

Similar wording

Please proceed.

Similar wording

So this is a request for a three-family dwelling on a large lot that's 15 by 100

Similar wording

in an ITE industrial zoning district,

Similar wording

where if we were proceeding under an RM zoning district,

Similar wording

we would be able to build four family dwellings on each parcel.

Similar wording

The request today is that we are asking for three family dwellings on each parcel,

Similar wording

each with two parking spaces.

Similar wording

As the chairman knows, in RM1, parking would not be required,

Similar wording

but here, in deference to the community's wishes,

Similar wording

each three family dwelling will have two parking spots.

Similar wording

These lots, and I'll get to that with aerial photographs, but these lots are through streets from federal to man.

Similar wording

So the second page is the table of contents.

Similar wording

Table of contents contains exhibits A1 through A11 with all the typical documents you would see in a zoning presentation,

Similar wording

including six zoning records indicating to the panel that this block is really not being used as industrial.

Similar wording

it's multifamily, some single family, and then some vacant lots. And both of these lots have

Similar wording

been vacant for at least five years. Next document is the refusal. And at the top,

Similar wording

you can see zoning district is I-2, it's industrial, and it's being refused the

Similar wording

application because multifamily household living is not permitted in an I-2 zoning district.

Similar wording

The next document is the RCO letter of support.

Similar wording

And you'll see in one of the additional documents,

Similar wording

I have actually a travel advisory from the night of the community group presentation.

Similar wording

It happened to be October 17th.

Similar wording

So there weren't a lot of people at the meeting, but they did vote in support of the meeting.

Similar wording

On October 17th, there was a Phillies game, a Flyers game, and a soccer game.

Similar wording

So that's why we went around the neighborhood and tried to get as many signatures as we could on a petition supporting the project, and that is in my packet, too.

Similar wording

Next is an aerial photograph.

Similar wording

This is looking south, and you can see where it says 2706 Federal Street.

Similar wording

There are two parcels there, 2706 and 2708.

Similar wording

You can see to the right, there's garages, actually four roll-top gates with curb cuts.

Similar wording

The only industrial that I'm familiar with on this block, Mr. Chairman, is an ironworks.

Similar wording

It's a gentleman who does, actually, he signed the petition.

Similar wording

He does ornamental iron for residential single-family and commercial, like railings, grab bars, and things like that.

Similar wording

the remainder of the block on the right-hand side has either been approved for multifamily

Similar wording

has either been approved for multifamily or is multifamily.

Similar wording

or is multifamily and when i get to the end of the

Similar wording

And when I get to the end of the presentation,

Similar wording

I have an aerial photograph with the multifamily demarcated

Similar wording

so that the panel can see exactly what is multifamily on the block,

Similar wording

what is vacant, and what is single-family.

Similar wording

The next group of photographs just show the vacant lot, again, looking southbound.

Similar wording

And then there's a few photographs looking eastbound

Similar wording

to show you the curb cuts that are existing already on Federal Street,

Similar wording

and you can see the roll-top gates in front of some of the garages on the block.

Similar wording

Then the larger photograph depicts Manton Street,

Similar wording

which is, as I said, the lot runs all the way from Federal to Manton.

Similar wording

It's 100 feet deep, and you can see that there are curb cuts on Manton Street.

Similar wording

There's no parking on Manton Street,

Similar wording

So we're providing two parking spots for each project.

Similar wording

The remaining photographs are photographs of the posting of the notices to the community about the hearing.

Similar wording

Next, we'll move on to the plans.

Similar wording

The first plan is the zoning plan, which shows a tire brick front.

Similar wording

The community group wants to see brick as much as possible.

Similar wording

um also there's a pilot house at the top there's a rooftop deck

Similar wording

then we can move on to the floor plans again these are three units mr chairman uh the basement

Similar wording

the first floor uh is one unit uh the first floor and second floor is the second unit and the third

Similar wording

second and third floor is a third unit now i brushed over this not not because i'm trying to

Similar wording

not bring it to your attention, but the first floor and basement is one unit in the sense that

Similar wording

the rear of the first floor is a bedroom for the basement. And so then the first floor and the

Similar wording

second floor, the rear bedroom on the second floor belongs to the first floor. And then the

Similar wording

second and third floor are their own units. And then there's a rooftop deck. We're going to have

Similar wording

Trash storage in the rear yards of both properties with containers

Similar wording

so that the tenants can come down and place their trash there on a regular basis.

Similar wording

Beyond the floor plans and the zoning plan,

Similar wording

we do have streets approval for both parking on both Federal Street as well as Manton Street.

Similar wording

The rest of the documents, we have an application for appeal.

Similar wording

We have the project information form.

Similar wording

We have the tax balance for a real estate printout indicating zero balance.

Similar wording

And then, Margie, if you can move down to the zoning district map, the colored map,

Similar wording

and you can see that the entire federal street of both sides of the block are I2 industrial.

Similar wording

Next is the deed indicating ownership by the Tardiglini family.

Similar wording

Then we have our notices to all the neighbors.

Similar wording

We mailed out 164 pieces of mail to the surrounding neighborhood.

Similar wording

And then the photograph I do want to spend some time on is the aerial photograph where I've marked in red the multifamily properties already on the block.

Similar wording

If you start from right to left, at the corner is a bar.

Similar wording

It's a 1201 bar.

Similar wording

It's been there for decades, at least 50 years.

Similar wording

moving right to left next is a 24 unit apartment building which was approved around two to three

Similar wording

years ago to the left of that is an approval for two dwellings that they're in the making

Similar wording

i was able to obtain that approval from the board about two years ago to the left of the two unit

Similar wording

dwelling is a four unit approved dwelling unit again that construction has not started and then

Similar wording

And as you move further left, you can see there's garages.

Similar wording

The first garage is where Mr. Breen has his ornamental iron business.

Similar wording

And then the other garage is storage, actually storage for my clients who operate a marble and granite business for well over 50 years at 25th and Ellsworth.

Similar wording

And then you can see the blank space, 270608 Federal Street.

Similar wording

That's where our proposed project is to be located.

Similar wording

And then in the foreground of the photograph, there's a six-unit apartment building.

Similar wording

Even though there is facing on Grace Ferry Avenue, that address is Federal Street.

Similar wording

And then to the left of that is another three-unit apartment building on the block.

Similar wording

And the following documents are the support for what I just related to the board.

Similar wording

These are the zoning records that reflect 2736 is 24 units.

Similar wording

That reflects 2736 is 24 units, 2731 is the next entry, that's the six-family dwelling, 2728, that's a four-family dwelling, 2721, that is a three-family dwelling, and 2732 is a two-family dwelling.

Similar wording

So in conclusion, Mr. Chairman, this is a block.

Similar wording

While it is zoned I-2, we try to design the building pursuant to RM1 regulations

Similar wording

because there are multifamily on the block, and it's trending multifamily as we move forward.

Similar wording

If we were in RM1 zoning district, we'd be able to build four units per lot by right with no parking.

Similar wording

we're seeking three units with parking on both 2706 and 2708 and again I ask that my presentation

Similar wording

for 2706 is duplicative of 2708 and I guess I can address that if the chairman is going to call

Similar wording

as a separate item. With that, I would ask the panel to consider this

Similar wording

application. We're not impacting anyone's latent error. We're in conformance with what the community

Similar wording

group wants. We're in conformance with the block and we are in harmony generally with the code.

Similar wording

So with that, I would conclude the testimony and ask for my client to adopt it and unmute himself.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Mr. Tartaglini, can you raise your hand, please?

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Mr. Tartaglini has been allowed to speak.

Similar wording

He's been allowed to speak.

Similar wording

Mr. Tartaglini, could you please state your name and spell for the court stenographer?

Similar wording

mr tartaglini mr tartaglini can you unmute yourself please yes i'm sorry can you hear

Similar wording

me yeah we can just name and please spell for the court stenographer sure my name is

Similar wording

Daniel Tartaglini

Similar wording

my D-A-N-I-E-L

Similar wording

last name

Similar wording

Tartaglini

Similar wording

T as in Tom

Similar wording

A-R-T-A-G-L-I-N-I

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm

Similar wording

to tell the truth

Similar wording

the whole truth

Similar wording

and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

Proceed, counsel.

Similar wording

Mr. Tartaglini

Similar wording

were you on the call

Similar wording

when I presented

Similar wording

your two projects

Similar wording

2706 and 2708

Similar wording

Federal Street?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And if you had

Similar wording

the opportunity

Similar wording

to testify in either one of those cases and or in both of those cases would you adopt my testimony

Similar wording

as your own and as true and correct yes sir thank you mr tardiglini questions thank you

Similar wording

no mr chairman no chair no chair questions or comments from our attorney hillary emerson

Similar wording

just a quick clarification um mr clinton are the parking spaces that are proposed one in the front

Similar wording

and one in the back of each property are those existing or are those new curb cuts that are

Similar wording

proposed right they are not existing they are they are new uh curb cuts for each okay they they came

Similar wording

up as existing on the plans that's why i was confused um so i think there may be i think

Similar wording

there may be a misrefusal then for the front loaded the front loaded parking um i will just

Similar wording

note that you know for the record okay thank you you know miss emery miss emerson i think that

Similar wording

they're the curb cuts that are there are so old and depressed i think uh they probably were

Similar wording

grandfathered in but i didn't want to say that they were because we still went and got streets

Similar wording

approval no problem no problem thank you from the virtual audience yes chair i have a person with

Similar wording

the phone number last for number seven seven nine eight i will allow to speak okay hi could you

Similar wording

state your name please and spell for the court stenographer hello do we see their hand the hand

Similar wording

i lowered the hand because i i did allow them to speak okay

Similar wording

hi could you state your name please okay here he is again okay hi could you state your name

Similar wording

Hi, could you state your name, please?

Similar wording

please and spell for the court stenographer caller with the phone number ending in seven

Similar wording

seven nine eight can you please unmute hello hi hi can you state your name hi could you

Similar wording

state your name and then spell for the court sonographer

Similar wording

edon schlomo for edon last name schlomo s-h-l-o-m-o right do you swear or affirm to tell

Similar wording

the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth i do are you a neighbor yeah i'm a near

Similar wording

i'm a near neighbor i'm a block away on 2500 federal okay please proceed i just want to say

Similar wording

I approve of these, or I think these projects to go ahead are approved.

Similar wording

I'm hoping they do.

Similar wording

Right now, they're just empty lots, and we really look forward to having some new construction projects there.

Similar wording

It's going to make the neighborhood more accessible, safe, clean,

Similar wording

and the developer worked with us in the community meetings or in the past well

Similar wording

just to make sure that our voices are heard,

Similar wording

and they added uh safety measures um to make sure that everything is added included and uh

Similar wording

i'm really appreciate we're we're i really appreciate that all right thank you for

Similar wording

taking the time to call and we appreciate it is there anyone else in the virtual audience

Similar wording

no hands chair hi planning commission

Similar wording

good afternoon chair peter bernard for the planning commission

Similar wording

peter could you spell your name please for the court stenographer yes i can p-e-t-e-r b as in

Similar wording

boy is an apple r as in roger and as a nancy is an apple r as in roger d as in dog you swear

Similar wording

a firm to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth i do chair please proceed

Similar wording

the comprehensive plan recommends a change to irmx industrial residential mixed use at these

Similar wording

locations we feel these proposals are largely consistent with the recommended zoning accordingly

Similar wording

the planning commission recommends the board grant the variances thank you hillary do we have to hold

Similar wording

the vote to make that correction um because it's not clear the status of the curb cuts mr chair

Similar wording

and they already got street approval um i think i think we're okay um on this and we can vote and

Similar wording

we can vote them together all right thank you number seven mi 2023 004 449 2706 federal street

Similar wording

and number 12 mi 2023 004 445 2708 federal street i vote yes to both

Similar wording

thomas holloman my vote is yes to both james snell my vote is yes to both

Similar wording

ishmael shaheed my vote is yes to both thank you mr clinton thank you mr chairman again thank you

Similar wording

for the accommodations very much appreciate it okay thank you we're going to go to our regular

Similar wording

List number one, MI 2023-005-681-2358, East Susquehanna.

Similar wording

Burn Anastasio is the attorney.

Similar wording

There's a letter of support from the Fishtown Neighbors Association, unanimous.

Similar wording

There's a letter of non-opposition from Council Member Squilla,

Similar wording

and the applicant also provided a petition in support signed by approximately 111 neighbors.

Similar wording

along with a letter of support from an adjacent neighbor

Similar wording

verne anastasio is coming back in as a panelist

Similar wording

good afternoon again mr chair just for the record state your name mr anastasio

Similar wording

yeah verne anastasio could you identify your client the relationship to this property

Similar wording

yes sir i'm representing will france boyas who is the owner of the property

Similar wording

and our vice chair has just a few questions thank you

Similar wording

Good afternoon, counsel. Do you agree to waive the reading of the refusal and stipulate

Similar wording

to its accuracy?

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

Will you email, then, all the required documents and exhibits that is needed and required

Similar wording

to proceed with this case in advance of this hearing?

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

Thank you. Please share your screen.

Similar wording

Thank you, I intend to, right, should work now, yeah, sometimes it's smooth and sometimes

Similar wording

sometimes it's smooth and sometimes it's not so maybe one second

Similar wording

there it is we've got a 69 page exhibit binder of evidence at 2358 east susquehanna avenue

Similar wording

the application is for the relocation of lot lines from two to one i'm sorry from one to one

Similar wording

and for basically a legalization of a four-family dwelling.

Similar wording

It is CMX2.

Similar wording

We have two decks also on the property that were proposed.

Similar wording

The decks had some setback issues,

Similar wording

which is their primary refusal.

Similar wording

And then we've got, because it's CMX2,

Similar wording

there is a commercial requirement on the first floor

Similar wording

that we are not meeting.

Similar wording

and for all intents and purposes they're the two material refusals here is the block

Similar wording

consolidation plan that's already been signed off and yep right there in addition we have

Similar wording

let's give you some exterior

Similar wording

elevation, the proposed south elevation.

Similar wording

Again, this is an existing structure.

Similar wording

Then we've got our interior layout, drawn to scale.

Similar wording

For each of the four units, here's additional renderings that show the two decks, one here

Similar wording

and one here.

Similar wording

Property will be owner-occupied in addition to the three other units.

Similar wording

property has been in major disarray for quite some time on a very high visible section in

Similar wording

Fishtown with Kalia and Soraya right around the corner. I mean, lots of folks see this corner.

Similar wording

And one of the reasons why we were able to get unanimous support from all immediate neighbors

Similar wording

and the RCO was because my client is going to be breathing new life with some landscaping and

Similar wording

and a small mural, and really doing justice to this otherwise dilapidated property.

Similar wording

Each unit has its own entrance, which is unique as well.

Similar wording

Here's the property in question, interior.

Similar wording

Robert Hopkinson, previous owner, Frankenstein, this property never consolidated the lots.

Similar wording

And as such, my client is ready, willing and able to not only consolidate and get the use squared

Similar wording

away, but then go through the process of getting a proper CO with all the health and safety and

Similar wording

building code requirements that it would entail.

Similar wording

As previously stated, we had a meeting with the Fishtown Neighbors Association.

Similar wording

Here is one of the letters that was sent out.

Similar wording

We have a copy of my appeal as well in here.

Similar wording

and we also have proof of mailing signatures of support letters from immediate neighbors

Similar wording

as well as under separate email a letter from fishtown neighbors and of course

Similar wording

council member mark squilla 190 individual households were placed on notice it was a very

Similar wording

well attended rco meeting as is the typically the case in fishtown and we are very pleased to bring

Similar wording

this project not only to the community but to this board because of the pre-existing non non-conforming

Similar wording

for family dwelling because it's a very large property that's been neglected for quite some time

Similar wording

already frankenstein we ask that the consolidation be approved uh the use be approved as well and

Similar wording

those decks, which will provide much needed eyes and ears on the sidewalk, according to

Similar wording

the neighbors, be approved as well. With that, I'd like to have Mr. Wilfrance, please raise

Similar wording

his virtual hand so we can get him to testify.

Similar wording

Wilfrance, Mr. Wilfrance is allowed to speak.

Similar wording

Yes. Hello, everyone. Can you hear me?

Similar wording

sir could you state your name and spell please for the court stenographer my name is will france

Similar wording

that's w as in willing i as enlisted l as in love f as in fun r as in rare a as an apple n as a nancy

Similar wording

F as in fun, R as in rare, A as in apple, N as in Nancy, C as in care, E as in extra, last name, who, yes, P as in person, O as in out, U as in under, Y as in year, E as in extra, S as in Sam.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth to hold truth enough about the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

Proceed, counsel.

Similar wording

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

Will, did you hear my presentation to the board this afternoon?

Similar wording

Yes, I did.

Similar wording

is it true and accurate to the best of your knowledge yes it is i mean i don't recall if

Similar wording

you um mentioned a letter of support by the neighbor i did yep it's all and all 69 pages

Similar wording

in addition to the letter of a council member have been submitted into evidence is it uh and

Similar wording

do you adopt it all as i presented as your own testimony yes sir thank you i have nothing further

Similar wording

questions from the board no mr chairman

Similar wording

questions or comments from our attorney hillary emerson

Similar wording

not at this time chair questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

yes chair robert everett has a hand up and i will allow him to speak

Similar wording

hi could you state your name please and spell for the court stenographer

Similar wording

yes good afternoon first name is robert r-o-b-e-r-t last name everett e-v-e-r-e double t

Similar wording

right do you swear or firm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

yes i do sir are you a neighbor i am a neighbor i'm also on the fna zoning committee

Similar wording

please proceed sir just want to confirm everything uh mr anastasio said is correct

Similar wording

It was all talked over extensively at the meeting, and everyone is very excited to have Will France join us in our community and get that property fixed up.

Similar wording

And just real quick, our letter of support, I drafted it, our chairman sent it.

Similar wording

It had the wrong MI and ZP number.

Similar wording

So if you need a corrected one, I can send that in to you.

Similar wording

I think our testimony will be enough, but thank you.

Similar wording

We appreciate it.

Similar wording

um is there anyone else in the virtual audience

Similar wording

there are no more hands here planning commission

Similar wording

good afternoon chair peter bernard for the planning commission

Similar wording

please proceed the comprehensive plan recommends no change to the existing cmx3 commercial mixed

Similar wording

use zoning at this location we feel the applicant has demonstrated sufficient hardship accordingly

Similar wording

the Planning Commission recommends the Board grant the variances. Thank you. MI 2023-005-681-2358

Similar wording

East Susquehanna Avenue. I vote yes, proviso, per refusal dated 9-26-23.

Similar wording

Thomas Holloman, my vote is yes, with proviso.

Similar wording

James Snell, my vote is yes, with proviso.

Similar wording

Thank you all.

Similar wording

Thank you, counsel. Number two, MI 2023-004-198-1603 Annan Street. Alan Nockamson is the attorney. Letter of support from East Point Breeze Neighbors Association provides a three-year temporary variance.

Similar wording

applicant also provided a petition of support from 16 neighbors along with eight form letters

Similar wording

of support uh mr knockamson

Similar wording

alan knockamson has been promoted to panelists thank you

Similar wording

good afternoon could you state your name please and spell for the court stenographer

Similar wording

yes alan knockamson a-l-a-n last name knockamson n-o-c-h-u-m-s-o-n

Similar wording

do you swear a firm to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Could you identify your client in a relationship to this property?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

My client is Nathaniel Itescu, the owner of the property.

Similar wording

And our vice chair has just a few questions.

Similar wording

Is this Edmund Street, Chair?

Similar wording

This is number two.

Similar wording

It's 1603 Annan Street.

Similar wording

Okay. Do you agree to weigh the reading of the refusal to stipulate towards accuracy?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Have you emailed in all the required documents and exhibits that is needed and required to proceed with this case five days in advance of this hearing?

Similar wording

Yes, we have.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

All right, so we're here to present 1603 Annan Street.

Similar wording

This proposal is for legalization of an Airbnb.

Similar wording

So first of all, we'll review the notice of refusal, then a letter of support from the East Point Breeze Neighbors Association.

Similar wording

In addition to getting support of the association, as well as the individuals who appeared at the community meeting, we also canvassed the neighborhood where my client obtained a decent amount of signatures that were attached to a petition, as well as letters of support.

Similar wording

I believe the immediate neighbor, 1601 Allen Street, also signed one of those petitions or letters.

Similar wording

Having an Airbnb is not uncommon in this neighborhood.

Similar wording

So we did a review of nearby visitor accommodation listings, and we provided a map to show that,

Similar wording

as well as the VRBO listing for the property to show, like, you know, the ward, what the property is all about.

Similar wording

Mr. Itescu is a responsible Airbnb operator. He has quiet hours from 10 p.m. to 6 a.m. He fines his occupants if there's unnecessary noise or rule violations.

Similar wording

He has agreed to put remote sound monitors in the property in case there's issues with noise.

Similar wording

And he has security cameras surrounding the exterior and the shared hallway of the property as well.

Similar wording

And he provides his contact information on the property itself.

Similar wording

And people in the neighborhood know who he is.

Similar wording

After looking at the listing, we'll review the maps of the area.

Similar wording

photographs of the property as well as uh you know from an exterior point of view as well as

Similar wording

an interior point of view or a simple plan like floor plan of the property um our rco meeting

Similar wording

notice um our application for appeal our deeds of property showing that mr detescue is the owner of

Similar wording

the property and a certificate of tax clearance showing that he owes no real estate taxes uh with

Similar wording

regards to this property at the conclusion of my presentation i would ask that mr detescue virtually

Similar wording

raise his hand, be sworn in, and then we can ask him some questions about our presentation.

Similar wording

The notice of refusal, so this is an RSA-5 property. We're not looking to increase density

Similar wording

here in any way. We're having single-family use. We're not renting by the room. All we're looking

Similar wording

to do is visit accommodations in an existing structure. Mr. Ittescu purchased the property

Similar wording

in 2017 with that intended purpose. And it would be a hardship on him for him to rent this for

Similar wording

long-term accommodations. Again, Mr. Teske is a well-known figure in the neighborhood. People

Similar wording

know who he is. He makes sure that people have contact information if there are issues, whether

Similar wording

it's long-term or short-term, but here short-term. And because of that, he receives support from the

Similar wording

community uh at large um if you look at it there are only two affected properties um who attended

Similar wording

the meeting and both individuals support the project as well so the people who are most

Similar wording

directly impacted are in support of this uh use and again as the mr chair stated um they

Similar wording

the request of the community is a three-year temporary variance you know that we embrace

Similar wording

Petition, you can see where we are in the neighborhood. We're on Hannon Street between 16th and 17th, between Ellsworth and Federal, but where we are, the property to the right of us signed a letter, or I believe maybe the petition in support of this matter.

Similar wording

and then here's a copy of our petition copy of some of the letters and actually the letter was

Similar wording

signed by james uh gerald welch uh at 1601 added street but we have many addresses close by of

Similar wording

people who signed uh this petition and or uh letters of support and then it's not uncommon to

Similar wording

have visitor accommodations uh nearby and you know we just wanted to show the board that

Similar wording

uh there's a map of properties within a three or four block radius uh so what we're offering

Similar wording

is not out of character to what would be expected in this part of the neighborhood we're not that

Similar wording

far off of from broad street uh so some people don't want to like you know have accommodations

Similar wording

um in center city um and some people you know have family visiting who live in the neighborhood

Similar wording

And this is a good way for them to have some overflow family stay, especially, you know, even if you think about in this holiday season.

Similar wording

And then this is the listing. We want to show you the fact that Mr. Teskew has a 4.9 rating, 111 reviews. He takes great care of his property. And, you know, he really does screen the tenants well.

Similar wording

And then this is the listing. We want to show you the fact that Mr.

Similar wording

and then this is just a zoning map of the area um again you know while our property is rsa5

Similar wording

there are many um other uses in the neighborhood like rm1 cmx1 looks like there's some icmx up

Similar wording

here as well cmx2 over here and then this is just you know you know we're also not that far from

Similar wording

washington avenue so you have public transportation on washington avenue you have public transportation

Similar wording

on broad street so there's ample public transportation as well and then photographs

Similar wording

of the property newly constructed property uh proof of posting of that property and then

Similar wording

and in street to right of the property and in street to left of the property um interior photos

Similar wording

again uh it's a well-maintained property and these are some of the photos that are online that mr

Similar wording

Tesco uses to encourage people to stay in the City of Philadelphia at his home.

Similar wording

And then our plans are drawing very basic you walk in first floor open floor plan downstairs

Similar wording

there's a recreation room with that it looks like a full bath go up a flight of steps two bedrooms

Similar wording

one in the front one in the back full bath third floor is a master suite. And our RCO meeting notice

Similar wording

we met on October 18th at 6.30 p.m. This is proof of email of that notice several weeks

Similar wording

before the meeting, and we send it not only to the RCO, coordinating the RCO for all RCOs,

Similar wording

as well as the council members' zoning aid. Then 172 addresses were notified via mail.

Similar wording

These are listed of these addresses. Proof of mailing to those addresses. Our application

Similar wording

for appeal on Mr. Ntescu's behalf, notice of refusal, project information form, deed to the

Similar wording

property showing that he owns the property, and a certificate of tax clearance. I would ask that

Similar wording

Mr. Ntescu virtually raise his hand so he can be sworn in. Okay.

Similar wording

so your client has been allowed to speak sure could you please share your name

Similar wording

my name is nathaniel atescu that's n-a-t-h-a-n-a-e-l

Similar wording

last name mitescu i t e s c u you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the

Similar wording

truth yes please proceed counsel oh yes mr itescu you heard everything i had to say today about

Similar wording

your zoning matter yes and is it true and correct yes and do you adopt as your own testimony yes

Similar wording

thank you questions from the board no mr chairman thank you chair questions or comments from our

Similar wording

attorney hillary emerson just a quick question for mr knockamson um mr knockamson is yeah the rco

Similar wording

requested uh proviso for a three-year temporary variance um does your client have an opinion on

Similar wording

that um yes we do we we embrace that we we're we're you know we're uh we're in agreement

Similar wording

okay thank you questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

there are no hands chair leaning commission

Similar wording

good afternoon chair peter bernard for the planning commission

Similar wording

the comprehensive plan recommends no change to the rsa 5 single family residential at this

Similar wording

location we feel the applicant has failed to demonstrate a hardship that would justify

Similar wording

short-term rental at this location accordingly the planning commission recommends the board

Similar wording

deny the variance thank you mi2023 004 198 1603 annan street i vote yes temporary variance expiring

Similar wording

12-1-26

Similar wording

Thomas Holloman

Similar wording

my vote is yes

Similar wording

with proviso

Similar wording

James Snell my vote is yes

Similar wording

with proviso

Similar wording

Ismail Shaheed my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

counsel

Similar wording

number three

Similar wording

MI 2023

Similar wording

004-196

Similar wording

11-7-3-1

Similar wording

Caroline Road

Similar wording

safety box magna is the

Similar wording

attorney for the owner

Similar wording

there is a recommendation of support from the Normandy Civic Association no way

Similar wording

recommendation of support from the normandy civic association no explanation

Similar wording

here there's ronald patterson with his hand up okay i'll promote him

Similar wording

he has been promoted i'm mr patterson could you state your name and spell please for the court

Similar wording

stenographer good afternoon i could you state your name please and spell for the court stenographer

Similar wording

sure my name is uh ronald patterson p-a-t-t-e-r-s-o-n

Similar wording

claire harrison law firm 1835 market street philadelphia pa 19103 you swear a firm to tell

Similar wording

the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth uh yes i do would you identify your client a

Similar wording

relationship to this property sure my client is n nancy b as in boyd p isn't paul room numeral

Similar wording

217131 caroline llc the parent company north bridge partners who which is the owner and

Similar wording

developer of the property chair has just a few questions good afternoon counsel do you agree to

Similar wording

the reading under refusal and stipulate to its accuracy? Yes, I do. Have you emailed in all the

Similar wording

required documents and exhibits that is needed and required to proceed with this case five days in

Similar wording

advance of this hearing? Yes, I have. Thank you. Please proceed. I see you've already shared your

Similar wording

screen. Thank you. You can see my screen? Yes. Okay, thank you. As I mentioned, this regards 1131

Similar wording

Caroline Road. It's vacant wooded land as you can see on this aerial photograph

Similar wording

and Northeast Philadelphia Industrial Park area. It's comprised of 12 acres

Similar wording

542,962 square feet. The zoning district is I1 Light Industrial. The

Similar wording

application, here are some additional photographs. The building actually lies

Similar wording

and located next to a Pepsi distribution center.

Similar wording

So this application proposes a single detached building,

Similar wording

small in comparison to the 12 acres of property of 70,310 square feet,

Similar wording

66,543 square feet would be warehouse, and 3,767 square feet would be office with 73 parking spaces.

Similar wording

This is an FAR district.

Similar wording

The allowable was 500, and we're nominal.

Similar wording

We're at 12.9%.

Similar wording

The structure and use and site improvements are all permitted as a matter of right.

Similar wording

This case, however, as you see, it's a wooded area.

Similar wording

It's the removal of three heritage trees.

Similar wording

Useful.

Similar wording

Which heritage trees are trees are more than greater than 24 inches in diameter.

Similar wording

Sure. First, I'd like to briefly, and I'll get to the meat of the matter in a minute, promote Jeffrey Sullivan, who's with the Owner Developers Group.

Similar wording

You can raise your hand, Jeffrey.

Similar wording

could you state your name and spell for the court stenographer

Similar wording

can we see a hand hello can you hear me now i was just on you sir could you state your

Similar wording

name please and spell for the course stenographer my name is jeffrey sullivan j-e-f-f-r-e-y-s-u-l-l-i-v-a-n

Similar wording

do you swear for him to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

i do proceed counsel thank you mr chairman uh uh good afternoon jeffrey um you've heard what i've

Similar wording

stated my testimony so far would you agree that it's true and accurate i do then you would adopt

Similar wording

of this if you if it were your own i do uh so you see on the on my screen there's a map with

Similar wording

some properties that are highlighted i do okay um could you describe to the board what this is just

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Okay. Could you describe to the board what this is just by way of letting them know how Northbridge has a footprint in this area?

Similar wording

Of course. Northbridge is an industrial fund manager based in Wakefield, Massachusetts.

Similar wording

Northbridge acquired 11731 Caroline in 2021, along with 11601 and 11631 Caroline.

Similar wording

In addition, we own eight buildings, or in total, we own eight buildings totaling over 800,000 square feet on 82 acres within a mile and a half of the subject property.

Similar wording

Great. And could you briefly tell us what the proposed use is here with the warehouse?

Similar wording

At this time, it is an industrial use, and we do not have a specific tenant.

Similar wording

We typically are a speculative developer.

Similar wording

Okay. Thank you. That's all I have for Mr. Sullivan, Mr. Chairman.

Similar wording

we could promote uh catherine weiss w-e-i-s-s okay

Similar wording

do we see your hand this wife should be coming back in as a panelist now chair thank you very much

Similar wording

could you state your name please and spell for the court stenographer

Similar wording

she muted

Similar wording

miss weiss please unmute yourself

Similar wording

okay there you go sorry about that i didn't

Similar wording

your name could you state your name please and spell the court sonographer katherine weiss k-a-t-h-e-r-i-n-e

Similar wording

weiss w-e-i-s all right do you swear for him to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the

Similar wording

truth i do we'll see you counsel thank you mr chairman ms weiss may i call you kate yes all

Similar wording

right thank you um like like i don't know you um tell me your involvement with uh this case

Similar wording

please sure i'm the civil engineer for the project i'm a professional engineer licensed

Similar wording

in Pennsylvania and a principal with dynamic engineering. I have over 15 years of land

Similar wording

development experience. Okay and you've prepared the site plan and conducted the surveys and

Similar wording

addressed the heritage tree issue in this matter and I guess the plan that I'm showing on the

Similar wording

screen here is that accurate? Correct. Could you describe the property for me? Yes so the overall

Similar wording

property is located between Caroline Road and Norcom Road. It has Walton Run that runs from

Similar wording

the northern to the southern portion that essentially transects the middle of the site.

Similar wording

In general, there is a significant portion of the site that is located within floodplain limits

Similar wording

and wetlands and associated wetland buffers. There's a steep slope in the western portion

Similar wording

of the site that grades up to an upland area where essentially the development is proposed here

Similar wording

the entire site is wooded the area the upland portion of the site has a significant amount

Similar wording

of historic fill debris tires material that's been brought in you know in prior years so just

Similar wording

something worth noting that it's not undisturbed um you know area even though there are trees there

Similar wording

you know today um it's an area of disturbance so this proposal is for um an approximate 70,000

Similar wording

square foot building it's got a truck court with 16 loading spaces where only four spaces are

Similar wording

required. It has 71 passenger vehicle parking spaces and bicycle parking as well. Okay, Kate,

Similar wording

and to focus on a few things, it's limited in the area where it can be developed, but what do you

Similar wording

estimate the undevelopable area to be? So of the total 12.5 acre lot, the developable portion is

Similar wording

approximately 5.2 acres which is about 42 percent of the overall lot. And that

Similar wording

area is near the front near Caroline Road is that correct? Correct the western

Similar wording

portion of the site. Okay and in that area where is where we removed or would we

Similar wording

remove a lot of trees and is where the three heritage trees are located? Correct

Similar wording

Correct. So within that area, it is wooded. And we can get into the details of what's there in a little bit. But the heritage trees are located within 75 feet. The heritage trees that we're seeking special exception for are located within 75 feet of the Caroline Road right of way.

Similar wording

so within that area it is wooded and

Similar wording

okay and um what how will you address the tree issue with removal and uh replacement

Similar wording

so there is um a tree replacement strategy here um understanding that removal of trees

Similar wording

and incorporating the development we're not able to replace the trees on site

Similar wording

we've proceeded with the fee in lieu um with the fee in lieu strategy so all of the trees

Similar wording

that are being removed including the heritage trees that are part of this application are all

Similar wording

proposed to be mitigated through the fee and loo process and you know through that the applicant

Similar wording

will be contributing close to 160 000 for tree replacement in the city and the important part

Similar wording

of this is that the building couldn't be developed on another portion of the property but only in the

Similar wording

area where the heritage trees are located is that fair to say correct okay and um on the screen i

Similar wording

have what the standards are for obtaining a special exception for heritage tree removal

Similar wording

so the applicant replaces the removed heritage trees in accordance with the tree replacement plan

Similar wording

and we've addressed that by how so we've calculated um all of the existing trees on

Similar wording

site and the density and we've calculated the amount of of trees that that are going to be

Similar wording

removed and then we've applied the fee in lieu to calculate the total amount of contribution

Similar wording

that the applicants required to provide for the application okay um that's all i have for

Similar wording

miss weiss if there's any questions um we did meet with the normandy civic association as

Similar wording

mentioned, we have a letter of support. I would conclude and say that, you know, we believe we've

Similar wording

met the criteria for the board to grant this special exception. We see no average impact by

Similar wording

removing the three trees. The site conditions actually create a hardship in that we're unable

Similar wording

to develop on areas other than where the heritage trees are. But we have alternative remedial

Similar wording

measures that we described that would mitigate any impact from the removal of this these three trees

Similar wording

as well as add even additional landscaping as you saw on the plans that are substantial and robust

Similar wording

um thank you thank you uh questions from the board no mr chairman no chair

Similar wording

no chair thank you questions or comments from our attorney hillary emerson

Similar wording

not at this time mr chair questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

yes chair alice you'd have a chance her hand up she's been allowed to speak

Similar wording

good afternoon alice could you just for the record state your name and spell for the court

Similar wording

personographer certainly good afternoon chairman members of the board alice udovich

Similar wording

u-d-o-v-i-c-h on behalf of councilman brian o'neill you swear affirm to tell the truth

Similar wording

the whole truth nothing but the truth i do please proceed the councilman has no objection

Similar wording

to the granting of the special exception at this location thank you very much for taking

Similar wording

the time to call us is there anyone else in the virtual audience

Similar wording

no hands chair by planning commission

Similar wording

good afternoon chair peter bernard for the planning commission

Similar wording

the comprehensive plan recommends no change to the existing i-1 industrial zoning at this location

Similar wording

given the applicant is paying the in-lieue fee for tree removal we feel the applicant has

Similar wording

demonstrated hardship accordingly the planning commission recommends the board grant the variance

Similar wording

mi2023004196 11731 caroline road i vote yes thomas holloman my vote is yes

Similar wording

james snell my vote is yes ishmael shahi my vote is yes council great thank you

Similar wording

Number six, MI 2023-004-442-4713 North Penn Street.

Similar wording

Alan Nockamson is the attorney.

Similar wording

There's a letter of support from the Frankford NAC RCO

Similar wording

and a letter of non-opposition from Council Member Lazada.

Similar wording

The applicant also provided a petition of support

Similar wording

signed by approximately 18 neighbors,

Similar wording

15 from the 46 and 47 on the block of North Bend along with 18 form letters of support

Similar wording

15 from the 46th and 47th block of North Penn,

Similar wording

along with the 18

Similar wording

Alan knockamson can you please raise your hand uh I'm actually still I guess connected to the

Similar wording

main panel Mr. Knoxon just for the record you've already been sworn state your name please yes

Similar wording

alan knockamson and can you identify your client the relationship to this property

Similar wording

uh yes my client is frankfurt capital three limited partnership and in the virtual audience

Similar wording

is its uh general manager abe silber the vice chair has questions good afternoon council do you

Similar wording

agree to waive the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy i do have you emailed

Similar wording

all the required documents and exhibits that is needed and required to proceed with this case

Similar wording

five days in advance of this hearing uh yes i have thank you please proceed to share your screen

Similar wording

thank you

Similar wording

so i'm here to present 4713 north penn street uh in our package you will first see our notice of

Similar wording

refusal, then the letter of support from the Frankfurt CDC.

Similar wording

I believe we also have a letter of non-opposition from the district council member, Council

Similar wording

Member Lozada.

Similar wording

We also did extensive canvassing of the neighborhood, so we have a petition which are signed by

Similar wording

many of the occupied properties on the 4,600 and 4,700 blocks of North Penn Street.

Similar wording

um after that you'll see the certificate of variance uh so this property uh was a six unit

Similar wording

apartment building at one point um you also then will see the for our analysis of the 4700 block

Similar wording

of north penn street so we reviewed the public record um and even though this is an rsa5 property

Similar wording

and even though the other properties on this block are also rsa5 it it really screams as this should

Similar wording

be like an rm1 use um and you'll see like all the multi-family structures of public record on the

Similar wording

4700 block of north penn street so what we're proposing is not out of character in the

Similar wording

neighborhood and then you'll review we will review together the lower northeast district

Similar wording

plan philadelphia 2035 where the city planning commission is actually recommending that the

Similar wording

that this property's zoning classification changed to R1.

Similar wording

So there's good reason why we're asking also

Similar wording

for multifamily use here.

Similar wording

The City Planning Commission also agrees with us

Similar wording

in that respect, aspirationally.

Similar wording

We'll then review maps of the area,

Similar wording

photographs of the property, our plans and drawings,

Similar wording

our RCO meeting, our application for appeal,

Similar wording

which shows that Frankfort Capital 3 Limited Partnership

Similar wording

you know filed this or we filed this appeal on their behalf along with the deed to the property

Similar wording

which shows their ownership in the property certificate of tax clearance showing that they

Similar wording

you know that they are in good standing with the state of Philadelphia as it

Similar wording

pertains to real estate taxes and then at the conclusion of my presentation I would ask that

Similar wording

Mr. Silber virtually raise his hand be sworn in and have a few questions for him about this

Similar wording

presentation notice the refusal so this is an RSA 5 property I believe it's an RSA 5 property

Similar wording

name only because it has an extensive history of multi-family use um and the neighbor the

Similar wording

neighboring properties on that block also are multi-family in nature it's a rather large lot

Similar wording

it's almost 1700 square feet uh rather large building as well um we're proposing five dwelling

Similar wording

units here so we met with the community um at a in a well-attended meeting i don't think there

Similar wording

are a lot of nearby neighbors and i guess that was one of the concerns that's why we we circulated

Similar wording

this petition uh to show that there's extensive support from members of this community but the

Similar wording

three board members of the coordinating rco all vote in favor of this project

Similar wording

and then because of that support the district council matter member also issued a letter

Similar wording

of non-opposition and in our petition um we garnered the support of the property to

Similar wording

left and right of us so some of the you know occupants who would be most affected by this

Similar wording

increased use all on this block um are in support of this prop this this proposed increased use

Similar wording

and then these this is the petition that was signed by them letters of support signed by some of them

Similar wording

and then certificate of variance which shows at one point um and this is like i guess old

Similar wording

And then Certificate of Variance, which shows

Similar wording

school way of saying things but this premises was one times used as one housekeeping unit

Similar wording

and five non-housekeeping units um six units so don't know how like how they differentiated

Similar wording

between a housekeeping unit and non-housekeeping unit but um there were six units in this property

Similar wording

at one point and then we really did canvas a neighborhood um again even though this is

Similar wording

rsa5 classification i've never seen something like this where everything's multi-family there

Similar wording

and then we reviewed the 2035 plan and according to 2535 plan

Similar wording

they're recommending to change this part of town into rmwatt as well

Similar wording

and then maps area so we're the sliver of rsa5 there's a little rsa3 here but really everything

Similar wording

here is multifamily um we are bordering cmx2 rm1 there's a little bit of icmx up here uh so

Similar wording

this this yellow is an anomaly based on what we saw and just based on the use and based on what

Similar wording

2035 plan is is recommending and then this is just from a google maps perspective where we are

Similar wording

so we are between arid and uh folk rod as well as griscom and leaper

Similar wording

and then photographs of properties a really nice property i you know my client's very excited

Similar wording

to you know fix it up inside and you know freshen it up outside but it has great bones and it's

Similar wording

rather large structure and the lot itself is rather large as well which can easily accommodate

Similar wording

the five units that we're requesting proof of posting from today's hearing as well is included

Similar wording

in our presentation packet then north penn street to the right of the property north

Similar wording

penn street to the left of the property our architectural plans and drawings there's no

Similar wording

basement living or use down here um you walk into a common vestibule area unit a is here walk down

Similar wording

the hallway unit b is here uh you go up a flight of step there's unit c unit d and then third floor

Similar wording

is unit e um again no roof deck no no basement living actually everyone has access to basement

Similar wording

so i would suspect that garbage would be stored down there um our rco meeting notice we had a

Similar wording

well-attended meeting on november 9th at 5 p.m this is proof of email of that notice a few weeks

Similar wording

before the meeting so we sent it to the all rcos including the coordinating rco the district

Similar wording

council member and such but we also mailed it out to 102 addresses a few weeks before the

Similar wording

community meeting. These are a list of addresses, proof of mailing to those addresses, our application

Similar wording

for appeal that we filed on behalf of Frankfort Capital III Limited Partnership, along with the

Similar wording

notice of refusal and the project information form, our deed to the property showing that they

Similar wording

own the property, and then finally our certificate of tax clearance. I would now ask that Mr. Silver

Similar wording

virtually raise his hand.

Similar wording

mr silber has been allowed to speak you please state your name and spell for the court sonographer

Similar wording

my name is abraham silber that is a b r a h a m s i l b e r you swear affirm to tell the truth

Similar wording

the whole truth nothing but the truth i do proceed counsel yeah mr silber did you hear

Similar wording

everything i had to state today about your zoning matter i did and is it true and correct it is

Similar wording

and do you adopt as your own testimony i do thank you questions or comments from the board no mr

Similar wording

questions or comments from our attorney hillary emerson

Similar wording

not at this time mr chair to comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

there are no hands chair planning commission good afternoon chair peter bernard for the

Similar wording

planning commission this area underwent a community-led remapping of the zoning in 2017

Similar wording

where the current rsa5 single-family zoning was supported by the council member and mayor

Similar wording

we feel the applicant has demonstrated a hardship for multi-family use accordingly the planning

Similar wording

commission recommends the board grant the variance thank you mi 2023 004 442 4713 north penn street

Similar wording

i vote yes thomas holliman my vote is yes

Similar wording

i vote yes thomas holloman my vote is yes james snell my vote is yes ishmael shaheed my vote is yes

Similar wording

thank you council thank you number eight mi 2023 zero zero four one six eight one zero seven zero

Similar wording

zero night road stephanie box of miss magna is the attorney uh recommendation of support from

Similar wording

the west tarsdale morrell park civic association ronald patterson is back in as a panelist here

Similar wording

hi mr patterson you've already been sworn just for the record could you state your name

Similar wording

good afternoon i've returned i just for the record state your name please

Similar wording

sure ronald patterson right and mr patterson could you identify you've already been sworn

Similar wording

could you could you identify your client a relationship with this property

Similar wording

towards tom and jefferson hospital is the parent uh entity that owns this property

Similar wording

okay our vice chair has just a few questions

Similar wording

good afternoon council do you agree to waive the reading of the refusal and stipulate to

Similar wording

its accuracy good afternoon yes i do have you emailed in all the required documents and

Similar wording

exhibits that is needed and required to proceed with this case five days in advance of this

Similar wording

hearing uh yes i have thank you please proceed thank you as mentioned this application in case

Similar wording

regards 10700 Knights Road is in Northeast Philadelphia. It's a standalone building

Similar wording

adjacent to an annex to Jefferson's Jefferson Frankfort Hospital, which I'm showing on the

Similar wording

screen right now. Did you see my screen change? Yes. Okay, great. So this is the property

Similar wording

located off of Knights Road. November of 2022, we appeared here in front of the board for use

Similar wording

variance to use a portion of this existing building as a medical use. And I say a portion

Similar wording

because this portion over here, which you can't really read from here, but it's the settlement

Similar wording

music school in a portion of this building. The application in this RSA 4 residential zoning

Similar wording

district was for physical therapy, occupational therapy use, which is a group medical use,

Similar wording

termed as an outpatient vestibular therapy use. And that was granted. So this application

Similar wording

is for a signed package. This is for you across the street.

Similar wording

The initial application was for four signs, two flat wall, this number two here, a door

Similar wording

sign, and another flat wall sign here at the entrance, as well as one freestanding sign

Similar wording

that will be placed at the entrance off of Knights Road.

Similar wording

And the cut sign package was coordinated with the existing settlement school

Similar wording

sign, as I mentioned. So the first sign, this Jefferson sign here, was the standard Jefferson

Similar wording

sign, health sign, with a logo of 52 square feet. The smaller sign, as I mentioned, near the entrance

Similar wording

was 13.2 square feet. The door sign and the monument sign measuring here seven feet wide by

Similar wording

11 feet in height with a total height of 13 feet for a total of 91 square feet.

Similar wording

We did meet with the RCO, the West Tarsdale Morrell Park Civic Association.

Similar wording

And as a result of that, we reduced this sign by two-thirds to a much smaller sign having 34 square feet.

Similar wording

And we've also agreed to remove this sign number three, which I guess is somewhat redundant in this case.

Similar wording

So, with that said, I'd like to promote Mr. Chacko, C-H-A-C-K-O, and while we're promoting

Similar wording

And while we're promoting him, we have prepared and did file a request for a proviso condition to adjust this application.

Similar wording

him, we have...

Similar wording

Right here.

Similar wording

You see the hand of this witness?

Similar wording

Mr. Chaco, you're free to speak.

Similar wording

hi mr chaco could you please state your name and spell for the court stenographer

Similar wording

yes my first name is myrtle last name is chaco first name is m-r-i-d-h-u-l last name chaco c-h-a-c-k-o

Similar wording

you swear affirm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

yes i do please proceed council thank you uh mr chaco what is your position with jefferson

Similar wording

i'm the director of rehabilitation services at jefferson and uh you familiar with and been

Similar wording

involved in this project yes and you've heard my testimony would you agree that it's true

Similar wording

and accurate and you would adopt it as if it were your own yes yeah um is it fair to describe this

Similar wording

is a the standard but perhaps reduced version of the typical jefferson signage a package

Similar wording

that would be contextual with this building yes and would you describe this

Similar wording

location is I guess fairly busy with high higher speed rates than normal yes

Similar wording

and the building set back quite a distance from Knights Road yes it is

Similar wording

okay and is it appropriate necessary to identify the building here to assist

Similar wording

patience to find the building?

Similar wording

Is that fair to say?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And we did meet with the Civic Group.

Similar wording

I think you were present.

Similar wording

And, Mr. Chairman, we have a letter of support.

Similar wording

That's the West Coastal and the Memorial Park Civic Association.

Similar wording

Correct.

Similar wording

With the conditions that we, as I mentioned, about reducing the monument sign.

Similar wording

So I would say that we believe that the building's location, its surrounding use, surrounding uses, traffic conditions, peculiar configuration now as it's located on the property, and that the use variance was granted last year, establishes a hardship to allow for this non-residential amount of signage in a residentially zone district, which only allows 15 square feet, which will be inadequate to appropriately identify this building.

Similar wording

building, both for identifying the building and also preventing adverse impacts with traffic

Similar wording

safety. Yet, we believe the type and size and location will cause no adverse impacts

Similar wording

to anyone. So, with the revised plans we formally submitted, dated 11-8-02-2023, we justified

Similar wording

um granting of this variance in this case thank you questions from the board

Similar wording

no mr chairman no chair no chair questions or comments from our attorney hillary emerson

Similar wording

not at this time mr chair questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

yes chair alice alice judovic has a hand up and i will allow her to speak

Similar wording

alice you've already been sworn just for the record state your name alice udovich u-d-o-v-i-c-h

Similar wording

on behalf of councilman brian o'neill the councilman has no objection to the grand

Similar wording

thank you for your call is there anyone else in the audience

Similar wording

yes chair audrey yep yes and now yes and off i will allow to speak

Similar wording

hi could you please state your name and spell for the court stenographer

Similar wording

audrey hi could you state your name and spell for the court stenographer

Similar wording

audrey has disappeared okay

Similar wording

all right is there anyone else in the virtual audience there are no more hands here

Similar wording

planning commission good afternoon chair peter bernard for the planning commission

Similar wording

this location was rezoned from ca1 to rsa4 in 2014 the district plan recommended no change

Similar wording

to the existing rsa4 residential zoning at this location in 2017 however this proposal

Similar wording

is largely consistent with the current ca1 commercial auto-oriented use we feel the applicant

Similar wording

has a demonstrated hardship accordingly the planning commission recommends the board grant

Similar wording

the variance thank you mi2023 zero zero zero zero one

Similar wording

thank you mi2023 000 168 10700 nitro i vote yes with proviso revised plans three pages

Similar wording

stamped by zba on november 29th 2023 thomas holloman my boot is yes with proviso

Similar wording

james snell my vote is yes with proviso ishmael shaheed my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

thank you very much thank you number nine mi 2023 004 443 22 16 north 7th street number ta

Similar wording

53960 alan knockupson is the attorney ishmael shaheed has recused himself from this

Similar wording

recommendation of support from the 37th ward rco applicant provided two form letters of support

Similar wording

from neighbors i'm sorry doreen hi chair this is tanya i just wanted to mention that we got a

Similar wording

couple um requests if you could um maybe put your volume up or speak a little louder louder they

Similar wording

having a hard time hearing you i'm fine i am yes you're a little low thank you kindly let me get

Similar wording

closer here okay thank you pleasure thank you uh good afternoon mr chair again mr knockamson you've

Similar wording

already been sworn um could you just state your name for the record alan knockamson could you

Similar wording

identify your client in the relationship to this property uh my client is threefold to 2216 is

Similar wording

owned by 2216 and 7th street llc 2218 is owned by 2218 and 7th street llc and 2220 is owned by abdph

Similar wording

llc um in the virtual audience is dimitri gordeski uh the member of each of these entities

Similar wording

mr hallman has a few questions for you sir thank you good afternoon council

Similar wording

do you agree to weigh the reading of the resolution i mean the refusal and stipulate to

Similar wording

his accuracy i do did you email all of the exhibits and documents that's required

Similar wording

five days in advance to this hearing yes we have thank you please proceed and share your screen

Similar wording

all right so 2216 north 7th street uh we're proposing a 12-unit uh building on this rm1

Similar wording

property uh it's a rather large lot and um you know we're hoping that the board uh sees

Similar wording

how the community saw in unanimously supporting this project all right so we have a couple of

Similar wording

we will review. First is the original notice of refusal, which is July 12, 2023. We did revise it with authorization of the ZBA, so I have a notice of refusal dated November 14, 2023.

Similar wording

we eliminated one refusal there was a refusal for a side yard we actually decreased another

Similar wording

refusal by by including instead of having a side yard as the open area we had the open area

Similar wording

completely in the rear where we had no rear yard setback previously now we have a five foot rear

Similar wording

yard setback which provides ample space to all of the occupants of the building who all have access

Similar wording

to it. And in our community meeting, there was commentary in the fact that they appreciated

Similar wording

this open space in the rear as well. We did meet with the 37th Ward Executive Committee,

Similar wording

Democratic Executive Committee, and the individuals in the audience as well as members of the

Similar wording

Democratic Organization were fully in support of this project. We also presented to them as well

Similar wording

as to you today letters to support from nearby neighbors the person to left and right of us the

Similar wording

property owners are in support of this project we have a letter of support i believe for 2222

Similar wording

2216 we couldn't get a letter from them but verbally you know they support this project and

Similar wording

mr uh gordeski would you know he's going to testify to that effect by adopting my testimony

Similar wording

property, or my representation right now. There's also what we're offering is not out of character to the neighborhood. This is an RM1 property. But there's similar the refusals that we're seeking for the amount of units, the occupied area, even the setback are all common to this, to this part of town. Similar situations where this board has granted

Similar wording

to this part of town. Similar situations where this board has granted those variances in the

Similar wording

past and we'll review that. Maps of the area, we're not that far from, you'll see that this

Similar wording

is an RM1 section of town. There is a lot of vacant land here, which is hurting the commercial

Similar wording

corridor in Germantown, which is a block and a half away. We're hoping that this density will

Similar wording

encourage other people to build in this neighborhood, but in addition to help support

Similar wording

that commercial border which is very important in the neighborhood as well then we'll see photographs

Similar wording

of the property in the surrounding area our plans and drawings or our rco meeting notice showing

Similar wording

proof that we um we sent that out uh to the community uh and proof of mailing of that notice

Similar wording

our application for appeal showing that we filed um our zoning appeal on behalf of these three

Similar wording

entities as well as deeds for these three entities for each of these properties are our certificate

Similar wording

of or certificates of tax clearance uh for these three properties and again at the conclusion my

Similar wording

presentation i would ask that dimitri virtually raise his hand he'll be sworn in i'll ask him a

Similar wording

few questions so he can adopt my testimony um so first things first is though notice the refusal

Similar wording

again we're not taking rsa5 property and trying to convert it into into multi-family use this is

Similar wording

an rm1 property um we think by combining these three properties together it makes it more

Similar wording

efficient rather than having you know either triplexes or quadplexes on these on each of

Similar wording

these properties which you know you'll then see basement use you'll see uh roof decks you'll just

Similar wording

see a funky floor plan not everyone's gonna have access to maybe the exterior the rear of the

Similar wording

property maybe not have trash rooms by combining these three properties together we're making

Similar wording

it very efficient and we think that having 12 units makes it a good use of these properties

Similar wording

there's a diversity of housing each floor will have a studio apartment a one-bedroom apartment

Similar wording

and a two-bedroom apartment equally important is that each of these this building will be

Similar wording

handicap friendly you'll see that there is built on grades so that was really important to

Similar wording

neighborhood too as you know there's an elderly portion of this neighborhood that can't find

Similar wording

housing and having a studio or one bedroom or even a two bedroom is helpful for these members

Similar wording

of the community but we originally had four refusals three of them remain after the change

Similar wording

in drawings and we would ask um you know again if the board you know uh supports this project and

Similar wording

you know, grants it. I don't know what the proper protocol is, but we just want to make sure that

Similar wording

the right refusal is reflected, you know, in the notice of decision. I don't know if you do that

Similar wording

by proviso and just reflect the date of the new notice refusal. But the old notice refusal is this

Similar wording

one. And, you know, we had a rear yard, excuse me, a side yard with refusal. And the other ones

Similar wording

for amount of units, occupied area, and rear yard depth, where we, again, originally we had zero

Similar wording

rear yard depth. We changed our plans. Instead of, you know, we expanded the building outward,

Similar wording

we set it back further in the rear. So with the board's approval, now we only have three refusals.

Similar wording

So we got rid of one. We still have the 12 units, where, again, it's not uncommon. This board has

Similar wording

granted such variances in the past the occupied area we still have you know 235 square feet of

Similar wording

open area in the rear which is more than enough for a beautiful common rear yard for the unit

Similar wording

occupants and then the rear yard depth we went from zero rear yard depth to five

Similar wording

to five feet of rear yard depth again closer into conformance of the code

Similar wording

and then again we we had a well-attended meeting not only are they in non-opposition they're in

Similar wording

actual support unanimous support of this project so they were they were very happy with the design

Similar wording

and the thoughtfulness of the project and then again you know we also reach out to the community

Similar wording

as a whole we have a letter of support from from the next door neighbor um next door property owner

Similar wording

verbally we have support from the one to left of us at 2214 and there's not a lot of development

Similar wording

around there's a lot of vacant lots um but we did reach out to many of the neighbors on north

Similar wording

franklin street which is to the rear bus where you know again maybe they're most directly impacted

Similar wording

by the by the lack of the conforming rear yard setback but even they are in these people on

Similar wording

north franklin street are in support of this project and then these are just the properties

Similar wording

and this is the 122 22 7th street

Similar wording

And then we use 2215 North 15th Street as a North, excuse me, North 7th Street as a guide.

Similar wording

and then we use 2250

Similar wording

Similarly, they proposed to combine three lots, put 12 dwelling units on there, and this board actually supported that as well in 2020 under calendar number MI-2020-001832.

Similar wording

So the amount of density created with this property is similar to the density that we're requesting to be created for our property.

Similar wording

And then maps of the area. Again, we're not in an RSA 5 district. Germantown Avenue is right here.

Similar wording

Tons of RM1, CMX2, a little purple here.

Similar wording

but this part of town for whatever reason hasn't been able to get going and we're hoping that this

Similar wording

this use along with some of the other newer buildings are going to help revitalize that

Similar wording

commercial corridor and again the individuals that would be most directly impacted by some

Similar wording

of the dimensional variances for rear yard setback and an open area are the ones who are in support

Similar wording

of our project too and then photographs of the property this is the front of the property

Similar wording

this is the hearing notice poster showing that we posted um in due course uh for today's hearing

Similar wording

this is 20 this is uh north 7th street to the right of the property uh north 7th street to

Similar wording

the left of the property then our plans and drawings that you can see we built on grade

Similar wording

um you know we're not you know seeking any height variance we're you know we're doing a flat brick

Similar wording

facade which i think was very important to the community we have you know a nice little cornice

Similar wording

that defines the property and most importantly and we have a huge backyard i mean it's slender

Similar wording

but it's huge where we can see we can put a lot of outdoor seating that's in common with the

Similar wording

neighbors no basement living each of the units are going to have its own storage locker which

Similar wording

again was important to the community because when you're dealing with studios or even one bedrooms

Similar wording

you're like where are you going to store your stuff and so my clients try to be as thoughtful

Similar wording

as possible and responsible as possible by not having basement living but but above that is to

Similar wording

have adequate storage for each of the units as well and then as you can see here everyone comes

Similar wording

in through this front door there's you come to the right and each floor is the same you have the

Similar wording

first unit is a studio there's a common hallway this is unit number two which is one bedroom one

Similar wording

bath and unit number three is a two bedroom two and a half bath instead of going down that common

Similar wording

hallway to the right, you keep going in the back, where everyone has access to a rear yard,

Similar wording

where, again, everyone's going to have access to outdoor space. Equally important is each of the

Similar wording

floors are going to have its own ventilated trash storage facility. So again, we're responsibly

Similar wording

storing trash. Given the amount of units, we're already going to be required to do commercial

Similar wording

trash pickup. But rather than doing what you see a lot of the duplex-triplex method,

Similar wording

where it's tough to, you know, where the trash is going to be stored. A lot of times we try to

Similar wording

store it in the units. We try to be responsible here and store the trash in a common hallway

Similar wording

where it will be disposed of by the client's property manager. And then again, it's the same

Similar wording

thing for all the other floors, the same floor plan. And then our RCO meeting notice, we had a

Similar wording

well-attended meeting November 21st at 6 p.m. We also emailed that notice several weeks before

Similar wording

the community meeting so the members of the leaders of the community knew of the existence

Similar wording

of that of that community meeting 131 addresses of you know for within that 250 square foot radius

Similar wording

of the property were mailed notice of that community meeting uh here are the addresses

Similar wording

proof of mailing to those addresses our application for appeal that we followed on behalf of these

Similar wording

corporate entities our original notice of refusal that we got updated and then our project

Similar wording

information form are in you know we have three deeds to the property one for each property that's

Similar wording

going to be consolidated and then our certificates of tax clearance uh with that being said i would

Similar wording

ask that dimitri virtually raise his hand dimitri has been allowed to speak could you state your

Similar wording

name please and spell for the court stenographer hello my name is dimitri gordeski could you

Similar wording

please spell it for the court stenographer first name d-m-i-t-r-y last name g-o-r-o-d-e-t-s-k-y

Similar wording

last name g-o-r-o-d-e-t-s-k-y right do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth and

Similar wording

nothing but the truth yes i do please proceed yes um dimitri you heard everything i had to state

Similar wording

today about your zoning matter yes and is it true and correct correct and do you adopt it as your

Similar wording

testimony all right thank you questions from the board no mr chairman no chair

Similar wording

no chair comments from our attorney hillary emerson not at this time mr chair questions

Similar wording

or comments from the virtual audience there are no hands here planning commission

Similar wording

good afternoon chair peter bernard for the planning commission

Similar wording

The comprehensive plan recommends no change to the existing

Similar wording

RM1 multi-family residential at this location.

Similar wording

We feel the applicant has failed to demonstrate a hardship

Similar wording

and this proposal represents an overdevelopment

Similar wording

as the proposal is twice the allowed unit density

Similar wording

and provides less than half the required open space.

Similar wording

Furthermore, the affordable housing provisions proposed

Similar wording

are unenforceable by the city.

Similar wording

Accordingly, the Planning Commission strongly recommends

Similar wording

the board deny the variances.

Similar wording

Mr. Chair, can I respond?

Similar wording

You can.

Similar wording

All right. So, again, we're allowed seven units as of right. So it's not more than we're not and we're asking for 12 and we're not doubling that. I didn't mention anything about affordability, although it does make it more affordable to have more units.

Similar wording

But again, in terms of the density that we're requesting, this board did approve a similar type of variance request for 12 units at 2248 North 7th Street, in addition to the 12 units that were approved at 2215 North 7th Street.

Similar wording

And then in terms of the occupied area, at 2120 North 7th Street, this board similarly granted a dimensional variance request.

Similar wording

And there's a number of properties nearby and a couple blocks over on Darien Street where they did the same.

Similar wording

and then for the rear yard depth this board granted a similar request for a deviant deviation

Similar wording

from you from the rear yard depth requirement nine feet at 2121 north 8th street and again the number

Similar wording

of these properties nearby and north darien street as well the property owners to the left and right

Similar wording

of us would be most directly impacted by the dimensional variances actually support our

Similar wording

project including a lot of the neighbors on north franklin street that are behind us who would be

Similar wording

directly impacted as well um so we for all those reasons we ask the board support uh the

Similar wording

variance request by way of the updated notice of refusal mi 2023 004 443 2216 north 7th street ta

Similar wording

A-53960, I vote yes with provisos.

Similar wording

Maximum 10 units per amended refusal, date 11-14-23.

Similar wording

Thomas Holloman, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

James Snell, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Thank you, counsel.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

number 10 mi 2023 004 233 403 south 42nd street leonard altieri is the attorney for the owner

Similar wording

a letter of non-opposition from spruce spruce hill community association

Similar wording

leonard altieri has been promoted

Similar wording

sir could you please state your name and spell for the court stenographer

Similar wording

unmute yourself sir good afternoon mr chairman how are you hi hi could you state your name and

Similar wording

spell for the court stenographer my name is leonard l-e-o-n-a-r-d altieri a-l-t-i-e-r-i

Similar wording

And I'm an associate at the law firm of Claire Harrison here in Center City, Philadelphia.

Similar wording

Do you swear a firm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Could you identify your client and relationship to this property?

Similar wording

Yep.

Similar wording

My client is Gabriel Boot 11.

Similar wording

He is the principal of the company of Boot 11 Holdings, LLC, which is the owner of the property located at 403 South 42nd Street.

Similar wording

all right and our vice chair has just a few questions sir good afternoon counsel do you

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

And our vice chair has just a few questions, sir.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, Councilor.

Similar wording

agree to waive the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy i do have you emailed

Similar wording

in all the required documents and exhibits that is needed and required to proceed with this case

Similar wording

spot these in advance of this hearing i have thank you please proceed and share your screen

Similar wording

you see the exhibit packet we can sir all right perfect so as i stated earlier um

Similar wording

we're here today to speak about the property located 402 south 42nd street this is a very

Similar wording

simple matter. This property has historically been used as a six-family apartment building.

Similar wording

The earliest records that we saw through the city was from 1933 all the way to 2012. However, the

Similar wording

occupancy seemed to expire in 2012. What my client is here today seeking is to bring it back up

Similar wording

to that historic level of the six units as you noted earlier we do have a letter of support

Similar wording

from the spruce hill community association which also references that the property had

Similar wording

historically been used as a six unit building this is the property itself an aerial church

Similar wording

located here in the front of the property to further show evidence of the fact that this has

Similar wording

always been six units we have as i'm showing on the screen right now uh six gas meters um for all

Similar wording

six of the units this photo right here is where the seventh meter was for the common area but

Similar wording

subsequently has been removed additionally we have six excuse me this is hillary i'm i'm and

Similar wording

maybe it's just me but i'm only seeing like your home screen i'm not seeing any exhibits

Similar wording

oh am i the only one yeah he's not moving through it all right okay let me try this again

Similar wording

how about now do you see electrical panels

Similar wording

yes yes i see them now thank you all right so i'll just just i won't go through that whole

Similar wording

thing yet but here are the six gas meters and then where the seventh one originally was right

Similar wording

here for the common area again the six electrical panels and the seventh one for the common area

Similar wording

and again the meters on the outside six of them with one on the outside as noted earlier this

Similar wording

property had historically been uh six units and as referenced the there's records dating back all

Similar wording

the way to 1933 that show that the units were that this building was always used as six units

Similar wording

The rental license expired in around 2012, and so what my client today is seeking is to renovate that building, keeping the exterior, and just putting in the units again.

Similar wording

So it'll be two units on the first floor, two units on the second floor, and two units on the third floor, which, again, is what has always historically been.

Similar wording

we are also adding on the back end just to make this even on floors two and three that extension

Similar wording

will not extend further uh on either side of the of the existing neighboring property so you can

Similar wording

see here the back left extends further on the property adjacent to us and you can kind of see

Similar wording

through the trees here same same there so that mr chairman i have no further testimony if i could

Similar wording

have my client mr boot 11 raise his hand and i'll have him sworn in okay

Similar wording

gabriel if you could raise your hand on the

Similar wording

he's been allowed to speak could you state your name and spell it please for the court stenographer

Similar wording

my name is gabriel buddha levin that's g-a-b-r-i-e-l-b-u-d-a hyphen l-e-v-i-n

Similar wording

right do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Similar wording

yes sir proceed counsel thank you very much gabriel were you on the call when you heard me

Similar wording

uh testify yes and is everything that you heard true and accurate yes and can you tell me what

Similar wording

your position is with buddha levin holdings llc uh i'm the ceo owner operator it's my company

Similar wording

and so you're authorized to speak on behalf of it uh yes and if i called you to testify

Similar wording

would you have adopted that testimony that i provided as your own yes and with that mr

Similar wording

chairman i have no further questions from the board no mr chairman chairman no chair

Similar wording

QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS FROM OUR ATTORNEY HILLIAR EMERSON?

Similar wording

questions or comments from our attorney hillier emerson not for this case mr chair but um just a

Similar wording

quick note for um tony if she could send another link to mr snell he was bumped out of the meeting

Similar wording

and is having a hard time getting back in thank you all right um questions or comments from the

Similar wording

virtual audience. There are no aims, Chair. Planning Commission.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, Chair. Peter Bernard for the Planning Commission.

Similar wording

The comprehensive plan recommends no change to the RTA1 residential attached zoning at this

Similar wording

location. The property has a long documented history of use as multifamily. We feel the

Similar wording

applicant has demonstrated hardship accordingly the planning commission recommends the board

Similar wording

grant the variances thank you mi 2023 004 233 403 south 42nd street i vote yes thomas holloman i vote

Similar wording

yes ishmael shaheed my vote is yes thank you counsel you have your votes thank you very much

Similar wording

everyone take care okay let's see here okay we're okay we'll have free votes all right

Similar wording

mi 2023 005 680 5800 city avenue eileen quickly is the attorney um

Similar wording

recommendation of non-opposition from winfield residents association a letter of support from

Similar wording

council member jones and there is a c cdr that we've received a copy of eileen quigley has been

Similar wording

promoted thank you good afternoon good afternoon council could you state your name please and

Similar wording

spell for the court stenographer yes my name is eileen quigley e-i-l-e-e-n quigley q-u-i-g-l-e-y

Similar wording

i'm from ballard spar llp 1735 market street 51st floor philadelphia 19103 do you swear or affirm

Similar wording

to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth i do could you identify your client

Similar wording

the relationship to this property yes i'm here on behalf of saint joseph's university

Similar wording

and with me is joe kender from saint joseph's university he's senior vice president university

Similar wording

relations as well as tracy luckenbell who is principal at blackney hayes architects

Similar wording

our vice chair has a few questions questions good afternoon council do you agree to weigh the reading

Similar wording

of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy no for one specific reason uh we don't agree with the

Similar wording

lni's refusal of the crest which they've designated as signs

Similar wording

but in the also we believe they are in designating those as signs but in the alternative if the board

Similar wording

does not agree with that position we would ask for the variance understood have you emailed in

Similar wording

all the required documents and exhibits that is needed and required to proceed with this case

Similar wording

spot these in advance of this hearing yes we have and i i may have missed you chair bergman when i

Similar wording

was being elevated but we did receive a letter of support from council member jones's office today

Similar wording

which we forwarded to board council hillary emerson we also have a letter of non-opposition from the

Similar wording

coordinating rco that we have in our exhibits packet um i would like to share my screen

Similar wording

thank you miss quickly please proceed this year thank you

Similar wording

can everyone see the exhibits packet make it a little bigger okay

Similar wording

so we have provided a whole list of exhibits for the board we'll just mention the deeds

Similar wording

certificate of tax clearance. We have photos of posted zoning notices and photos of the site

Similar wording

and surrounding area. We've included the notice of refusal and referral, the applications for

Similar wording

appeal and special exception, and below the neighbor notice letters, the certificates of

Similar wording

mailing, the curriculum vitae, the resume of Tracy Luckinville, as well as, as I said, the Winfield

Similar wording

Residents Association coordinating RCO letter of non-opposition. With that, we would like to

Similar wording

proceed uh just by way of background first we're here today regarding the request for variance and

Similar wording

special exception related to the new residence hall at 5800 city avenue this process we have

Similar wording

been through the cdr process so we had a meeting in the summer with the rco and the community

Similar wording

In the summer, we concluded Civic Design Review in September of this year.

Similar wording

in the summer we concluded civic design review in september of this year

Similar wording

The master plan was amended for St. Joe's University and was approved by City Council in June of this year,

Similar wording

which allows for the residence hall that you see here.

Similar wording

I'm going to show a photo, an aerial photo now of the site.

Similar wording

So we're here today for variance and special exception as it relates to the new residence hall.

Similar wording

This new residence hall is really of vital importance to St. Joe's University mission, which is to move student activity and living accommodations away from the neighborhood and within the campus, and it will also replace to existing dorms that are already across the street.

Similar wording

So this will be a new, state-of-the-art, modern, environmentally sound and sustainable building at this site.

Similar wording

We just want to orient everybody. This is 5800 City Avenue. This is Cardinal Avenue. This is Overbrook Avenue. To the rear of the property is another St. Joseph's University property, and this is City Avenue, as I said.

Similar wording

so the first variance that we're requesting is for the setback so it's important to note that

Similar wording

the spins district in which this property lies does not require a setback or a front yard setback

Similar wording

but because the property abuts adjacent residential districts lni applies the most

Similar wording

restrictive setback which actually is from the rsd3 zoning district which is to the rear of this

Similar wording

property and is the st joseph's university property and that's a 25 foot setback the other

Similar wording

residential district is to the right we're over here by overbrook avenue and that setback is eight

Similar wording

feet the setback most of this building is within the 20 meets the 25 foot setback but l and i has

Similar wording

issued the refusal for these bay windows right here. So the setback from the bay windows to the

Similar wording

property line is 6.9 feet. If you were to go with the setback for the RSA district, which is eight

Similar wording

feet, this is really de minimis and is in keeping with the Villiger Hall and St. Joe's University

Similar wording

campus across the street. This setback is required. Actually, if we don't have the setback,

Similar wording

what happens is if you move the building back it number one encroaches upon the welcome the

Similar wording

wolfington welcome center here and then you have an overcrowding of the land in this area with the

Similar wording

building setback and also and more importantly due to the grading and the physical conditions

Similar wording

of the property back here if we weren't able to have this setback here this room right here really

Similar wording

allows for space to provide accessible slopes for the pedestrian pathways. So not having this space

Similar wording

creates a hardship in that way. The setbacks, as I noted, the property, the building from here to

Similar wording

Overbrook Avenue is over 340 feet. From the back of the building to the property line, which abuts

Similar wording

the other residential property owned by St. Joe's, is more than 280 feet. And it meets the setback

Similar wording

here of course from city avenue because it's over 25 feet i'd like to move on to the next

Similar wording

slide to show you a site section so you can see as i said here's a north site section

Similar wording

here's city avenue here's the side of the proposed residence hall the driveway

Similar wording

here's the property as it slopes to Overbrook Avenue and as I said that distance from this

Similar wording

proposed building to Overbrook Avenue is over 340 feet and here is the proposed building

Similar wording

here's Cardinal Avenue and here's Villager Hall which is also a St. Joseph's University property

Similar wording

and these are very close to one another so it's really makes more sense for this setback to meet

Similar wording

what is happening across the street we understand what setbacks are typically used for so there's a

Similar wording

consistency with the buildings but in this case this building is really a standalone within

Similar wording

acres and acres of property so not to have that setback as i mentioned before would really create

Similar wording

a hardship next we move to the variance for the fencing we're proposing fencing to meet the height

Similar wording

of the existing fencing now we're moving the we have a new entry gate here at the intersection

Similar wording

of cardinal avenue and city avenue and the new fencing meets the existing fencing so they added

Similar wording

to create that whole coordinated and consistent frontage it has to meet the existing

Similar wording

coordinated and consistent frontage. It has to meet the existing fencing. It's eight feet. It

Similar wording

will all be consistent. It doesn't create any danger to the public health, safety, or welfare

Similar wording

in making this the same height. Similarly, and I'll move to the special exception. There's a

Similar wording

special exception required for the removal of heritage trees. Now, in this case, there are

Similar wording

certain heritage trees that are being removed because they are dead, but those heritage trees

Similar wording

that are being removed to allow for the construction of this new residence hall there there are 11

Similar wording

and in replace to replace those 11 heritage trees we are planting about 111 trees throughout this

Similar wording

site and on campus as needed but there will be additional trees planted on this site so it also

Similar wording

so it maintains and actually enhances the on-site landscaping so we don't believe that there's any

Similar wording

detrimental impact to the neighbors with the removal of these 11 trees because the new

Similar wording

plantings of 111 trees actually exceeds the required caliper inches that would be needed.

Similar wording

We're planting about 1,100 caliper inches with the new trees and removing about 1,000,

Similar wording

replacing about 1,000 inches. So we are exceeding that requirement.

Similar wording

uh finally i'd like to move to the renderings which show these are the crests that l and i

Similar wording

is designated as signage these are part of the building fabric these are really reliefs of the

Similar wording

building it's a saint joe's crest it's not illuminated as i said it's really a building

Similar wording

relief there is one here at the intersection of cardinal and city avenue

Similar wording

here's another good view so you can see the setbacks here

Similar wording

and how really consistent it looks coming down cardinal avenue from city avenue

Similar wording

this is the interior of the space and here's the second crest that l and i has designated as a sign

Similar wording

again we don't believe these are signs but if the board does not agree with our position we would

Similar wording

ask for a variance in the alternative with that we would like to state that obviously there's no

Similar wording

specific or detrimental impact with the removal of the heritage trees as it's being replaced

Similar wording

in kind and in excess of what's really required and the grant of the variances really would create

Similar wording

hardship especially with the setback so we believe that this request the special exception

Similar wording

and variance meet the criteria set forth in the zoning code and with that we'd like to elevate

Similar wording

joe kender and tracy luckenbill

Similar wording

tracy luckenbill is allowed to speak could you please state your name and spell for the court

Similar wording

stenographer good afternoon my name is tracy luckenville spelled t-r-a-c-i-l-u-c-k-e-n-b-i-l-l

Similar wording

do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Similar wording

i do um do you want to swear in your other client at the same time yes please

Similar wording

i don't see the other client uh miss quigley what was the name joe kender k-e-n-d-e-r okay thank you

Similar wording

so there he is joe joe k-e-n-d-e-r yeah i got it joe kinder is he's going to be allowed to speak

Similar wording

also thank you all right mr tender could you please state your name and spell for the court

Similar wording

sonographer yes my name is joe kender j-o-e joseph k-e-n-d-e-r do you swear for him to tell

Similar wording

the truth the whole truth is nothing but the truth i do proceed counsel thank you chair uh first

Similar wording

tracy i would like you to confirm that your curriculum vitae or resume is attached to your

Similar wording

exhibit 18 and that this is your resume that is my resume yes thank you and also um miss luck

Similar wording

bill you heard my presentation correct i did and is it accurate miss quigley i think there's just

Similar wording

one thing i may have misheard we're actually replacing 311 trees on this parcel so i just

Similar wording

want to make sure that that was clear we're adding a total 376 um for the 11 that we're removing

Similar wording

other than that yes i agree with it i apologize for that uh mistake maybe i misheard it but

Similar wording

I want to make sure that's clear.

Similar wording

No, so we were planning many more than I said. So I appreciate that clarification. So other than that, it was accurate?

Similar wording

No, so we were planning many more than I said, so I appreciate that clarification.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And if you were to testify, would you adopt my testimony as if you were testifying today?

Similar wording

I would.

Similar wording

Thank you. Mr. Kender?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Did you hear my presentation today?

Similar wording

I did.

Similar wording

And would you agree that it was accurate?

Similar wording

Yes, I agree that it was accurate.

Similar wording

and specifically as it relates to the vital importance of this residence hall and the

Similar wording

granted this very these variances and special exception uh would you believe would you um

Similar wording

state that that is also accurate that is accurate and if you were to testify would you adopt my

Similar wording

testimony with regard to the vital importance of this project as your own yes i would thank you

Similar wording

mr kendra um questions questions no chair no chair comments from our attorney hillary emerson

Similar wording

not at this time mr chair questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

no hands here planning commission good afternoon chair peter bernard for the planning commission

Similar wording

the comprehensive plan recommends no change to the special use institutional zoning at this location

Similar wording

this proposal was presented in front of the civic design review board where it was positively

Similar wording

received we feel the applicant has a demonstrated hardship regarding heritage tree removal

Similar wording

accordingly the planning commission recommends the board grant the variances and special exception

Similar wording

thank you hillary how about the one issue that uh miss quigley raised about

Similar wording

she where she disagreed do we have to add anything um i mean the if the board wants to make a finding

Similar wording

on that then we should probably hold it and discuss it because i wasn't previously aware that was an

Similar wording

issue um if um otherwise the board can just vote on it and and proceed as if it you know a variance

Similar wording

was needed but it is up to the board whether they would like to make a separate finding on

Similar wording

that particular issue why don't we just approve this today okay mi 2023 005 680 5800 city line

Similar wording

avenue i vote yes thomas holloman my vote is yes james snell my vote is yes ishmael shaheed my vote

Similar wording

is yes thank you counsel chair before i leave may i move my exhibits into evidence please

Similar wording

absolutely absolutely thank you that concludes my business may i please be excused

Similar wording

after yes you can thank you thank you all very much for your time

Similar wording

number 13 mi 2023 003 725 1 crescent drive robert careless is the attorney

Similar wording

recommendation of non-opposition from the veteran stadium neighbors civic association

Similar wording

Robert Kerales has been promoted.

Similar wording

Mr. Kerales, could you please state your name and spell for the court stenographer?

Similar wording

Good afternoon, Mr. Chairman. Robert Kerales, C-A-R-E-L-E-S-S.

Similar wording

Right. Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Could you identify your client and relationship to this property?

Similar wording

my client is one crescent holdco llc the record owner of the property

Similar wording

our vice chair has a few questions for you sir sure good afternoon counselor do you agree to

Similar wording

the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy i do have you emailed in all the required

Similar wording

documents and exhibits that is needed and required to proceed with this case by these in advance of

Similar wording

this hearing i have thank you please proceed and you have already shared your screen yeah thank you

Similar wording

and then just one quick note that we have a referral not a refusal um but the answer is

Similar wording

still the same um and thank you this we're here on one crescent drive otherwise known as parcel

Similar wording

7c of the philadelphia navy yard the subject property is currently comprised of an existing

Similar wording

office building as a surface accessory parking lot of approximately 300 spaces uh we're here

Similar wording

before you today due to the proposed subdivision of the property into parcel 7c1 and parcel 7c2

Similar wording

7C1 will contain the existing office building and 58 accessory spaces.

Similar wording

Parcel 7C2 will contain the remaining 242 spaces.

Similar wording

And by virtue of the proposed subdivision, will become a non-accessory surface parking lot and thus require a special exception approval from this board under its CMX3 zoning district.

Similar wording

So, with that background, we have our exhibits.

Similar wording

I'll go through them briefly.

Similar wording

Exhibit A1 is our deed into the property.

Similar wording

Exhibit A2 is our Certificate of Tax Clearance. Exhibit A3 is our Application L&I. Exhibit A4, our Appropriate Referral.

Similar wording

Application L&I, Exhibit A4, our appropriate referral for the non-accessory parking lot use. Exhibit A6 is our application to this board. Exhibit A6, I'm sorry, Exhibit A6 is the posting of the property. Exhibit A5 was the application, excuse me, the application of the board.

Similar wording

exhibit a7 just for orientation purposes for the board we are here at the navy yard

Similar wording

where my cursor is is the boundary of the property we have what crescent drive to our north south

Similar wording

13th street to our east intrepid avenue to our south exhibit a8 is the drawings that we submitted

Similar wording

to l and i and then for the board's ease of reference we have the the drawings overlaid

Similar wording

with a mark here so the board can easily see what we're proposing in the blue solid boundary is the

Similar wording

property line that exists today part in the purple color here is proposed parcel 7c1 that is not

Similar wording

before the board today but that would be the existing office building with the 58 accessory

Similar wording

spaces and the green is what is before the board today we're asking for the special exception

Similar wording

due to the subdivision of this from the overall parcel that will become a non-accessory

Similar wording

parking lot however it will continue to function the way it is today part of the reason why we're

Similar wording

asking for this is that the 2022 master plan for the Navy does eventually call for a building site

Similar wording

in this general area with parking mid-block. But that is down the road. And then for the subdivision

Similar wording

purposes, the parking lot will continue to remain and operate as it is today. Exhibit A-9 is our

Similar wording

letter from the RCO. We met with the RCO on October 9th. We have a letter of opposition from

Similar wording

Veterans Stadium Neighbor Civic Association. And Exhibit A-10 is my list of witnesses. Mr. Chairman,

Similar wording

this is a straightforward special exception i know the board is has heard a lot today so

Similar wording

i'd like to just promote mr mark seltzer and miss elizabeth norton as panelists if they

Similar wording

could raise their hands i can name down my testimony and we can answer any questions the

Similar wording

board may have okay they have been allowed to speak mr seltzer yes hi could you state your

Similar wording

name, please, and spell for the court stenographer.

Similar wording

Mark Seltzer,

Similar wording

M-A-R-K-S-E-L-T-Z-E-R.

Similar wording

Right. Do you swear

Similar wording

or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing

Similar wording

but the truth? Yes.

Similar wording

And the engineer, please,

Similar wording

your name? Elizabeth Norton,

Similar wording

E-L-I-Z-A-B-E-T-H,

Similar wording

N-O-R-T-O-N.

Similar wording

Right. Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth,

Similar wording

the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes. Please proceed, counsel.

Similar wording

Thank you. Mr. Seltzer, you are

Similar wording

the managing director at Ensemble.

Similar wording

MR. Correct.

Similar wording

MR. And you are an authorized representative of the record owner of the property?

Similar wording

MR. Yes.

Similar wording

MR. And did you hear my testimony today?

Similar wording

MR. Yes.

Similar wording

MR. And was it correct, to the best of your knowledge?

Similar wording

MR. Yes.

Similar wording

MR. And would you adopt and affirm that testimony as if it were your own?

Similar wording

MR. Yes.

Similar wording

MR. Thank you. Ms. Norton?

Similar wording

MR. Yes.

Similar wording

MR. You are the Associate Vice President of Land Development Division Manager at Pannoni?

Similar wording

MR. Correct.

Similar wording

MR. And you are the record engineer for this project?

Similar wording

MR. Yes.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And did you hear my testimony today?

Similar wording

I did.

Similar wording

Was it correct to the best of your knowledge?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And would you adopt it as if for your own?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Mr. Chairman, I don't have any further questions for the witnesses.

Similar wording

Questions from the board?

Similar wording

No, Mr. Chairman.

Similar wording

No, Chair.

Similar wording

No, Chair.

Similar wording

Questions or comments from our attorney, Hillary Emerson?

Similar wording

Not at this time, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

Questions or comments from the virtual audience?

Similar wording

No, Haines, Chair.

Similar wording

planning commission

Similar wording

good afternoon chair peter bernard for the planning commission

Similar wording

the comprehensive plan recommends no change to the existing cmx3 commercial mixed use at this

Similar wording

location we feel the application has demonstrated a hardship accordingly the planning commission

Similar wording

recommends the board grant the variance thank you just just a clarification this is a special

Similar wording

exception for me i'm sorry it's just a special exception just want to clarify that for the record

Similar wording

mi2023-003-725-1 crescent drive i vote yes thomas holliman my vote is yes

Similar wording

jane snell my vote is yes yes my vote is yes thank you counsel thank you for your time all

Similar wording

All right, we're going to go to number 16, MI 2023, 004191, 1807 Pine Street.

Similar wording

Sean Whalen is the attorney, and we also have another attorney who's representing a neighbor.

Similar wording

So could they both come back on, please?

Similar wording

Yes, I will promote now, Chair.

Similar wording

Proud.

Similar wording

they have both been promoted

Similar wording

mr whalen could you state your name and please and spell for the word sonographer

Similar wording

mr whalen could you state your name and please and spell for the words and

Similar wording

certainly sean whalen w-h-a-l-e-n from vintage law here on behalf of the applicant and owner

Similar wording

of 1807 pine street and i um you've already been sworn earlier

Similar wording

and the counsel for the neighbor please identify yourself

Similar wording

I'm Krista Stafkiewicz from Eckert-Siemann, sharing him a lot.

Similar wording

Okay, and you've already been sworn.

Similar wording

I would note there's a letter of support from the Center City Residents Association.

Similar wording

And Mr. Whale, why don't you start?

Similar wording

Thank you very much, Chair.

Similar wording

The Vice Chair has a few questions. I'm sorry.

Similar wording

Of course.

Similar wording

good afternoon council do you agree to wait the reading of the refusal and stipulate towards

Similar wording

accuracy yes i do have emailed in all the required documents and exhibits that are

Similar wording

needed and required to proceed with this case five days in advance of this hearing

Similar wording

yes i have thank you please proceed share your screen thank you very much

Similar wording

so just quickly um i can't tell what you're viewing can you see a uh an aerial map a map

Similar wording

that has um yeah perfect okay all right so as i stated i'm here on behalf of the owner and the

Similar wording

applicant of 1807 pine street that's where this uh big red blob is fronts on pine street and all

Similar wording

these properties on Pine Street go all the way back to this very narrow alley-like street called

Similar wording

Panama Street. This building right here is the existing frontage. We would note there's no change

Similar wording

to the frontage or to the overall height. We did get a height refusal, but that's only for this

Similar wording

existing height at the frontage of over 50 feet. There is nothing else proposed that is coming

Similar wording

close to the 50-foot height. This is in the rear. This is a better photo. You can see this is along

Similar wording

Panama Street down here. There is a single car garage entrance with a curb cut and a pedestrian

Similar wording

walkway entrance, both with, you know, a one-story addition here. There's another three-story addition

Similar wording

here. This is all

Similar wording

100% lot coverage, and this is proposed to be

Similar wording

demolished in the rear and rebuilt. Essentially, the condition you will

Similar wording

see is the same condition as is right next

Similar wording

to us. This is 1805 Pine Street.

Similar wording

That condition was granted a variance for

Similar wording

the 100% lot coverage and fully built out at the third floor.

Similar wording

This, again, you can see, and I assume it will come up.

Similar wording

The property to the right of this screen is 1809 Pine Street.

Similar wording

That is who is represented by council today.

Similar wording

They are set back.

Similar wording

They have a third three-story building there as well.

Similar wording

Both properties are set back and have windows on the side.

Similar wording

Our property would be, as I said, continuing this iteration from 1805, and we would have a large window well cutout extending much of the distance and leaving light and air for 1809.

Similar wording

So again, you can just see this is the 1805 property that is fully built out. The only

Similar wording

difference is we will have a narrower garage and continue to have a single door for pedestrian

Similar wording

entrance. This is that Panama Street that I was describing. On the left is the rear of the homes

Similar wording

that front on Delancey. On the right is the rear of the homes that front onto Pine Street. So again,

Similar wording

it's sort of an alleyway condition in the rear but as you can see both here go look this is looking

Similar wording

east and then here looking west there is almost an entirely garage-like atmosphere in the rear

Similar wording

with virtually every property being a hundred percent built out and those that are not a hundred

Similar wording

percent built out similar to the next door neighbor are built out almost a hundred percent with two-car

Similar wording

parking in the rear. You can see this condition a few times. So we did go before CCRA twice in fact.

Similar wording

We went for the first time in September and they voted to oppose the project. Their opposition

Similar wording

and they voted to oppose the project. Their opposition was related to basically protecting

Similar wording

the light and air of the current residents at 1809, the next door neighbor, and therefore they

Similar wording

asked us. We had proposed a four-story rear addition, and they requested that we reduce

Similar wording

that to a three-story rear addition, and therefore they agreed to host us again for a second meeting

Similar wording

last night, and they voted not to oppose. So they changed their position upon our submission of

Similar wording

revised plans. We submitted revised plans, one page, and a proviso plan form indicating that

Similar wording

reduction of the rear addition, and those are in the package. So again, just to give you an idea,

Similar wording

This is an aerial view. Here's 1807 Pine. This full existing building and frontage, this is the 50-foot frontage. That's going to remain untouched. That's what's facing on Pine Street.

Similar wording

It's this rear portion that will be demolished, and we are seeking to put eight units in. There

Similar wording

are four units currently. We're seeking to put eight units in, add elevator, and full ADA

Similar wording

accessibility. It's our understanding that this would be the first ADA accessible building

Similar wording

on the entire block. And I should note here that the number of units is wholly contextual.

Similar wording

So there are actually seven units at 1808, 1809, 1814, 1815, 1817, 1819, 1820, and 1826.

Similar wording

and there are nine units at 1801 and 1810.

Similar wording

So there's a similar condition of multi-

Similar wording

Mr. Well, one point.

Similar wording

Go ahead.

Similar wording

I don't show currently three dwelling units.

Similar wording

You said four.

Similar wording

Sorry, I believe I misspoke.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Oh, that's fine.

Similar wording

That's fine.

Similar wording

Just check.

Similar wording

I will double check that with my client right now,

Similar wording

but I believe it, I thought it was four,

Similar wording

but if it's three, then it is three.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

So, again here, this is our property in the rear. As you can see, existing three-story addition. This will all be demolished and will become a three-story replacement addition.

Similar wording

we also received so we received a very a refusal for height that height again is the existing

Similar wording

condition of the front of this of our property that's unchanged and we're not going up to that

Similar wording

height with the proposed addition then we received a refusal for 100 lot coverage and

Similar wording

that is an existing condition at the property currently and we are actually reducing that

Similar wording

because we will have 135 square foot light well that will be adjacent to 1809 here,

Similar wording

the individual who's represented by council today.

Similar wording

So we will be maintaining, you can see kind of there's an alleyway-esque atmosphere

Similar wording

in between the two properties.

Similar wording

Obviously, any property can build out to the property line,

Similar wording

but when these two were built, these two rear portions were built,

Similar wording

they were set back in order to afford the opportunity for windows.

Similar wording

So again, this is just more evidence you can see were set back.

Similar wording

This rearmost portion would be built out to our property line, which is the cinder blocks.

Similar wording

The whole portion where you see from about 16, 17 feet from this full height of the front building

Similar wording

all the way out down along here will be the open atmosphere airway.

Similar wording

And then here, I apologize, this aerial view came out a little squiggly,

Similar wording

but this was just to show this is what CCRA wanted.

Similar wording

So we had proposed that this rear addition would be four stories,

Similar wording

which we felt was contextual.

Similar wording

Again, you can see from looking up and down the block,

Similar wording

there are a lot of four-story buildings there.

Similar wording

However, CCRA at its first meeting felt that in order to, you know, kind of look out for this building at 1809 and its interests, even though they were not represented at the September meeting, they asked us to reduce the height proposed for our rear addition, and we did so.

Similar wording

So again, this is the one page of revised plans that you have in front of you.

Similar wording

revised plans that you have in front of you. And I will just call your attention to, so we're

Similar wording

And...

Similar wording

maintaining the curb cut and this will be where that pedestrian entryway is.

Similar wording

We have a new elevator going in. Again, we believe will be the first fully accessible ADA

Similar wording

property on the block. And this is that large lightwell. It's actually 20 feet long.

Similar wording

And this is, I should be clear, this is 1809 to the left. So we flipped orientation. So this is

Similar wording

where the alleyway is right now that has sort of setback on both sides. Obviously, we don't have

Similar wording

to set back on our side. Everyone's allowed to, again, build to the property line. But we thought

Similar wording

that it was a better design to set it back there. Again, just so that the board is clear,

Similar wording

we submitted a proviso plan form with a single change to reduce the proposed rear addition from

Similar wording

four stories to three stories. Again, these are the, whatchamacallit, here are the refusals that

Similar wording

I've already walked through. We could use a permitted five units. We are proposing eight

Similar wording

units, and I will use it this time. So five units are permitted by right with no bonuses.

Similar wording

Seven units are permitted by right with bonuses. We are seeking eight units, which we believe is

Similar wording

least minimum variance because we are already proposing very large, roughly 1,000 square foot

Similar wording

plus two-bedroom units. And in order to, you know, if we were to reduce the unit count,

Similar wording

we would be increasing those unit sizes really to difficult rental numbers as is.

Similar wording

I mean, we are proposing, likely to propose a three-unit building unit on the very first floor

Similar wording

fronting on Delancey. That will be, you know, sorry, three-bedroom unit fronting on Delancey,

Similar wording

which will be very large. And I should note that the zoning district is RM1.

Similar wording

So this is multifamily and that's what we're seeking to continue.

Similar wording

Now, I know that there, you know, an issue has already been raised with regard to notice.

Similar wording

So I will unfortunately take the time to walk through this. September 5th, the mailing was

Similar wording

sent out with regard to the CCRA meeting at the end of the month. That meeting was, that letter

Similar wording

was sent out to 130 addresses. This is their certificate of mailing. You can see at line 108

Similar wording

here, it was sent to 1809 Pine Street, the next door neighbor who's represented today.

Similar wording

At all times, this is a screenshot from 1807 Pine in the Atlas site.

Similar wording

At all times, this has represented the variance request and refusals.

Similar wording

And the property has been fully posted in the front.

Similar wording

This is the front of the property and the rear of the property.

Similar wording

this is our property over here. So again, just to go back, CCRA held us, you know, agreed to have a

Similar wording

second meeting if we could meet their conditions. We did so. We believe that we have a hardship here

Similar wording

because while we can, because, and I do recall where I conflated the three and four units,

Similar wording

I apologize, board chair. It is three units. Even if we were to buy right, build out this property, and we could do so fully out to the property line, we would have to make an ADA accessible unit because we'd be going, even at buy right, at four stories, we'd have to have a fully accessible buy right unit.

Similar wording

We're trying to put in an elevator, trying to become an ADA accessible building.

Similar wording

That can only happen with that increased cost.

Similar wording

We're also seeking that one basically additional unit.

Similar wording

We do have a very large old existing building that we're trying to bring up to current standards and will be required to bring up to current building code standards with by and through this change in use.

Similar wording

There is no effect to the public health, safety, or welfare, negative effect that is. We are fully contextual, and that was noted by CCRA at both meetings in unit count.

Similar wording

The, you know, there is no effect to the public health, safety or welfare.

Similar wording

And we will have actually this building will become significantly safer if we are allowed to make this addition and build it out to the current code, both with sprinklers, ADA accessibility and improved fire escape access, which right now, ironically, the fire escape requires anyone leaving to jump into the property at 1809.

Similar wording

9 in order to escape any fire that would be taking place. And lastly, I think, as everyone

Similar wording

can see, there's been, you know, a large change in this neighborhood, which by itself can justify

Similar wording

a hardship. You know, there is along both Pine Street and Delancey, not only on this block,

Similar wording

but on others, a significant increase in density. And, you know, the general context, as I walked

Similar wording

through, most of the properties are seven and nine units. And we are seeking eight with regard to

Similar wording

how those lay out. Again, we believe that there is, you know, we have a fully built condition,

Similar wording

we intend to not exacerbate that fully built condition, but to proceed. And really, the only

Similar wording

reason why we're coming before you with those issues um the dimensional issues are because

Similar wording

we're seeking that variance for the eight units which CCRA had no issues with and that's why they

Similar wording

changed their vote to not oppose um so with that I know I went very quickly I'm happy to answer

Similar wording

any questions that board chair the other members of the board may have otherwise I'll call my

Similar wording

witnesses. Why don't we bring your witness on? Just one

Similar wording

question. Either side of you, what are the unit counts?

Similar wording

1809, which

Similar wording

you will hear shortly, is

Similar wording

seven units. Right here, that's really the

Similar wording

lone objector to this property.

Similar wording

And who was I had a note in 1805 because they also appeared

Similar wording

at

Similar wording

I don't have it right in front of me,

Similar wording

but I know my witness will be able to tell you.

Similar wording

Why don't we bring your client on?

Similar wording

Certainly.

Similar wording

Adam Singer should be on.

Similar wording

There's Adam Singer.

Similar wording

I'll allow him to speak.

Similar wording

could you please state your name sir and spell for the court stenographer

Similar wording

adam singer a-d-a-m-s-i-n-g-e-r right do you swear a firm to tell the truth the whole truth

Similar wording

nothing but the truth i do proceed counsel thank you uh mr singer you're here on behalf of the

Similar wording

LLC owning the property, correct? Correct. And the name of that LLC is I Hate 1807 Pine

Similar wording

ST LLC? Correct. Okay. Did you hear all of the testimony that I already provided?

Similar wording

I did. And do you believe it to be true and correct to the best of your knowledge,

Similar wording

information, and belief? I do. And would you adopt that testimony as your own?

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Now, separately, Mr. Singer, you live locally, correct?

Similar wording

What is your address?

Similar wording

It's 1802 Delancey.

Similar wording

It's the one with the trees right there.

Similar wording

So your property at Delancey Street backs all the way up to Panama Street, correct?

Similar wording

It does.

Similar wording

And do you go up and down Panama Street every day?

Similar wording

Yeah, I park my car in the garage at the Pine Street building, and I go in the back door, out the back door all the time.

Similar wording

Okay. And you would agree with me that this really acts kind of like a rear alleyway, not a street, even though it is a street, correct?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Okay. And did you, just because this has been raised as an issue, did you notice that the rear of the property was posted with signage during this period?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay. And did you notice it just once or over a period of time?

Similar wording

No, I've seen it multiple times.

Similar wording

Okay. And again, because you go up and down Panama Street, if not every day, almost every day, because you live backing up to Panama Street yourself, correct?

Similar wording

Correct.

Similar wording

Okay. Thank you, Chair. I have no further questions for Mr. Singer. I do have one more.

Similar wording

Thank you, Chair. I have no further questions for Mr. Singer. I do have one more witness.

Similar wording

Hillary, I'm going to open this up for Cross.

Similar wording

Yes, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

Council?

Similar wording

Hello, Mr. Singer.

Similar wording

Hi there.

Similar wording

I just have one question for you.

Similar wording

So you have repeatedly walked down the street every day, you stated?

Similar wording

Not every day, but almost every day, yes.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And my client on Monday and Tuesday of this week has taken photos that there were no postings on the street the two days before the hearing.

Similar wording

I just wanted to put that on the record.

Similar wording

uh chair first and foremost i don't hear a question but secondly i think the question

Similar wording

would be the last two days did he see anything thank you sorry the last two days did you see

Similar wording

anything posted yes i did okay at what time

Similar wording

uh i don't know multiple multiple times a day i i really don't know

Similar wording

okay on monday and tuesday you saw the posting multiple times a day

Similar wording

on monday we got word that it came down from the storm we put it back up tuesday was there all day

Similar wording

for sure okay i have a dated photo that it was not there on tuesday morning um can i share my screen

Similar wording

and enter that photo into evidence uh but board chair i think i can help this along wait i guess

Similar wording

the question would be asking him did he see it tuesday uh board chair i think he testified that

Similar wording

he saw it on tuesday and i think i can stipulate i mean um but board chair i'm willing to stipulate

Similar wording

that it was not there tuesday morning my next witness will testify that it was posted uh in

Similar wording

the afternoon. Okay. And that was her job to repost it after I informed her that we had learned that

Similar wording

it had come down. Okay. Thank you. Cancel any more questions? No further questions. Thank you. Okay.

Similar wording

Sean, do you have another witness? Yes, I do. Gemma Dietrich.

Similar wording

Gemma Dietrich, can you raise your virtual hand, please?

Similar wording

oh there she is i'll allow her to speak okay i could you state your name please to spell for

Similar wording

the court stenographer my name is jenna dietrich j-e-n-n-a last name is spelled d-i-e-t-r-i-c-h

Similar wording

wait do you swear or firm to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth

Similar wording

i do will she cancel sorry excuse me mr chair um with the witnesses who are testifying we should

Similar wording

bring them up as panelists so that they can turn on their video okay I will promote our to panelists

Similar wording

now okay okay Jenna Dietrich has been promoted you've already been sworn counsel please proceed

Similar wording

certainly thank you board chair Ms. Dietrich you are an expediter with the city correct

Similar wording

That's correct.

Similar wording

All right. I misspoke in the city, not with the city, right?

Similar wording

That's correct. Six years. Yes.

Similar wording

For what business entity do you work for?

Similar wording

I work for JAD Development Company.

Similar wording

Okay. You do not work for me, correct?

Similar wording

I do not.

Similar wording

You're an independent third-party expediting service?

Similar wording

That's correct. And I'm licensed and insured.

Similar wording

thank you um excuse me can miss dietrich is miss dietrich able to turn on her video

Similar wording

um let me see here for you

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

oh i can see you now miss dietrich thank you

Similar wording

um so miss dietrich uh do you post properties often for zoning appeals yes very frequently

Similar wording

and are you familiar with the posting requirements for zoning appeals yes i am it has to be posted

Similar wording

on the frontage of the property and on the rear of the property okay and were you retained to post

Similar wording

1807 Pine for this zoning appeal? Yes, I was. Thank you. And did you, in fact, post 1807 Pine?

Similar wording

Thank you. And did you, in fact, post 1807 Pine?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And you posted both the zoning poster and the refusal?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay. And you posted them on the street frontage on Pine?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And do you see the image that is up on the screen? I hope it's up on the screen right now.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And is this where you posted the property?

Similar wording

Yes, I did that.

Similar wording

Okay. And now, did you also post the rear of the property?

Similar wording

I did.

Similar wording

And in fact, did you post the rear of the property twice?

Similar wording

I did, yes.

Similar wording

Did you learn on Monday, actually from myself, after I learned from Mr. Rosenblum that the posting had come down in the rear?

Similar wording

I did.

Similar wording

And you reposted the property, correct?

Similar wording

I did, in the afternoon.

Similar wording

I wanted to do it as soon as I could be.

Similar wording

I cut you off.

Similar wording

You were saying you posted the property in the rear?

Similar wording

I did.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And did you post that in the morning or the afternoon?

Similar wording

Afternoon.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And do you see the image on the screen now?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And you recognize this rear door is where you posted the property?

Similar wording

That's correct.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And was there evidence on that door of your original posting?

Similar wording

No, there was not.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

But you did post it the first time, correct?

Similar wording

I did.

Similar wording

And how do you post things on the property?

Similar wording

I have to use a scotch wall-safe tape so I don't damage any property, any glass, any doors, anything like that.

Similar wording

So that's what I use to post.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Now, Ms. Dietrich, you know, you said you post a lot of properties.

Similar wording

Was there a condition at this property that made you made this one more memorable?

Similar wording

Just the fact that I had to redo it.

Similar wording

Also, I remember it being like a tiny alleyway.

Similar wording

I wasn't sure exactly where the rear was.

Similar wording

I had to count the houses back in that alleyway to post it.

Similar wording

Just that's standard kind of stuff.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So is this the alleyway that you're talking about?

Similar wording

Right.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay. And so, I didn't meant to do it. And this is the rest of the alleyway, correct?

Similar wording

Yeah. Yes.

Similar wording

Okay. Thank you very much, Board Chair. I have no further questions for Ms. Dietrich.

Similar wording

Cross-examine.

Similar wording

Hi, Ms. Dietrich. I just have one question.

Similar wording

how frequently does the posting need to be checked to ensure it hasn't fallen off?

Similar wording

I don't check it. I post it and then I let my client know that it's been posted.

Similar wording

If there's inclement weather, there's a chance that it could come down. So,

Similar wording

it's always wise to have somebody check it. And how frequently should the property owner

Similar wording

check it i i can't give you an answer on that i don't know i don't know if there's a rule for

Similar wording

that um my job is to do the posting yeah okay questions you want no follow-up uh no i have

Similar wording

no follow-up thank you counsel you want to present your case yes um so again for the record my name

Similar wording

is krista stepkovic from eckert siemens and i'm representing 1809 pine street association who's

Similar wording

the owner of 1809 pine street which is immediately adjacent to 1807 prime first for the record my

Similar wording

client stated that the ccra meeting was not held for my client's property benefit but for the

Similar wording

benefit of 1805 which is on the other side of 1807 and that's why the fourth floor was removed

Similar wording

he was not even aware of this meeting until this past monday and at the hearing yesterday they said

Similar wording

they took that top floor off at the request of 1805 not 1809 and my client never even saw this

Similar wording

plan before monday um i think at this time my client is going to testify so i'd like to have

Similar wording

him sworn in he is uh right next to me please yep hi could you please state your name and spell for

Similar wording

the court stenographer uh martin rosenblum m-a-r-t-i-n rosenblum r-o-s-e-n-b-l-u-m

Similar wording

right do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

MR.

Similar wording

Please proceed, counsel.

Similar wording

my client opposes this project and as the board knows we requested a continuance earlier

Similar wording

My client opposes this project, and as the

Similar wording

um i'll have my client testify that there was no posting at the property for at least monday

Similar wording

and tuesday of this week applicant is required to repeatedly check and make sure the posting

Similar wording

hasn't come down which wasn't done he stated he walked down the street every day and you know

Similar wording

particularly after inclement weather he should have checked the posting um my this led my client

Similar wording

to not finding out about this hearing until a few days ago and this is a significant structure so

Similar wording

we are requesting a continuance um still at this time to meet with the applicant

Similar wording

the case is going on we're going to hear the case and okay we'll eventually make the right

Similar wording

this would make it an appropriate decision okay um can i enter into evidence the photos

Similar wording

you can of the posting yep okay i did send them to the zoning board you need me to share my screen

Similar wording

with them i would appreciate it yes okay sorry am i able to share my screen here

Similar wording

Green button on the bottom.

Similar wording

I don't have a button on the bottom.

Similar wording

What kind of computer do you have?

Similar wording

Thinkpad. But it should give me the option to share somewhere, shouldn't it?

Similar wording

Board Chair, I think if, based on Ms. Stefkovic's testimony, the photos are going to show that

Similar wording

posting was not on that rear door on this Monday, November 27th, and not this month, this Tuesday

Similar wording

in the AM on November 28th. I would stipulate to that and actually Mr. Rosenblum provided me

Similar wording

directly via email a copy of what I believe the photo is that Ms. Tufkovich will show.

Similar wording

Okay, fine. Thank you.

Similar wording

Okay, thanks.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So as to the merits of this case, then I'm going to ask my client, Martin Rosenblum, a few questions to address the board.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So first, can you confirm that you're the managing partner of 1809 Pine Street Association?

Similar wording

Yes, I am.

Similar wording

And that owns 1809 Pine Street?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

And your property is immediately adjacent to?

Similar wording

It is.

Similar wording

Okay. And based on your knowledge, what was the actual use of the property, 1807, for the past few years?

Similar wording

Well, it was an absolutely luxurious three-family residence. She ran a business out of it. I suggest if anyone is interested in what it looked like, it's on Zillow, because it was just sold.

Similar wording

and it was in norma took very good care of the interior of the property it is absolutely stunning

Similar wording

and it three units to eight units is quite a jump uh i would like to add that although there

Similar wording

is full lot coverage on the ground floor there is not full lot coverage above the ground floor

Similar wording

It is well set back. And every other building on the block has some gap. Even the building directly behind Mr. Singer, which is built all the way across, is only at the ground floor, which he has.

Similar wording

everyone is set back for the remainder of their addition from the lot line okay other than himself

Similar wording

the rear of my property of the original l of the building which is how these buildings were built

Similar wording

in the 19th century identically matches the l of his building and i might add is perfectly

Similar wording

serviceable as rental units i have a hundred percent occupancy so uh i don't i i don't

Similar wording

understand why it will be the first block building on the block that goes property line to property

Similar wording

line on the rear and i will add that it was said at the meeting the other night that is identical

Similar wording

to 1805, which

Similar wording

by the way is a single family

Similar wording

house, but it is

Similar wording

But it is not identical to 1805 because 1805's rear addition does not go the full width of the property.

Similar wording

not identical to 1805

Similar wording

because 1805's real

Similar wording

It stops short of the full width of the property.

Similar wording

So this is on the south side of the alley will be the only building that goes full width.

Similar wording

Everyone else stops short.

Similar wording

and most of the buildings that have been built out on the block retain their l which means they

Similar wording

have a full light court and only close in at the very rear okay in fact they are proposing to

Similar wording

cut in to what is an existing light area cutting off air and light from units in my apartment

Similar wording

building so they are radically expanding they are taking down an l which suffices for every other

Similar wording

one of the 20 or 30 buildings and they have made no accommodation to me i had asked for continuance

Similar wording

with the hope we could discuss this um it didn't happen i'm local i was never shown a plan

Similar wording

i was never shown any respect for that matter and i might add sir let's sir let me ask you

Similar wording

question did you go to the meeting last did you go to the meeting last night i certainly did and

Similar wording

i will say that you raise all these issues at that meeting i yes i did and i will also

Similar wording

residents association still i drop the opposition away i'm sorry i told them the occupancy of every

Similar wording

building on the east end of the block okay okay and it is a three family a five family a single

Similar wording

unit a seven family and the building after me is a three family they totally go back to my question

Similar wording

you told all them this last night i did and they still took their opposition away they

Similar wording

they they he told them at the meeting last night who's he uh the lawyer sean okay said that the

Similar wording

fourth floor was removed to accommodate 1805 pine street a single family house because it was

Similar wording

on their deck. Sean has said now at this meeting that it was removed at my behest when I never

Similar wording

saw the drawings. Nothing was removed to accommodate me because I didn't even know

Similar wording

that anything was going on. Okay, so I would like to start to state for the record that I would

Similar wording

expect that what was said at eight at the meeting to ccra is consistent what is said today and it

Similar wording

is not no accommodation was made to me sean whalen said the accommodation was made to accommodate

Similar wording

1805 pine street which is a single family house okay thank you

Similar wording

counsel do you have anything more from your client um yes so in your opinion is there any

Similar wording

hardship here there's tremendous hardship and there's no i'm sorry for me no for the owner

Similar wording

for the owner there's no hardship it was a totally occupied and performing building with

Similar wording

three units in it there are other three unit buildings on the block there is no hardship

Similar wording

okay thank you and are you concerned about negative impacts this development would have

Similar wording

on your property or the other neighboring properties tremendous um i'm not going to

Similar wording

dispute what was said at the meeting last night because that hasn't been entered into the record

Similar wording

here but as i said no l on any building on this block has ever been taken down in its entirety

Similar wording

they have only been added to demolition and i know they explained the meeting but demolition

Similar wording

i am an architect and i am a restoration architect i've lived up the block for 40 years

Similar wording

you cannot they are taking this building down under through a six foot wide alleyway

Similar wording

that we are all all used for access to our parking and they have said this isn't going to be a

Similar wording

problem when we have plumbers working on the street it's a problem and everyone is honking

Similar wording

their horn and by the way i have two rented parking spaces behind my building i don't know

Similar wording

I have two rented parking spaces behind my building.

Similar wording

I don't know how they will exist or how they will get in and out.

Similar wording

I'll see you next time.

Similar wording

So it is going to inconvenience my tenants tremendously if they even stay.

Similar wording

There is a lot, as I said, in the same footprint that he has.

Similar wording

I have seven totally successful units.

Similar wording

There is no reason to demolish.

Similar wording

There is no reason to build up. And as far as the ADA, there are steps in front of the building

Similar wording

into a vestibule and then you go up. I have partial information. There's a narrow on the back

Similar wording

and the floor levels between the front and rear portion of the building differ by almost five

Similar wording

feet. So I'm trying to figure out how an elevator operates to a second floor where half the second

Similar wording

floor is five feet higher than the other. There are too many questions here. I have never seen

Similar wording

a section through their building, which I would like to see. They are putting a deck, which no

Similar wording

one's said much about, on their roof, which is going to overlook the neighbor next door who they

Similar wording

so graciously um uh accommodated with no accommodation to me but there's a roof deck

Similar wording

up there i own several properties in the neighborhood access to the roof particularly

Similar wording

open access by more than one tenant is hideous they go out they walk across the roofs you get

Similar wording

beer cans i have a building on the 1800 block of spruce i have a building on locust i can tell you

Similar wording

about communal decks so we're not going to try it with what we want to do is try to concentrate on

Similar wording

this building here and not multiple buildings around the city so okay on this building he's

Similar wording

putting the deck i'm sorry that's okay all right any more questions council might i add one other

Similar wording

fact sir um you can add a fact i mean tell your council okay um we just have uh one other comment

Similar wording

are you concerned about the trash that could result from eight units and that'd be kept

Similar wording

and we'll go out yeah we haven't seen plans with where the the dumpster is going to go for this

Similar wording

increased um density on this property all right all right thank you um and so based on my client's

Similar wording

testimony and it is clear there's no legal hardship here the applicant is asking for more than they

Similar wording

would need and this would have an adverse impact on the neighborhood mr whale cross-examine uh i

Similar wording

have a closing argument but no no questions for mr rosenberg okay why don't why don't you perceive

Similar wording

your closing argument thank you very much um and not to belabor any points i'll try to move quickly

Similar wording

because i know we are the last on the list um no we have another whole group of people but that's

Similar wording

Coming in, we're already past that next list, so I apologize. I'll be as fast as possible.

Similar wording

You heard that we are seeking eight units with a minimal rear addition. Those eight units will

Similar wording

have wholly internal trash. That was covered at the CCRA hearing and was a big issue for them

Similar wording

at the time. Wade Albert, who represents CCRA, told me yesterday he would be on this hearing

Similar wording

so I don't know if he is or not. I can't see the participants, but I'll let him discuss CCRA's

Similar wording

position. Again, CCRA voted to oppose this project in September. They did so for one reason,

Similar wording

because of the height of the fourth story in the rear. To be very clear, their request for us to

Similar wording

reduce that rear addition from four stories to three stories was solely for the benefit of 1809

Similar wording

Pine Street, Mr. Rosenblum's property. The reason why they did that and why they took that position

Similar wording

was because Mr. Rosenblum nor any of his partners were present at the September meeting and they're

Similar wording

the ones who have the windows facing our property on their own setback. So they took the position

Similar wording

that if we reduce that, that would benefit, even though we're not required to, and we could build

Similar wording

to 100% lot coverage, as could Mr. Rosenblum, if he so desired, that would benefit the property at

Similar wording

1809. We did so and represented to CCRA last night, and they voted not to oppose. As you heard

Similar wording

from Mr. Rosenblum. He was present last night. He found out about this meeting.

Similar wording

he was present last night. He found out about this meeting. I'm not sure he could have certainly

Similar wording

found out about the September meeting as well, but was president last night's meeting. I don't

Similar wording

believe Ms. Stefkovich was or not, but she can speak for herself. I didn't see all the attendees.

Similar wording

And Mr. Rosenblum raised all of the issues that you just heard today. CCRA still,

Similar wording

in hearing all of those issues, they determined, as this board has, that most of Mr. Rosenblum's

Similar wording

issues are not zoning issues. He has issues of he doesn't like the design. He personally has

Similar wording

seven units, but somehow our requesting more units is inappropriate. We should remain with

Similar wording

three units. I showed you, and the photos are in the package, the rear alley shows numerous

Similar wording

properties that are built out 100% lot line to lot line. You know, that's just a matter of fact.

Similar wording

The, you know, the demolition of the rear is by right. There's no question, you know,

Similar wording

because Mr. Rosenblum is frustrated with or doesn't like the demolition of the rear addition

Similar wording

is of no moment. One of the things last night at the meeting that the CCRA members appreciated and

Similar wording

why there was some questions about, you know, difficulty traversing Panama Street and so forth

Similar wording

was that, again, the owner of this property, Mr. Adam Singer, who testified already,

Similar wording

lives at 1802 Delancey. He's catty-cornered to this property, literally could throw a stone

Similar wording

against it. He drives Panama Street all the time. Therefore, not only is it being a good neighbor

Similar wording

to keep Panama Street open, it's selfish that he needs to and wants to keep Panama Street open.

Similar wording

So, you know, I understand that Mr. Rosenblum has frustrations with something happening in the rear and wants the status quo to remain.

Similar wording

As this board is well aware and has found numerous times, it is not a self-created hardship nor any basis to refuse the granting of a variance because a purchaser buys a property with the intention of doing something different with that property than is currently being done or even that would require a variance.

Similar wording

um also there is no legal requirement in fact uh the as the board voted in another case of my own

Similar wording

um there is no legal requirement for the continual checking of whether a posting remains posted

Similar wording

rather as miss emerson has quite eloquently set forth in numerous findings the legal requirement

Similar wording

under the code is for the applicant to show that they posted the property through substantive

Similar wording

substantive evidence, which we did. And then that burden shifts to the protestant to determine

Similar wording

whether or not and show that it was not posted. You heard no such evidence. It was arguably not

Similar wording

posted for at least all day, Monday, the 27th and a.m. on the 28th. But those are a day and a half

Similar wording

out of the entire posting period. That's not substantive evidence sufficient to carry their

Similar wording

burden and overcome the presumption that we established. So just to summarize,

Similar wording

there is clear hardship both in the change of the neighborhood, the contextual character of

Similar wording

the neighborhood, including the immediately adjacent property. This was held and determined

Similar wording

by CCRA upon a second review of the property

Similar wording

and this is the least minimum

Similar wording

variance as I already set forth and fully in context with everything

Similar wording

else going on on the block and finally this will actually benefit

Similar wording

the public with no detriment. So with that

Similar wording

board chair I appreciate your time and consideration of this matter.

Similar wording

Thank you. Council do you have anything you want to add

Similar wording

to summarize um nothing that i haven't already summarized we don't believe there's a hardship

Similar wording

or that this was the least minimum variance questions questions from the board no mr chairman

Similar wording

no chair

Similar wording

questions questions or comments from our attorney hillary emerson

Similar wording

Chairman, I do see Wade Albert has his hand raised if you let me get to the to the virtual audience, I will get to him.

Similar wording

I'm sorry, Ms. Ellison.

Similar wording

I apologize.

Similar wording

That's okay. Hillary, no questions.

Similar wording

No questions.

Similar wording

Questions or comments from the virtual audience.

Similar wording

Yes, Wade Albert.

Similar wording

i will allow mr albert could you state your name please and spell for the court stenographer

Similar wording

sure my name is uh wade albert w-a-d-e last name is a-l-b-e-r-t right do you swear a firm to tell

Similar wording

the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth i do mr sure please proceed sir thank you so i am

Similar wording

a counsel for the center city residents association i'm uh attorney for uh with the law firm stevens

Similar wording

and lee um i just wanted to raise a few points the the description of of the process is is largely

Similar wording

accurate we heard this case uh originally on september 26th and at that time we opposed uh

Similar wording

based on concerns that were raised by uh individuals in the community and by our by our

Similar wording

committee members that the the height of the proposed addition in the rear was out of context

Similar wording

with the character of the neighborhood uh and at that after that i i spoke with mr whalen and

Similar wording

communicated that um if they were to reduce the height then ccri would reconsider um that change

Similar wording

that we requested i and i know there is some conflicting testimony i want to be very clear

Similar wording

about that it was not for the benefit of any particular neighbor it was for the community

Similar wording

generally was not we did not make ask to reduce the height to to to help the 1809 or 1805 or any

Similar wording

other property. It was just, we wanted to bring what we believed, um, the, this property back

Similar wording

into the context of, of the character of the neighborhood. Um, and so, um, we, we got those

Similar wording

revised plans and, and, um, gave, uh, the applicant an opportunity to, um, to, to represent last

Similar wording

night, which they did. Um, and as a result, um, CCRA voted to not oppose. I also want to comment

Similar wording

that this the uh mr rosenblum who um is i you know i totally understand the issues that he has raised

Similar wording

with um his you know his property in particular that he owns with his llc and we have tried i i

Similar wording

myself have tried very hard to um to connect mr rosenblum and mr whalen um and i i've spoken to

Similar wording

them, both of them, several times over the past two days. Mr. Rosenblum first sent me an email

Similar wording

or sent an email to CCRA, I believe, on Monday, which was forwarded to me. I immediately shared

Similar wording

the concerns about the notice postings with Mr. Whalen, and I think that's what got things moving

Similar wording

forward. We always try to be a neutral touchpoint for the neighbors and to facilitate any sort of

Similar wording

communications that would hopefully get everybody to agree on development.

Similar wording

I know that it may appear that that is not the case here, but we were hoping that maybe

Similar wording

there's some sort of agreement could be reached, and it appears that it cannot.

Similar wording

But that being said, having heard the plans twice, CCRA does not oppose.

Similar wording

CHAIRMAN BRYANT. Thank you. Mr. Whelan, do you have any questions?

Similar wording

MR. No, I do not for Mr. Albert. Thank you.

Similar wording

CHAIRMAN BRYANT. Counsel, do you have any questions?

Similar wording

no i do not thank you okay um is there anyone else in the virtual audience

Similar wording

or has comments no more hands here planning commission uh ron bednar city planning your

Similar wording

first name ron r-o-n last name bednar b-e-d-n-a-r do you swear affirm to tell the truth the whole

Similar wording

truth nothing but the truth i do please proceed the comprehensive plan recommends no change to

Similar wording

existing rm1 multi-family zoning at this location we feel the applicant has not demonstrated a

Similar wording

hardship for either the unit density or lack of open space as any existing archip is removed as

Similar wording

part of the demolition accordingly planning commission recommends that the board deny the

Similar wording

variance thank you um for both council uh we've had a lot of testimony i want to take this on the

Similar wording

consideration the executive session next week and we will vote on this next wednesday at 2 p.m

Similar wording

and and thank you all and thank you for all the comments that everyone made thank you all right

Similar wording

thank you very much right the record is closed is closed um is there um is there anyone in the

Similar wording

audience uh who's a 2 p.m class case was not called there are no hands chair okay we're

Similar wording

there are no hands chair okay we're going to take a five minute break so our

Similar wording

going to take a five minute break so our

Similar wording

our court reporter can get set we'll be right back and we're going to finish up the list

Similar wording

thank you chair

Similar wording

good afternoon my name is bill bergman and i will be chairing the zba hearing the 330 list

Similar wording

with me is our vice chair ismail shaheed

Similar wording

he's here our board member thomas holliman present mr chairman our board member james snell

Similar wording

present mr chairman also present is hillary emerson our attorney and our executive director

Similar wording

tanya sunken here's our virtual format be advised the proceedings are being recorded

Similar wording

A video will be available by contacting TanyaSunkett at philo.gov.

Similar wording

For the benefit of our court stenographer, we ask attorneys and witnesses to identify themselves before testifying.

Similar wording

If you're participating by phone and you wish to testify, press star 9 to raise your hand and star 6 to unmute.

Similar wording

To enter an appearance statement, call 267-270-5548.

Similar wording

Leave your email and the address of the property in question.

Similar wording

And finally, the question and answer box on the screen is not for comments or testimony.

Similar wording

All comments should be directed to our executive director, Tanya Sunken.

Similar wording

Let's look at our schedule for this 3.30 list.

Similar wording

Number one, MI 2023, 002-622-238 North 53rd Street.

Similar wording

That case is continued.

Similar wording

Number two, MI 2023-002-653-2750 North Broad Street.

Similar wording

Zen Jin is the attorney.

Similar wording

Zen has a letter of non-opposition from Allegheny West Civic Association, but Swamp Poodle RCO has called for a continuance.

Similar wording

Mr. Jin, could you please come on?

Similar wording

mr chair could you call number four with that as well i will request for continuance was for both

Similar wording

both appeals thank you so number four is in the same building it's mi 2023 002 687 2750 north

Similar wording

broad street yes sir good afternoon this is engine state your name for the record please at all

Similar wording

Yes, Zen Jin, Z-H-E-N, J-I-N, 1617 John F. Kennedy Boulevard, Suite 1838,

Similar wording

.LVPA 19103 here on behalf of the applicant.

Similar wording

You swear for him to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Mr. Jin, I see that you do have a letter from the Allegheny West Civic Association,

Similar wording

but I see Swamp Poodle call that I requested for a continuance.

Similar wording

Could you tell me your position on that?

Similar wording

Yes, we would state that all the notifications that were required was done. There was actually two community meetings, one which we sent mail for notification to near neighbors, and a second meeting requested by Allegheny West where we sent notifications by flyer to the near neighbors.

Similar wording

I also want to point out we did mail Swampudo, and Swampudo was initially included in all emails also of our outreach.

Similar wording

The problem is, of course, our outreach started in May, and we didn't get any response from any RCO until almost September, or at least August.

Similar wording

So it was not for lack of effort.

Similar wording

I don't know why Swampudo did not get our mail or the notification otherwise about the meetings itself,

Similar wording

but i can assure the board that the meetings did take place and i believe for the purpose of

Similar wording

allowing the neighbors to have a full understanding of what we're trying to present that has been done

Similar wording

through the two meetings we had with alligators are you ready to proceed i am okay is there a

Similar wording

Representative from Swampoodle in the audience?

Similar wording

Yes, Chair.

Similar wording

Phone number ending in 3552.

Similar wording

I will allow to speak.

Similar wording

Hello?

Similar wording

Adrienne, just state your name for the record, because I think I swore you in earlier today.

Similar wording

Yes, you did.

Similar wording

My name is Adrienne Fernandez.

Similar wording

My last name is F-E-R.

Similar wording

N-A-N-D-E-Z.

Similar wording

Right.

Similar wording

Adrienne, what's your position on this?

Similar wording

Everything I wrote in the email, Mr. Jen, sorry, has nothing to prove that he notified no one.

Similar wording

There are five or six RCOs on this address that are affected RCOs, and we've had numerous problems.

Similar wording

um on this address that are affected rcos and we've had numerous problems with allegheny west

Similar wording

foundation who is a developer breaking the zoning law or not complying with the zoning law and

Similar wording

holding private meetings with other developers in this case this is similar um we are asking that

Similar wording

um the other five or six rcos are allowed to hold the meetings that the zoning code gives us the

Similar wording

right to have. The only communication we received

Similar wording

I put in the letter, my memory, I believe it was May

Similar wording

15th, August 9th,

Similar wording

and August 11th, a staff person of his

Similar wording

sent three letters to Allegheny West Foundation and they copied us

Similar wording

possibly other RCOs and said that they couldn't get in touch with Allegheny West

Similar wording

Foundation. We have no plans, no

Similar wording

no documents no notices of public meeting um he sent nothing out to rcos and it is inadequate for

Similar wording

him to send flyers when the code requires usps delivery we have no proof of mailing we have

Similar wording

nothing i don't think it's fair to have nothing about listen to me uh we do have the coordinating

Similar wording

rco in non-opposition we're going to hear the case we're all equal you listen me we're going

Similar wording

hear the case both cases you'll have an opportunity to speak and right now these cases are going to

Similar wording

go on and i'm going to continue with the continuations and also the cases that we do not have

Similar wording

documents so you will be coming back to this case shortly thank you okay how can we um

Similar wording

number number three mi 2022 006 757 1134 1134 waverly street two are that case is continued

Similar wording

what street are there any other requests for continuances

Similar wording

there are no hands here and i have two cases that we do not have exhibits for number six

Similar wording

mi 2022 006 746 226 rittner street no exhibits second listing attorney should be needed on this

Similar wording

case no one also appeared the last time on 5323 no exhibits

Similar wording

Mr. Chair, I just want to note that JG Premier Homes, LLC, is the listed owner, and CGI Construction Incorporated is the listed applicant.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

We have heard from neither entity.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

And there's no hands up.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So MI 2022-006-746-226 Ritten Street.

Similar wording

This is the second listing.

Similar wording

We have no documents, and we also, no one appeared the last time for the hearing.

Similar wording

I vote to dismiss.

Similar wording

Thomas Holloman, my vote is to dismiss.

Similar wording

James Snell, my vote is to dismiss.

Similar wording

We have the votes.

Similar wording

Number 7, MI 2022, 006-880, 2219 Sigel Street.

Similar wording

No exhibit, second listing.

Similar wording

no one appeared the last time mark must be heard michael newman is the listed applicant

Similar wording

newman investing llc is the listed owner

Similar wording

no hands here okay so mi 2022 006 880 2219 single street this is the second listing we

Similar wording

still have no exhibits no one appeared at the first listing i vote to dismiss

Similar wording

Thomas Holloman, my vote is to dismiss.

Similar wording

James Snell, my vote is to dismiss.

Similar wording

Thank you. Thank you, Jim.

Similar wording

We're going to go to our first case, which is number eight.

Similar wording

MI 2023-002-628-1458 North 30th Street.

Similar wording

Kevin Bryan is the owner of Pro Se.

Similar wording

this application is for visitor accommodation in existing structure

Similar wording

the proposed use visitor accommodation is prohibited in the cmx one zoning district

Similar wording

kevin bryan has been promoted

Similar wording

i'm mr bryan could you state your name please and spell for the court stenographer

Similar wording

trying to get my my video going um hello everyone uh mr chairman name first spell

Similar wording

Trying to get my V

Similar wording

for the court stenographer my name is kevin bryant last name b-r-y-a-n-t

Similar wording

okay um do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

i do or uh mr hallman has a few questions for you

Similar wording

good afternoon sir yeah i hear you i hear you as i didn't hear you the first time around

Similar wording

please proceed us go ahead counsel do you agree to weigh the reading of the refusal and stipulate

Similar wording

to his accuracy have you emailed in all the required documents and exhibits that is needed

Similar wording

to proceed with this case five days in advance of this hearing uh no i did not did not

Similar wording

okay what is it that we're still missing um so i have my wife who's also uh on this call

Similar wording

i'd like to bring her in if possible um what i'd like to do is um i'd like to explain to the court

Similar wording

uh to the panel um what's going on so far with my process i'm very new i don't have an attorney

Similar wording

so i just wanted to explain my part of this process

Similar wording

hillary do we have all the documents um no mr chair um i advised mr mr bryant um earlier today

Similar wording

and i apologize for for the lateness of the notice um but we do not have proof of an rco meeting

Similar wording

occurring um there are no interior photos of the property and no proof of tax compliance submitted

Similar wording

so um we we cannot go ahead unless we know that there has been an rco meeting

Similar wording

um and we need the photos as well the tax compliance we can hold the vote for right

Similar wording

mr bryant did you meet with an rco um my wife i believe she did um i'd like to bring her in if

Similar wording

possible okay where is she at hello um i'm here um you state wait a minute wait a minute could

Similar wording

you please state your name and spell for the quartz demographer it's chadi bryant c-h-o-d-d-i-e

Similar wording

b-r-y-a-n-t do you swear for him to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

i do did you meet with the rco um we're new at this i don't even know that's okay that's okay

Similar wording

no i didn't because i didn't know what an rco was or how to do it all right so so so here here's

Similar wording

what we're going to do and i'm sorry we kept you so long we're going to have to continue this

Similar wording

but what i want you to do is call the office they will tell you everything that you need

Similar wording

and they will the next time around we'll be ready to go okay okay is there all the office

Similar wording

they'll explain they'll explain to you the rco process all the other forms that you need and

Similar wording

we'll make sure we make this work for you okay okay is there a number that um excuse me chair

Similar wording

we'll put it in the chat miss brian yeah they're going to put it in the chat and just go into the

Similar wording

chat you'll get for you thank you so much oh no no that's fine that's fine we we don't expect

Similar wording

everybody to understand it all the time okay thank you so much thank you and number nine

Similar wording

mi 2023 002 682 1317 south ruby jason farris is the owner applicant pro se this application

Similar wording

is for the proposed use of a non-accessory surface parking on existing vacant lot to

Similar wording

Proposed use, non-accessory parking, is prohibited in the RSA-5 zoning.

Similar wording

There is a letter of support from the 51st Ward Democratic RCO and received streets approval for a curb cut.

Similar wording

Mr. Farris.

Similar wording

Mr. Farris has been promoted.

Similar wording

Good evening, Mr. Farris. Could you state your name, please, and spell for the court sonographer?

Similar wording

jason ferris j-a-s-o-n-f-a-r-r-i-s do you swear for him to tell the truth the whole truth nothing

Similar wording

but the truth yes i do our vice chair has just a few questions

Similar wording

good afternoon sir have you emailed in all the required documents and exhibits that is needed

Similar wording

and required to proceed with this case five days in advance of this hearing i have thank you please

Similar wording

Please proceed and share your screen.

Similar wording

uh thank you for seeing me today um i'm proposing a surface park a single surface parking spot um

Similar wording

on the property next door to my home which i also own um can you see my screen we can excellent um

Similar wording

This is the submitted drawings, the refusal, application for appeal.

Similar wording

This is from my RCO meeting, and the letter is sent out to the near neighbors.

Similar wording

The RCO meeting, there was at least one near neighbor in attendance, and this is a letter

Similar wording

of support from the RCO, the 51st Ward.

Similar wording

This is the deed for the property.

Similar wording

and my certificate of tax clearance

Similar wording

um i'd say that um you know as big concern for many parking spots is that it would take away or

Similar wording

many off street parking spots is that it would take away a on-street parking spot i live on a

Similar wording

one-way street um all of the existing street parking is on the other side of the street so

Similar wording

this won't eliminate um it'll actually um provide an extra parking spot on the street since my

Similar wording

vehicle would be off um i've not expressed or experienced any opposition to this from any of

Similar wording

the neighbors that i've talked to um and haven't uh none none were um came to the rco meeting to

Similar wording

express

Similar wording

opposition.

Similar wording

Mr. Farris,

Similar wording

does anybody else on the block have that type of

Similar wording

parking?

Similar wording

There are other vacant properties,

Similar wording

but

Similar wording

at the other end of the block,

Similar wording

one of those is

Similar wording

parked in, but it's not legal.

Similar wording

There are no curb cuts or

Similar wording

legal parking on the block.

Similar wording

And you went

Similar wording

to the streets department too?

Similar wording

yeah i started with the streets department and i did get their approval before it went on

Similar wording

to um i thought that this would be um granted as right but

Similar wording

um since my deeds are not combined it can't be an accessory to anything

Similar wording

um questions from the board no mr chairman

Similar wording

no chair

Similar wording

questions from our attorney hillary emerson

Similar wording

not at this time mr chair questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

no hands chair planning commission uh ron bednar city planning properties indicated for residential

Similar wording

use on the city plan or adopted distant plan recommends no change the existing zoning at this

Similar wording

location the applicant's hardship is not supported with evidence of unique physical circumstances or

Similar wording

condition of the property that prevented from being used conforming with the parking requirements of

Similar wording

the code front-loaded driveways is inappropriate at this location particularly may block therefore

Similar wording

we recommend request advance not be granted thank you um mr faris i think what i want to do is

Similar wording

sit and talk to the other board members next wednesday we'll vote on this next wednesday at

Similar wording

2 p.m okay uh can i say one thing further you you can sir uh just as a as a note i do own this

Similar wording

property and i have no intentions of ever building a structure on it so um without the parking spot

Similar wording

it would continue to always be an open vacant block okay all right thank you very much sir

Similar wording

thank you and thank you and the record is closed mr chair record is definitely closed

Similar wording

here we're going to go dear two so we're going to go to we'll do number two and number four

Similar wording

at the same time mi 2023 002 653 2750 north broad street zen jin is the attorney and number four

Similar wording

is MI-2023-002-687-2750

Similar wording

North Broad Street.

Similar wording

Zen is also the attorney there.

Similar wording

Both of these requests

Similar wording

have a letter of non-opposition

Similar wording

from Allegheny West.

Similar wording

Good evening.

Similar wording

You've already been sworn,

Similar wording

could you identify your client

Similar wording

and their relationship to this property?

Similar wording

Yes, my client is

Similar wording

West Broad Associates

Similar wording

uh west broad associates llc uh ww broad associates llc uh mr ivan way uh is the

Similar wording

LLC, WW Broad

Similar wording

Associates LLC.

Similar wording

representative from the llc that's going to be with us here today and our our vice chair has just

Similar wording

good afternoon council do you agree to waive the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy

Similar wording

i do have you emailed then all the required documents and exhibits that is needed to

Similar wording

received the case five days in advance of this hearing i did thank you please proceed and share

Similar wording

your screen thank you i'm going to share with the board what was submitted previously

Similar wording

there are two refusals both for the same property i want to clarify that one refusal is for four of

Similar wording

the units which we will see on the plans it's unit one through four they're individually asked to be

Similar wording

restaurants under that refusal and the second refusal is for unit five which is actually the

Similar wording

lower level of the building and that is a auto repair business so i'm going to go ahead and

Similar wording

start with unit one through four and then we will go to unit five as a second part of our presentation

Similar wording

so this is an application for use as a restaurant in four different tenant spaces in the building

Similar wording

27 north broad 27 50 north broad street is zoned i1 which it's industrial zoning what this building

Similar wording

is and i'm going to jump to photographs because it's probably clear to look at the photos to

Similar wording

understand what we're talking about here this is a large former industrial structure on the corner

Similar wording

of west somerset and north broad street this entire structure including the back area here

Similar wording

all belongs to the same building.

Similar wording

The building was at one point

Similar wording

some kind of industrial factory.

Similar wording

However, it has been vacant by,

Similar wording

I believe my client's estimate

Similar wording

and neighbor's confirmation

Similar wording

somewhere around 30, 40 years.

Similar wording

It might've been vacant for,

Similar wording

it has not been used in an industrial format

Similar wording

for as long as many people can remember.

Similar wording

At this point,

Similar wording

North Broad Street is becoming

Similar wording

a commercial corridor.

Similar wording

and my client is trying to revitalize this building in phases.

Similar wording

This is the beginning of the revitalization.

Similar wording

He has done some repairs required to first make the building safe

Similar wording

because it was unsafe when he acquired it.

Similar wording

Now he is trying to get commercial spaces put in at the front of the building

Similar wording

facing Broad Street.

Similar wording

These are the five spaces that we're here before the board for.

Similar wording

one two three and four unit one to four that we're looking for small restaurant uses and then

Similar wording

this is the entrance to the lower level where unit five would be for the purpose of auto repair

Similar wording

the plans can better show just how little of the building we're really talking about with unit one

Similar wording

through four i'm going to zoom in a little bit but you can see that this is the portion of the

Similar wording

building this each one of these is one of the units so this is unit one through four they all

Similar wording

have their own separation from the rest of the building which actually runs a substantial amount

Similar wording

deeper into somerset street we're trying to at least start phase one of the revitalization of

Similar wording

this building by starting these units and these units if allowed and completed would be completely

Similar wording

separated by wall and further space from Unit 5, the automotive use, so that they would not

Similar wording

in any way interfere with each other, both from a safety standpoint and also from an environmental

Similar wording

standpoint. The restaurant uses are small restaurants with one tenant already looking to

Similar wording

move into the space that my client has been in negotiation with, and the additional spaces he's

Similar wording

negotiation with other potential tenants so we know that at least one unit immediately would

Similar wording

be occupied and will be started should the board permit the use north broad street at this area

Similar wording

is still in between development it's not quite up and running as a as a lot of commercial uses

Similar wording

nearby are still not really supporting the neighborhoods in the area most of them are

Similar wording

car washes and those kind of auto there are other auto repair shops further down the street but

Similar wording

the restaurants were actually well received as a proposal with the neighborhood and the neighbor

Similar wording

that did show up to the meeting the so these four would be individually numbered as units however

Similar wording

they're all part of the front of the building trash would be stored inside and removed from

Similar wording

Somerset Street as needed. There are no operating hours at this point because some of these are

Similar wording

still currently vacant. However, the corner property would be occupied and would run as a restaurant.

Similar wording

However, the corner property would be occupied and would run as a restaurant.

Similar wording

We have agreed as part of speaking with the community group and also neighbor feedback that additional lighting would be provided.

Similar wording

That essentially the biggest concern in the area has been safety.

Similar wording

uh the these the building being large covering a large part of street additional lighting would

Similar wording

bring an additional activity would bring greater safety to that corner uh that being said i would

Similar wording

like to move on to the second uh refusal which is the automotive repair that is uh in unit 5

Similar wording

so to better understand unit 5 unit 5 is actually going to take majority of what is the

Similar wording

lower level of the building so this part will be the entrance to unit 5 along with a driveway

Similar wording

to understand scale the vehicle two vehicles can actually go side by side inside the driveway

Similar wording

and then the actual work would be done further down in the building in the back where the lifts

Similar wording

are so there's substantial amount of storage space here for vehicles um this this is a decent

Similar wording

representation of how small vehicle would look within the hallway but um when we were at the

Similar wording

actual meeting the operator of the business that that is trying to open indicated he can actually

Similar wording

get three vehicles side by side as needed within that drive aisle towards where he can have the

Similar wording

cars worked on everything will be deep inside the building and the building actually sinks down so

Similar wording

it is a ramp that you drive into that goes down towards the back of the building which is actually

Similar wording

lower than the area here and that is the area where the automotive repair would take place

Similar wording

there's a complete dividing masonry wall and again additional space an actual open hallway

Similar wording

and staircase and space that separates the automotive use from the restaurants so they

Similar wording

would have no interaction or interference with each other when it comes to the uses so the to

Similar wording

give the board a better idea of how that looks here's the um the hallway i'm going to zoom in

Similar wording

little bit so it's easier to see so this is the driveway this is where cars are tend to be stored

Similar wording

the working areas are actually recessed within here and there's a lot of there are actually a

Similar wording

lot of extra space that can be in addition used for vehicle parking if needed again this is a

Similar wording

starting the business trying to move in they try to start and then they realize that the

Similar wording

The zoning wasn't permitted, so right now everything stopped and is shut down and waiting for this case to move forward.

Similar wording

So we've had the inspector has been down there to look at the tire removal and tire storage.

Similar wording

And because of the amount of space available, the tires can be spread out, therefore not causing the kind of fire hazards a pile of tire being shoved into a small space would cause.

Similar wording

And the inspector, the fire inspector has been in working with the tenant on making sure that is not going to be an issue moving forward.

Similar wording

So we have basically been able to work with the fire inspector and also explain this to neighbors.

Similar wording

and they understand that with the space inside there won't be the typical issue of a lot of cars

Similar wording

gathering out on the sidewalks where other auto shops up and down north broad street have

Similar wording

been found to have done where they leave cars outside so because of all these reasons and

Similar wording

because of the size of the building we received again no opposition from the coordinating rco

Similar wording

or the neighbor regarding the application and our request.

Similar wording

I want to point out that we actually did have two meetings.

Similar wording

So the initial meeting, which was mailed and notified to everyone,

Similar wording

including the various RCOs that are involved,

Similar wording

that meeting, no neighbor actually showed up.

Similar wording

And because of that, the coordinating RCO was not comfortable making a decision

Similar wording

So they asked us as applicants to come back for a second meeting, and they also reached out to the council office, and we coordinated a second meeting where both they, the RCO, and Mike.

Similar wording

and we coordinated a second meeting where both they the rco and my client went and flyer the

Similar wording

neighborhood to try to get more notification and reaction from the immediate neighbors and

Similar wording

neighbors within the area on the list and even with all that effort i think only very few

Similar wording

neighbors actually showed up to the actual meeting the surrounding area does have some residential

Similar wording

properties. However, the aerial photo shows that majority

Similar wording

of the residents are actually across Broad Street, and

Similar wording

within reach of the building, a block radius, there are very few

Similar wording

active use households. So

Similar wording

with that, and with the non-opposition of the RCO,

Similar wording

the coordinating RCO, and the intrinsic hardship that this building

Similar wording

really isn't suitable at this point for heavy industrial

Similar wording

use, we would ask for the board's favorable review of this application

Similar wording

and grant the requested variances. I am happy to

Similar wording

answer any questions. Can you have your client here to accept your tone or adopt your testimony?

Similar wording

I believe Mr. Ivan Wei should be in the audience. Ivan, can you raise your hand

Similar wording

on Zoom to be identified? I'm going to stop sharing

Similar wording

so that I can see.

Similar wording

Ivan Wei, can you please unmute?

Similar wording

yes can you hear me hi sir sir could you please state your name and spell for the court stenographer

Similar wording

yes uh my name is ivan i-v-a-n uh last name is w-e-i way or also called sound from way x-i-a-n-g-f-e-n-g

Similar wording

last name w-e-i way you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

yeah i do proceed counsel thank you ivan um did you see my presentation and also hear my

Similar wording

testimony before the zoning board yes can you verify what i have represented is true and correct

Similar wording

and adopted as your own testimony yes and in addition can you also further verify what i

Similar wording

stated about the number of meetings and the fact that you had went out to flyer the neighbors that

Similar wording

is all true and correct yes we actually paid the third party to drop all the flyers to door by door

Similar wording

and that's after you already paid for the mailing which we did for the first meeting correct

Similar wording

that was for the second meeting only yep thank you questions from the board

Similar wording

no mr chairman no chair no chair questions or comments from our attorney hillary emerson

Similar wording

uh just a quick question um mr jim um does your client want provisos specifying that the uses are

Similar wording

for particular units i i think the two so the first refusal was for unit one and one to four

Similar wording

actually states for four separate i don't believe we need provisos it is already clear on the uh

Similar wording

refusal itself okay that is fine thank you thank you comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

yes chair i believe that swan poodle i will allow to speak yeah

Similar wording

hello hello i'm adrian fernandez again swan poodle neighborhood process association rco

Similar wording

please proceed you've already been sworn yes um for both addressed for both zoning permits

Similar wording

and both um meeting ids um we sent a request for continuance um there was no compliant meeting

Similar wording

even when the applicant attorney spoke he never gave dates of meetings at all also um

Similar wording

And there's eight affected RCOs on this address.

Similar wording

For any address, RCO coordinators are assigned per address, and RCO coordinators are equal to all other RCOs.

Similar wording

There is no hierarchy amongst RCOs.

Similar wording

So he's speaking as if he can just talk to Allegheny West Foundation, who never follows the zoning code and the instructions and the RCO notice.

Similar wording

They never follow the instructions.

Similar wording

And he can just ignore the other seven RCOs who know nothing about this project at all.

Similar wording

All we received was three emails from, I believe it was Linda Trong, a staff member of his, and she said she couldn't get in touch with Allegheny West Foundation for a meeting.

Similar wording

Allegheny West Foundation, against the rules and instructions and the zoning code, they never communicated any scheduling or plans with the other RCOs as required so we could plan a meeting.

Similar wording

We have no meeting summary form. We have no floor plans, no site plans. We have nothing.

Similar wording

In a case like this, some of the RCOs would probably have wanted to make a site visit.

Similar wording

The project information forms that are completed have misinformation and incomplete information.

Similar wording

There's no explanation for traffic to these four restaurants at one location.

Similar wording

traffic to these four restaurants at one location and also there's tires there which people in the

Similar wording

neighborhood are not trying to go back to having a lot of tire businesses. We had no opportunity

Similar wording

to even discuss that or to find out what the applicant is presenting because we have no

Similar wording

information about this project. We're asking that this be continued and that the remaining

Similar wording

seven affected RCOs out of the eight affected RCOs, and 143 addresses. Most of them are houses,

Similar wording

some of them are businesses, that our rights be maintained to have public meetings before the

Similar wording

public hearing about development in our neighborhood. There is a conflict also with

Similar wording

Allegheny West Foundation, who served as coordinator, because they are a developer,

Similar wording

and they're doing favors for other developers, hoping that they can get favors when they need

Similar wording

them and they do this consistently adrian listen adrian listen one minute have you talked to

Similar wording

allegheny west about any of this we knew nothing about any of this i'm trying to explain to you

Similar wording

that we had three emails from linda tron who did write us all so she can write all the rcos we can

Similar wording

also receive notices of public meeting by email she wrote us three times i put that in the um

Similar wording

request for continuous because she did write us three times sorry she wrote allegheny west

Similar wording

foundation but she copied everybody else so that ability is there for her to do that when she's

Similar wording

trying to get a meeting date which she should do then allegheny west foundation has a duty

Similar wording

inside of the rco notice and by section 14-303 e1 to consult with all affected but adrian just

Similar wording

just for the point of information this is not the only time you've told us about allegheny west

Similar wording

they do this repeatedly and we have proof of it so we're talking about it today because um you know

Similar wording

i tried to call some of your rcos but we many times have time to talk on the phone none of them

Similar wording

mentioned this address because we didn't even know that meetings were being planned we're supposed

Similar wording

to be involved in the planning part of the meeting per section 14 303 e1 and they want to ignore this

Similar wording

all the time i have numerous writings where i've informed them um excuse me mr chair and excuse me

Similar wording

miss fernandez um i so i i understand that this is a very frustrating situation for you but the

Similar wording

zoning board does not does not oversee the rcos they are overseen by the planning commission so

Similar wording

you really need to direct your right so so the board is right miss fernandez please let me finish

Similar wording

um so the the board's concern here is one that the meeting occurred and two you know whether

Similar wording

the appropriate zoning standards are met for what is being requested um if you have comments related

Similar wording

to what has been requested by the applicant,

Similar wording

you can certainly give those comments.

Similar wording

But the board can unfortunately not able to assist

Similar wording

with concerns you have about the other RCOs

Similar wording

being included in the process.

Similar wording

Adrian?

Similar wording

I understand what you're saying, Hillary.

Similar wording

I have proof that the Planning Commission

Similar wording

has been notified for years about the problems of the Allegheny West Foundation

Similar wording

and even further back with Cindy Bass, Councilwoman Cindy Bass.

Similar wording

However, if Section 14-303-E1 is part of the zoning code

Similar wording

and if Section 14-303-12 is part of the zoning code,

Similar wording

Mr. Zinn has no right to take our rights away.

Similar wording

I cannot go into the Chinese community as part of the black community

Similar wording

and just decide to build major developments in their neighborhood

Similar wording

and act like they're not there and take away their rights.

Similar wording

listen to me this is not about mr jenny represents a client i think your battle is

Similar wording

continuing with allegheny west and and it's not what mr jinn does or doesn't do so i think

Similar wording

we have to move on if you have anything else you want to offer please do it but you know your

Similar wording

your continual argument is about allegheny west and and i think we've got to find a way to just

Similar wording

fix that but right now allegheny west was the coordinating rco in both cases they have

Similar wording

non-opposition to this project we're going to continue one okay

Similar wording

you can continue mr chair thank you thank you thank you um anyone else in the virtual audience

Similar wording

there are no aims chair any commission this is ron bednar city planning now while this property

Similar wording

is currently indicated for industrial use on the city plan given our proposed 2006

Similar wording

commercial rezoning for this site we recommend that the uh that both the requested variances

Similar wording

be granted thank you hillary when i vote this when i give the address i'm going to make one

Similar wording

two three you know units one two three and four for the first one and unit five for the second one is

Similar wording

You know, units 1, 2, 3, and 4 for the first one and unit 5 for the second one.

Similar wording

Is it okay?

Similar wording

it okay

Similar wording

Yes, that is fine, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

So I'm going to vote separately.

Similar wording

MI 2023, 002-653-2750 North Broad Street, units 1, 2, 3, and 4.

Similar wording

I vote yes.

Similar wording

Thomas Holloman, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

James Snell, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Ishmael Shaheed, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

And number four, MI20230026872750North Broad Street, unit number five, I vote yes.

Similar wording

Thomas Holloman, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

James Snell, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Ishmael Shaheed, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you, counsel.

Similar wording

We're going to number five, MI 2022-006-822-2521 Jefferson Street.

Similar wording

Lynn Nichols is the attorney.

Similar wording

Letter of non-opposition from Brewery Town's Shardswood Community Civic Association with provisos.

Similar wording

Streets Department also has approval received for 16 feet curb cut.

Similar wording

um the vote was nine in support nine in opposition miss nichols

Similar wording

good evening good good evening now i i think much earlier today i swore you in

Similar wording

just for the record state your name please thank you lynn nichols l-y-n-n last name n-i-c-h-o-l-s

Similar wording

Could you identify your client in relationship to the property?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

David Jackson should be on the call, and he's the owner of the property.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Our vice chair has just a few questions.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, counsel.

Similar wording

Do you agree to waive the reading of the refusal and stipulate to his accuracy?

Similar wording

Yes, I do.

Similar wording

Have you emailed in all the required documents and exhibits that is needed and required to proceed with this case five days in advance of this hearing?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Please proceed and share your screen.

Similar wording

Yes, thank you.

Similar wording

Can everyone see the screen?

Similar wording

We can.

Similar wording

Yes, thank you.

Similar wording

And just a little note, there were nine opposed, nine in agreement, and four that took no position.

Similar wording

So apparently they believed there was no opposition, and we agree with that.

Similar wording

So in our packet, we have a petition of appeal, the L&I project form, a deed, tax clearance, the impacted neighbors that were notified,

Similar wording

proof of mailing community letter l and i refusal photographs of the property the zoning notice

Similar wording

the site plan and i will move through to the site plan we notified 37 near neighbors

Similar wording

we had a very lively meeting and you know we appreciated all the comments from the neighbors

Similar wording

as you can see in this photograph the curb cut is pre-existing on this property so i tried to

Similar wording

find some history but obviously there was a pre-existing use of this as some type of parking

Similar wording

because of the curb cut mr jackson did not create this curb cut and he does not intend to widen it

Similar wording

in any way whatsoever which is the agreement that we made with the um rco um he intends to

Similar wording

um if this is approved remove this portion portions of this so that the um property could

Similar wording

be used for the two parking spots that we're asking for um again another view of the existing

Similar wording

curb cut on this property this is a view looking to the left this is a view on stillman street

Similar wording

the entrance actually to the property is on stillman street which is right here this is

Similar wording

jefferson street which is facing the camelot school which is located in the north part of

Similar wording

this picture and this is a view looking down jefferson street um on the other side of the

Similar wording

property here is a view looking directly at 2521 jefferson and you can see that the area where we

Similar wording

proposed to have the parking spots is located here in the rear of the property this is looking

Similar wording

at the zoning notice that's posted another view looking down jefford uh stillman street i'm sorry

Similar wording

and here is the uh site plan which i'll turn around for everyone to see

Similar wording

all right so um this is the corner of the property here on the side is the uh proposed parking with

Similar wording

is the proposed parking with the existing curb cut. We are proposing two accessory parking spaces

Similar wording

the existing curb cut we

Similar wording

here. They would be eight feet by 16 feet each. I would note for the panel that an average car

Similar wording

is approximately 15 by 15 feet by six. So this area can easily accommodate two average cars in

Similar wording

the area. We are asking for these spaces because there is an existing issue of congestion with

Similar wording

parking here on Stillman Street. I want to bring up a Google view. As you can see, this is Stillman

Similar wording

Street. There are a number of curb cuts that already exist on Stillman Street for properties,

Similar wording

whether it's for a garage I want to take you down Stillman Street to an area here where there is

Similar wording

parking that's existing for this property here and again we have a number of curb cuts that

Similar wording

already exist on Stillman Street you can see this is a garage it looks abandoned but here there's

Similar wording

parking that's going in and out on this lot where a curb cut exists we have curb cuts here

Similar wording

on the block. There's another curb cut over here to the left. So there are existing curb cuts

Similar wording

already on the block. So this property, again, we're asking for two spaces to alleviate congestion

Similar wording

in the area and to take two parking spaces off the street. I stated at the meeting that

Similar wording

my son just bought a house about three blocks from here and the parking is horrendous. Whenever I go

Similar wording

visit him I have to park three blocks away to walk to his house because there's no parking

Similar wording

so I can personally attest to how difficult it is finding parking spaces in this area now

Similar wording

so at this time I would like to bring my client in David Jackson

Similar wording

could you please state your name as fellow for the course stenographer

Similar wording

My name is David Jackson. First name David, D-A-V-I-D. Last name Jackson, J-A-C-K-S-O-N.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Please proceed, counsel.

Similar wording

Mr. Jackson, are you owner of 2521 Jefferson Street?

Similar wording

I am.

Similar wording

And have you heard my testimony here today?

Similar wording

I have.

Similar wording

do you agree with and adopt the testimony that i've given to the board today

Similar wording

i do is there anything that you would like to add there is not thank you from the board

Similar wording

no mr chairman no chair chair no chair questions or comments from our attorney hillary emerson

Similar wording

just um one kind of a comment um the i know that streets did did review this um as a 16-foot curb

Similar wording

cut which is being proposed and i know that um from what i understand the applicant has agreed

Similar wording

to not enlarge the curb cut beyond what's what's already there um i would like an opportunity just

Similar wording

to talk with the streets department because the reviews for zoning are very preliminary and my

Similar wording

concern is that when they if they do enough have to do another review before the permit is issued a

Similar wording

more extensive review they may say that the curb cut is not sufficient um for the two cars that

Similar wording

are proposed so i just i want to make sure all of all of the things like the turning radius and

Similar wording

sight lines and whatnot were taken into consideration at the initial review so that

Similar wording

don't put a proviso on that comes back later that you know if the board grants um they put

Similar wording

a proviso on that says that that then contradicts what the street's guidance is does that make sense

Similar wording

miss nichols it makes sense hillary my only um i thought from what i understood from our architect

Similar wording

is that the widest or the narrowest point of this curb cut is 16 feet but i appreciate that you do

Similar wording

that so that we wouldn't have any issues later on yeah because i know that there's different levels

Similar wording

of review at different points in the process so i you know wouldn't want to to place a place a

Similar wording

limit and thank you for the clarification about it looked like on the plans where i saw that it

Similar wording

was 16. i didn't realize that was the narrowest part too yeah that's my understanding i could be

Similar wording

wrong um i'm not an architect but i appreciate that you would want to do that level of scrutiny

Similar wording

because we don't want any issues yeah okay i can i can look into that so we can we can

Similar wording

we can hold this mixture chair once we've uh sorry gone to the first audience

Similar wording

no hands here we want planning to take a position now hillary or even away yes they they can take a

Similar wording

we want planning to take a position now hillary or even away yes they they can take a position

Similar wording

positions.

Similar wording

that's fine i just i just want to do a technical check thank you thank you ron bednar city planning

Similar wording

the comprehensive plan recommends no change in residential single-family zoning at this location

Similar wording

no unique physical circumstances uh or condition of the property that would prevent it from being

Similar wording

used in conformity with the parking requirements of the code therefore city planning commission

Similar wording

recommends that the board deny the variance okay so this is closed right except the information

Similar wording

we've received from the city will give um council a chance to respond to it too is that right

Similar wording

that is correct okay um and hillary will we can do this in a week or do you think it

Similar wording

um in case it takes a little longer for streets let's say two weeks

Similar wording

okay so just to make sure not just two weeks to the next would be december 13th december 13th

Similar wording

okay thank you um we'll vote on this at 2 p.m miss nichols thank thank you okay um is there

Similar wording

anyone in the virtual audience who's their case has not been called from the 330 list

Similar wording

no hands chair thanks everybody thank you got a lot done today thank you bill thank you

Similar wording