civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - September 23, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Sep 23, 20267h 31m

The hope is to get a smaller, like a cafe-style use.

Similar wording

With no kitchen?

Similar wording

Or is the plan to have the tenant do the fit out?

Similar wording

I see the architect is coming.

Similar wording

well phil why don't you handle that what do you sure go ahead

Similar wording

phil did you hear the question phil

Similar wording

i think we lost you might have muted yourself

Similar wording

phil are you there you hear me yes good now we can okay

Similar wording

Yes, I heard the question. And there could be some minor cooking facilities, either at the first level or down in the basement. But if I had my druthers, I would take a florist shop. Thank you.

Similar wording

And the basement is strictly storage and utilities, by the way.

Similar wording

Okay. And is the basement restricted to that commercial unit or can all tenants in the building access the basement?

Similar wording

There are different portions to the basement.

Similar wording

There will be tenant storage on the northwest end of the basement, and there will be, in the front, underneath the commercial, that will be dedicated to the commercial tenant.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Go ahead.

Similar wording

I guess another question I have is about mail and just package drop-off, package management.

Similar wording

I see you do have a dedicated residential lobby, but it does seem to have mostly space for people to transit through it.

Similar wording

And I just want to know, what's your plan for managing seven units worth of Amazon packages and DoorDash?

Similar wording

Yeah, actually, what has been described as a bike room is really a package room.

Similar wording

I misspoke.

Similar wording

I might also add, this is going to be an elevator building with direct access to each unit from the elevator, which will open on the front or back, depending on which unit it's accessing.

Similar wording

So private entrance and private elevator access for each apartment.

Similar wording

We're really looking to get a higher end user here and people who will be more stable.

Similar wording

So DeMarco, your architect has been attempting to put his hands up several times.

Similar wording

Yeah, he can talk.

Similar wording

Do you want me to swear him in?

Similar wording

Yeah, please.

Similar wording

I misspoke.

Similar wording

Please state your name and spell it for the stenographer.

Similar wording

Richard Dullo.

Similar wording

real quick i misspoke that's a package room not a bike room that's for amazon packages

Similar wording

richard villa r-i-c-h-a-r-d-v-i-l-l-a do you swear or firm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing

Similar wording

but the truth yes mr demarco he's sworn in do you have questions or referrals for him or no i can i

Similar wording

i can just say have him state mr bill mr villa you're the architect for this project yes um is

Similar wording

this project the minimum uh development necessary to overcome the hardship posed by the original

Similar wording

structure yes i'll go ahead mr chairman uh i'm fine does anybody have a question for the architect

Similar wording

i was just going to clarify the all right go ahead uh that the we do have a bike room um mr

Similar wording

demarco uh correct himself we do have a bike room all right sorry a package room i gotta correct

Similar wording

myself a package room a trash room we have an area right next to the front door that is labeled as

Similar wording

mail so we can do mail and packages uh and as far as bikes the units upstairs are nice size two

Similar wording

bedrooms i think anybody's going to bring their bike up to their unit which happens in a lot of

Similar wording

buildings i do other questions storage in the basement i don't have a question i just think

Similar wording

just two general comments i think the while the facade is really nice i would put something that

Similar wording

allows people to know which door is the main door for the lobby i think you have four doors you'd

Similar wording

the emergency egress you have the trash door you have the commercial door and i think yes you're

Similar wording

showing the number but like something that lets visitors and like delivery people know that that's

Similar wording

the main entrance i will say that we do intend to put the name of the building and do me a favor get

Similar wording

it closer sorry but to put the name of the building and the address closer to the front door and then

Similar wording

allow the space above the commercial to have the commercial signage which would come back for its

Similar wording

own zoning permit i think the second thing is it's always great when you have a ground floor

Similar wording

apartment to be able to allow the people that might have mobility needs

Similar wording

to be able to allow the people that might have mobility needs to access those units.

Similar wording

I do see you have the wheelchair circle along the leading up to it.

Similar wording

So I'm hoping that the developer keeps that restricted to people who need wheelchair access.

Similar wording

And I'd just like to point out that we did present this brick, which is a nice,

Similar wording

it's like a burgundy brick with a nice sheen to it.

Similar wording

And that'll be the brick facade.

Similar wording

And the brick does have, the facade has some nice details to it, nice big windows.

Similar wording

all right thank you any other questions questions from our attorney

Similar wording

more uh to make a comment actually to let the applicant mr harvey know that um it's not going

Similar wording

to affect um what's happening here today but that his date of consolidation is incorrect

Similar wording

and he might want to get it corrected because it's indicates the property at 828 is 828 south

Similar wording

fourth street not south eighth street oh i did not notice thank you because i just looked at

Similar wording

your deed data consolidation i noticed i'm like they're not next to each other so you might want

Similar wording

to look into that and um i don't know the opa numbers everything like that you just might want

Similar wording

to look into that definitely the data consolidation we will definitely look into it yeah i see there's

Similar wording

there's a it's a scrivener's error you're right yeah right here okay you see it look oh yes yes

Similar wording

i do see it oh wait yeah no that can't be right everybody sees it hold on a moment questions or

Similar wording

comments from the virtual audience not at this time chair planning commission

Similar wording

madison matera planning commission staff the comprehensive plan recommends no change to the

Similar wording

existing CMX 2 commercial mixed use zoning at this location. The refusal for ground floor use

Similar wording

dimensions is de minimis. The appellant has demonstrated that there are unique conditions

Similar wording

or circumstances of the property that are perfect conformance with the code for rear yard depth,

Similar wording

occupied area, and building height. The proposed lot size per dwelling unit is a de minimis

Similar wording

deviation from the zoning code. The Planning Commission recommends the board grant the

Similar wording

request of variances for rear yard depth, occupied area, building height, ground floor,

Similar wording

use dimensions and seven units. Thank you. MI 2026 002 856 824 to 26 South A Street I vote yes.

Similar wording

Michael Johns my vote is yes. Cheryl Gaston my vote is yes. Tanetta Graham my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Ryan McAdams my vote is yes. Iowyn my vote is yes. Thank you Mr. DeMarco. Thank you for your time

Similar wording

everybody have a good night. Great and thank you for August you moved me up so I could make dinner

Similar wording

on my birthday. Oh, here you go. I made it. Thank you. We appreciate it. We're happy to

Similar wording

hear that. Okay. All right. So number 10, MI 2026-002-888-5911 Ridge Avenue. Brett

Similar wording

Feldman is the attorney, and I see that Brett is not here.

Similar wording

here you go it is me andrea so we know we think we know that could you please state and spell

Similar wording

your name for this stenographer andrea solomon a-n-d-r-e-a-s-a-l-o-m-o-n right do you swear

Similar wording

or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth i do could you identify

Similar wording

your client a relationship to this property yes my client is nikki group uh l i believe llp uh

Similar wording

with me today is corey goodman they're the owner of the property and with us today also is a

Similar wording

representative of the proposed tenant concentra urgent care and the project architect mr robert

Similar wording

lynn okay our our vice chair has a few questions good afternoon have you submitted your documents

Similar wording

exhibits 14 days in advance of this hearing we did and this is a special exception so do you

Similar wording

waive the rating of your referral as to play to its accuracy thank you all right thank you

Similar wording

you can share your screen to proceed with your case and the central roxford has you as unanimous

Similar wording

support i am raising my hand but do not not see the share screen can we make sure you're in

Similar wording

One moment, please.

Similar wording

Angela, you have been promoted.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

I'm just sharing my screen.

Similar wording

okay thank you again andrea solomon from claire harrison harvey bransburg on behalf of the

Similar wording

applicant the nikki group this is an application for a special exception approval at the former

Similar wording

rite aid location on 59 11 ridge avenue one of many rite aid locations that are looking for

Similar wording

one of many Rite Aid locations that are looking for redevelopment of this large footprint building.

Similar wording

redevelopment of this.

Similar wording

This is, I think, a proposed use that will fit nicely into it, a proposed urgent care facility

Similar wording

for Concentra. Matt is here and he can speak a little bit to the need and their growth,

Similar wording

but their current location in Roxborough is at the Roxborough Memorial Hospital. They have about

Similar wording

half the square footage that they would be growing into and able to expand their services

Similar wording

our application received we met with the Central Roxborough Civic Association about two weeks ago

Similar wording

and received their unanimous support we worked a lot with them even though this application is

Similar wording

just for the use as part of the new tenant coming in the owner will be making some some improvements

Similar wording

to the facade, the streetscape, and the parking configuration that come out of their requests

Similar wording

and they're wanting to be more pedestrian access, just a better streetscape in what

Similar wording

is their busy commercial corridor.

Similar wording

Again, we received their unanimous support.

Similar wording

We also have a letter of support from Drexel University, which is one of the bigger

Similar wording

clients that Concentra serves, as well as Matt will speak to, a lot of work-related injuries

Similar wording

for the city as well. The property is zoned CMX 2.5 and located, as I mentioned, right at the

Similar wording

commercial corridor of uh Roxborough Avenue um we can keep flipping um it's it's long been vacant

Similar wording

since I think about two years since Rite Aid left and there is another vacant tenant space

Similar wording

that used to be a Chinese restaurant we're preserving that restaurant use

Similar wording

demising the Rite Aid space into two tenant properties so one will be a vacant commercial

Similar wording

tenant space that we're hoping to fill the bigger of the two tenant spaces will be uh inhabited by

Similar wording

concentra again this has been long vacant uh here's a picture of the parking field and the

Similar wording

building as it is now and behind me i know bob has been near the playground the the playground

Similar wording

isn't the playground right there no no i'll see that there's there's a wendy's because i can't

Similar wording

yeah at the end there there's a there's a church and a cemetery across ridge ave

Similar wording

and the wendy's diner right next door the diner is close by okay all right yeah

Similar wording

and and we are just down the street from rocksboro memorial which is where concentra is now

Similar wording

um here's here's a little bit better view of where we are

Similar wording

okay with the wendy's next door and uh we love to see empty ride aids but this is

Similar wording

this is what they look you know you can imagine what they look like and it'll be

Similar wording

uh of course improved um with that i'd love if we could swear in mr lynn so that he can speak

Similar wording

to a little bit could you please state and spell your name for the stenographer absolutely robert

Similar wording

h lynn l-i-n-n business address 1140 north providence road media do you swear or affirm

Similar wording

to tell the truth told truth nothing but the truth yes i do counsel please proceed thank you

Similar wording

hi bob uh can you please state for the record uh your title and your relationship to this project

Similar wording

certainly nice seeing everybody again thanks for serving here um uh bob lynn i'm the principal

Similar wording

lynn architects we just started our 45th official year on monday so we've been hanging around while

Similar wording

i formed the company 45 years ago which does make me slightly old that's okay um uh we are architects

Similar wording

civil engineers and code officials um we are in delaware county um i'm 31 years now on the planning

Similar wording

Commission to the Providence Township. I'm the zoning officer in one municipality, which is

Similar wording

Upper Providence, and I co-chair that position in two other municipalities in Delaware County, so

Similar wording

I see zoning a lot. I have worked on five comprehensive plans in three municipalities,

Similar wording

and again, we do site civil and architecture for a living, and I've had the privilege of appearing

Similar wording

in front of you several times. Why don't we proceed? Yeah, and Bob, you've been retained

Similar wording

by the owner on this project. I have indeed, yes. And I know you've walked the property,

Similar wording

And I know you've walked the property. Just describe briefly the conditions that it's in now.

Similar wording

just describe briefly the conditions that it's.

Similar wording

Certainly. And I'll give you a couple. I'm going to make this less than five minutes, I promise.

Similar wording

Well, I can't be much time. You gave me 30 last time. I used 27. I got three spare, if you recall.

Similar wording

That's hearing. We basically have 246 feet of frontage on Ridge Avenue.

Similar wording

We have 144 feet of frontage on Gerard Street or Gerhard Street on the side.

Similar wording

What Andrea just described was three different pieces of the puzzle.

Similar wording

The entire site is 26,789 square feet, which is about 0.61 acres.

Similar wording

There's a 10,967-foot building on the site.

Similar wording

The proposed use we are talking today is on the left-hand side under my pointer.

Similar wording

The recently closed sit-down take-out restaurants on the right-hand side,

Similar wording

and the space we'd like to see a tenant for is in the center of the parcel.

Similar wording

Basically, the consent for use, which Matt will describe more fully in a minute,

Similar wording

is about 7,165 square feet of the entire building.

Similar wording

We took a design approach of attempting to enhance the facade.

Similar wording

The site is in pretty bad condition.

Similar wording

Sorry, I was just, I'll lean first and then I'll, excuse me.

Similar wording

The site and the property is not in great condition. I think the photographs you saw gave you a better idea of what we're looking at.

Similar wording

Again, the facade is something left over from the 1960s. You saw that earlier in photographs. I don't even know what the pent roof is, frankly.

Similar wording

So we took the approach of doing six things. We first of all put a water table to anchor it in a simulated stone at the bottom with a little concrete cap.

Similar wording

We cleaned up all the fenestration in the facade doors.

Similar wording

We cleaned up this sign band.

Similar wording

The signs, if you look at the photographs, are left over where they put them right on the roof, which is the old school way of doing them.

Similar wording

And then we went ahead and we did a new pent roof, and we did some brackets under the pent roof.

Similar wording

They were the initial passes we took.

Similar wording

We also did some decorative lighting on the facade of the building.

Similar wording

When we interfaced with the RCO, they had some really well-thought-out suggestions what they wanted to see, and they were quite engaged in the project.

Similar wording

And they came up with, that was June 23rd of this year, they came up with six suggestions, which we incorporated.

Similar wording

First of all, they wanted to see a wider sidewalk at the building.

Similar wording

The current sidewalk is only five feet.

Similar wording

So what we did was we expanded the sidewalk.

Similar wording

That was something they thought would be more of a sense of arrival.

Similar wording

Plus, when you're parking there, your car bumper, when it hangs over, doesn't close the door of the building, which happens on these narrow sidewalks.

Similar wording

They didn't want to see us increase parking.

Similar wording

Parking right now is just abysmal.

Similar wording

It's a series of angular spaces.

Similar wording

And you really can't get in or out of any of them.

Similar wording

You can't circulate through the lot for 24 spaces.

Similar wording

We thought at first everybody wanted to see increased parking.

Similar wording

There is no parking required for this particular use.

Similar wording

But they said, no, we're a walkable community, decreased parking of anything.

Similar wording

So we did a new configuration.

Similar wording

We went from 24 to 22.

Similar wording

But what we did is we created legitimate spaces with legitimate backup distance, no more confusion.

Similar wording

So you have head-in spaces to the new widened sidewalk and head-in spaces to Ridge Avenue.

Similar wording

The next piece we did was we widened this particular landscape buffer.

Similar wording

Right now it's zero.

Similar wording

It's literally right up to the property line.

Similar wording

And we took that, we went from zero feet to 14 and a half feet.

Similar wording

So now we have a legitimate piece of landscaping on the front, and that introduced another 1,152 square feet of area because one of the other goals was to get more pervious surface.

Similar wording

So we've got a stormwater management recharge situation available to us, quite a bit more there.

Similar wording

There's also a little pot over on the side where we enhance the landscaping.

Similar wording

The final piece, they wanted to see a safe pedestrian path from the Ridge Avenue to the building.

Similar wording

So we literally, and you can see it in the rendering, there's a little stamp pattern that leads you directly from Ridge along the side.

Similar wording