civus
Hearing audio

ZBA Hearing - April 15, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Apr 15, 20266h 18m

We got them, I think, a day or two later.

Similar wording

And then we were following up with the staff of Council President Johnson because this is his district.

Similar wording

And they told me that they were conferring with the RCO to find out why it was they didn't give us a meeting.

Similar wording

yesterday we found out for the first time that there was a meeting on uh on monday night i

Similar wording

believe or i think it was monday night we were not invited to it so that would have been the rco

Similar wording

meeting we would have we would have uh flired the neighborhood in addition because we already put

Similar wording

out the the mailing that we needed to do from the planning commission uh but we didn't have a date

Similar wording

for the meeting so we wanted to to have a date and then we would flyer uh so we're basically ships

Similar wording

passing through the night we haven't had that kind of conversation um i think um what i would prefer

Similar wording

is that if we could go forward today and then if if you want to hold the vote and have a and have

Similar wording

a an rco meeting happen in the next couple weeks that that um seems to me to be an appropriate

Similar wording

response here. I certainly want to have an RCO meeting, but I don't want the RCO to be delaying

Similar wording

things when this case has, it has been going on for a long time, but it's not because we have

Similar wording

been delaying things. It's because there were issues with, that Al and I, we wanted to address

Similar wording

with Betsy Baldwin, and ultimately, she determined that she couldn't help us. All right. So, Craig,

Similar wording

Greg, we're going to hear the case.

Similar wording

We will hold the vote, and we will try to get this done in the next couple weeks where you can have an RCO meeting, okay?

Similar wording

So I'll call you when your case is ready.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

I think you're number six on the list.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Thanks so much.

Similar wording

Thank you very much.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Is there anyone else who's requesting a continuance?

Similar wording

I see no hands at this time, Chair.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

We're going to go to number three, MI 2024-006-408, hold on, wait a minute, I got, I got one

Similar wording

Hold on. Wait a minute. I got one ad on to do it. One ad on it. MI 2025 006 364 1842 Master Street.

Similar wording

AND ADULTS.

Similar wording

I vote no.

Similar wording

Michael Johns. My vote is no.

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston. My vote is no.

Similar wording

Ryan McAdams, my vote is no.

Similar wording

Ryan McAdams, my vote is no.

Similar wording

Tonetta Graham, my vote is no.

Similar wording

Number two, MI 2025-007-104, 1838 North Van Pelt Street.

Similar wording

The vote in this matter will be at 2 p.m. this afternoon.

Similar wording

Now we're going to go to number...

Similar wording

let's see here number two

Similar wording

right number two mi 2024

Similar wording

zero zero three

Similar wording

three nine four thirty nine fourteen

Similar wording

oh i'm sorry mr chair it's number three it's number three

Similar wording

that we're doing first yeah two is withdrawn okay that's right you're right i'm sorry

Similar wording

number three mi 2024 006 208 632 edmond street um

Similar wording

this is a spanish interpreter will handle this case could the spanish interpreter please come on

Similar wording

the applicant and the spanish interpreter had both been promoted to panelists okay

Similar wording

and good morning my name is stephen aubain aubain interpreter id ym 288 i'll be the spanish

Similar wording

interpreter all right do you swear or affirm to tell the do you swear or affirm that you will um

Similar wording

interpret accurately completely and uh from english to spanish and also from spanish to

Similar wording

english to the best of your ability yes i do all right could you please call the um the owner force

Similar wording

and in this mission

Similar wording

or a cn a arcina y señor arcena si puede entrar a la llamada por favor

Similar wording

ok y otra

Similar wording

spell for the stenographer por favor díganos su nombre y de letrero para el reportero mi nombre

Similar wording

es newton bautista aracena my name is newton bautista aracena jura y afirma decir la verdad

Similar wording

toda la verdad nada más que la verdad sí ante dios yes this application is for use as a two family

Similar wording

household living así que esta solicitud es para uso multifamiliar de vivienda para cambiar mi

Similar wording

zonificación de una familia a dos familias yes it's a change from single family to a multi-family

Similar wording

where the proposed use to family household living is prohibited in the rsa3 zoning district

Similar wording

Y donde el uso de vivienda multifamilial está prohibido bajo el distrito de zonificación RSA-3.

Similar wording

Nuestro vicepresidente tiene algunas preguntas.

Similar wording

Good morning. Have you submitted your documents and exhibits five days in advance of this hearing?

Similar wording

Buenos días. Usted ha sometido sus documentos y evidencia cinco días de antemano de esta reunión.

Similar wording

yes

Similar wording

okay and the chair of red your refusal so to you stipulate to the accuracy of the

Similar wording

refusal así que el presidente leyó el este el retiro y usted estipula la certeza de ese retiro

Similar wording

see yes thank you you can proceed with your case

Similar wording

yes thank you you can proceed with your case and show your screen

Similar wording

yeah thank you

Similar wording

are you able to see it

Similar wording

I can see it.

Similar wording

Si lo puedo ver.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

So we have that document.

Similar wording

Así que tenemos ese documento.

Similar wording

So he can move on.

Similar wording

Puede proceder.

Similar wording

Mi nombre es Newton Bautista Aracena.

Similar wording

so my name is nilton bautista sarah and i live on 30 30 i mean 6032 admin street

Similar wording

estoy aquí con la finalidad de solicitarle a ustedes el cambio de mi sonificación

Similar wording

So, I'm here to ask and request for a zone change if it's in the possibilities.

Similar wording

Okay, so Steven, could you do me a favor? Could you tell him to move to photos or the plans he has for the project?

Similar wording

Así que puede proceder a enseñarnos las fotos del proyecto y planos del proyecto.

Similar wording

Ok, muchas gracias. Ya se lo envíe.

Similar wording

Y si puede, puede regresar para atrás al principio y ir un poco más despacio.

Similar wording

Así que esta es la parte afuera de la propiedad, ¿correcto?

Similar wording

Esa es la parte adentro.

Similar wording

Esa es la parte adentro donde están los parques.

Similar wording

ok

Similar wording

but but hillary we only have we're doing that just the yes so yes the parking the

Similar wording

the parking is listed on the application as two existing spaces ok así que el estacionamiento

Similar wording

está listado en la solicitud como en todo espacio existente

Similar wording

y la propiedad corrientemente la está utilizando como un duplex

Similar wording

así que ya un duplex y lo está tratando de legalizar que yo resido en el primer piso y

Similar wording

so yes i live on the first floor and that's why i'm requesting um permission for the second floor

Similar wording

so that i can rent it out wait a minute wait a minute but it's already done it's already

Similar wording

it out to be a duplex right micro pero ya usted terminó el trabajo ya está como un duplex si me

Similar wording

pido perdón por hacerlo antes de antemano y en 10 años for forgiveness for doing it beforehand

Similar wording

hand okay all right all right so show us the first show us the drawings of the first floor

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

so this is the first floor and it has like washer and dryer and everything

Similar wording

Okay. How many bedrooms in the first floor?

Similar wording

¿Cuántos cuartos en el primer piso?

Similar wording

Dos cuartos.

Similar wording

Two rooms.

Similar wording

Two rooms, one bathroom.

Similar wording

Este es el segundo piso ahora.

Similar wording

And this is the second floor.

Similar wording

How many bedrooms on the second floor?

Similar wording

¿Cuántos cuartos en el segundo piso?

Similar wording

Dos cuartos.

Similar wording

Two.

Similar wording

Y un baño.

Similar wording

Two bedrooms and one bathroom.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

and how long has it been a duplex like this?

Similar wording

and how long has it been a duplex like this?

Similar wording

like a year

Similar wording

like more or less a year

Similar wording

tell me about when he met with the RCO

Similar wording

he tried two times

Similar wording

you tried to meet with the RCO

Similar wording

you tried to meet with the RCO

Similar wording

yes, I tried to meet with the RCO

Similar wording

yes, I tried two times

Similar wording

this

Similar wording

So I had two meetings with the RCO.

Similar wording

One of them was declined because of the snow.

Similar wording

but here is one of the meetings that we have with the neighborhood and these are all the signatures

Similar wording

of support from the neighbors could show us that please y si no puede enseñar este la firma por

Similar wording

favor si señor yes they're here just about the people next door the people next door agree with

Similar wording

it y la persona o vecino a su alrededor están de acuerdo con esto y si ellos son soportes

Similar wording

yes so the people that are list on the list they um showed complete support and they even said

Similar wording

that they're available to come to any meeting if they need to come and they were at the second rco

Similar wording

meeting to show support as well all right questions

Similar wording

so 60 um 36 is the uh house that's closest to me and they're on the list

Similar wording

as well and all the ones on the list are closed by

Similar wording

okay questions from the board do both units have access to the rear yard in

Similar wording

si ambas unidades tienen acceso a este la yarda atrás y el estacionamiento sí correcto y es correcto

Similar wording

así que veo los planos para el primero y segundo piso cuáles son los planos para el sótano

Similar wording

so it has the basement has an uh front and back entrance

Similar wording

and the basement is for utilities okay so there's no laundry on site for either unit

Similar wording

y adónde está la lavandería para las unidades los dos a los dos

Similar wording

dentro de cualquier ficción a qué se refiere con los dos

Similar wording

ahí está la lavandería y dentro del apartamento

Similar wording

y si puedes señalar a dónde está eso en los planos

Similar wording

and also what's the point of what's the point of the full bathroom in the basement

Similar wording

if it's just for utility permitan me permitan un momento un momento por favor y cuál es el

Similar wording

uso de un baño entero en el sótano si es solamente para utilidades como fue la pregunta

Similar wording

The interpreter will repeat,

Similar wording

¿Cuál es el uso de un baño entero en el sótano

Similar wording

si solamente es para utilidades?

Similar wording

No, lo que pasa es que ya estaba

Similar wording

cuando yo compré la propiedad.

Similar wording

So the bathroom was already there

Similar wording

whenever I purchased the property in the basement.

Similar wording

Solamente arreglé las paredes.

Similar wording

I just fixed the walls.

Similar wording

Okay, the question is,

Similar wording

could he point out

Similar wording

where the washer and dryer is on the drawing?

Similar wording

Ahora en los planos, ¿puedes señalarnos dónde está la lavadora y secadora?

Similar wording

Aquí, en esta parte.

Similar wording

¿Estás able to see it there? It says laundry.

Similar wording

¿Qué es eso?

Similar wording

¿Estás able to see it on the plants? It says laundry.

Similar wording

Al lado del baño.

Similar wording

Al lado del baño.

Similar wording

¿Algo más de las preguntas?

Similar wording

questions questions from our attorney hillary emerson

Similar wording

so just so i have a couple of things

Similar wording

first can you show the parking plan again

Similar wording

Así que este es Hillary Emerson, que es la abogada.

Similar wording

Y si puede enseñarnos dos cosas.

Similar wording

Si nos puede enseñar primeramente los planos de estacionamiento.

Similar wording

Correcto.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

On this plan, it looks like you are proposing multiple parking spaces,

Similar wording

but the refusal says two parking spaces.

Similar wording

parking and this is the interpreter can i let them know that if a party is speaking the other

Similar wording

No, dile que dos parking spaces.

Similar wording

Permítame, and this is the interpreter.

Similar wording

Can I let them know?

Similar wording

party cannot be speaking because it's interfering asi que si están hablando por favor no pueden

Similar wording

hablar yo necesito escuchar lo que están diciendo por favor manténgase en silencio en lo que yo

Similar wording

escucho you can continue okay no i just wanted to i was a little bit confused because the refusal

Similar wording

So the proposal says there's two existing parking spaces and this appears that they're proposing six parking spaces.

Similar wording

Así que no está muy claro porque la denegación dice que solamente hay dos estacionamientos existentes

Similar wording

y eso como aparece en la propuesta y en la propuesta de usted están pidiendo seis estacionamientos.

Similar wording

so we're just asking for two parking spaces one for the first floor and one for the second

Similar wording

okay um and then i just wanted to note that the fence that you have in front of the parking

Similar wording

it looks like it's non-compliant so you will need to um get a permit for that um it's it's about

Similar wording

six feet tall and it's completely opaque which is not permitted

Similar wording

así que también acerca de este la cerca el frente del estacionamiento aparece

Similar wording

que no está en cumplimiento usted va a necesitar un permiso para eso porque

Similar wording

hace seis pies alto y está completamente opaca y eso no está permitido aunque lo

Similar wording

voy a hacer y también este la petición que usted enseñó nosotros nos recibimos una copia de eso

Similar wording