civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - September 20, 2023

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Sep 20, 20235h 43m

It's nothing different that I want to change.

Similar wording

It has been used since 2011.

Similar wording

After the building was purchased,

Similar wording

it has been well kept and different uses

Similar wording

as Garrison Lime, Private Club,

Similar wording

and now I want to use it as a cafe breakfast spot

Similar wording

where you can come in and eat a nice clean area

Similar wording

with good breakfast.

Similar wording

You will also find in my package

Similar wording

Copies of applications, appeals, deeds, project information, floor plan

Similar wording

Pictures, posting of zoning, certified melon

Similar wording

pictures, posting of zoning, certified mail-in to neighborhood, and tax clearance.

Similar wording

Love Cafe hours of operation Monday through Saturday, 7 a.m. to 2 p.m., employee 4.

Similar wording

We will have cameras and lighting on premises and buildings.

Similar wording

We have an alarm system, dumpster on the front, secure for commercial pickup.

Similar wording

commercial pickup weekly at first and then change to two times a week as business grow

Similar wording

and one employee will clean surrounding area attached is a health department committed issue

Similar wording

in 2021 for the cafe building is consistent with neighborhood changes year built 1930 estimate

Similar wording

building description row typical number of stories two stories commercial first floor

Similar wording

and residential on second floor future basement for utility base i'm sorry basement for utilities

Similar wording

is zoned as a rm1 residential motor family one

Similar wording

and this is what brings me here okay so you want to open up a cafe there right yes okay questions

Similar wording

on the board no chair no mr chairman questions or comments from the brussel audience

Similar wording

no hands chair planning commission this is uh ron bednar city planning the property is indicated for

Similar wording

um currently indicated for residential use in the city plan but given the use history and physical

Similar wording

So conditions of the site, we recommend the request of answer to be granted.

Similar wording

We will hold this case.

Similar wording

It is closed except for information from the RCO and also the council person.

Similar wording

Thank you so much.

Similar wording

Hillary, is that okay?

Similar wording

Yes, that is fine, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

I'd also say if the applicant wishes to respond to the information submitted.

Similar wording

Yeah, the applicant, you'll have an opportunity.

Similar wording

It's cases basically closed, but you'll have an opportunity to respond to the RCO and or the council person.

Similar wording

OK. OK. Thank you so much.

Similar wording

Well, I appreciate it. Thank you for your time.

Similar wording

OK. Thanks a lot.

Similar wording

All right. We're going to go back to.

Similar wording

Number eight.

Similar wording

We do that one.

Similar wording

That's one the council had a hard time with, right?

Similar wording

Yes, that's one where there was technical difficulties.

Similar wording

We can go back to that one.

Similar wording

4830 B Street.

Similar wording

Council, are you ready to go?

Similar wording

Who was that person, Chair?

Similar wording

Well, it was a different council came in.

Similar wording

Remember, we originally had...

Similar wording

David Chandler.

Similar wording

David Chandler

Similar wording

David Chandler has been promoted to panelists

Similar wording

Thank you

Similar wording

Mr. Chandler

Similar wording

Okay, can you hear me?

Similar wording

I can, could you show us your screen

Similar wording

I want to see your screen

Similar wording

Yep

Similar wording

Okay

Similar wording

Did you get your computer working?

Similar wording

Yes

Similar wording

Yes. Okay. You've already been sworn. Start presenting your case.

Similar wording

Okay. I will just have to call up the exhibits right now.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Yeah, open, I don't want to, say open that.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Yeah, open.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

It's open.

Similar wording

I don't know.

Similar wording

What would I do?

Similar wording

Oh, where did I go?

Similar wording

Yeah, that's something.

Similar wording

Is that fancy?

Similar wording

Do you want to hit me again?

Similar wording

I'm going to do anything else.

Similar wording

No, of course.

Similar wording

we make an answer uh well okay we'll just try to this at work is that no no it's still loading

Similar wording

it's still okay loading and just make sure the documents are open first before you hit the green

Similar wording

share button. Okay, um, okay.

Similar wording

Is that the one? Yeah. Okay.

Similar wording

Yeah. Okay.

Similar wording

You got it?

Similar wording

You got it?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Where? That one?

Similar wording

And you're going to hit the green button.

Similar wording

Green button. Share screen.

Similar wording

Yeah. Okay.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Exhibit. Exhibit what?

Similar wording

Click the first one, whichever one.

Similar wording

Click the first one, whichever one.

Similar wording

Exhibit one.

Similar wording

Whichever, yeah.

Similar wording

Okay, do you see?

Similar wording

This is Exhibit one.

Similar wording

This is the notice of...

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Yep, we're aware.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And basically, Mr. Castillo is requesting a...

Similar wording

He's applying for a variance.

Similar wording

It's a two-story corner building, as I said, in the Perihill section of the city.

Similar wording

and the first floor he wants to use as a commercial uh area he uh basically he bought

Similar wording

the property in 2016 2010 2010 i'm sorry 2010 and uh it has not been used as as commercial

Similar wording

property since then uh but then he wants basically it's a zoned rsa-5 and um as a

Similar wording

And RSA-5 allows commercial property if he obtains a variance.

Similar wording

Basically, he wants to use the first floor as a multi-services commercial store by appointment only.

Similar wording

Basically, he would have several things he would offer.

Similar wording

One is he would sell athletic apparel to local schools, to local students at schools who need athletic apparel.

Similar wording

In addition, he also would like to have an area where he could send money to people overseas.

Similar wording

As you know, the area is heavily Spanish-speaking, a lot of relatives in Latin America, and he would like to have a place where they could send money to their relatives in Latin America.

Similar wording

Also, he'd provide translation services from Spanish and English and vice versa.

Similar wording

And basically, because he's concerned with possible parking problems on the weekends, he will open his store as a multi-service store by appointment only.

Similar wording

Could you go through your document and show us a picture of the property, please?

Similar wording

Sure.

Similar wording

picture of property where is it look at that one

Similar wording

that's number one now where's number two okay i don't know hit this hit that okay

Similar wording

number two yeah that's the application for the peel okay let's go there number three

Similar wording

that's the um project information form number four i need the photos need the photos right okay

Similar wording

yeah okay uh try six six six is this is is a architect drawing those are the the uh

Similar wording

drawing the drawings and you put the drawing put the drawings up then okay yeah we have the drawings

Similar wording

here okay

Similar wording

exhibit six

Similar wording

okay here you see the drawings

Similar wording

blow that up just a little bit then we can see the photo there too oh and the

Similar wording

close it no you want photo photo yeah good okay

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

where is it the other one david

Similar wording

zoom zoom

Similar wording

go back to the files

Similar wording

okay okay seven those are the photos where they're posting on them on the on the building

Similar wording

oh you have to upload that I'm sorry share screen and here yeah here okay can you can you see it

Similar wording

Yeah. Okay. Can you, can you see it?

Similar wording

Yeah. I mean, could you, yeah, it's okay.

Similar wording

So it's a corner property you have, right? Yes.

Similar wording

And he wants to open this up. Now let me ask you this.

Similar wording

When he went to the RCO, what happened at the RCO?

Similar wording

Well, we weren't representing him at the time, but his pre,

Similar wording

but as I understand it, there was no opposition at the RCO.

Similar wording

There was an opposition? There was no opposition. Is that correct?

Similar wording

so yes he says that that is correct i i think we show the letter there's a letter of opposition

Similar wording

from the rco hillary am i right yes mr chair there's a letter of opposition from the rco

Similar wording

there's a letter of opposition from the council member oh is there

Similar wording

not anymore not anymore well according to miss castillo uh any opposition has been has been dropped

Similar wording

um excuse me mr chandler this is hillary um we received uh the letter and i don't know if the

Similar wording

council office is on um yeah i think mr mr folks has has left but we were resent the letter from

Similar wording

the rco as well as a letter of opposition a current letter of opposition from the council

Similar wording

office just this week so we we are not aware of any change in the position of the rco or the

Similar wording

council office at this time okay question questions from the board hold on a minute

Similar wording

you want to bring your client on and adopt your testimony

Similar wording

okay yes mr castillo is here jesus castillo c-a-s-t-i-l-l-o right you you swear or affirm

Similar wording

to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth sir yes i do okay um proceed counsel

Similar wording

excuse me can we see mr castillo please oh sure

Similar wording

okay okay uh mr mr castillo do you own the property at um 4830 b street yes and uh what

Similar wording

would you like to um do with the first floor okay i'm gonna

Similar wording

hold on we can't remember council we we asked before we he he we can't have somebody interpret

Similar wording

for him we needed an interpreter and that's what i'm gonna i'm gonna do by myself okay

Similar wording

speak english the best you can okay okay so i try to do the multi-service like he said

Similar wording

Send me money, do copy, say sport stuff, you know, baseball stuff.

Similar wording

Because people ask me because I got a field close to my corner, you know.

Similar wording

So, and do something out like Pennsylvania lottery.

Similar wording

Maybe, you know, somebody hit the number right there, the power board.

Similar wording

So, you know, it's multi-service.

Similar wording

It's a lot of stuff coming to multi-service.

Similar wording

But it's good for the neighborhood, not something bad for the neighborhood.

Similar wording

That's what I want to do.

Similar wording

Mr. Castillo, are you aware of opposition from the residents?

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Did you ever receive any notice of opposition from the council person's office?

Similar wording

No, I don't receive that.

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

um basically previously uh people who opposed it now they changed their were there people

Similar wording

who previously opposed it who changed their mind and are now supported yes yes and did you talk to

Similar wording

them yes okay do you know of anyone right now who is opposed to your project no

Similar wording

council what you can call the office later and our our council will make sure you get copies of

Similar wording

letters that we have questions from the board no chair no mr chairman questions or comments from

Similar wording

the virtual audience um chair no hands chair okay planning commission ron bednar city planning

Similar wording

while this property is currently indicated for residential use on the city plan given the

Similar wording

cites physical circumstances.

Similar wording

We recommend the request of advance be granted.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

MI 2023-004-664-4830 B Street.

Similar wording

664-4830 B Street, I vote yes.

Similar wording

I vote yes.

Similar wording

Thomas Holloman, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

James Snell, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

You have your vote, sir.

Similar wording

Thank you very much.

Similar wording

Thank you, Mr. Chairman.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Appreciate it.

Similar wording

God bless you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

And may we be excused?

Similar wording

Yes, you can.

Similar wording

Yes, you can.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording