civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - September 23, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Sep 23, 20267h 31m

our proviso it's already on there that's tax taxes are okay we're okay okay you does you have the tax

Similar wording

it's fine all right please proceed sir okay can everyone see my screen here you can okay so yeah

Similar wording

so we're just proposing a straightforward application uh we're proposing a car repair shop

Similar wording

um these are images of the front of the property um the entrance is that draw

Similar wording

bridge there this is a copy of the referral um principal use is allowed um this is a this is a

Similar wording

uh this is allowed under special exception as as it was said um and we're just doing personal

Similar wording

vehicle repair and maintenance um no car sales uh the notice of the zoning appeal this is the

Similar wording

notice um that we printed out here this was the letter that we provided the the residents

Similar wording

prior to the public meeting.

Similar wording

This is the addresses that were mailed out.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And this is our proof of mailing here.

Similar wording

Total price was $26.

Similar wording

This is another image.

Similar wording

Adjacent to the property is a closed down car repair shop

Similar wording

that was closed.

Similar wording

And we're directly across the street from Sunoco Gas Station.

Similar wording

And the address is pretty good for this location

Similar wording

because this is the I2 Industrial District,

Similar wording

and they wanted to designate this spot specifically for these type of things

Similar wording

that it doesn't become a public nuisance and no loud noises.

Similar wording

These are pictures of the interior of the shop,

Similar wording

which is a substantial amount of room for parking vehicles,

Similar wording

so we don't have to worry about the nuisance of vehicles parked on the street.

Similar wording

This is the entrance where you see the Mitsubishi.

Similar wording

That's actually my car.

Similar wording

this is going into the parking space or where individuals will be able to come into it,

Similar wording

make a left where the lifts are and get their vehicles repaired. And then storage will happen

Similar wording

in the back when needed for customers. We plan to have roughly about, we only have about three

Similar wording

lifts. So it's a small repair shop, three to four customers and not overdoing it.

Similar wording

Again, this is an I2 district. This is a picture of the space on State Road.

Similar wording

And as mentioned, this is a copy of the of what this is going to look like.

Similar wording

So to the left where you see the offices, that's the office where individuals able to sit.

Similar wording

They come in to the left are the lifts and then the back where this travel distance there is in the parking lot.

Similar wording

All of this is a parking area and storage area.

Similar wording

This is a notice of the pill that was posted on the door in time.

Similar wording

This is a letter from the ZBA for not opposed.

Similar wording

This is a lease agreement as well.

Similar wording

And that ends my presentation.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Questions from the board?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Can you point out where the parking lot is that you mentioned?

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

So there's parking inside of the, so I'll show you here.

Similar wording

Inside the building.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

Inside of the building.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

So if you look here, you see where where this vehicle is here, the black truck.

Similar wording

Yes. So all of that in the back is all parking space.

Similar wording

OK, I think the question I have is really about because it doesn't look like there's a lot of street parking on State Road.

Similar wording

No, I know when we look at other personal care vehicle locations, they often have these cars like backed out, parked down the street, blocking the sidewalk.

Similar wording

What's going to be your sort of plan to navigate and move and temporarily store the vehicles while you're doing while you and your team are doing work?

Similar wording

Yeah. So as mentioned, and thank you for the question, which is a big nuisance.

Similar wording

So as mentioned here, if you can see the screen that I have up here, if you see the entrance where it says car entrance, this is to the left of my screen.

Similar wording

so the vehicles are coming in through the car entrance um and then the the v

Similar wording

So the vehicles are coming in through the car entrance, and then the vehicle repair is being done where you see the auto lifts at.

Similar wording

So that means everything where you see the oil drums and all that, that's all room for storage.

Similar wording

So that can store over maybe 50 or so cars.

Similar wording

It's a large storage area.

Similar wording

50?

Similar wording

I mean, it's gigantic.

Similar wording

This is 175 feet in travel distance if you look here, and then this is 195 feet in travel distance.

Similar wording

So, I mean, I could be exaggerating, but a lot of cars could be stored.

Similar wording

You know, cars can be like just a little bit.

Similar wording

Cars like 50 feet long each.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Yeah, yeah.

Similar wording

It was 195 square feet in travel distance.

Similar wording

Make it 75 cars.

Similar wording

75 cars.

Similar wording

Yes, there we go.

Similar wording

So it sounds like just for your operation purposes, you're only ever going to have cars being repaired on lifts.

Similar wording

you have four lifts and then any other car whether you're waiting for a part or you're

Similar wording

waiting for pickup will be stored inside this building on in one of your sort of parking or

Similar wording

storage areas i couldn't have said it better okay and then um are there any uh like locations or

Similar wording

staff restricted places i'm thinking like break room um place from like i didn't see a bathroom

Similar wording

on the plan um no so there's no there's there's that one office location okay um and um that's

Similar wording

it that's that sorry um that's my son just came in um there's that one office location um that is

Similar wording

uh where where you see this person at in the front um and that's that's the only location

Similar wording

adjacent to the property there's a warehouse okay i'm sorry you said um adjacent to the property

Similar wording

uh is a um it's another rental property that um we rent as a warehouse so that's access to the

Similar wording

facilities or restrooms and different things like that as well okay and then my last question is

Similar wording

about the storage of like oil used oil chemicals things like how are you containing them and

Similar wording

disposing of them safely yes perfect yeah so it will be picked up um there's storage drums that

Similar wording

are expected to be it's not there now but there's oil drums that will be here um and they will be

Similar wording

picked up by a commercial by a commercial vendor okay all the questions yes so uh what are you

Similar wording

going to be doing in terms of this car repair this is just oil changes higher changes what

Similar wording

what are you going to be doing exactly so just personal vehicle repair um there's not going to

Similar wording

be any body work being done here um so uh standard alternators transmissions you know the the standard

Similar wording

things. We're not an engine specialist shop, but all the other standard repairs,

Similar wording

brakes, stuff like this. Okay. And then about how many customers do you have a day?

Similar wording

Well, we don't have any customers now. We're expecting roughly four to five customers daily.

Similar wording

okay all right and this will be by appointment is that how you're going to do this by appointment

Similar wording

up until we up until we have a sign up and then individuals they can you know of course pull in

Similar wording

inquire and at the inquiry all depending on as is mentioned today storage and availability

Similar wording

then we can take that take that car okay all right and um you have the hazardous waste disposal

Similar wording

you will have hazardous waste disposal is that 100 all right okay and um are you going to store

Similar wording

tires at this no we do not plan to do that okay all right thank you questions from our attorney

Similar wording

um i know we had exchanged emails on it but i wanted to make sure it's on the record that

Similar wording

you are only using this location for uh personal vehicle repair and maintenance you are not using

Similar wording

for personal vehicle sales and rental that is correct questions or comments from the virtual

Similar wording

audience not at this time chair planning commission madison matera planning commission

Similar wording

staff the comprehensive plan recommends no change to the existing i2 medium industrial zoning at

Similar wording

this location the appellant has demonstrated that the proposed use will not cause detrimental

Similar wording

impacts beyond what we reasonably would be expected the planning commission recommends

Similar wording

the board grant their crusted special exception for personal vehicle repair and maintenance

Similar wording

okay um MI 2026 002 255 7352 to 82 state road I vote yes with proviso approve use for personal

Similar wording

vehicle repair and maintenance and limited to unit 104. Michael Johns my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

Gerald Gaston, my vote is yes with proviso. Tanetta Graham, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

Ryan McAdams, my vote is yes with proviso. Tyia Nguyen, my vote is yes with proviso. Sir.

Similar wording

Thank you so much, Chair. So you you have your votes and I have to tell you,

Similar wording

you made a great presentation. Thank you so much, everyone. Well,

Similar wording

I got to say that it sounds good. All right, we're back to number one, Gabriel.

Similar wording

you're not tired hear me and see me

Similar wording

uh mr chair can you hear me yeah i can wait i'm going to share my screen how are we doing okay

Similar wording

Good.

Similar wording

Good.

Similar wording

Can you see my screen?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Yeah, here we go.

Similar wording

You're moving now.

Similar wording

Now we are losing.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Do you need me to swear in again or say my name or anything?

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

Sure.

Similar wording

My name is Gabriel Fellis, J-B-R-I-E-L.

Similar wording

I already swore you in, didn't I?

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

I didn't know if you need me to do it again.

Similar wording

Go ahead.

Similar wording

You just do a state your name and then start your presentation.

Similar wording

Yeah, it's Gabriel Fellas. My client is Enid Breppenridge. She's the owner of the property.

Similar wording

Breppenridge is the owner of the property at 5861 Willows Ave. She's looking to use the lower

Similar wording

level of the property as a takeout waterized stand. Her plan is to use the basement of the property

Similar wording

for prep and storage, and then customers will be able to place takeout orders from a window

Similar wording

at the side of the property. I'll show you the layout and proposed configuration a little later

Similar wording

on uh properties previously held a variance in place for use of the lower level as a funeral home

Similar wording

hasn't been in operation for as a funeral home for a number of years so miss breckenridge is

Similar wording

just looking for a new commercial use of that space it's a bit more in line with what would

Similar wording

best serve the community so here we have that zoning history for the property as i mentioned

Similar wording

for a funeral home and residential living above

Similar wording

Here we have some rough proposed site plans, the layout of the prep area in the basement.

Similar wording

So the plan here is just to use the basement for prep and storage, and these plans show

Similar wording

the orientation of the basement.

Similar wording

But this gives a little bit of a better layout.

Similar wording

So there's an above ground door right here that leads to stairs that go straight down

Similar wording

to the basement and then right next to that door right where the zba posters are hanging now

Similar wording

the proposal is to actually have a sliding window where customers can place those orders and and

Similar wording

take out their their orders and these are these bill card doors are just another means of egress

Similar wording

and ingress into the basement but again this is take out no customers are going to come

Similar wording

into the basement or onto the property besides just taking out from that window

Similar wording

So here we have some photos of the basement in its current condition, which is unfinished right now.

Similar wording

Eden and her daughter originally filed this appeal on their own.

Similar wording

They worked with the third ward executive committee directly to set up the community meeting and speak with the neighbors.

Similar wording

They ended up having that meeting with the community on January 26th, and they received

Similar wording

this letter of non-opposition.

Similar wording

Mr. Waters, the RCO chair, and he helped them through that process of notifying neighbors

Similar wording

and sending out their required mailing.

Similar wording

This is our zoning map, again, the property is zoned RM1.

Similar wording

And this is the most recent deed to the property showing Enid as a sole owner, but she's actually

Similar wording

been an owner of the property in one way or the other for over 30 years so here we have our

Similar wording

application for appeal that they did on their own and their project information form

Similar wording

here we have proof of the real estate tax paying plan that miss breckenridge has with the city

Similar wording

and here we have the zba posters notifying neighbors of the hearing here today

Similar wording

so with that i'd like to invite enid on um she might be on her daughter's

Similar wording

zoom and her daughter's name is maya so it's either enid or maya

Similar wording

Enid.

Similar wording

Enid has been promoted to panelists.

Similar wording

What's your name again?

Similar wording

Enid.

Similar wording

Enid.

Similar wording

Hello?

Similar wording

Hello?

Similar wording

Hi.

Similar wording

Could you please state your name as spelled for the stenographer?

Similar wording

First name is E-N-I-D-E-N-E-D-B-R-E-A-K-E-N-R-I-D-G-E.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Please proceed, counsel.

Similar wording

And have you heard my testimony today?

Similar wording

What did he say?

Similar wording

yes yes yes and it wasn't true and correct to the best of your knowledge yes and would you adopt it

Similar wording

as if it were your own yes great uh any questions we have an answer so this is just all take out

Similar wording

right so people are going to stand on the pavement and uh be serviced through uh there's a you want

Similar wording

to put in a window or yes the goal is to put in the window yes yes so a window is going right

Similar wording

there next to the door and so people will come up and get um and get service there okay yes

Similar wording

and then the rest of and the rest of this basement is just going to be for servicing this this take

Similar wording

out yes okay and then what all are you going to be servicing i know it's a water high stand but

Similar wording

I know a lot of other water art stands do nachos and pretzels and just want to be clear.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

So what are you serving?

Similar wording

Hot dog, pretzels, and chips.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And then are all of the, I guess, the equipment that you're using to heat things up, are they all electric?

Similar wording

yes okay i have a question just about the trash management um like what are you

Similar wording