civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - August 19, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Aug 19, 20266h 49m

I'll start with Exhibit 1, which is the Notice of Referral.

Similar wording

This application asks for a special exception to approve an event assembly facility

Similar wording

that occupies a portion of this fairly large building.

Similar wording

The other uses which occupy the other half, approximately, of the building

Similar wording

are warehouse commissaries and catering services uses translation essentially the other half of

Similar wording

the building is a commercial kitchen and the board already saw this application in 2020 so

Similar wording

what you'll notice here is that only the event assembly facility is not a buy right use that's

Similar wording

That's why the other uses are only mentioned up here, but they're not listed as referrals.

Similar wording

The buy right uses were originally permitted in 2019, and the event facility was permitted

Similar wording

by this board in 2020.

Similar wording

But what happened thereafter is that my client pulled a building permit, proceeded to renovate

Similar wording

the building under that building permit, completed the work, and then, I think because of some chaos

Similar wording

caused by COVID-19, the L&I inspector did not close that building permit. We then understand

Similar wording

the L&I inspector left the city's employment, so that building permit was left hanging open,

Similar wording

even though the work was done, and these businesses have now been up and running for five years,

Similar wording

But recently, Elle and I noticed that our building permit was never closed and it issued

Similar wording

a violation and it expired our zoning.

Similar wording

So we had to kind of start from scratch.

Similar wording

So that's why we're here.

Similar wording

It's to get use approvals for these uses again.

Similar wording

And I will present the whole case to you.

Similar wording

I'm not just going to hang my hat on the fact that the board saw it in 2020, since many

Similar wording

The board saw it in 2020, since many of you were not here in 2020, but I just wanted to give you that context.

Similar wording

of you were not here in 2020.

Similar wording

20.

Similar wording

And feel free to ask me any questions about that now or later.

Similar wording

Exhibit 2 is a memo of law which identifies why we believe our application satisfies the code's requirements for a special exception.

Similar wording

In the highlighted text here, I basically run through exactly what I just told you.

Similar wording

So I won't repeat it, but this is also available in writing if you need to review that history.

Similar wording

Exhibit 3, just skip ahead a little bit.

Similar wording

Here we go.

Similar wording

Exhibit 3 is permits to provide evidence of what I just talked about.

Similar wording

so here in 2020 is the zoning permit that uh authorized our uses you'll see here assembly

Similar wording

and entertainment and commissaries and catering services um this was obtained by my colleague

Similar wording

meredith furliger uh back then um since 2020 assembly and entertainment has been broken down

Similar wording

into new subtypes so we are now uh an event assembly facility rather than assembly and

Similar wording

entertainment but same use uh as was sort of planned for back then is exactly what we're doing

Similar wording

now it's basically a banquet hall it's where people have weddings and events of that nature

Similar wording

no public ticketed events um the creation of the event assembly facility category was partially to

Similar wording

distinguish facilities like ours that are not open to the public and do not have you know ticketed

Similar wording

events. And then just continuing here, here's the notice of referral from back then to just to show

Similar wording

you that this went through the ZBA. Here is the notice of decision showing that the ZBA said yes.

Similar wording

Here is a record of our building permit. I have the floor plans under which our work was performed,

Similar wording

so you'll kind of see what this building permit was issued on. But in any event,

Similar wording

um l and i recently expired this permit as is highlighted here so we're going to reobtain a

Similar wording

building permit l and i is going to look at our floor plans again and compare it to the work that

Similar wording

was completed so everything will be um you know according to code and per inspection

Similar wording

here's the zoning map at exhibit four just to show you that uh the entire frankfurt arsenal

Similar wording

business park is considered one parcel by the various city agencies and it's zoned irmx

Similar wording

It is sort of walled off from surrounding residential neighborhoods by Tacony Street and I-95, so there's really no impact on residents from what we're doing.

Similar wording

And then the business park is sort of chopped up into land condominium units.

Similar wording

So my client, Building 39 LLC, which is really a business venture of the Wiser family, owns Building 39, which is one of the two buildings highlighted in yellow here.

Similar wording

It also owns Building 38, which I think is the other building highlighted in yellow, but only Building 39 is before you today.

Similar wording

And you'll also see here that there's a parking lot that the clients and customers of Building 39 have use of.

Similar wording

it's very easy to get to you pull into the arsenal right here off of taconi street this is the main

Similar wording

gate and our parking lot really is the first thing you stumble across so it's very easy to get to

Similar wording

just some aerials of the subject building here where the yellow arrows are

Similar wording

and then I have some photos of our zoning posters not for the posters themselves but just to give

Similar wording

you a street level perspective of the building so here it is as seen from Tacony Street

Similar wording

the next couple of photos are from Bridge Street which is really nowhere near the building but we

Similar wording

required to put posters up there too. This is the floor plan. I do have the architect I believe on

Similar wording

the line if you have any questions but as I mentioned this was already reviewed and approved

Similar wording

by L&I for a building permit back in 2020. We're going to submit it again and essentially the

Similar wording

building is sort of divided in two as I mentioned. So there's the open event space here on the left

Similar wording

to the southwestern side and on the right to the northeast you have the back of house space which

Similar wording

consists of a commercial kitchen various storage spaces and bathrooms

Similar wording

exhibit eight oh pardon me that's my cell phone i'm so sorry let me mute that

Similar wording

i have to tell my wife i'll talk to her after so exhibit eight here has a couple photos of the

Similar wording

Exhibit 8 here has a couple photos of the space in use.

Similar wording

space in use so you have

Similar wording

So you have sort of this garage door thing going on on the left side, which again is the event area.

Similar wording

So during nice weather, you can have weddings and other events that sort of flow in and out.

Similar wording

The right side there is the back of house space that I mentioned.

Similar wording

And this is the interior of the event space getting ready for an event.

Similar wording

and the back of house space would be behind that wall.

Similar wording

The Wisers maintain different websites for the event space and for the kitchen.

Similar wording

And I will explain why the kitchen has its own website in a moment,

Similar wording

but I'll start with the event space.

Similar wording

Just we'll flip through this really quickly at Exhibit 9.

Similar wording

Just to show you this is a proper business.

Similar wording

It's been up and running for years now.

Similar wording

It provides rentals of the different equipment that you might need to throw a wedding here or another event.

Similar wording

Just some other photos of the space in use.

Similar wording

It talks about the different amenities that you can rent.

Similar wording

Exhibit 10 is our various letters of support.

Similar wording

The first one, just because the chairman didn't mention this one, is unique to our application because this is a condominium association.

Similar wording

So this is from the association itself, evidencing that there's no internal objection to our continuation of these uses that have now been up and running for years.

Similar wording

I think this is signed by the president of the association, Mr. Hankin.

Similar wording

we have letters of support from the only affected RCO other than the coordinating RCO which is

Similar wording

Wissenoming Civic we have a letter of support from Councilman Driscoll we have a letter of support

Similar wording

from BCAA who is the coordinating RCO their meeting summary will tell you that only one

Similar wording

member of the public came out to the meeting we did mail a lot of surrounding properties the

Similar wording

required mailing it just as i showed you is not a residential area so it was not exactly a surprise

Similar wording

to us that this didn't generate a ton of public interest we we do have this letter also from a

Similar wording

woman who happens to own two other buildings in the arsenal and very flattering i'll just

Similar wording

read you this one paragraph she's very supportive of what's been going on on our property she says

Similar wording

quote, I am as hardcore a historic preservationist as you're going to find, and I have been awed by what has been done with that building to preserve both its fabric and its spirit and service of entirely new functions, end quote.

Similar wording

Very nice to sort of get something like this out of the blue.

Similar wording

Exhibit 11 is an article by WHYY that I included just to sort of talk about the kitchen portion of the building.

Similar wording

Even though that's not before you today, all I wanted to mention about it is this is a kitchen that provides a function.

Similar wording

When there are no events in the event space, this is used as a co-working space.

Similar wording

It's sort of like a WeWork for chefs.

Similar wording

So if you owned a food truck or if you provided catering to other venues outside of the arsenal, you can be a member of this co-working kitchen to provide you a space to store your goods, to cook, and to collaborate with other chefs.

Similar wording

It's a really unique, sort of fabulous place to give people who are in this industry, which can be grinding and isolating, sort of a sense of belonging.

Similar wording

I think that this picture is of the Building 38 Kitchen, which is also a part of this business.

Similar wording

So just want to be clear on that for the record.

Similar wording

But in the text here, people are talking about belonging to Culinary Collective, which is the name of the business, and using both the kitchens in Building 39, this building, and Building 38.

Similar wording

And you just have some pictures of some of the members here.

Similar wording

I think that that is it.

Similar wording

When I get on.

Similar wording

Brandon, is this a 20-year-old business?

Similar wording

It's not 20 years old.

Similar wording

I believe about five, Mr. Chairman.

Similar wording

and that is the conclusion by the way all right all right why don't you bring your client sure

Similar wording

sure um craig weiser could you raise your virtual hand

Similar wording

craig weiser will be rejoining as a panelist thank you

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

i am hi boys could you hi how are you could you please state your name and spell for this

Similar wording

doctor my name is craig weiser c-r-a-i-g-w-e-i-z-e-r you swear or affirm to tell the truth

Similar wording

told truth nothing but the truth i do also thank you uh craig uh are you authorized to speak on

Similar wording

behalf of building 39 llc i am okay did you hear my testimony in your case this afternoon i did

Similar wording

was it true and accurate to the best of your knowledge was true and extremely accurate okay

Similar wording

and would you therefore adopt my testimony on behalf of the llc as if it had been your own

Similar wording

I do. Okay. Thank you. Questions from the board.

Similar wording

Questions from our attorney. Yes. Hi, Lynn Riedel, Huber board counsel. I just wanted to clarify

Similar wording

on your deed. I believe the property that you're asking for the variance on is unit 39,

Similar wording

but you've referred to it as building 39. Yes, that would be the same thing. It is,

Similar wording

it is officially known as unit 39 by the city building 39 is sort of the doing business as name

Similar wording

okay i just want to make sure thank you yeah questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

i do not see any hands mr chair planning addison matera planning commission staff the

Similar wording

comprehensive plan recommends no change from the existing irmx industrial residential mixed

Similar wording

use zoning at this location this property was rezoned in 2015 according to recommendations

Similar wording

in the north delaware district plan the opponent has demonstrated that the proposed use will not

Similar wording

cause detrimental impacts beyond what would be reasonably expected the planning commission

Similar wording

recommends the board grant the requested special exception for event assembly facility

Similar wording

am i 20 26 002 123 123 2275 bridge street i vote yes with proviso use limited to unit 39

Similar wording

michael johns my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

cheryl gaston my vote is yes with proviso tenetta graham my vote is yes with proviso

Similar wording

Taya Nguyen, my vote is yes, supervisor.

Similar wording

Thank you, counsel.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Thank you, Lord.

Similar wording

Number 11, MI 2026-002-137-2814 Master Street.

Similar wording

Al Nachamson is the attorney.

Similar wording

So, Nachamson, I believe you were sworn this morning at one point.

Similar wording

Am I right?

Similar wording

Right. And could you just state your name and spell it for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Alan Nockamson, A-L-A-N, last name Nockamson, N-O-C-H-U-M-S-O-N.

Similar wording

Could you identify your client, the relationship to the property?

Similar wording

Yeah, I actually have two clients here. I have Stelios Tisonontides, that's a tongue twister, who is representing Majesty Beauty.

Similar wording

And I also have Sandra Clark, who's representing the bakery. Sofa Lena. All right. I see there. You have letter of support from brewery town. That's correct. And non opposition from council member young. Yes. That's our vice chair has just a few questions. Thank you. Yep. Good afternoon. Have you submitted your documents and exhibits five days in advance of this hearing? Yes, we have. And do you waive the reading of the refusals and stipulate to the accurate? I do. All right. Thank you.

Similar wording

You can see your screen and proceed.

Similar wording

So the board saw this project in 2019.

Similar wording

They approved for this RSA five property corner property at at the corners of master new Kirk,

Similar wording

a commercial commercial on the ground floor and two residential units above as part of

Similar wording

their approval um it just said vacant commercial space i think this has changed a little bit now

Similar wording

you can have vacant commercial space and designate it as you know for instance cmx2 and if we would

Similar wording

have done that we wouldn't be here today so we're just doing some cleanup here um we have 14 exhibits

Similar wording

here at the conclusion my presentation i would ask that stellios and or sandra adopt my testimony

Similar wording

at their own uh rsa5 property um so my client's bakery is more of a catering bakery there's no

Similar wording

like it's not a retail component she started doing it from her home she's she's doing well um there

Similar wording

she started doing it from her home she's she's doing well um there while there's cooking the

Similar wording

premises there's no venting she has a ventless stove there um and you know as far as the hair

Similar wording

salon again small operation neighborhood operation and um the community has much approval for it

Similar wording

letter of support you can see it's a letter of support from the brewery town chargewood

Similar wording

Community Civic Association referencing the small custom bakery and the hair

Similar wording

salon operations which will be side-by-side hopefully property history

Similar wording

I just want to give you the use permit which included the approvals from this

Similar wording

zoning board and stated vacant space on first floor use registration permit

Similar wording

required prior to occupancy and that's why we're here today much support in the

Similar wording

community for this for these businesses to open up a little bit about sofa lena again sandra

Similar wording

has started out in her own kitchen her operations got bigger nerve bigger but it's still just her

Similar wording

and her hours of operations from nine to four monday through friday and then saturdays nine

Similar wording

to one she's the only employee there her menu includes cookies cakes cake pops cookie bouquets

Similar wording

cupcakes. She's SafeServe certified. The space has already been preliminarily approved by the

Similar wording

health department. We have those approvals. And the oven is electric. It does not require

Similar wording

ventilation. It doesn't produce smoke, grease, vapors, or steam. It's an MVP group access

Similar wording

AX-513. It's 22 inches wide. This is some of her product that she has.

Similar wording

again some approvals preliminary approvals uh from from the city

Similar wording

maps of the area it's pretty straightforward in that um we are rsa5 but you know again this

Similar wording

has been approved it's baking commercial space from the board photographs this is what the

Similar wording

outside looks like it's very nice i mean my clients didn't do this but the owner did do that

Similar wording

um this um is the entry point for the commercial uh i guess catering space uh you know she doesn't

Similar wording

expect to have any um residents any customers come in like to just buy cookies for instance

Similar wording

by the way this is the space for the hair salon and then but this is what the building looked like

Similar wording

before the renovation so the owner did a great job and you know um definitely retrofitted the

Similar wording

space for those two commercial spaces and hoping for these commercial businesses to

Similar wording

open up in Brewery Town.

Similar wording

These are the hearing notice postings.

Similar wording

This is New Kirk to the right of the property, to the left of the property, Master Street

Similar wording

to the right of the property, to the left of the property.

Similar wording

Interior photos.

Similar wording

While the apartments are not included as part of the presentation, I just wanted to show

Similar wording

you how much you know how nice this building is how much the owner did to the building

Similar wording

we should applaud that from a variant standpoint that someone actually effectuated what they

Similar wording

promised to do this is so for lena's space it's really small uh her space is i think 300 square

Similar wording

feet and the salon is only 350 square feet but this is the oven you can see here

Similar wording

and different interior photos we did some simple simple floor plans so you can see it

Similar wording

from that another oven in the back there i think that's a refrigerator but okay yeah

Similar wording