L&I Review Board appeal HA-2021-004313 at 1435-41 WALNUT ST
Dataset record from Board of License and Inspection Review, Undated
Appeal HA-2021-004313
DecidedTypeL&I Review Board Codes
GroundsThe Historical Commission's denial of Appellant's application for the alteration of windows along Walnut Street and S. 15th Street was an abuse of discretion and an error of law. The Historical Commission (the "Commission"): (i) failed to adequately consider and review the criteria outlined in the Philadelphia Historic Preservation Ordinance (the "Ordinance"); (ii) completely disregarded unrebutted testimony; (iii) completely disregard the recommendation of Commission staff; and (iv) improperly focused on the identity of the potential user of the space instead of the alteration itself.
In making a determination as to the appropriateness of proposed alterations, the Commission must consider: (a) the significance of the building; (b) the effect of the proposed alteration; (c) the compatibility of the proposed alteration with the character of the site; and (d) the design of the alteration. (Phila. Code Section 14-1005(6)(e)). The Commission is encouraged to use the Secretary of the Interior's "Standards for Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings" as a guide in making its determination. (Phila. Code Section 14-1005(6)(e)).
When reviewing the Appellant's application, the Commission staff relied on the Secretary of the Interior's Standards, and ultimately, recommended approval of the alterations as submitted in the Appellant's application. The staff found that the alterations would have "minimal impact on the historic integrity of the property" and that the alterations "should be approved to ensure that the important historic building is self-sustaining and to allow for the restoration and public appreciation of the significant interior space."
In the face of this strong staff recommendation, which aptly relied on criteria outlined in the Ordinance, the Commission denied the application, and in doing so, consciously disregarded unrebutted evidence and testimony presented before it. The Commission did not discuss t
Address1435-41 WALNUT ST
DispositionDenied Classified from the decision text by software. How to read this
Decision textRefused
ProvisosREMANDED/ HISTORICAL
AppellantDEVON BEVERLY DBA: BALLARD SPAHR LLP (as listed by the City)
Owner of recordADR DREXEL L P (as listed by the City)
Names appear as the City lists them in its record. To ask for a correction or removal, write to hello@civus.org or read how corrections work.