civus
Hearing audio

ZBA Hearing - April 15, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Apr 15, 20266h 18m

I have an intuition to my lawyer.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Because I went to the justices, the peaceful intelligence, made the first step.

Similar wording

I follow him.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And the son he got, he talked about the studio musician, musician something, instrument.

Similar wording

Now he got another history.

Similar wording

For the abuse of prey, the next month, the attorney department got the poverty for sale.

Similar wording

Right.

Similar wording

Okay, so that's what we're going to have to do.

Similar wording

You're going to have to get your attorney and take the action against the individual.

Similar wording

The attorney department got $300,000.

Similar wording

He won a ticket.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

I say, no, I'm not touching it.

Similar wording

Hillary, what do you have something?

Similar wording

No, just give me one second because while I was looking on Atlas, it didn't have the most updated.

Similar wording

So I just want to look at.

Similar wording

um i just i just emailed it to you larry wait wait let me because it it looks

Similar wording

is this under so the address that we have is a consolidated address is it listed as

Similar wording

two separate parcels on the deed okay listed as 1911-13 okay and this i could

Similar wording

mean the document or the recording number is five four one six three four two eight it's dated 2023

Similar wording

yeah atlas was funky for me too yeah so i asked that you know the the current owner to send me

Similar wording

the deed um and you have the i do and i just give this a copy i sent it to hillary i can submit it

Similar wording

i'm having so sorry i think i'm also having um internet issues today i keep getting a notice

Similar wording

that my connection is unstable so um

Similar wording

yeah and atlas is not the last thing i have on here is from 2000 that's sorry

Similar wording

and also share my screen if you want me to share my screen sorry can you share your screen it's

Similar wording

not coming through yeah thank you i just don't put that on the record

Similar wording

sheriff's deed dated it was recorded March 28th 2023 references the parcel scroll just scroll

Similar wording

down okay all right I assume this this is Louise yeah okay so it was it was sold at Sheriff Dale

Similar wording

He passed away.

Similar wording

The person borrowed the $30,000.

Similar wording

I mean, he passed away a long time ago.

Similar wording

And the lawyer used his son.

Similar wording

Every time they call, keep going.

Similar wording

Every time I have a cold day, they just ask him for the young orphan.

Similar wording

He say, oh, no, the son will be here.

Similar wording

But he let me let you know that he died.

Similar wording

The father died.

Similar wording

you're welcome all right so yeah so i um in accordance with what what the chair recommended

Similar wording

sir if so this was this appears to be have the property has been sold at a sheriff's sale three

Similar wording

years almost three years ago um if there are if you have concerns about what happens then you

Similar wording

do need to speak um with an attorney but the property does appear to be in the ownership of

Similar wording

another entity at this time and that's the entity that is selling the property and one of the things

Similar wording

to the court to the city to the charity department because the lawyer okay they set out the brain

Similar wording

right so listen i'm i'm we're really sorry about your problems but you're going to have to find a

Similar wording

way to handle it with your attorney and we're going to need to move on okay but thank you very

Similar wording

much i know you sat here a long time thank you very much next day i got to the department was

Similar wording

I got loose, empty car, one piano, three saxophones, a trumpet, everything.

Similar wording

He never let me know about another car.

Similar wording

I see one car in the social media.

Similar wording

My car's son, all car, like an antique.

Similar wording

Yep.

Similar wording

He said two close to Atlantic City, one young car.

Similar wording

I don't know the rest of the 18 car.

Similar wording

All right, so thank you very much.

Similar wording

We're sorry about your problems, okay?

Similar wording

Thank you, sir.

Similar wording

all right thank you all right um we're going to move on right number 12 we did everything we did

Similar wording

right no uh mr sure i think we had only started the vote on that last one so we

Similar wording

finished that we need to finish the or just start the vote i think i'll yeah the vote over come on

Similar wording

i'll yeah vote over come on yes sorry

Similar wording

Yes. Sorry.

Similar wording

so mi 2025 007 361 1911 to 13th north 2nd street

Similar wording

I vote yes with proviso per amended refusal dated January 7th, 2026.

Similar wording

John's Vice, vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Fenetta Graham, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Ryan McAdams, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Taya Wayne, my vote is yes with proviso.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

All right, so number 12, Mr. Goldberg again.

Similar wording

M-I-2025-007-397-1921 Poplar Street.

Similar wording

Mr. Goldberg, could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Alex Goldberg, A-L-E-X-G-O-L-D-B-E-R-G.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Could you identify your client, the relationship to the property?

Similar wording

Sure.

Similar wording

my clients are jeremy peskin and sarah manning peskin and they should be in the virtual audience

Similar wording

um and we also have a letter of non-opposition from councilmember young and i see also franklin

Similar wording

bill is here too okay um you also the applicant has 12 sign signatures right our vice chair has

Similar wording

a few questions for you. Good afternoon. Have you submitted your documents and exhibits five days in

Similar wording

advance of this hearing? I have. And do you waive the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its

Similar wording

accuracy? I do. Okay. Thank you. You can share your screen and see what your case. Okay. This is an

Similar wording

RSA 5 property that has an existing two, that has existing two family living in it that was

Similar wording

legally done and approved under buy-ride zoning at the time when it became a two-unit dwelling.

Similar wording

My client bought it. The proper licenses were not maintained. The zoning changed to RSA-5,

Similar wording

and now they're here because in order to get a two-unit rental license for their two-unit dwelling,

Similar wording

they obviously need to go through the variance process again.

Similar wording

Here's the notice of refusal, which states, again, this is a two-family dwelling.

Similar wording

And I have sort of a timeline of events that I think will paint a clear picture, but there's

Similar wording

a certain exhibit that I want to get to before explaining that.

Similar wording

Here's a letter from the coordinating RCO.

Similar wording

We had an in-person meeting.

Similar wording

My client, Sarah, was there with me.

Similar wording

They live in Philadelphia.

Similar wording

She works for the University of Pennsylvania.

Similar wording

There was no one opposed to the project.

Similar wording

It looks like 17 in support and two not opposed.

Similar wording

um they sort of felt like you know and i agreed that there was a hardship here and you know it's

Similar wording

been a duplex for over 20 years converting it back to a single family uh would be would be a large

Similar wording

burden here's a petition of neighbors there are several other multi-family properties on that

Similar wording

block 1925 poplar 24 31 26 41 and 27 all of those are because this was a multi-family zone block

Similar wording

So a lot of those multifamily licenses were maintained. This one was not since my clients purchased the property in 2016. They have had tenants since that time. According to Sarah, they've had no more than 15 days of vacancy since 2016, and the majority of their tenants have stayed for over five years.

Similar wording

so they have not had a lot of turnover here.

Similar wording

They were not aware of the fact that they didn't have the proper licensing

Similar wording

until they were advised by a realtor and hired us immediately.

Similar wording

Here's the property history showing the two-family living in 2005

Similar wording

when it was converted that way under multifamily zoning from a vacant structure.

Similar wording

And in 2005, that same year, an individual, the owner by the name of Andrew Storer,

Similar wording

got a two-unit rental license.

Similar wording

you can see in the affidavit sign on your screen that under his ownership he for the entire time

Similar wording

lived there so what andrew decided to do when it was a multi-family zone property was get a single

Similar wording

unit rental license because he didn't need a rental license for himself and at the time

Similar wording

we did not foresee the zoning would change to rm1 so we had the one unit rental license

Similar wording

and then in 2016 my client purchased the property with a one unit rental license and the zoning

Similar wording

changed in 2018 and by that point you couldn't get the two unit rental license back because it had

Similar wording

And by that point, you couldn't get the two-unit rental license back because it had been lapsed for some time.

Similar wording

it had been

Similar wording

So I hope that made sense.

Similar wording

Property was legally converted, had a CO.

Similar wording

The owner-occupied individual chose to get a one-unit rental license, and that caused this issue, unfortunately.

Similar wording

Here's the 1900 block of Poplar.

Similar wording

Those addresses that I mentioned are all two- or three-unit structures.

Similar wording

This is a two-unit building.

Similar wording

We're planning to keep it that way.

Similar wording

Here's the bill in 2018 when it changed from RM1 to RSA 5.

Similar wording

Again, they bought it in 2016 as an RM1 property.

Similar wording

Here's where that parcel was for the existing zoning at the time of the zoning change,

Similar wording

and then after it became RSA 5.

Similar wording

Here's the zoning map.

Similar wording

Google Maps perspective.

Similar wording

here's the photo so this is the front of the property we have a bunch of interior photos as

Similar wording

well there's a parking spot off of west george street which is sort of a rear street with a

Similar wording

bunch of other parking spaces that's the only thing i would point out about the refusal it

Similar wording

doesn't reference that parking space that surface parking spot i looked in the atlas file there's

Similar wording

reference to um the seeking of a of a variance for it in addition to other variances um i don't

Similar wording

see anything beyond that it's been that way for some time i know that the records can be spotted

Similar wording

on atlas we believe it to be a legal parking spot and i would ask if that's reflected in the record

Similar wording

and maybe we have to defer to the streets department for that here's the notice posting

Similar wording

at the front and the back of the property here's the backyard so the first floor unit has access to

Similar wording

this space under the deck and the first floor parking spot the second floor unit has access

Similar wording

to this back deck there it is here's poplar street to the right and the left and then west george

Similar wording

which is a narrow street to the right and the left where you can see parking is not out of character

Similar wording

interior photos so this is unit one these units we're not proposing to do anything different

Similar wording

to them these are listing photos the I believe the second floor unit is occupied and the first

Similar wording

floor unit is vacant the first floor unit is a one bed two bath there is basement use which is

Similar wording

existing you can see a photo of it right here which it looks like a workout room and a home

Similar wording

office there's not a bedroom down there the second floor unit second and third floor unit I should

Similar wording

say is a three bed two and a half bath this is what that looks like

Similar wording

very basic illustrative floor plans you can see the first floor unit is this

Similar wording

green color kitchen living in a bedroom at the back with access to the rear off

Similar wording

of the living room and then in the basement you can see there's a utility room and then that gym

Similar wording

at home office and a bathroom and then on the upper floors you have basically kitchen and living on

Similar wording

the on the second floor and then three bedrooms and two bathrooms on the third floor

Similar wording

the rco meeting we met with united france civil civic association on february 12th

Similar wording

The mailing certificates, the application for appeal, deed to the property showing they purchased it in 2016 from Andrew Storer, and then lastly is the tax clearance certificate.

Similar wording

I know my client's availability for this was depending on how long today ran, because I think they may be at the airport, so let's give them a try.

Similar wording

try to quote yeah jeremy or sarah

Similar wording

could that person please raise their hand there's currently no person with that name in a virtual

Similar wording

audience the goldberg you're an officer of the court we'll take your testimony questions from the

Similar wording

board questions from our attorney hillary emerson

Similar wording

not at this time mr chair questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

no hands at this time chair cleaning commission

Similar wording

and before with the planning commission the comprehensive plan recommends no change in

Similar wording

and zoning to the current RSA 5 commercial mixed use,

Similar wording

I'm sorry, RSA 5 residential single family.

Similar wording

The proposed use is consistent with documented prior use.

Similar wording

the proposed use is consistent with documented prior use the planning commission recommends

Similar wording

The Planning Commission recommends

Similar wording

that the board grant the requested variance for three-family household living

Similar wording

that the

Similar wording

by 2025 007 397 1921 poplar street i vote yes sir michael johns my vote is yes

Similar wording

Cheryl guest and my boot is yes. Did we say 2? 2 units? Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Oh, all right. Okay. Oh, thank you. Yeah. I missed that. It's just 2. Yeah. Yeah. That's what they're saying. Yeah.

Similar wording

All right. Okay, uh, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Ryan McAdams, my vote is yes, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Okay, thank you number 9.

Similar wording

mi 2025 007 378 22 15 to 21 north 11th street andrea solemn is the attorney

Similar wording

non-oppositions from council member young and 37th ward unanimous of their support 15.

Similar wording

could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer good afternoon andrea solomon a n d

Similar wording

r e a s a l o m o n you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole truth nothing but the truth

Similar wording

i do could you identify your client a relationship to the property yes my client is two two one two

Similar wording

through two one north 11th street llc with me today is mr sanjeev jane the owner okay and our

Similar wording

vice chair has a few questions good afternoon um have you submitted your documents and exhibits

Similar wording

five days in advance of this hearing we have and do you waive the reading of the refusal and

Similar wording

stipulate to its accuracy i do okay thank you you can share your screen and proceed with your case

Similar wording

thank you uh sorry i'm not seeing the oh yes the share screen button here we go

Similar wording

okay good afternoon again um with me here today are Mr. Sanjeev Jain and Mr. David Whipple the

Similar wording

project architect is with us virtually um that we're here today with an application for the

Similar wording

change of use for the multi-family residential 12 dwelling units and an existing structure

Similar wording

it was previously permitted for a machine shop and warehouse most recently it was used

Similar wording

as a church though it has long been vacant. We have a letter in support from the RCO unanimous

Similar wording

support and a letter of non-opposition from Councilman Young. The vacant structure sits

Similar wording

at the corner of North 11th Street and West Kelowna Street across the street from the

Similar wording

Penrose playground and directly abuts the regional rail line, making this a really difficult lot to

Similar wording

redevelop. It's zoned I2, medium industrial, but the block is largely residential with the other

Similar wording

properties being zoned RM1, CMX2, and the Penrose playground is zoned RSA3.

Similar wording

um the i-2 designation is what resulted in the refusal for multi-family use

Similar wording