civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - December 1, 2020

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Dec 1, 20208h 28m

um do we have any what we have up to what 115 or now

Similar wording

i was going to say mr chairman i have three long witnesses i mean it might make sense to break now

Similar wording

rather than possibly have to break in the middle of somebody's testimony we could go to 115 if we

Similar wording

to give it could you wrap it up by 115 mike um i'm sorry tanya um yes if we could um go to 115

Similar wording

uh possibly 120 ish um and then i can just ask that the staff and others involve leave we not

Similar wording

ask for um anything else for planning commission or whatever and then i'll just stay on the line

Similar wording

for this particular case but if we can wrap up in a few more minutes that would be great

Similar wording

okay i can go on to the next witness then mr chairman okay zba staff you can pop out as

Similar wording

necessary for your lunch as well as planning however you um feel and then i'll stay in and

Similar wording

wrap this case up thank you uh let's still like to call jeremy drummond

Similar wording

Mr. Drummond you have been unmuted you're free to speak

Similar wording

Good afternoon this is Jeremy Drummond D-R-U-M-M-O-N-D

Similar wording

I am an owner and principal at L2 Partridge

Similar wording

I am an owner and principal at L2 Partridge.

Similar wording

We are the architect working

Similar wording

We are the architect working with Parks, Casino, and Chickies and Pete's on this project.

Similar wording

Take the sparement, Mr. Chairman.

Similar wording

You swear and affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, sir, I do.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Please proceed.

Similar wording

I'm going to go ahead.

Similar wording

All right. Thank you, Mr. Drummond. What's your profession or occupation?

Similar wording

I'm a registered architect at L2 Partridge and one of the owners of the company.

Similar wording

And I have on my screen now a copy of your CV or resume. Is this accurate regarding your experience and background?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Are you the person responsible for preparation

Similar wording

of the plans for the accommodation of the parks

Similar wording

sports book in the existing Chickie and Pete's restaurant and sports bar?

Similar wording

Yes. Could you explain to the board

Similar wording

and to the public what you

Similar wording

intended to achieve with your design work on this project?

Similar wording

Yeah, so as Pete and Matt have alluded to

Similar wording

So we're taking the existing private dining area in the back and converting it into a sports book.

Similar wording

And aesthetically, the goal was to create an overall enhanced user experience.

Similar wording

So with people that are watching sports being a sports book, a sports bar, there seems to be a natural synergy here.

Similar wording

So the design concept was really to create more of a high-end user experience and just a fully immersive sports viewing and wagering experience.

Similar wording

And will Chickies and Peach continue to operate their restaurant at this location?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And are you familiar with the turf club at 700 Packer Avenue?

Similar wording

I am, yes.

Similar wording

And what's the square footage of that operation now?

Similar wording

Approximately 36,000 square feet.

Similar wording

And after they move inside Chiqui and Pete's, what will the square footage of the relocated sportsbook be?

Similar wording

Approximately 2,600 square feet.

Similar wording

And will sportsbook business have a separate entrance or exit?

Similar wording

no as testified earlier the entrance to the sports book will be through the main restaurant

Similar wording

and patrons will enter through the main doors of chickies and pete's excuse the interruption i

Similar wording

think we can stipulate that the only way into this sport the sports book will be through the

Similar wording

main entrance in this chicken pizza will be no other entrances to the facility for as it relates

Similar wording

the sports book sure follow up on that though is there a reason for limiting entrance to the sports

Similar wording

book from inside chicken pizza only primarily just to control access uh for engagement strategies

Similar wording

for chickies and pete's and just for overall security reasons okay um and what will the

Similar wording

design capacity i'm sorry excuse me counselor what is is there any physical barrier for

Similar wording

for minors at the entrance of the door to the sports bar, to the sports bar?

Similar wording

Yes, there is.

Similar wording

Mr. Drummond can address that.

Similar wording

Yeah, I apologize.

Similar wording

Yes, there is.

Similar wording

So the rendering you're seeing on the screen, actually.

Similar wording

So once you enter the restaurant, as you head back towards the sports book, there is a glass

Similar wording

entry, a secure entry.

Similar wording

And as Matt testified, there will be a security guard at that entry controlling access.

Similar wording

Is this the entry that I'm pointing to?

Similar wording

Correct.

Similar wording

Yes, that is the entry.

Similar wording

And is the rest of this a walled-in area?

Similar wording

Correct.

Similar wording

The entire space is enclosed.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

I think if I go down to the renderings, I can show that a little bit further as well.

Similar wording

Yeah, so this is the entry to the sports book from the inside of Chickies and Peets.

Similar wording

We don't see that.

Similar wording

We're not seeing that.

Similar wording

Oh, okay.

Similar wording

That's not coming up?

Similar wording

I see it.

Similar wording

I'm sharing the rendering.

Similar wording

I thought my screen was sharing, Mr. Chairman.

Similar wording

This is all.

Similar wording

You had it up earlier, but not now.

Similar wording

It's not up now?

Similar wording

I can see it.

Similar wording

I can see it.

Similar wording

Yeah, because the board members, I don't think the board can see it.

Similar wording

The board can't see it.

Similar wording

It's a problem, obviously.

Similar wording

Should I stop and restart the screen, Chair?

Similar wording

Should I stop and restart the screen share?

Similar wording

Let me restart the screen, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

Oops, that's not it.

Similar wording

is it up mr chairman yeah i see it yes thank you sorry about that

Similar wording

so the rendering you're looking at is a view looking into the sports book from chickies and

Similar wording

pete's main restaurant as you approach the entry and that is a glass uh enclosure

Similar wording

and these are all glass here correct so where's the where's the security uh barrier

Similar wording

you have a total glass enclosure that you that you can't walk through Mr. Holloman

Similar wording

there's a door that'll open it to allow you into the sportsbook correct this is a door

Similar wording

correct it stays closed until people want to enter or exit

Similar wording

and they're correct correct and i i'm sorry michael go ahead no i was going to say there'd

Similar wording

be security personnel uh the station at the door and we do have our security expert who can talk

Similar wording

about the specifics of how that will work he's going to testify later as well mr problem

Similar wording

maybe we should have had the security guard in the picture that would help

Similar wording

anyway well or maybe you can well we're going to have this continue at some point maybe you

Similar wording

could just show us a visual where it will be okay so let me ask you a question to go back

Similar wording

of the earlier I think Mr. Manione you may have I think I asked about occupancy or you brought it

Similar wording

up. Occupancy is 59. Is that 59 guests or is that 59 include the employees?

Similar wording

Patrons is 59 or is that the grand total of patrons and employees? 59 is the number of

Similar wording

seats Mr. Chairman which we have right here and and Mr. Drummond can can speak to that a little

Similar wording

bit but here is your okay yeah i thought you did i wanted to double check all right 59 seats and

Similar wording

then you have employees okay correct and uh again mr drumming is that the correct number of seats

Similar wording

59 that is correct okay and um what's presently um in this area in chickies and pete so currently

Similar wording

that is three private dining rooms or three dining rooms that creates a flexible environment

Similar wording

for Chickies and Peets so they can seat large parties back there or they can rent out the

Similar wording

separate spaces for private dining events and fundraisers. And is that present seating capacity

Similar wording

of that area 138? Yes, it is currently. So we will be reducing from 138 seats to 59 seats?

Similar wording

Correct.

Similar wording

And will that use be discontinued, at least in that area of Chickies and Peets?

Similar wording

Yes, it will.

Similar wording

And what will the occupancy of the Chickies and Peets restaurant and sports bar be after the sports book is relocated there, the total occupancy?

Similar wording

514 occupants.

Similar wording

And is that a reduction of the present occupancy?

Similar wording

Yeah, it is a reduction of the overall occupant load by approximately 80.

Similar wording

I think 79 to be exact.

Similar wording

Other than the planned alterations of building the sportsbook,

Similar wording

were there any other alterations to the chicken pizza operations you're aware of?

Similar wording

No to the operations.

Similar wording

We are making some accommodations in the Play 2 area to accommodate the loss of the private dining spaces.

Similar wording

If these changes are made, will Chickies and Pete's with the relocated sports book, relocated as your design proposes,

Similar wording

will the operation meet all the applicable zoning use and dimensional restrictions for this area?

Similar wording

Are you building anything beyond the four walls that already exist?

Similar wording

no we are only making interior modifications

Similar wording

does your plan alter the exterior of the building that houses chickies and peets in any way

Similar wording

no it doesn't and will the changes create a need for additional parking or other changes to the

Similar wording

parking area provided for the present occupants of this building no and are you familiar with

Similar wording

And are you familiar with the zoning codes provisions applicable for uses which are permitted

Similar wording

the zoning codes provisions applicable for uses which are permitted

Similar wording

by special exception?

Similar wording

Yes, I am.

Similar wording

And are there any use specific provisions applicable to the proposed use under the zoning

Similar wording

code section 14601C7?

Similar wording

14601C7.

Similar wording

i'm sorry michael repeat that please i'm sorry are there any use specific provisions

Similar wording

applicable to the proposed use under zoning code section 14601c7 is this any of the special uses

Similar wording

listed in that section yes assembly and entertainment okay and um in your opinion

Similar wording

will approval of this application for special exception

Similar wording

have any detrimental impacts on the community

Similar wording

beyond that which might normally be expected

Similar wording

from the proposed use described in your plans?

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

And why do you have that opinion?

Similar wording

Well, because as you've heard testimony earlier,

Similar wording

to me, it's a natural synergy between these two parties.

Similar wording

And I actually believe this is going to enhance

Similar wording

the overall user experience.

Similar wording

and make Chicks and Peets more competitive with what's happening in the neighboring community

Similar wording

with some of the other facilities that are being constructed.

Similar wording

And will the proposal cause congestion in the public streets or transportation systems?

Similar wording

No, because it's an overall reduction of seating capacity.

Similar wording

And will this interior design change cause overcrowding of the land?

Similar wording

no i don't believe so for the same reason it's a reduction in overall seating capacity

Similar wording

will these changes cause any added burden on water sewer systems or on local schools parks

Similar wording

or other public facilities no we're not making any alterations to the building outside of the

Similar wording

building envelope will these changes injure the use of the neighboring properties no

Similar wording

And will these changes impair light and air to the neighboring property?

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

And in your opinion, is the proposal consistent with the city's comprehensive plan?

Similar wording

Yes, it is. It's a commercial auto-oriented facility, and it's going to remain that.

Similar wording

And in your opinion, will approval this proposal have any negative impacts upon the community or neighborhood?

Similar wording

No, I don't believe so.

Similar wording

and why do you have that opinion well because as i said i mean this is a natural um uh synergy

Similar wording

with chickies and peats it seems consistent with what they've always done i'm very familiar with

Similar wording

chickies and peats i've been working with them a long time and i'm also an avid sports watcher and

Similar wording

and wager and it's um you know what we're trying to do here and what chickies and peats and parks

Similar wording

is trying to do here is really create just an enhanced environment so you can see from the

Similar wording

rendering that this is really more of a high end upscale facility designed, you know, taking

Similar wording

concepts from some of the higher end waging locations in like Las Vegas and things like

Similar wording

that. So it's designed to be consistent with the existing clientele that Chickas and Pete's

Similar wording

caters to. And I don't see any reason why that would change.

Similar wording

mr chairman i have no further questions for mr droman i have a question i don't know i don't

Similar wording

it's not for mr cullen but if i'm going to use an example uh and i'll use myself as the example

Similar wording

if i'm sitting in tricky and pizza i'm either at the bar or at a table i'm not in the uh sports

Similar wording

book and i have my uh cell phone or whatever will i be restricted will i still be able to make bets

Similar wording

off my phone even though i'm not in the sports book area so in other words am i blocked out or

Similar wording

does life go on for me i can still bet at the bar i don't have i'm not going to be forced into that

Similar wording

facility correct into this i'm not being forced to go into the sports book if i'm a philadelphia

Similar wording

resident i'm not talking about outsiders i think that's a question for matt but i'm i'm saying

Similar wording

from what I understand no would not make a difference just a little bit from your phone

Similar wording

okay all right very good thank you uh counselor the counselor

Similar wording

I can't see the plan clearly but is there restrooms within that space

Similar wording

are there any restrooms no there are not therefore so therefore you have to come back into

Similar wording

Chips and Pete

Similar wording

to use the restrooms and come back to the sports bar.

Similar wording

to use the restrooms and come back

Similar wording

to the sports bar.

Similar wording

Correct.

Similar wording

Correct.

Similar wording

Tom, it's not like unusual.

Similar wording

I mean, when they have banquets there or fundraisers,

Similar wording

people who are in that area that we're looking at now,

Similar wording

they all have to leave that section.

Similar wording