civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - November 18, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Nov 18, 20251h 19m

it's been uh you know used as a single family for as long as i i know basically

Similar wording

um this is just an overview of the block i hope you guys can see it

Similar wording

This is just an overview of the block.

Similar wording

I hope you guys can see everything.

Similar wording

So technically, the reason why I'm requesting a variance is because the property is too big to rent affordably or practically as a single family.

Similar wording

It's been vacant for a long time.

Similar wording

It's really hard to do anything with.

Similar wording

It's been broken into many, many times.

Similar wording

I've had squatters, a full family of squatters taking over the house in the past and destroying it, basically.

Similar wording

And there's not much that I can do with it.

Similar wording

the moment um the block uh the 30 it's uh i'm sorry the west esquina block between 30th to 31st

Similar wording

this is the distribution of the properties on the block there are 42 parcels all together 12 vacant

Similar wording

lots two of them are in shell condition and about seven are multi-families i think it's two duplexes

Similar wording

four triplexes and one quadplex

Similar wording

or maybe even a fiveplex.

Similar wording

So there's ample parking essentially

Similar wording

and I don't think another one will cause any nuance

Similar wording

to the neighborhood.

Similar wording

So the division that I'm proposing

Similar wording

is essentially the classic duplex layout

Similar wording

where the first floor will be a single family.

Similar wording

The first floor will be unit one

Similar wording

and the second and third floors will be second unit

Similar wording

essentially not a lot of work to create the division and I will show that on

Similar wording

the plans in a second so some pictures of the current state of the property as

Similar wording

it is right now got the kitchen this is the second floor to the left third

Similar wording

floor right here on the right that's one of the showers and then second floor as

Similar wording

well I have more pictures if you I think I have more pictures at least it's my

Similar wording

proof of mailing sent out the list of the addresses here I have a bigger list

Similar wording

for everything each one of these have its own document in case you'd like to

Similar wording

see it I can pull it up my notice template 2 we had some issues getting

Similar wording

the date so I could not present to the community last month and this month it's

Similar wording

in two days, in Thursday, so this is when we'll be presenting, and I've sent a notice.

Similar wording

I've been in touch with Pastor Williams, he's the RCO, so we had good communication, and

Similar wording

I guess he notified you guys.

Similar wording

I forgot to tell him that I'm on, so I should have, so it's my fault.

Similar wording

I did.

Similar wording

I have the full document in case you guys want to see it, just let me know, please, and I'll pull it up.

Similar wording

Tax clearance, my name.

Similar wording

and right here i have the plans so essentially everything that is black and white is existing

Similar wording

and everything that is in red is the proposed addition so as you can tell right off the bat

Similar wording

is a minimal addition minimal change to the house essentially we'll have to create a partition right

Similar wording

here all the separation walls will be one hour fire rated including the doors as per code should

Similar wording

be another door in here basically going upstairs the classic duplex uh division unit two is second

Similar wording

floor we'll have three bedrooms uh two bath two full bath and right here this will be essentially

Similar wording

the living the living room and the kitchen um yeah else yeah trash days on thursday to be

Similar wording

notified to the tenants as per the request of the RCO. And that's pretty much it. Short

Similar wording

presentation. If you have any questions, please let me know and I can answer.

Similar wording

Questions from the board. Yes. Is there a basement?

Similar wording

Yes. I'm so sorry. I forgot to mention the basement. No work whatsoever in the basement.

Similar wording

It's existing. It's not finished. I think it's just a mall trap in general. I don't think it's

Similar wording

right to finish a basement ever uh it's basically just standard regular basement and has no no work

Similar wording

proposed to it i did write it here somewhere as well i'm sorry i forgot to go over it's my first

Similar wording

time it's fine so um my question is for this new unit that you're going to create on the second

Similar wording

floor how are they going to have access to utilities uh they'll have their own utilities

Similar wording

everything so so you're adding a utility closet that's not shown in red on the second or third

Similar wording

floor that's a great point i'm sorry yeah i uh drew part of it but right here there is an addition

Similar wording

uh closet in the bathroom and that will be uh good enough for it and the second floor has about

Similar wording

seven closets i believe so there is plenty of options i just didn't get to it but if you look

Similar wording

right here there is one big closet that can almost a bedroom size one here one here and there's

Similar wording

another one right here um and then they have closets in every bedroom so this can uh definitely

Similar wording

I will have to work that out, but absolutely separated meters and

Similar wording

separated utilities, potentially mini-split for

Similar wording

potentially mini split for upstairs. I just didn't get to it just yet, but I'm sorry I didn't

Similar wording

upstairs. I just didn't get to it just yet, but I'm sorry.

Similar wording

point it out. Okay. I have two other questions. So for the third floor in that bathroom,

Similar wording

is that a full-size tub? That bathroom? Do you have a photo of that bathroom? Is that because

Similar wording

it's existing? It is existing. Yeah. I might be, yeah, you can see it right here in the corner.

Similar wording

Yeah. I just want to know because the plan, the tub is not to scale. And then my third question

Similar wording

is for the first floor unit are you expanding the powder room so that that unit has a full

Similar wording

bathroom yes absolutely so i'll have to be either expanded a little bit or maybe shifted a little

Similar wording

bit um and a little bit gotta get a whole shower in there i sure will i promise you uh i will do

Similar wording

all the uh the planning correctly i'm a mechanical engineer and uh i'm not going to do any sloppy

Similar wording

layout i promise i just uh i did not draw these plans myself they were submitted to lni in the

Similar wording

past for a building permit i just went on top of them i did not have access to the cad file

Similar wording

um so i added the ruffins onto it but you're absolutely right it is my fault okay and then

Similar wording

for the first floor this is going to be a studio apartment not a one bedroom yes studio apartment

Similar wording

right here no no division okay i have no further questions any other questions from the board

Similar wording

questions for our attorney hillary embers

Similar wording

not at this time mr chair questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

here we have pastor tyrone williams he has been unmuted and allowed to speak

Similar wording

sure good morning chair and board good morning pastor how are you today i'm blessed thank you

Similar wording

for asking could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer yes tyrone t-y-r-o-n-e

Similar wording

Williams. W-I-L-L-I-A-M-S.

Similar wording

You swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, I do. Please proceed with your testimony. I just wanted to

Similar wording

confirm that Mr. Shea

Similar wording

is scheduled to present the clock on

Similar wording

Zoom this first evening. As he stated,

Similar wording

we have had some scheduling conflicts with our schedules, but we

Similar wording

finally got our act together, so

Similar wording

we will be presenting on Thursday.

Similar wording

He will. Okay. And

Similar wording

I also listened

Similar wording

to the testimony, so

Similar wording

I would just reiterate

Similar wording

to those in the meeting

Similar wording

what was testified today,

Similar wording

so they'd be full transparency.

Similar wording

Okay. Thank you for taking

Similar wording

the time to calls. We appreciate it.

Similar wording

Is there anyone else in the virtual audience?

Similar wording

I've seen

Similar wording

all the hands at this time, Chair.

Similar wording

Planning Commission. Thank you,

Similar wording

Chairman, and good morning. David Fecto with the City Planning Commission.

Similar wording

Chairman and board members, the comprehensive plan recommends no change to the RSA 5 residential

Similar wording

single-family zoning at this location. The city rezoned this neighborhood in 2014

Similar wording

in accord with recommendations in the comprehensive plan. The city issued a rental license for one

Similar wording

dwelling unit for this property in 2024. This is a primarily single-family block face. There is no

Similar wording

unique physical condition or circumstance of this property that would prevent it from being used in

Similar wording

strict conformity with the zoning code. The City Planning Commission recommends the board deny the

Similar wording

proposed use variance for two dwelling units. All right, thank you very much. As we stated,

Similar wording

we're going to hold the vote on this. Hillary, we would close this except for a letter from the RCO

Similar wording

no end possible response from the appellate correct but everything else is closed yes and

Similar wording

um we'll figure out a date later in is that correct yeah two weeks two weeks yeah we'll do

Similar wording

yes we'll we'll um yeah we'll schedule for two weeks which is december 3rd i believe

Similar wording

yes december 3rd december 3rd we'll be back okay 9 30 and i just want to note um

Similar wording

there if you could the powerpoint presentation if you could please um upload that so that we

Similar wording

have that as part of the record and there's a lot of things in it that you previously submitted but

Similar wording

we just want to have on the record um what you presented to the board that would be greatly

Similar wording

appreciated got it and that's uploaded through the portal the same place yes absolutely i'll do

Similar wording

that today thank you very much thank you thank you sir is there anyone in the first one is whose

Similar wording

case has not been cool i see no hands chair okay thank you everyone and see everyone tomorrow

Similar wording

morning right early thank you chair thank you board

Similar wording